Quantum spacetime from constraints: wave equations and fields
Tommaso Favalli · 2025
Read Quantum spacetime from constraints: wave equations and fields by Tommaso Favalli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-12698.txt.
Introduction
Time and space might not be the stage of physics but products of it. Tommaso Favalli pushes that idea in this 2025 paper, building on a formalism where a timeless, constrained universe yields time through entanglement with a quantum clock. Adding quantum rods to the clocks gives a fully relational model of spacetime, with no background coordinates.
Working in one space dimension plus time, Favalli shows the standard wave equations of quantum theory fall out of the constraints directly. The Schrödinger, Klein-Gordon, and Dirac equations all appear without assuming any outside spacetime. The paper also sets up second quantization in the same frame. The results support the view that dynamics in spacetime grows from entanglement and global rules.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tommaso Favalli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 78 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-12698
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum spacetime from constraints: wave equations and fields Tommaso Favalli Abstract In previous works, we showed that both time and space can emerge from entanglement within a globally constrained quantum Universe, with no background coordinates. By extending the Page and Wootters quantum time formalism to include both quantum clocks and rods, and imposing global constraints on total energy and momentum, we constructed a fully relational model of quantum spacetime. Here we take a further step: working in 1+1 dimensions, we show that the standard wave equations governing quantum particles—the Schrödinger, Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations—emerge naturally from this framework. The solutions of the equations are derived directly from the constraints, without assuming any external spacetime structure. The second quantization formalism is also implemented and discussed. Our results provide further support for the idea that quantum dynamics in spacetime may emerge from entanglement and constraints. I Introduction In the quantum gravity literature, quantum reference frames have been suggested to play a key role in formulating a consistent and workable quantum theory of gravity dewitt ; afundamental ; QG1 ; QG2 . This idea stems from the observation that, in the absence of an external classical background, notions such as time and space must be defined relationally, with respect to other quantum degrees of freedom. The Page and Wootters (PaW) mechanism pagewootters ; wootters ; pagearrow offers a compelling framework in this direction: by considering the Universe as a globally constrained quantum system and treating time as an internal degree of freedom (encoded in a suitably chosen clock subsystem) it becomes possible to recover the Schrödinger dynamics of a subsystem conditioned on the clock (see also Refs. lloydmaccone ; vedral ; vedraltemperature ; chapter2 ; nostro ; nostro2 ; nostro3 ; librotommi ; nostro4 ; interacting ; timedilation ; simile ; simile2 ; review ; review2 ; scalarparticles ; dirac ; foti ; brukner ; esp1 ; esp2 ). In previous works nostro3 ; librotommi , we extended this approach to include both temporal and spatial reference frames, introducing a model in which time and position emerge from entanglement in a globally “timeless” and “positionless” Universe. By imposing global constraints on total energy and momentum, we showed that the conditional states of a subsystem evolve coherently in both time and space, relative to internal quantum clocks and rods. This construction yielded a fully relational model of non-relativistic emergent spacetime, formulated without any external coordinates or background geometry. In this work, we investigate how the familiar wave equations governing quantum particles—namely the Schrödinger, Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations—and their solutions emerge directly from global constraints imposed on the total state of the Universe . Thus, we will consider a Universe composed of a clock and two quantum particles. The clock subsystem, denoted C , provides the temporal reference, while the two particles play distinct roles: one as the spatial reference frame R , and the other as the physical system S under study. In general, both R and S evolve in time according to the internal dynamics generated by the global constraints. However, under the assumption that the kinetic energy of the reference particle R is negligible (e.g., by taking its mass M sufficiently large compared to the relevant momentum scales), one can effectively study the dynamics and resulting wave equation for the system S alone. In the Schrödinger case, we also analyze the scenario in which the energy of R cannot be neglected and the effect of an interaction potential between R and S . In addition, we also develop the second quantization formalism within our framework. This not only illustrates the internal consistency of the approach but also shows that the transition to a field-theoretic description is compatible with the underlying relational structure. The paper is organized as follows. Section II reviews the framework of quantum spacetime from global constraints. In Section III, we study the Schrödinger equation, while in Sections IV and V we address the relativistic Klein-Gordon and Dirac cases, respectively. In Section VI we introduce the second quantization formalism and in Section VII we give our conclusions and outlook. Finally, we note that throughout this paper we work in 1+1 dimensions (i.e., considering a single spatial coordinate) to facilitate the reading, since the extension to 3+1 spacetime is straightforward (requiring independent momentum constraints for each spatial direction) and its implementation has already been discussed in Refs. nostro3 ; librotommi . II Review of quantum spacetime In this Section, we briefly review the formalism of emergent quantum spacetime from global constraints, following the framework developed in Refs. nostro3 ; librotommi . II.1 Subsystems in the Universe We consider a closed quantum Universe composed of three non-interacting subsystems: a clock C , a reference particle R , and a system particle S . The total Hilbert space of our Universe is thus given by \mathcal{H}=\mathcal{H}_{C}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{R}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{S} . To describe the temporal degree of freedom, we consider the clock Hamiltonian \hat{H}_{C} , which we assume to have a discrete, non-degenerate spectrum with rationally related energy ratios. More specifically, we define a set of d_{C} energy states \ket{E_{i}} and energy levels E_{i} with i=0,1,2,...,d_{C}-1 such that (E_{i}-E_{0})/(E_{1}-E_{0})=A_{i}/B_{i} , where A_{i} and B_{i} are integers with no common factors. We thus obtain ( \hslash=1 ): E_{i}=E_{0}+r_{i}\frac{2\pi}{T} (1) where T=2\pi r_{1}/E_{1} , r_{i}=r_{1}A_{i}/B_{i} for i>1 (with r_{0}=0 ) and r_{1} equal to the lowest common multiple of the values of B_{i} . In this space we define a continuous family of non-orthogonal time states \ket{t}_{C}=\sum_{i=0}^{d_{C}-1}e^{-iE_{i}t}\ket{E_{i}}_{C},\quad t\in\left[t_{0},t_{0}+T\right) (2) which provide the resolution of the identity \mathbb{1}_{C}=\frac{1}{T}\int_{t_{0}}^{t_{0}+T}dt\,\ket{t}\bra{t} (3) thus defining a positive operator-valued measure (POVM) with elements \frac{1}{T}\ket{t}\bra{t}dt . This framework makes it possible to define time operationally as an internal quantum observable with continuous values, while retaining a discrete and bounded energy spectrum. Moreover, the rationality condition on energy ratios can be safely relaxed: while the identity ( 3 ) is no longer exact for a generic spectrum, the resulting corrections can be made arbitrarily small, since any real number can be approximated with arbitrary precision by rational ones nostro3 ; librotommi ; nostro ; nostro2 ; nostro4 . The framework naturally extends to the case of a continuous and unbounded spectrum for \hat{H}_{C} lloydmaccone . In this case the time states ( 2 ) can be written: \ket{t}_{C}=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dE\,e^{-iEt}\ket{E}_{C},\quad t\in\left(-\infty,\infty\right), (4) and the resolution of the identity becomes \mathbb{1}_{C}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dt\,\ket{t}\bra{t}. (5) In this case the time states are orthogonal and satisfy \braket{t|t^{\prime}}=2\pi\delta(t-t^{\prime}) . We emphasize that, throughout the paper, we denote time states as \ket{t}_{C} and label time values by t , regardless of whether they are constructed from a discrete or continuous energy spectrum. This will not cause confusion, as the Sections where a continuous and unbounded clock Hamiltonian is used will be clearly specified. Importantly, the choice between the two cases does not alter the form or the dynamics of the relational states, which will be introduced in the following paragraph. Turning to R and S , we start assuming the momentum operators \hat{P}_{R} and \hat{P}_{S} with bounded, non-degenerate, discrete spectra. The reference particle R plays the role of a quantum spatial frame, allowing us to define position as a relational observable. In particular, for the reference R we consider 2N_{R}+1=d_{R} momentum eigenstates \ket{p_{k}}_{R} with eigenvalues p_{k}=\frac{2\pi}{L_{R}}k,\quad