Echoes and quasinormal modes of asymmetric black bounces

A. C. L. Santos, L. A. Lessa, R. V. Maluf, G. J. Olmo · 2025

Read Echoes and quasinormal modes of asymmetric black bounces by A. C. L. Santos, L. A. Lessa, R. V. Maluf, G. J. Olmo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-11096.txt.

Introduction

Santos, Lessa, Maluf, and Olmo studied the ringing of black bounce objects in twenty twenty-five. Black bounces are regular alternatives to black holes, sourced here by anisotropic fluids; some versions keep a horizon, others do not. When disturbed, such objects ring at characteristic tones called quasinormal modes, and layered potentials can produce late echoes.

The team derived the effective potential for massless scalar waves and computed the tones three independent ways, which agreed. Symmetric bounces with horizons show the standard single-barrier potential. Horizonless ones can show several barriers, and those generate gravitational wave echoes sensitive to the fluid's density and the bounce's size parameter. Asymmetric versions, matching the charged Reissner-Nordström solution outside, ring without echoes, making them hard to tell from ordinary charged black holes.

Catalog record

CREATORA. C. L. Santos, L. A. Lessa, R. V. Maluf, G. J. Olmo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-11096

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Echoes and quasinormal modes of asymmetric black bounces A. C. L. Santos, L. A. Lessa, R. V. Maluf, G. J. Olmo Abstract We study quasinormal modes and echoes of symmetric and asymmetric black bounce solutions generated by anisotropic fluids within the framework of general relativity. We derive the effective potential governing massless scalar fields and compute the corresponding quasinormal mode spectra using three independent methods: sixth-order WKB, Pöschl–Teller and time-domain evolution. Our results show that symmetric black bounce configurations with horizons yield a standard single-barrier potential, while horizonless solutions may exhibit multiple potential barriers that generate gravitational wave echoes. These echoes are sensitive to model parameters such as the fluid energy density and the regularizing parameter a a that defines the minimal 2 − 2- sphere. The asymmetric models considered recover the Reissner–Nordström solution in their external region but can be bounded or unbounded in the inside, depending on the sign of a parameter. Both cases have similar qualitative properties as far as wave emission is concerned but show no echoes. This makes it very difficult to distinguish them from standard Reissner–Nordström configurations. I Introduction One of the main open questions in theoretical physics is understanding the behavior of gravity in strong-field scenarios. Despite the experimental success of general relativity (GR) Will:2014kxa , the conceptual challenges posed by singularities Penrose:1964wq ; Geroch:1968ut in scenarios involving natural matter sources suggest that the theory should be improved in some way, leaving observable imprints at some scales. This million dollar question has stimulated a good deal of activity in the theoretical physics community in many diverse fronts. In this sense, recent years have seen a rise in phenomenological models aiming to “resolve” these singularities within a classical framework, without relying on prior knowledge of the underlying mechanisms of a potential quantum theory of gravity Malafarina:2017csn ; Kelly:2020lec ; Bambi:2013caa . Among the most widely investigated models in this regard, black bounces Simpson:2018tsi appear as a reasonable alternative to traditional black holes, and even may emerge in non-perturbative quantum gravity approaches Muniz:2024wiv . The term black bounce was first coined in a seminal paper by Visser and Simpson Simpson:2018tsi . These objects are characterized by smoothly interpolating between nonsingular black holes and wormholes, depending on a single free parameter that can be tuned at will. Specifically, for spherically symmetric configurations, the area of the 2-spheres is constrained to have a lower bound or “bounce”. When this minimal sphere is hidden behind an event horizon, one speaks of a black bounce Lobo:2020ffi ; Mazza:2021rgq . These objects are (usually) free from singularities because the bound in the radial sector keeps curvature invariants finite and, crucially, allows geodesic congruences to reexpand beyond the throat, guaranteeing geodesic completeness LimaJunior:2025uyj ; Carballo-Rubio:2019fnb . Since the areal function is key to keeping curvature invariants in these models within finite bounds, it is important to understand how the matter sources contribute to shape the radial sector of the metric. In Bronnikov:2021uta it was shown that the Simpson-Visser metric is supported by a matter content consisting of nonlinear electrodynamics plus a phantom scalar field, with the electromagnetic source corresponding to a magnetic charge. Interestingly, these solutions can also be replicated by considering an electrically charged source Alencar:2024yvh . Furthermore, the relation between these models and modified gravitational dynamics has been explored in Alencar:2024nxi ; Junior:2024vrv ; Junior:2024cbb ; Atazadeh:2023wdw ; Fabris:2023opv . Their impact on various physical observables, including gravitational lensing Nascimento:2020ime ; Cheng:2021hoc ; Islam:2021ful ; Ghosh:2022mka , black hole shadows Guerrero:2021ues ; Olmo:2023lil ; Guerrero:2022qkh , and gravitational wave echoes Silva:2024fpn ; Ou:2021efv ; Yang:2021cvh , among other phenomena Franzin:2022iai ; Zhang:2022zox ; Yang:2022ryf ; Javed:2023iih ; daSilva:2023jxa , have also been extensively investigated. In all these works, the condition g_{tt}=g_{rr}^{-1} was assumed. However, new classes of black bounce solutions can be derived by relaxing this condition, as demonstrated recently in Ref. Lessa:2024erf . These solutions are supported by an anisotropic fluid that adheres to certain simplifying constraints on the matter content. Specific examples of such fluids are nonlinear theories of electrodynamics. Leaving aside theoretical considerations and focusing on observational aspects, the recent detection of gravitational waves by LIGO/Virgo from the mergers of binary black holes LIGOScientific:2016aoc ; LIGOScientific:2016sjg ; LIGOScientific:2017bnn ; LIGOScientific:2017ycc and binary neutron stars LIGOScientific:2017vwq has significantly heightened the relevance of studying gravitational wave emissions from massive compact objects. The ringdown phase of such mergers can be described using perturbation theory and is characterized by a set of complex frequencies known as quasinormal modes (QNMs), where the real part is associated with the oscillation frequency and the imaginary part with the damping rate. Interestingly, these complex frequencies depend essentially on the parameters that characterize the interaction between the spacetime and the corresponding test field — such as mass, charge and angular momentum Berti:2009kk . For this reason, the computation of QNMs has also become a focus of intense research Konoplya:2025hgp ; Volkel:2018hwb ; Magalhaes:2023xya ; Konoplya:2025mvj ; Alfaro:2024tdr , including black bounce scenarios Yang:2022ryf ; Wu:2022eiv ; Ou:2021efv ; Guo:2021wid . In particular, investigations of scalar perturbations for a background described by the rotating Simpson-Visser solution can be found in Ref. Franzin:2022iai . Any deviation from the classical black-hole paradigm is expected to leave a distinct imprint on the QNM spectrum and, consequently, provide a means to distinguish between different spacetime configurations, as demonstrated in wormhole-like models featuring multiple potential barriers and gravitational wave echoes Bambi:2025wjx . The spectroscopic characterization of compact objects is thus a line of research that is gaining momentum in recent years Volkel:2025jdx ; Berti:2025hly ; Furuta:2024jpw ; Moreira:2023cxy ; Cardoso:2019rvt ; Dreyer:2003bv . In this sense, the main goal of this work is to examine the ringdown phase of the previously mentioned exact compact object solutions in the context of general relativity Lessa:2024erf , focusing on the propagation of linear test fields, which describe scalar perturbations minimally coupled to the metric. We compute the QNM spectrum using three independent methods —sixth-order WKB (Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin) expansion, Pöschl–Teller approximation, and time-domain integration— finding good agreement among the results. In addition, we investigate the possible emergence of gravitational wave echoes arising from the structure of the effective potential in horizonless configurations. In particular, we will consider two different types of black bounces, one representing a standard symmetric object, built in terms of the Kiselev solution and replacing r\to\sqrt{a^{2}+r^{2}} , and another illustrating an asymmetric bounce, which may transition to a bounded universe or to an unbounded universe, depending on the sign of a parameter. The relevance of this second example, which we will compare with a Reissner-Nordström geometry, lies in the fact that one can have three different geometries with similar properties away from the minimal 2-surface but completely different internal regions. Our goal is to determine if such different internal structures can be clearly identified by the observation of gravitational waves emission during the ringdown phase. As we will see, the interaction of waves with the internal regions not always allow to clearly distinguish them from other structures, such as a standard Reissner-Nordström configurations (naked or not). Our paper is organized as follows: In Sec. II , we introduce the symmetric and asymmetric black bounce geometries derived from GR coupled to an anisotropic fluid.

Read the complete text