Anomaly cancellation for a U ( 1 ) U(1) factor
Ben Gripaios, and Khoi Le Nguyen Nguyen · 2025
Read Anomaly cancellation for a U ( 1 ) U(1) factor by Ben Gripaios, and Khoi Le Nguyen Nguyen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-11583.txt.
Introduction
In particle physics, a theory with a U(1) symmetry is consistent only if certain anomaly equations cancel, and finding charge assignments that do so can be a hunt. Ben Gripaios and Khoi Nguyen apply arithmetic geometry in 2025 to solve those equations for a single U(1) factor, given that one solution exists. The equations carve out a cubic surface in projective space.
A theorem of Kollár says such surfaces are usually unirational, so secant and tangent tricks can generate infinitely many solutions from a few. For the Standard Model's algebra, even with one generation plus two sterile neutrinos, infinitely many anomaly-free hypercharge assignments follow. Whether the trick finds every solution stays open.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ben Gripaios, and Khoi Le Nguyen Nguyen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-11583
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Anomaly cancellation for a U ( 1 ) U(1) factor Ben Gripaios, and Khoi Le Nguyen Nguyen Abstract We use methods of arithmetic geometry to solve the abelian local anomaly cancellation conditions for a four-dimensional gauge theory whose Lie algebra has a single 𝔲 1 \mathfrak{u}_{1} summand, assuming that a solution exists. The resulting polynomial equations in the integer 𝔲 1 \mathfrak{u}_{1} charges define a projective cubic hypersurface over the field of rational numbers. Generically, such a hypersurface is (by a theorem of Kollár) a unirational variety, making it possible to find a finitely-many-to-one parametrization of all solutions (of which there are necessarily infinitely many). (Otherwise, such a hypersurface is either reducible or is a cone over an elliptic curve and all solutions can again be found in practice.) As an example, for the Standard Model Lie algebra with its three generations of quarks and leptons (or even with just a single generation and two 𝔰 𝔲 3 ⊕ 𝔰 𝔲 2 \mathfrak{su}_{3}\oplus\mathfrak{su}_{2} -singlet right-handed neutrinos), it follows that there are infinitely many anomaly-free possibilities for the 𝔲 1 \mathfrak{u}_{1} hypercharges. 1 Introduction For a gauge quantum field theory to make sense, anomalies must cancel. For even the most basic kind of anomaly, namely the local (a.k.a. perturbative) anomaly arising from chiral fermions, the problem of finding the anomaly-free representations of the gauge Lie algebra is a tough one, since it boils down to solving polynomial equations in the integers 1 1 1 For the abelian summand of the Lie algebra, these integers are the charges; for the semisimple summand, they are the Dynkin labels. that label the representations. There has recently been significant progress in attacking this problem in four spacetime dimensions, beginning in Costa_2019 with the observation that in the simplest case of the Lie algebra \mathfrak{u}_{1} (as in, e.g. , quantum electrodynamics) with an arbitrary fixed number of charges, there is a way to produce a new solution from a pair of old ones. In Allanach_2020 , it was shown that this construction is an ancient one in arithmetic geometry (where it goes by the name of either the method of chords or of secants) and that it can be used to find all solutions. In brief, the polynomial equations define a projective variety over the field \mathbb{Q} of rational numbers, 2 2 2 Since \mathbb{Q} is not algebraically complete, we should work in the setting of schemes . But we shall use the lingua franca of varieties in the hope of remaining readable by physicists. with the points corresponding to nonchiral (a.k.a. vectorlike) solutions forming linear subspaces; by choosing a disjoint pair of such subspaces whose dimensions sum to that of the variety itself, one can be sure that some secant between them goes through any other point in projective space, ergo every point on the variety corresponding to a chiral solution. To use the jargon, 3 3 3 The jargon is admittedly confusing for the initiate, owing to the fact that we have both rational numbers and rational functions in mathematics. By way of clarification, here a variety over the rationals , on the one hand, means a variety whose defining equations have coefficients lying in \mathbb{Q} , while a rational point is one whose coordinates lie in \mathbb{Q} , rather than some field extension thereof. The notions of rational variety and unirational variety that follow, on the other hand, involve rational functions and make sense for a variety over any field. this argument shows that the variety is a rational variety. Roughly (we shall be more precise later), this means that we can use rational functions to define a bijective map from almost all of projective space 4 4 4 Namely, away from the vanishing loci of the denominators of the rational functions. to almost all of the variety; this map provides a 1-1 parameterization of almost all of the points and the remaining points can be found with a little extra work. In this paper, we examine a case which is much more general and seemingly much more forbidding: namely, we suppose that the Lie algebra corresponding to the gauge group has \mathfrak{u}_{1} as its abelian summand. 5 5 5 The case with an abelian summand of higher rank will be discussed elsewhere Gripaios_toappear_fano . In other words, it may have an arbitrary semisimple part, such as the \mathfrak{su}_{2}\oplus\mathfrak{su}_{3} of the Standard Model. This will be a sum of n simple summands. Here the problem itself decouples into a sum of two parts. The first part is to ensure that the anomaly of the semisimple summand cancels. This reduces to the problem of finding the anomaly-free representations of the simple Lie algebras \mathfrak{su}_{N} , with N\geq 3 . This part is far from being completely solved, but again there has been encouraging progress Gripaios_2024_irreducible ; Gripaios_2025_products . We will have nothing more to say about it here, supposing instead that, as our starting point, we are given an anomaly-free representation of the semisimple summand. This will be a sum of m irreducible representations. Our task, then, is to solve the second part of problem, which is to deal with the \mathfrak{u}_{1} summand. Even this part is still much harder than the pure \mathfrak{u}_{1} case, for two reasons. Firstly, we have n additional equations in the m unknown integer \mathfrak{u}_{1} charges to satisfy, coming from the mixed anomalies between each simple summand and the \mathfrak{u}_{1} summand. Secondly, the coefficients of the equations now depend on the choice of semisimple summand and its representation, via the integer dimensions and Dynkin indices. Nevertheless, we will see that it is again possible to completely solve for the allowed charges in all cases where there exists as least one solution. 6 6 6 We have not found any non-trivial examples with no solutions. Such a case would certainly be interesting, but not for physics! The reason that this is possible is that the n additional equations are homogeneous and linear in the m charges, so the equations may still be considered as defining a projective cubic hypersurface. These are objects of intense study in algebraic geometry and much is known. In particular, it is known that such a cubic hypersurface (over any field!) is typically (again, we will be more precise later) a unirational variety Kollar_2002 . Roughly, unirational means that we can use rational functions to define a surjective map from almost all of projective space to almost all of the variety; this map provides a finitely-many-to-one parameterization of almost all of the solutions. The remaining solutions in such cases can, as we will see, be found with a little extra work. We must also, of course, deal with atypical cases of cubic hypersurfaces. These correspond either to the hypersurface being reducible, in which case it is a union of a hyperplane and a quadric and all rational points are easily found, or an elliptic curve (or a cone thereon), in which case the usual arsenal of techniques can be deployed to find the rational points Silverman_1992 . As well as allowing us to write down explicit formulæ for the solutions, our methods allow us to draw an important qualitative conclusion for physics. Namely,