An empirical determination of the Cosmic Shoreline
P. Meni-Gallardo, E. Pallé · 2025
Read An empirical determination of the Cosmic Shoreline by P. Meni-Gallardo, E. Pallé (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-12865.txt.
Introduction
Pedro Meni-Gallardo and Enric Palle refine the cosmic shoreline idea in this 2025 paper. The shoreline is a line meant to split planets that keep atmospheres from those that lose them. It weighs the total harsh radiation a planet has faced against how strongly its gravity holds gas. Solar system planets first anchored the line. Since then, astronomers have used it to rank small planets for costly telescope time. The pair revisit it with fresh data.
They draw on two exoplanet data collections plus solar system values. Their aim is a consistent, empirical version of the line. A better line would help pick which planets merit deep study with new telescopes. Atmosphere checks are slow and expensive, so triage matters. The authors reconcile older versions of the concept in their update. The paper is aimed at the exoplanet survey community.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | P. Meni-Gallardo, E. Pallé |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-12865
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An empirical determination of the Cosmic Shoreline P. Meni-Gallardo, E. Pallé Abstract The Cosmic Shoreline concept was introduced as a way to separate planets with and without atmosphere, based on the relationship between the cumulative instellation and the escape velocity observed in the Solar System. The exoplanet community has tried to refine the way we understand the cosmic shoreline in order to provide a consistent tool for establishing the hierarchy for exoplanet observations. This is particularly relevant when trying to unveil small exoplanet atmospheres with the JWST or the upcoming ELTs. Here, our goal is to use an empirical approach to refine the Cosmic Shoreline concept. In particular, we used the data provided by the ExoAtmospheres database, using the largest available sample of exoplanets with confirmed atmospheric detections, and the NASA Exoplanet Archive, along with solar system data. We reconcile limitations in the classical shoreline definition by anchoring our Empirical Cosmic Shoreline (ECS) to both Mars and the irradiated super-Earth 55 Cnc e. The resulting relation exhibits a significantly steeper slope than previously theorized. Notably, it aligns with tentative atmospheric detections for planets like GJ 9827 d, L 98-59 d, and Pi Mensae c, while consistently categorising Solar System moons and dwarf planets according to their atmospheric properties. Applied to planets orbiting M dwarfs, prime targets for habitable-zone studies, the ECS suggests that a larger fraction retain atmospheres than predicted by classical models when using standard I XUV I_{\mathrm{XUV}} estimates. However, incorporating revised XUV fluence histories for low-mass M dwarfs ( M ∗ < 0.35 M ⊙ M_{*}<0.35\,M_{\odot} ; Pass et al. 2025) reveals severe atmospheric vulnerability: only seven small planets ( R ≲ 1.7 R ⊕ R\lesssim 1.7\,R_{\oplus} ) orbit securely within the retention zone of these stars. We finally identify high-priority targets for the JWST Rocky Worlds survey and future ELT observations based on their ECS positioning and Transmission Spectroscopy Metrics. Future efforts must focus on expanding the empirical validations of the ECS, particularly through high-precision observations of borderline candidates and systems with well-constrained XUV histories. 1 Introduction Exoplanetary science has seen a vast development over the past three decades, leading to a large diversity of confirmed planetary systems. With each new progress, the field is focussing more and more on the search and characterisation of small worlds: sub-Neptunes, super-Earths, and Earth-like planets. This pursuit is driving ambitious space missions and the construction of extremely large ground-based telescopes (ELTs), with temperate, Earth-sized habitable zone planets as key targets. Following JWST’s successful launch, the next milestone is the ELTs’ first light. By the time the first ELTs operate (2030s), current and upcoming missions such as TESS ( Ricker et al. 2015 ) , CHEOPS ( Benz et al. 2021 ) , and PLATO ( Rauer et al. 2014 ) , plus ground-based surveys, should have identified and characterised the most promising potentially habitable planets. If JWST is not able to do it for a few selected targets, high-resolution spectrographs on ELTs, already in advanced design, will be the first instruments capable of probing habitable zone planet atmospheres ( Palle et al. 2025a ) . Their role is to go beyond mass and radius, exploring atmospheric structure, composition, surface conditions, and potential biomarkers ( Des Marais et al. 2002 ) . M dwarfs dominate the solar neighbourhood ( Henry et al. 2018 ; Reylé et al. 2021 ) , and their smaller size facilitates the detection of lower-mass planets. However, theory suggests that planets around M stars are highly vulnerable to atmospheric loss ( Luger & Barnes 2015 ; Wordsworth 2015 ; Dong et al. 2018 ) , raising concerns about their long-term habitability under intense stellar radiation ( Schaefer et al. 2016 ; Owen & Mohanty 2016 ) . Currently, we lack even the basic knowledge of whether M dwarf rocky habitable zone planets possess atmospheres. The initial JWST results are ambiguous at best ( Lustig-Yaeger et al. 2023 ; Moran et al. 2023 ) , prompting a major public DDT programme to address this ( Redfield et al. 2024 ) . This highlights the need for optimal strategies and target selection to maximise the returns of expensive facilities. To tackle this problem, ( Zahnle & Catling 2017 ; Zahnle & Catling 2013 ) explored a planet classification based on the relation between the cumulative radiation received by the planets from the hosting stars and the escape velocity, known as the Cosmic Shoreline. Given the lack of information on exoplanet atmospheres at the time, they tried to constrain the parameters that define this concept by using the most reliable data they had: the Solar System planets. They proposed that a line could be drawn that separates whether the planets are able to retain an atmosphere or not. Using this method they classified the Solar System objects in terms of their atmosphere and extended it to the whole template of exoplanets. Other recent works have built on the original cosmic shoreline idea. Ji et al. 2025 revisited the concept of cosmic shoreline, focussing on atmospheric retention of rocky planets, by incorporating hydrodynamic escape models for various atmospheric compositions. They computed time-integrated atmospheric loss across a range of stellar and planetary parameters, considering realistic stellar XUV evolution. Their analysis demonstrates that the shoreline is probably not a sharp boundary, but a broad transition zone shaped by non-linear escape physics and an initial volatile inventory. Pass et al. 2025 also revised estimates of atmospheric retention for rocky exoplanets orbiting mid-to-late M dwarfs by incorporating updated stellar activity lifetimes and XUV emission histories. Using recent observations of stellar rotation and magnetic activity, the authors find that these stars remain in the saturated regime far longer than previously assumed, leading to significantly higher cumulative XUV fluence. As a result, many of the known planets shift above the cosmic shoreline, implying that only the most massive rocky planets are likely to retain an atmosphere. Other authors Ih et al. 2025 ; Berta-Thompson et al. 2025 , have tried statistical approaches for detailed small planet characterization and to provide refined frameworks for prioritising observational programmes focused on exploring small planet atmospheres. Despite the complexity proposed by these authors, which we can not still test with the available data, in this paper, we provide an alternative, empirical definition of the cosmic shoreline, based on the cumulative knowledge to date of exoplanet atmospheric observations and solar system exploration data. 2 Data In this paper, we make use of data from the IAC community ExoAtmospheres database 1 1 1 https://research.iac.es/proyecto/exoatmospheres/index.php . The ExoAtmospheres database is a repository of all exoplanet atmospheric detections, collecting information on the properties of the planet, chemical species detected, atmospheric properties, and related literature. Up to now 58 different chemical species have been detected among 274 explored planets, ranging from ultra-hot Jupiters to temperate rocky worlds. We downloaded the ExoAtmospheres database and created an up-to-date list of which planets have empirical detections of an atmosphere, that takes into account planet type; atmospheric species detections, featureless spectra retrievals, albedos; etc. While it is not possible to infer unequivocally from the ExoAtmospheres data that a planet has no atmosphere (as a non-detection could always be related to poor data or an atmospheric signal below the