Bayesian Inference of Gravity through Realistic 3D Modeling of Wide Binary Orbits: General Algorithm and a Pilot Study with HARPS Radial Velocities

Kyu-Hyun Chae · 2025

Read Bayesian Inference of Gravity through Realistic 3D Modeling of Wide Binary Orbits: General Algorithm and a Pilot Study with HARPS Radial Velocities by Kyu-Hyun Chae (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-11996.txt.

Introduction

Kyu-Hyun Chae tests Newton's gravity against the orbits of widely separated star pairs, using a Bayesian method that models each orbit in three dimensions. When a pair's separation, velocity, and orientation are measured, the orbit can reveal the strength of gravity rather than assuming it. Writing in twenty twenty-five, Chae presents a general algorithm needing two sharp sky positions plus four other well-measured quantities. He applies it as a pilot to pairs from the Gaia catalog. Those pairs have precise ground-based radial velocities from the HARPS instrument.

For pairs with stronger Newtonian acceleration, the result matched Newton's constant, as the author reports. For the weakest-acceleration pairs, he reports a discrepancy beyond three and a half standard deviations. Chae frames the split as evidence about gravity in the low-acceleration regime; the paper is explicit that suitable pairs are still rare, so the test is provisional.

Catalog record

CREATORKyu-Hyun Chae
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-11996

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bayesian Inference of Gravity through Realistic 3D Modeling of Wide Binary Orbits: General Algorithm and a Pilot Study with HARPS Radial Velocities Kyu-Hyun Chae Abstract When 3D relative displacement 𝐫 \mathbf{r} and velocity 𝐯 \mathbf{v} between the pair in a gravitationally-bound system are precisely measured, the six measured quantities at one phase can allow elliptical orbit solutions at a given gravitational parameter G G . Due to degeneracies between orbital-geometric parameters and G G , individual Bayesian inferences and their statistical consolidation are needed to infer G G as recently suggested by a Bayesian 3D modeling algorithm. Here I present a fully general Bayesian algorithm suitable for wide binaries with two (almost) exact sky-projected relative positions (as in the Gaia data release 3) and the other four sufficiently precise quantities. Wide binaries meeting the requirements of the general algorithm to allow for its full potential are rare at present, largely because the measurement uncertainty of the line-of-sight (radial) separation is usually larger than the true separation. As a pilot study, the algorithm is applied to 32 Gaia binaries for which precise HARPS radial velocities are available. The value of Γ ≡ log 10 ⁡ G / G N \Gamma\equiv\log_{10}\sqrt{G/G_{\rm N}} (where G N G_{\rm N} is Newton’s constant) is − 0.002 − 0.018 + 0.012 -0.002_{-0.018}^{+0.012} supporting Newton for a combination of 24 binaries with Newtonian acceleration g N > 10 − 9 g_{\rm N}>10^{-9} m s -2 , while it is Γ = 0.063 − 0.047 + 0.058 \Gamma=0.063_{-0.047}^{+0.058} or 0.134 − 0.040 + 0.050 0.134_{-0.040}^{+0.050} for 7 ​ or ​ 8 7\text{ or }8 binaries with g N < 10 − 9 g_{\rm N}<10^{-9} m s -2 (depending on one system) showing tension with Newton. The Newtonian “outlier” is at the boundary set by the Newtonian escape velocity, but can be consistent with modified gravity. The pilot study demonstrates the potential of the algorithm in measuring gravity at low acceleration with future samples of wide binaries. I Introduction Gravitationally-bound binary systems have played pivotal roles in astronomy and physics. The orbital motion of planets in the Sun-planet binary systems provided the early experimental foundation of Newtonian gravitational dynamics. The gravitational anomaly in Mercury’s orbital motion in a relatively strong gravity regime provided an early experimental success of Einstein’s general relativity. Binary (and higher-multiplicity) stars have been playing fundamental roles in determining stellar masses and radii and constraining star formation and evolution models (e.g., G. Duchêne & A. Kraus 2013 ; K. El-Badry 2024 ). A currently interesting use of binary stars in studies of fundamental physics is to probe gravity in the low-acceleration ( \lesssim 10^{-9} m s -2 ) regime with wide binaries. The dark matter (DM) phenomena in galaxies indicate a critical acceleration scale a_{0}\approx 1.2\times 10^{-10} m s -2 , known as Milgrom’s or modified Newtonian Dynamics ( M. Milgrom 1983 , MOND; ) constant (see the reviews by R. H. Sanders & S. S. McGaugh 2002 ; B. Famaey & S. S. McGaugh 2012 ). As Milgrom proposed, the presence of a_{0} in galaxies may indicate the breakdown of standard Newton-Einstein gravity in the low-acceleration regime, opening possibilities of gravity theories breaking the strong equivalence principle ( M. Milgrom 1983 ) . This can be directly tested by wide binaries in the solar neighborhood as wide binary internal dynamics cannot be affected by the dark matter density inferred for the Milky Way ( X. Hernandez et al. 2012 ) . There is a fundamental limitation in probing gravity with individual wide binaries because those of interest have long periods of \gtrsim 10^{5} yr and thus their orbits cannot be traced for significant segments. When the relative displacement \mathbf{r} and the relative velocity \mathbf{v} between the pair are measured with sufficient precision, the six components at one phase can be used to reconstruct the orbit assuming Newtonian gravitational dynamics (see, e.g., P. Kervella et al. 2017 and R. Akeson et al. 2021 for reconstructed orbits of Proxima around \alpha Cen AB). However, the same data may be equally well fitted by nonstandard theories of gravity with varied orbits. In other words, globally different orbits for different theories of gravity may fit the instantaneous displacement and velocity equally well. Thus, such degeneracies must be dealt with in using wide binaries for testing gravity through 3D orbit modeling. Wide binaries with precise \mathbf{r} and \mathbf{v} are rare because it is challenging to measure the relative radial (line-of-sight) displacement and the relative radial velocity (RV) with sufficiently good precision. In particular, the measurement uncertainties of the relative distances are usually (much) larger than the radial separations, whereas precise RVs are currently being obtained for increasingly larger samples. Recently, two studies considered 3D orbit modeling to test gravity based on samples of limited quantity and/or quality. For 32 binaries selected from the Gaia data release 3 ( A. Vallenari et al. 2023 , DR3; ) database, R. Saglia et al. 2025 derived very precise RVs from the High Accuracy Radial Velocity Planet Searcher (HARPS) spectrograph database. Their sample covers a broad range of Newtonian gravitational acceleration 10^{-11}\lesssim g_{\rm N}\lesssim 10^{-6} m s -2 including about 8 wide binaries with g_{\rm N}<10^{-9} m s -2 as will be shown below. Notably, their sample includes only a few binaries with uncertainty of distance difference ( \Delta d ) satisfying \sigma_{\Delta d}<s/\sqrt{2} where s is the sky-projected 2D separation. Thus, individual orbit inferences and gravity tests are limited by overall imprecise radial separations (note that tangential separations derived from Gaia astrometry have negligibly small errors). Moreover, even if \sigma_{\Delta d} is sufficiently small, degeneracies between orbits and gravity theories need to be dealt with. R. Saglia et al. 2025 presented only non-unique Newtonian orbit solutions for all their binaries except for one system (#24) with stars HD189739 and HD189760 which they interpret as an unbound system. They have not derived uncertainties or probability distributions of orbit parameters, but they noted that some orbit phases seemed unnatural. K.-H. Chae 2025 introduced a Bayesian methodology to infer for each binary a posterior probability distribution of (nuisance) orbit parameters along with the gravitational boost (or anomaly) parameter \Gamma\equiv\log_{10}\sqrt{\gamma_{g}}\equiv\log_{10}\sqrt{G/G_{\rm N}}, (1) where G is the generalized gravitational parameter and G_{\rm N} is Newton’s constant. The individual PDFs of \Gamma are then statistically consolidated ( T. P. Hill & J. Miller 2011 ) for binaries having similar internal gravitational accelerations to derive \Gamma as a function of acceleration. The methodology was applied to a sample of 312 wide binaries with relative RV uncertainties <380 m s -2 selected from the Gaia DR3. One caveat of K.-H. Chae 2025 was that the orbit configuration suppressed one of the two parameters representing the direction of the orbit axis with respect to the observer’s view, in part because the observational constraints were not sufficient. For this reason, the K.-H. Chae 2025 methodology will be referred to as ‘simple Bayesian’ throughout. The purpose of this work is two-fold. One is to present a fully general version of the K.-H. Chae 2025 methodology that can be used for wide binaries with sufficiently precise measurements of all components of \mathbf{r} and \mathbf{v} . At present, such wide binaries are extremely rare, but it

Read the complete text