Quest for particles production in the plane gravitational wave spacetime
Nail Khusnutdinov · 2025
Read Quest for particles production in the plane gravitational wave spacetime by Nail Khusnutdinov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-11558.txt.
Introduction
Spacetime itself might create particles when it ripples, and a passing plane gravitational wave is the cleanest test case. Nail Khusnutdinov computes the Green's functions for massless scalar and vector fields in that background, in closed form, three independent ways. One route solves the governing equation directly; the other two build the answer recursively through classic schemes from quantum field theory in curved spacetime.
All three routes agree exactly with the standard expansion used in the field. That agreement points to no massless particles being produced by the wave at all. Khusnutdinov also addresses a rival line of work whose coefficient calculations predicted creation, explaining why the closed-form result should stand. The dispute matters because particle creation by gravity underpins ideas from Hawking radiation onward.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nail Khusnutdinov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-11558
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quest for particles production in the plane gravitational wave spacetime Nail Khusnutdinov Abstract Massless vector and scalar Green’s functions are obtained in closed form for a plane gravitational wave spacetime using three independent methods: direct solution of the Green-function equation and construction via the DeWitt and Hadamard recursive schemes. The results coincide exactly with the DeWitt–Schwinger expansion, indicating no massless particles production in this background. Contrasting interpretations, based on Bogolyubov coefficient calculations predicting massless particle creation, are also addressed. 1 Introduction The problem of particle production was first addressed in the early development of quantum electrodynamics. One of the most notable predictions in this context was made by J. Schwinger [ 1 ] , who demonstrated that a strong external electric field can induce particle creation from the vacuum – a phenomenon now known as the Schwinger effect . In this scenario, the vacuum becomes unstable under the influence of the external field [ 2 ] , leading to the creation of particle–antiparticle pairs. Gravitational fields can likewise produce particles, a possibility first predicted in the early 1960s [ 3 , 4 ] (see also the historical account by L. Parker [ 5 ] ). The most famous example of particle production by a gravitational field is Hawking radiation [ 6 , 7 ] . Comprehensive discussions of particle creation in gravitational backgrounds can now be found in several monographs [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . Various methods have been proposed to compute the vacuum expectation value of the energy–momentum tensor. The most widely used is the point-splitting method [ 8 ] , in which the energy–momentum tensor is expressed as the action of a two–point differential operator on the renormalized Green’s function, followed by the coincidence limit. Renormalization in this approach consists of subtracting from the Green’s function its DeWitt–Schwinger adiabatic expansion. Another common technique is the Pauli–Villars subtraction method [ 13 ] , in which each Green’s function in a Feynman diagram is renormalized by subtracting analogous functions with large regulator masses, which are taken to infinity at the end of the calculation (see also the modified Pauli–Villars method in Ref. [ 14 ] ). The Bogolyubov method (see, e.g., [ 10 , 2 ] ) is likewise based on the concept of an unstable vacuum. The fields are assumed to be free in the infinitely distant past and future, but with different vacuum states – commonly referred to as the in and out vacua. The annihilation operators that annihilate the in vacuum do not, in general, annihilate the out vacuum. A linear transformation between the annihilation and creation operators of the in and out vacua involves two parameters, known as the Bogolyubov coefficients. One of these coefficients characterizes scattering, while the other determines the density of created particles. In principle, the Bogolyubov method and the vacuum expectation value approach should yield identical results; however, this equivalence does not hold in the case of a plane gravitational wave background. The interaction between gravitational waves (GWs) and electromagnetic waves (EMWs) has a long history. Within classical physics, the conversion of weak GWs to EMWs – and vice versa – in the presence of external electric or magnetic fields was first considered by Gertsenshtein in 1962 [ 15 ] and later in Refs. [ 16 , 17 , 18 ] . In the framework of quantum gravity in the weak–field approximation [ 19 , 20 ] , the cross sections of such processes have been calculated (see, e.g., [ 21 ] ); the effect is proportional to the square of the external electric or magnetic field strength. The conversion of weak GWs to EMWs in the absence of external electromagnetic fields has been investigated in Refs. [ 22 , 23 ] , with the corresponding cross section scaling as (G/c^{3})^{2} , where G is the gravitational constant and c is the speed of light. The Green function for a scalar field in a plane gravitational-wave spacetime was first derived by Gibbons [ 24 ] , who demonstrated that it coincides exactly with its DeWitt–Schwinger expansion. This result implies that plane gravitational waves do not induce scalar particle production. In contrast, Refs. [ 25 , 26 , 27 ] present a different scenario for massless scalar fields, suggesting that particle production may occur when the particle momenta are exactly aligned with the propagation direction of the gravitational wave. This claim is based on the analysis of the Bogolyubov coefficient \beta , which quantifies the particle number density. The Bogolyubov approach, originally developed by Garriga and Verdaguer [ 28 ] , yields \beta=0 for massive particles, confirming the results of Ref. [ 24 ] . However, Refs. [ 25 , 26 , 27 ] argue that in the massless case, \beta can be nonzero when the gravitational-wave and particle momenta are precisely collinear. Specifically, \beta is proportional to \delta(k_{v}+l_{v}) , where k_{v}=\omega-k_{x} and l_{v}=\omega^{\prime}-l_{x} are the v -components of the wave vectors of the in and out scalar modes 1 1 1 \omega and \omega^{\prime} are frequencies of in and out scalar waves, correspondingly, and the direction of propagation of the gravitational wave is the axis x . . For massive particles, k_{v}+l_{v}>0 , ensuring \beta=0 ; for massless particles, the sum can vanish, allowing \beta\neq 0 . This leads to an apparent tension between the DeWitt–Schwinger and Bogolyubov approaches in the context of plane gravitational wave backgrounds (for a comparative discussion, see Refs. [ 8 , 9 ] ). In this work, we compute the Green function for the vector (Maxwell) field using three complementary methods: direct integration of the Maxwell equations, the DeWitt–Schwinger expansion, and the Hadamard elementary solution. We show that the retarded Green function for the vector potential has support not only on the past light cone but also within its interior. By contrast, the Green function of the physical electromagnetic field (the field-strength tensor) is supported strictly on the past light cone. This property, in the context of the Huygens principle, was previously noted in Ref. [ 29 ] for fields of (0,1,2)-form type, and for the Maxwell field in Ref. [ 30 ] in the context of self-force calculations. The paper is organized as follows. Sec. 2 reviews the general properties of plane gravitational waves and establishes a convenient computational frame. Sec. 3 presents the derivation of the scalar and massless vector Green functions. Sec. 4 discusses the results and their physical implications. 2 The geometry, biscalar, bivector and frame Let us first consider the general form of a plane gravitational wave propagating in the x -direction. The corresponding metric 2 2 2 Hereafter, i,j=2,3=y,z , u,v=(t\mp x)/\sqrt{2} , \mu,\nu=u,v,y,z , and \sqrt{-\textsl{g}}=L^{2} . The overdot is derivative with respect to u . (a),(b)=0,1,2,3 are frame indexes, \mathrm{x}=(u,v,y,z) – event in spacetime and \mathrm{dx}=\sqrt{-\textsl{g}(\mathrm{x})}\mathrm{d}^{4}\mathrm{x} is the invariant measure. The units with c=G=\hbar=1 are used. can be written as (see, e.g., [ 31 ] ) \mathrm{d}s^{2}=-2\mathrm{d}u\mathrm{d}v+\gamma_{ij}(u)\mathrm{d}x^{i}\mathrm{d}x^{j}. (1) The coordinates in which the metric takes the form ( 1 ) are known as Baldwin–Jeffery–Rosen (BJR) coordinates, named after the works [ 32 , 33 ] in which this representation first appeared. It is well established that the spacetime geometry of a plane