On the set of atoms and strong atoms in additive monoids of cyclic semidomains

Jiya Dani, Anna Deng, Marly Gotti, Bryan Li, Arav Paladiya, Joseph Vulakh, Jason Zeng · 2025

Read On the set of atoms and strong atoms in additive monoids of cyclic semidomains by Jiya Dani, Anna Deng, Marly Gotti, Bryan Li, Arav Paladiya, Joseph Vulakh, Jason Zeng (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-11319.txt.

Introduction

Jiya Dani and six co-authors ask which combinations of atom counts can occur in a family of number systems built from algebraic numbers. Their 2025 paper works with additive monoids of cyclic semidomains, where atoms are the unfactorable building blocks. A strong atom is stricter still: every power of it factors in exactly one way.

For each algebraic number, its monoid has some count of atoms and some count of strong atoms. The pair is called realizable when some number produces it. The team's goal is to map which pairs occur, hunting whole families of examples as a step toward the full classification. The atomic structure, they note, braids number theory with semigroup theory in intricate ways. The paper stakes out new territory in that map.

Catalog record

CREATORJiya Dani, Anna Deng, Marly Gotti, Bryan Li, Arav Paladiya, Joseph Vulakh, Jason Zeng
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-11319

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the set of atoms and strong atoms in additive monoids of cyclic semidomains Jiya Dani, Anna Deng, Marly Gotti, Bryan Li, Arav Paladiya, Joseph Vulakh, Jason Zeng Abstract . Let M M be a cancellative and commutative monoid. A non-invertible element of M M is called an atom (or irreducible element) if it cannot be factored into two non-invertible elements, while an atom a a of M M is called strong if a n a^{n} has a unique factorization in M M for every n ∈ ℕ n\in\mathbb{N} . The monoid M M is atomic if every non-invertible element factors into finitely many atoms (repetitions allowed). For an algebraic number α \alpha , we let M α M_{\alpha} denote the additive monoid of the subsemiring ℕ 0 ​ [ α ] \mathbb{N}_{0}[\alpha] of ℂ \mathbb{C} . The atomic structure of M α M_{\alpha} reflects intricate interactions between algebraic number theory and additive semigroup theory. For m , n ∈ ℕ 0 ∪ { ∞ } m,n\in\mathbb{N}_{0}\cup\{\infty\} (with m ≤ n m\leq n ), the pair ( m , n ) (m,n) is called realizable if there exists an algebraic number α ∈ ℂ \alpha\in\mathbb{C} such that M α M_{\alpha} has m m strong atoms and n n atoms. Our primary goal is to identify classes of realizable pairs with the long-term goal of providing a complete description of the full set of realizable pairs. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 20M13, 11R04, 20M14; Secondary: 16Y60, 11S05, 11R09 1. Introduction The study of factorizations in algebraic structures such as commutative monoids, rings, and semirings has become a vibrant area of modern algebra, intersecting with combinatorics [ 1 ] , number theory [ 17 ] , and geometry [ 18 ] . A particularly rich framework for these investigations is provided by additive monoids arising from commutative semidomains [ 4 ] , especially the so-called simple extensions \mathbb{N}_{0}[\alpha] of the semidomain \mathbb{N}_{0} for all \alpha\in\mathbb{A} , where \mathbb{A} denotes the set of all algebraic numbers (see [ 2 , 8 ] and references therein). For each \alpha\in\mathbb{A} , we denote by M_{\alpha} the underlying additive monoid of the semidomain \mathbb{N}_{0}[\alpha] . The atomic structure of M_{\alpha} is tightly connected to the arithmetic and algebraic properties of the minimal polynomial of \alpha , denoted m_{\alpha}(x) throughout this paper. A nonzero element of M_{\alpha} is called an atom if it cannot be expressed in M_{\alpha} as a sum of two nonzero elements. We let \mathscr{A}(M_{\alpha}) denote the set of all atoms of M_{\alpha} . The monoid M_{\alpha} is said to be atomic if every nonzero element can be written as a sum of finitely many atoms (repetitions allowed). It was shown in [ 8 , Theorem 4.2] that M_{\alpha} is atomic if and only if 1 is an atom; in this case, \mathscr{A}(M_{\alpha})=\{1,\alpha,\dots,\alpha^{n}\} for some n\in\mathbb{N}_{0} when M_{\alpha} is finitely generated while \mathscr{A}(M_{\alpha})=\{\alpha^{n}:n\in\mathbb{N}_{0}\} when M_{\alpha} is not finitely generated. An atom a in M_{\alpha} is called a strong atom if, for each n\in\mathbb{N} , the only decomposition of na as a finite sum of atoms in M_{\alpha} is the obvious one, which consists of n copies of a . The set of all strong atoms of M_{\alpha} is denoted by \mathscr{S}(M_{\alpha}) . It follows from the definition of a strong atom that \mathscr{S}(M_{\alpha})\subseteq\mathscr{A}(M_{\alpha}) . A nonzero p\in M_{\alpha} is defined to be a prime if for all b,c\in M_{\alpha} , the condition b+c\in p+M_{\alpha} implies that either b\in p+M_{\alpha} or c\in p+M_{\alpha} . The set of all primes of M_{\alpha} is denoted by \mathscr{P}(M_{\alpha}) . Clearly, every prime in M_{\alpha} is a strong atom. It was established in [ 3 ] (CrowdMath 2022) that, for each positive algebraic number \alpha\in\mathbb{A} , the monoid M_{\alpha} contains prime elements if and only if it is a unique factorization monoid (UFM). In such a case, one has \mathscr{P}(M_{\alpha})=\mathscr{S}(M_{\alpha})=\mathscr{A}(M_{\alpha})=\{\alpha^{n}:n\in\llbracket 0,d-1\rrbracket\}, where d is the degree of the minimal polynomial of \alpha . However, as we will see in Example 3.1 and Theorem 3.6 , the monoid M_{\alpha} may contain strong atoms even when it is not a UFM. More generally, the notions of atoms, strong atoms, and primes can be defined for any commutative cancellative monoid M analogously to the way we have just defined these notions in M_{\alpha} . For such a monoid M , we obtain the natural inclusions (1.1) \mathscr{P}(M)\subseteq\mathscr{S}(M)\subseteq\mathscr{A}(M), where \mathscr{P}(M) , \mathscr{S}(M) , and \mathscr{A}(M) denote the sets of primes, strong atoms, and atoms of M , respectively. For an integral domain R , we let R^{*} denote its multiplicative monoid (the multiplicative monoid consisting of all nonzero elements of R ). In the recent paper [ 12 ] , Fadinger et al. study the chain of inclusions ( 1.1 ) in the setting of multiplicative monoids of integral domains, providing explicit examples of atomic integral domains that exhibit each of the eight possible combinations regarding the existence or absence of primes, strong atoms that are not atoms, and atoms. The first systematic study of the atomic and factorization-theoretic structure of the family of monoids M_{\alpha} was carried out by Correa-Morris and Gotti in [ 8 ] . Motivated by their investigation, we undertake a detailed analysis of the sets of atoms and the sets of strong atoms in the monoids M_{\alpha} with the aim of determining the possible pairs (|\mathscr{S}(M_{\alpha}))|,|\mathscr{A}(M_{\alpha})|) as \alpha varies over \mathbb{A} . Since we have already observed that M_{\alpha} is a UFM precisely when it contains primes, we focus our attention on the sets \mathscr{A}(M_{\alpha}) and \mathscr{S}(M_{\alpha}) and disregard \mathscr{P}(M_{\alpha}) in our analysis. We say that a pair (m,n)\in\mathbb{N}_{0}^{2} is realizable if it belongs to the set \big\{(|\mathscr{S}(M_{\alpha})|,|\mathscr{A}(M_{\alpha})|):\alpha\in\mathbb{A}\big\}. In this paper, we try to understand which pairs of \mathbb{N}_{0}^{2} are realizable. Towards this end, we introduce and analyze the function f\colon\mathbb{A}\to(\mathbb{N}_{0}\cup\{\infty\})^{2} defined as follows: f(\alpha):=(|\mathscr{S}(M_{\alpha})|,|\mathscr{A}(M_{\alpha})|) for all \alpha\in\mathbb{A} . The function f describes the number of strong atoms and atoms of the associated monoid M_{\alpha} . We identify various realizable and non-realizable pairs, provide constructive methods to produce algebraic numbers \alpha for which f(\alpha) assumes prescribed values, and examine how transformations of minimal polynomials (such as the substitution x\mapsto x^{k} ) affect atomic and factorization-theoretic properties. Our results shed new light on the algebraic and combinatorial behavior of the monoids M_{\alpha} and establish connections to classical results, including Descartes’ Rule of Signs and Curtiss’ Theorem. This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we introduce the notation, terminology, and known results that we shall use throughout the paper. Then in Section 4 , we determine the pairs of \mathbb{N}_{0}^{2} that are realizable by the algebraic numbers of degree 2 , namely, those algebraic numbers whose minimal polynomials have degree 2 . Finally, in Section 5 , we first prove that for every (k,c)\in\mathbb{N}\times\mathbb{N}_{0} , the pair (4k+c,5k+c) is realizable, and we then prove that the pair (n,n+1) is realizable if and only if n\geq 4 . This last result also illustrates that not every pair (m,n)\in\mathbb{N}_{0}^{2} with m\leq n is a realizable pair. 2. Background 2.1. General Notation Throughout this paper, we let \mathbb{Z} , \mathbb{Q} , \mathbb{R} , \mathbb{A} , and \mathbb{C} stand, as usual, for the set integers, rational numbers, real numbers, algebraic complex

Read the complete text