DIT: Dimension Reduction View on Optimal NFT Rarity Meters Journal: Blockchain: Research and Applications
Dmitry Belousov, Yury Yanovich · 2025
Read DIT: Dimension Reduction View on Optimal NFT Rarity Meters Journal: Blockchain: Research and Applications by Dmitry Belousov, Yury Yanovich (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-12671.txt.
Introduction
Dmitry Belousov and Yury Yanovich take a fresh look in 2025 at how to score the rarity of NFTs, the one-of-a-kind digital tokens sold as art and collectibles. A token's price leans heavily on how rare its traits are, yet rival rarity meters are hard to compare without the full collection data.
A shared benchmark, ROAR, lets meters face the same test. The pair build an optimal meter with a scaling method that works from ranked likeness, not raw numbers. They also coin a new score, DIT, drawn from how tokens trade, and a meter of the same name that cannot be read by eye. That meter topped the benchmark, they report, which raises a fair question about trust in black-box scores.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dmitry Belousov, Yury Yanovich |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-12671
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
DIT: Dimension Reduction View on Optimal NFT Rarity Meters Journal: Blockchain: Research and Applications Dmitry Belousov, Yury Yanovich Abstract Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have become a significant digital asset class, each uniquely representing virtual entities such as artworks. These tokens are stored in collections within smart contracts and are actively traded across platforms on Ethereum, Bitcoin, and Solana blockchains. The value of NFTs is closely tied to their distinctive characteristics that define rarity, leading to a growing interest in quantifying rarity within both industry and academia. While there are existing rarity meters for assessing NFT rarity, comparing them can be challenging without direct access to the underlying collection data. The Rating over all Rarities (ROAR) benchmark addresses this challenge by providing a standardized framework for evaluating NFT rarity. This paper explores a dimension reduction approach to rarity design, introducing new performance measures and meters, and evaluates them using the ROAR benchmark. Our contributions to the rarity meter design issue include developing an optimal rarity meter design using non-metric weighted multidimensional scaling, introducing Dissimilarity in Trades (DIT) as a performance measure inspired by dimension reduction techniques, and unveiling the non-interpretable rarity meter DIT, which demonstrates superior performance compared to existing methods. 1 Introduction Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have become a transformative digital asset, with each token representing a unique identifier often linked to digital objects such as artworks Oliveira2018 , Angelo2020 , Wang2021 . Some NFTs are stored in collections within blockchain-based smart contracts and are actively traded on platforms such as OpenSea, Solanart, and Singular across blockchains including Ethereum, Bitcoin, and Solana Wood2016 , Nakamoto2008 , Yakovenko2018 . The value of NFTs is determined by a set of unique traits that define each token within a collection (see Figure 1 ). While all NFTs are inherently unique, their trade values vary significantly based on factors such as rarity. This has spurred interest in measuring and quantifying NFT rarity, both within the industry and in academic research, particularly in the context of blockchain-based information systems. Rarity meters have been developed to assess NFT rarity Rarity.tools2021 . However, comparing these meters is challenging due to the lack of convenient access to underlying NFT collection data Krasnoselskii2023 . To address this, the Rating over all Rarities (ROAR) benchmark was introduced Belousov2024 , providing a standardized framework for evaluating NFT rarity. This benchmark is particularly relevant for blockchain-based systems, as it enhances trust and transparency in NFT valuation. Nevertheless, the performance measure in ROAR makes it computationally intensive and slow to compute. Rarity serves as a one-dimensional representation of the dataset, where tokens with higher values are deemed more valuable. This paper explores a dimension reduction perspective on rarity design, resulting in new performance measures and meters. Our work contributes to the broader field of blockchain-based information systems by addressing the challenges of rarity quantification in a decentralized and trustless environment. The main contributions of our paper are as follows: 1. Formulate an optimal rarity meter design using non-metric weighted unidimensional scaling. 2. Generalize a computational method for non-metric unidimensional scaling for measurements weighted with arbitrary weights. 3. Introduce Dissimilarity in Trades (DIT) as a performance measure, inspired by dimension reduction and computationally simpler than traditional weighted correlation methods. 4. Introduce the non-interpretable rarity meter DIT, which demonstrates superior performance compared to existing competitors at the cost of losing interpretability. Figure 1 : NFT n=173 is part of the Bored Ape Yacht Club (BAYC) collection, which consists of 10,000 unique tokens. The contract address for this collection is 0xbc4ca0eda7647a8ab7c2061c2e118a18a936f13d . BAYC tokens have seven distinct traits: background, clothes, eyes, hats, earrings, fur, and mouth. For NFT n=173 , the trait values are as follows: Yellow, Guayabera, Bored, Bayc Flipped Brim, None, Blue, and Bored. The remainder of the paper is structured as follows. Section 2 reviews related work on NFT rarity, rarity meter designs, and dimension reduction techniques. Section 3 provides formal definitions and an overview of state-of-the-art rarity meters. Section 4 introduces the dimension reduction framework for designing optimal rarity meters. Sections 5 and 6 present the theoretical foundations for the DIT rarity meter and its methodology, respectively. Section 7 details the numerical experiments and performance evaluations conducted using the ROAR benchmark. Section 8 discusses the implications of our findings for blockchain-based information systems. Finally, Section 9 concludes the paper and outlines future research directions. 2 Related Work 2.1 The Demand on Rarity Rarity has long been a driving force in various markets, from collectibles to luxury goods, as it appeals to the human desire for uniqueness and exclusivity. Collectors often value rare items not just for their utility but for their scarcity, which can significantly influence market prices. For instance, in the numismatic market, rare coins often command higher prices due to their limited mintage and historical significance PauleVianez2022 . Similarly, brands leverage rarity to create a sense of exclusivity, thereby increasing consumer demand and profitability Chailan2018 . However, quantifying the exact value of rarity remains a complex task, as it often intertwines with other factors such as design, historical context, and market trends. The impact of rarity on pricing has been empirically studied in various contexts. For example, Koford1998 examined the effect of original mintage on the prices of Morgan Dollars and Liberty Head Eagles from 1878 to 1921. By analyzing 95 mintages, the authors isolated the influence of rarity from other factors such as design and beauty. Their linear model, which used the logarithms of coin age and mintage as features, demonstrated that rarity had a stronger influence on market prices than age, particularly in trade data from 1988 and 1993 Hastie2009 . In the realm of collectible card games, Hughes2022 investigated the impact of rarity on the secondary market prices of “Magic: the Gathering” (MTG) cards. While MTG cards have intrinsic utility in gameplay, their rarity–ranging from common to mythic rare–also plays a significant role in determining their market value. Hughes collected price data from TCGplayer for sixteen recent releases over a six-week period in March-April 2019. His linear model, which incorporated in-game attributes, rarity indicators, and the odds of obtaining the card, showed a moderate but statistically significant fit to the trade data. The study found that publisher-assigned rarity indicators and the odds of obtaining the card were important factors influencing card prices in the secondary market. Beyond collectibles, rarity also plays a crucial role in other domains such as luxury goods, art, and even conservation. For example, the rarity of certain species can drive eco-tourism, while the scarcity of luxury items can enhance their desirability and market value. These examples underscore the pervasive influence of rarity across different markets and its importance in understanding consumer behavior and pricing dynamics. 2.2 Rarity Meter Designs The design of rarity meters for NFT collections has evolved significantly since the 2021 surge in NFT popularity. Unlike traditional collectibles such as coins or MTG cards, NFTs are characterized by structured sets of traits, which necessitate specialized approaches to quantify rarity. This subsection reviews the development of rarity meters, focusing on their design principles and methodologies. The first widely adopted rarity meter was introduced by Rarity.tools Rarity.tools2021 , which proposed a formula based on the summation of the inverse frequencies of trait values. This approach,