Differential Physiological Responses to Proxemic and Facial Threats in Virtual Avatar Interactions
Birgit Nierula, Mustafa Tevfik Lafci, Anna Melnik, Mert Akgül, Farelle Toumaleu Siewe, Sebastian Bosse · 2025
Read Differential Physiological Responses to Proxemic and Facial Threats in Virtual Avatar Interactions by Birgit Nierula, Mustafa Tevfik Lafci, Anna Melnik, Mert Akgül, Farelle Toumaleu Siewe, Sebastian Bosse (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-10586.txt.
Introduction
Birgit Nierula and co-authors study personal space in virtual reality in a 2025 arXiv paper. People guard their personal space, and avatars can trigger the same reactions as real people. The team asked how threat cues and the phase of an encounter shape body responses.
Sixteen participants faced avatars that either intruded on their space or kept distance, with neutral or angry faces. Personal space limits were set for each person in advance. Skin conductance, heart rate measures, and discomfort ratings were recorded. Standing close after intrusion aroused people more than the approach itself. Angry faces lowered heart rate variability and raised discomfort.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Birgit Nierula, Mustafa Tevfik Lafci, Anna Melnik, Mert Akgül, Farelle Toumaleu Siewe, Sebastian Bosse |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-10586
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Differential Physiological Responses to Proxemic and Facial Threats in Virtual Avatar Interactions Birgit Nierula, Mustafa Tevfik Lafci, Anna Melnik, Mert Akgül, Farelle Toumaleu Siewe, Sebastian Bosse Abstract Proxemics, the study of spatial behavior, is fundamental to social interaction and increasingly relevant for virtual reality (VR) applications. While previous research has established that users respond to personal space violations in VR similarly as in real-world settings, phase-specific physiological responses and the modulating effects of facial expressions remain understudied. We investigated physiological and subjective responses to personal space violations by virtual avatars, to understand how threatening facial expressions and interaction phases (approach vs. standing) influence these responses. Sixteen participants experienced a 2×2 factorial design manipulating Personal Space (intrusion vs. respect) and Facial Expression (neutral vs. angry) while we recorded skin conductance response (SCR), heart rate variability (HRV), and discomfort ratings. Personal space boundaries were individually calibrated using a stop-distance procedure. Results show that SCR responses are significantly higher during the standing phase compared to the approach phase when personal space was violated, indicating that prolonged proximity within personal space boundaries is more physiologically arousing than the approach itself. Angry facial expressions significantly reduced HRV, reflecting decreased parasympathetic activity, and increased discomfort ratings, but did not amplify SCR responses. These findings demonstrate that different physiological modalities capture distinct aspects of proxemic responses: SCR primarily reflects spatial boundary violations, while HRV responds to facial threat cues. Our results provide insights for developing comprehensive multi-modal assessments of social behavior in virtual environments and inform the design of more realistic avatar interactions. \leadauthor Nierula Physiological Responses to Proxemic and Facial Threats keywords Proxemics | Personal Space | Virtual Reality | Electrodermal Activity | Skin Conductance Response | Electrocardiography | Psychophysiology {corrauthor} birgit.nierula and hhi.fraunhofer.de Introduction Proxemics refers to the study of how humans perceive and use space during communication and is a core pillar of non-verbal communication ( 1 ) . This field explores how spatial behavior reflects cultural context and is fundamental to organizing social interaction, making it particularly relevant for understanding avatar interactions in virtual environments. A key aspect of proxemics is the concept of personal space, which refers to the invisible space directly surrounding a person; violations to this space trigger physiological arousal and experienced discomfort ( 2 ) . Personal space represents a dynamic perception that plays an important role in social communication and behavior across species ( 3 , 4 ) . For example, the extent and shape of personal space boundaries can be influenced by personal factors ( 5 ) , social cues ( 6 ) , or cultural norms ( 7 ) . Regarding personal space perception, virtual reality (VR) users exhibit behaviors similar to those in real-world settings. Multiple studies confirm that users react to personal space violations in single- and multi-user VR scenarios ( 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ) . Beyond reported discomfort, participants exhibit elevated skin conductance response (SCR) to personal space violations in VR, with magnitudes comparable to those observed during violations between real humans ( 11 ) , and amplified responses with the number of avatars ( 9 ) . In the current study, we were interested in whether a threatening facial expression of the avatar would lead to additional changes in discomfort ratings and physiological parameters. Previous work demonstrates that angry facial expressions increase personal space ( 13 ) . Furthermore, angry faces evoke stronger SCRs than neutral faces ( 14 , 15 ) and elicit stronger changes in heart rate than happy faces ( 16 ) . Previous studies either investigated the phase when personal space was intruded upon in isolation ( 11 ) or examined approach and standing phases together ( 9 ) . However, the approach of another human could by itself constitute a threat. Consequently, the field still lacks (i) phase-specific autonomic markers of proxemic violations and (ii) evidence that an avatar’s facial affect modulates those markers. We address both gaps by combining SCR with heart rate variability (HRV) and orthogonally manipulating avatar facial expression (neutral vs. angry) during individually calibrated personal space intrusions. We tested the following hypotheses: H1—SCR will be larger during standing compared to the approach phases; H2—SCR will be larger for personal space intrusions than for respected distances; H3—angry facial expressions will further amplify SCR; H4—HRV will be smaller for personal space intrusions; H5—angry facial expressions will further decrease HRV, reflecting reduced parasympathetic activity. Methods Participants Twenty healthy volunteers (10 females) with normal or corrected-to-normal vision participated in the experiment. Four datasets were excluded due to acquisition problems, yielding 16 participants (mean age=26±5 years). This sample size matches prior proxemics studies ( 9 , 11 ) . Participants were naïve to the research question, provided written informed consent, and received monetary compensation. The local ethics committee approved the experiment. Virtual Reality Environment The virtual environment was developed in Unity (version 2020.3.20f1) and presented via a Meta Quest Pro HMD (106 ∘ field of view, 1800 \times 1920 pixels per eye, 90 Hz frame rate). An androgynous avatar from the Unity Asset Store was selected to minimize gender perception confounds. The virtual room featured a standard living room environment. Physiological Recordings Electrocardiography ECG was recorded with passive Ag/AgCl electrodes (Easycap, Wörthsee, Germany) placed according to Einthoven lead I on the left (positive) and right (negative) wrists, with ground over the left ankle’s lateral malleolus. Skin Conductance Response SCR was recorded with two sensors (Brain Products GmbH, Gilching, Germany) on the second phalanx of the second and third digits of the non-dominant hand. Additional EEG (64 electrodes) and respiratory data were recorded, but are not reported here, as they remain part of ongoing analysis. Data were acquired using wireless LiveAmp amplifiers (Brain Products GmbH, Gilching, Germany) with third-order sinc filtering (-3 dB at 131 Hz) and a 500 Hz sampling rate. Lab Streaming Layer (LSL, www.github.com/sccn/labstreaminglayer) ensured temporal synchronization. Offline analysis was performed in Python (version 3.10.14) using the MNE-Python toolbox ( 17 ) . Stop-distance procedure (SDP) The SDP ( 18 , 19 , 20 ) was used to assess individual personal space boundaries and calibrate avatar walking distances. Participants said "stop" when the slowly approaching avatar reached their comfort threshold. This distance served as a reference (100%) for experimental manipulations. SDP was measured five times (before each block, plus at the end of the experiment) to control for habituation. Experimental Procedure The experiment used a 2×2 factorial within-subject design with factors Personal Space (intrusion vs. respect) and Facial Expression (neutral vs. angry). Figure 1 displays the four experimental conditions ( PSrespect+FEneutral , PSrespect+FEangry , PSintrusion+FEneutral , and PSintrusion+FEangry ), which consisted of 15 trials randomly distributed across four blocks. Figure 1: Experimental Conditions. The experiment employed a 2×2 factorial design with factors Personal Space (intrusion vs. respect) and Facial Expression (neutral vs. angry), resulting in four conditions. Physiological sensors were placed while participants sat in an armchair. An experimenter then helped participants don the HMD; they stood up, and the avatar height was matched to their height. Next, participants were asked to explore and describe the virtual environment to enhance presence. Each block began with an SDP assessment followed by 15 avatar approach trials. Between blocks, participants were able to