TeV-scale scalar leptoquarks motivated by B anomalies

improve Yukawa unification in SO(10) GUT · 2025

Read TeV-scale scalar leptoquarks motivated by B anomalies by improve Yukawa unification in SO(10) GUT (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-11745.txt.

Introduction

Xiyuan Gao and Ulrich Nierste connect two puzzles of particle physics in this two thousand twenty-five paper. Flavor anomalies, persistent mismatches between measurements of certain B meson decays and standard model predictions, are often explained by inventing new particles case by case. The explanation gains credibility if the new particles live inside a deeper theory fixing other problems. The authors embed TeV-scale scalar leptoquarks, their anomaly fix, into an SO(10) grand unified theory.

The extra fields change how standard model parameters run with energy. In particular, the leptoquarks bend the Yukawa couplings' evolution so that bottom-tau unification, a classic grand unification test, succeeds in a minimal SO(10) model. Adding a second fermion multiplet with small flavor-violating terms makes leptoquark flavor violation grow under evolution while the Higgs's stays small. Mass splittings inside the model's large multiplet amplify the effect from tiny starting perturbations.

Catalog record

CREATORimprove Yukawa unification in SO(10) GUT
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-11745

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

TeV-scale scalar leptoquarks motivated by B anomalies improve Yukawa unification in SO(10) GUT Abstract It is common practice to explain deviations between data and Standard-Model predictions by postulating new particles at the TeV scale ad-hoc. This approach becomes much more convincing, if one successfully embeds the postulated particles into a UV completion which addresses other conceptual or phenomenological shortcomings of the SM. We present a study of an SO(10) grand unified theory which contains scalar leptoquark fields employed to explain the “flavour anomalies” in b → s b\rightarrow s and b → c b\rightarrow c decays. We find that the additional degrees of freedom improve the renormalization group evolution of the SM parameters and may explain some of the observed fermion masses. In particular, the light leptoquarks modify the renormalization-group evolution of the Yukawa couplings such that successful bottom-tau unification becomes possible in a minimal SO(10) GUT with only a 126 126 -plet coupling to fermions. P3H-25-058, TTP25-027 1 Introduction Grand unification theories (GUTs) Georgi:1974sy ; Fritzsch:1974nn offer an appealing framework for new physics beyond the Standard Model (SM). One of their key successes is the explanation of the quantization of hypercharge in units of the weak isospin, which implies the quantization of electric charge in a way that neutron and neutrinos are electrically neutral. No fundamental principles within the SM can forbid deviations from this pattern Foot:1992ui ; Babu:1989tq , but it has been tested to extremely high precision; for instance, the neutron charge is constrained to be smaller than about 10^{-21}~e Bressi:2011yfa . This puzzle reflects the arbitrariness in constructing anomaly-free representations of the SM gauge group G_{\text{SM}}=SU(3)_{C}\times SU(2)_{L}\times U(1)_{Y} , while, by contrast, the quantum numbers of SM fermions do not appear random in reality, but directly point to an extended symmetry: Each generation, with a right-handed neutrino, fits neatly into the spinor representation 16_{F} of SO(10). ‘Unifiability’ is a rare feature among all possible anomaly-free assignments of G_{\text{SM}} representation Herms:2024krp , and strongly suggests that the fundamental gauge group of nature is a single semi-simple group G_{\text{GUT}} , such as SU(5) or SO(10) containing G_{\text{SM}} as a subgroup. Moreover, various fits to gauge coupling unification for SO(10) suggest that the GUT breaking scale M_{\text{GUT}} lies around 10^{16} GeV Deshpande:1992au ; Deshpande:1992em ; Bertolini:2009qj ; Ohlsson:2019sja , in principle making the GUT idea testable by future proton decay experiments Hyper-Kamiokande:2018ofw ; Dev:2022jbf . GUTs predict that gauge coupling unify. With the measured values of the SM gauge couplings one finds that this feature holds qualitatively, as the couplings converge to each other at high energies, but fails quantitatively Amaldi:1991cn ; Langacker:1991an . Quantitative gauge coupling unification can be achieved in multiple ways by "populating the desert" between the electroweak scale and M_{\text{GUT}} . For example, in supersymmetric GUTs the superpartners of the SM particles with {\cal O}(1-100~\text{TeV}) masses make gauge unification possible, but one can also employ mass splittings among the members of the large Higgs multiplets to modify the renormalization group (RG) evolution of the couplings near M_{\text{GUT}} . This paper addresses the unification of Yukawa couplings. This topic has two key elements, the number of Higgs multiplets coupling to fermions and the light degrees of freedom invoked to change the RG evolution of the Yukawa couplings between the electroweak scale and M_{\text{GUT}} . Unfortunately, the most economical SU(5) or SO(10) Yukawa sectors fail in reproducing the observed fermion masses and mixing angles. It is instructive to study the wrong prediction of the b-\tau mass relation. New particles are required to achieve realistic fermion masses and mixings — either heavier than M_{\text{GUT}} (entering as effective operators Ellis:1979fg ; Preda:2022izo ; Preda:2024vas ) or lighter (such as additional scalars containing Higgs doublets Georgi:1979df ; Bajc:2002iw ; Babu:2016bmy ; Preda:2025afo or vector-like fermions Dorsner:2014wva ; Babu:2016cri ). The predictions of the most minimal GUTs are replaced by fits within minimal realistic models which contain additional free parameters; see Refs. Bajc:2005zf ; Joshipura:2011nn ; Dueck:2013gca ; Babu:2016bmy ; Ohlsson:2019sja ; Mummidi:2021anm ; Chen:2021zwn ; Patel:2022xxu ; Haba:2023dvo ; Chen:2024cht for examples of non-supersymmetric GUTs. Here with most minimal we mean GUTs in which only one Higgs multiplet couples to fermions, in the case of SO(10) the corresponding representations can be 10_{H} , 120_{H} , or 126_{H} . As a common feature of the proposed minimal realistic models, many robust and discriminative predictions of the most minimal GUT are lost. However, it would be premature to claim that most minimal GUTs are unrealistic: The loophole is the assumption of a particle desert between the electroweak and GUT scales, usually deduced from naturalness criteria Georgi:1979md . The impact of the deviation of the desert picture on Yukawa unification is best studied in supersymmetric GUTs, in which the infrared (IR) theory is the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM). The threshold correction to the matching relation between SM and MSSM Yukawa couplings can be enhanced when \tan\beta , the ratio of the vacuum expectation values (VEVs) of the two MSSM Higgs doublets, is large Hall:1993gn ; Carena:1993ag ; Carena:1999py ; Diaz-Cruz:2000nvf ; Girrbach:2011an ; Deppisch:2018flu . This fact changes the predictions of minimal GUT, and together with successful gauge coupling unification, has been viewed as indirect support for low-scale supersymmetry. However, the SUSY GUT is far from minimal. It requires many more physical particles than the non-SUSY one, and the huge number of physical degrees of freedom brings a new puzzle that perturbative expansion could fail Milagre:2024wcg ; Bajc:2016efj . Recently, the authors of Ref. Patel:2023gwt ; Shukla:2024bwf proposed a new idea, that the wrong b-\tau mass relation in minimal SU(5) can be resolved by introducing a large mass hierarchy among the particles within the same scalar multiplet. This hierarchy requires that some particles lie far below the M_{\text{GUT}} , and suggests the desert picture together with the naturalness criterion should be reconsidered. The wrong fermion mass pattern does not necessarily falsify the minimal GUT; rather, it implies that SM alone cannot serve as a viable IR theory. Some scalar particles from the GUT sector need to be included in the light spectrum. In some cases, such particles also lead to successful gauge coupling unification; see, for instance, Ref. Dorsner:2005fq ; Bajc:2006ia ; Preda:2022izo ; Preda:2024vas . From a different perspective, doubts on the particle desert picture are nurtured by experimental data on flavor-changing B meson decays. For more than a decade several observables related to b\to s\mu^{+}\mu^{-} or b\to c\tau\nu decays have been found to deviate form their SM predictions. The current status of the "flavor anomalies" is as follows: b\to c\tau\nu is probed through the ratios of branching ratios R(D^{(*)})=\text{BR}(B\to D^{(*)}\tau\nu)/\text{BR}(B\to D^{(*)}\ell\nu) ( \ell=e,\mu) and polarisation data with very robust theory predictions, because the only non-perturbative quantity involved is a ratio of form factors multiplying a term suppressed by the mass ratio m_{\tau}^{2}/m_{B}^{2} . An analysis exploiting experimental information on form factor shapes finds the combined b\to c\tau\nu data deviating from the SM predictions by 4.4 \sigma Iguro:2024hyk . A recent paper calculating form factors from first principles finds compatible results with slightly larger theory uncertainties. Moreover, if one tried to change the form factor ratio in R(D^{*}) to a level that the data are reproduced, predictions of measured polarisation data

Read the complete text