GW200105: A detailed study of eccentricity in the neutron star-black hole binary

Aasim Jan, Bing-Jyun Tsao, Richard O’Shaughnessy, Deirdre Shoemaker, Pablo Laguna · 2025

Read GW200105: A detailed study of eccentricity in the neutron star-black hole binary by Aasim Jan, Bing-Jyun Tsao, Richard O’Shaughnessy, Deirdre Shoemaker, Pablo Laguna (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-12460.txt.

Introduction

When a neutron star falls into a black hole, the orbit need not be circular. Aasim Jan and co-authors re-listen to the first confirmed such merger for the ovalness of its path, in a 2025 paper. The event, GW200105, was recently claimed eccentric by a study using a simplified inspiral-only model.

This team applies the full modern machinery: effective-one-body waveforms covering inspiral, merger, and ringdown, with the oval orbit, spin precession, and higher wave modes all switched on. The eccentricity survives the sterner test, with a perfectly circular orbit ruled out at the ninety-nine percent level. Their mass ratio, though, lands back near the original LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA value rather than the newer claim. A puzzling multi-peaked shape in the evidence for ovalness gets its own forensic section, backed by computer simulations of the merger itself.

Catalog record

CREATORAasim Jan, Bing-Jyun Tsao, Richard O’Shaughnessy, Deirdre Shoemaker, Pablo Laguna
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-12460

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

GW200105: A detailed study of eccentricity in the neutron star-black hole binary Aasim Jan, Bing-Jyun Tsao, Richard O’Shaughnessy, Deirdre Shoemaker, Pablo Laguna Abstract GW200105_162426 is the first neutron star–black hole merger to be confidently confirmed through either gravitational-wave or electromagnetic observations. Although initially analyzed after detection, the event has recently gained renewed attention following a study Morras et al. 2025a that employed a post-Newtonian inspiral-only waveform model and reported strong evidence for orbital eccentricity. In this work, we perform a detailed analysis of GW200105 using state-of-the-art effective-one-body waveform models. Importantly, we present the first study of this event utilizing a physically complete model that incorporates both orbital eccentricity and spin precession across the full inspiral, merger, and ringdown stages, along with higher-order gravitational wave modes. Our results support the presence of eccentricity in the signal, with zero eccentricity excluded from 99 % 99\% credible interval, but yield a mass ratio closer to the original LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA analysis, differing from the findings of Morras et al. 2025a . Additionally, similar to previous eccentric-only analysis de Lluc Planas et al. 2025a , we observe a multimodal structure in the eccentricity posterior distribution. We conduct targeted investigations to understand the origin of this multimodality and complement our analysis with numerical relativity simulations to examine how the inclusion of eccentricity impacts the merger dynamics. I Introduction On January 5, 2020, the LIGO–Virgo Collaboration et al. 2015 ; Acernese et al. 2014 network detected gravitational waves from a compact binary system, with the signal consistent with a neutron star–black hole (NSBH) merger Abbott et al. 2021 . This event, designated GW200105, is particularly significant as it marks the first confident detection of an NSBH system via either gravitational or electromagnetic observations. Alongside a second NSBH event GW200115 Abbott et al. 2021 , detected just ten days later, GW200105 provided crucial evidence that neutron stars and black holes can indeed form binaries and coalesce within a Hubble time, an outcome long anticipated by theoretical models but previously unconfirmed by observations Abbott et al. 2021 . In its initial analysis, the LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA (LVK) collaboration estimated the source-frame primary mass of this binary to be 8.9^{+1.1}_{-1.3} , well above the maximum neutron star mass Rhoades and Ruffini 1974 ; Abbott et al. 2018 ; Cromartie et al. 2019 ; Shibata et al. 2019 ; Farr and Chatziioannou 2020 ; Fonseca et al. 2021 ; Nathanail et al. 2021 , while the source-frame secondary mass was estimated to be 1.9^{+0.2}_{-0.2} , consistent with the known mass range for neutron stars Antoniadis et al. 2016 ; Abbott et al. 2017 ; Alsing et al. 2018 . The analysis reported no evidence of tidal deformation or spin precession. Additionally, it did not address the possibility of orbital eccentricity as the waveform models employed assumed quasi-circular orbits. This choice is well justified as binaries formed through isolated stellar evolution are expected to circularize before entering the detector frequency band Stevenson et al. 2017 . Furthermore, full inspiral–merger–ringdown (IMR) waveform models capable of capturing the effects of orbital eccentricity have only recently become available Liu et al. 2020 ; Ramos-Buades et al. 2022 ; Gamba et al. 2024 ; Gamboa et al. 2024 ; de Lluc Planas et al. 2025b . Since then, GW200105 has attracted renewed attention, particularly regarding the possibility of non-zero orbital eccentricity. A recent analysis Morras et al. 2025a employing a post-Newtonian (PN) waveform model Morras et al. 2025b that simultaneously accounts for eccentricity and spin precession found the signal to be consistent with an eccentric binary, estimating an orbital eccentricity of 0.145^{+0.007}_{-0.097} at a reference frequency of 20 Hz. This analysis also inferred a detector-frame total mass M_{\text{tot}} of 13.0^{+0.7}_{-1.9} and a mass ratio q of 0.13^{+0.06}_{-0.01} . An independent analysis de Lluc Planas et al. 2025a using a complete IMR waveform model incorporating eccentricity (but restricted to aligned spin configurations) de Lluc Planas et al. 2025b also found strong evidence for orbital eccentricity, estimating an eccentricity of 0.12^{+0.02}_{-0.03} ,, with M_{\text{tot}}=10.83^{+1.06}_{-0.60} and q=0.24^{+0.04}_{-0.05} . Notably, the eccentricity posterior distribution in this analysis exhibited a bimodal structure, in contrast to the unimodal eccentricity distribution found in Morras et al. 2025a . The evidence of eccentricity in this NSBH system is particularly exciting, as it offers valuable clues about the formation pathways of NSBH binaries. Understanding the formation mechanisms is one of the key objectives of GW astronomy. Isolated binary evolution channel, currently favoured channel for NSBH formation Belczynski et al. 2002 ; Broekgaarden et al. 2021 ; Mandel and Smith 2021 , will lead to NSBH systems with low spins and nearly circular orbits Broekgaarden et al. 2021 . Therefore, the observation of measurable eccentricity in this event indicates the possibility of alternative formation processes. One such possibility involves interactions with a tertiary companion Silsbee and Tremaine 2017 ; Toonen et al. 2016 ; Antonini et al. 2017 ; Fragione and Loeb 2019 , which can sustain eccentricity through angular momentum exchange between the inner binary and the outer object von Zeipel 1910 ; Lidov 1962 ; Kozai 1962 . Eccentric orbits can also arise in systems assembled dynamically through interactions in dense stellar environments Freire et al. 2004 ; Fragione et al. 2019 ; Ye et al. 2019 ; Rastello et al. 2020 ; Trani et al. 2022 . The detection of eccentricity in this NSBH candidate suggests that formation through dynamical interactions may be more common than previously anticipated. Additionally, this finding is likely to motivate renewed scrutiny of both past and future GW events for potential signatures of orbital eccentricity. In this work, we analyze GW200105 using state-of-the-art effective-one-body (EOB) waveform models Buonanno and Damour 1999 ; Buonanno and Damour 2000 ; Damour et al. 2000 ; Damour 2001 ; Ramos-Buades et al. 2023 ; Gamboa et al. 2024 ; Gamba et al. 2024 , including a physically complete IMR model that incorporates both orbital eccentricity and spin precession. We examine how different choices of eccentricity priors affect the resulting eccentricity posterior distribution. In addition, we study the structure of the inferred eccentricity posterior distributions and investigate possible sources of systematics. To complement our analysis, we also utilize numerical relativity (NR) simulations to validate and deepen our understanding of the event The paper is organized as follows: Sec. II presents an overview of the Bayesian inference framework and describes the NR code used in our study. In Sec. III , we present our parameter estimation results, compare them with previous studies, and assess the impact of potential sources of systematics on posterior distributions. This section also includes a discussion of our NR simulations for the event. Lastly, Sec. IV provides a summary of our main conclusions. II Methods II.1 Bayesian inference To extract the physical properties of a compact binary system from GW observations, the data d is compared against theoretical predictions of GW strain under some hypothesis \mathcal{H} . These predictions are generated using waveform models, which typically serve as approximations to full general relativity. The posterior distribution for the model parameters \bm{\Theta} is then obtained via Bayes’ theorem p(\bm{\Theta}|d,\mathcal{H})=\frac{\mathcal{L}(d|\bm{\Theta},\mathcal{H})\pi(\bm{\Theta}|\mathcal{H})}{Z(d|\mathcal{H})}~, (1) where \mathcal{L}(d|\bm{\Theta},\mathcal{H}) denotes the likelihood function, \pi(\bm{\Theta}|\mathcal{H}) is the prior probability distribution and Z(d|\mathcal{H}) , called the evidence, is calculated as \int\mathcal{L}(d|\bm{\Theta},\mathcal{H})\pi(\bm{\Theta}|\mathcal{H})d\bm{\Theta} . The

Read the complete text