Quantifying the Value of Seismic Structural Health Monitoring for post-earthquake recovery of electric power system in terms of resilience enhancement
Huangbin Liang, Beatriz Moya, Francisco Chinesta, Eleni Chatzi · 2025
Read Quantifying the Value of Seismic Structural Health Monitoring for post-earthquake recovery of electric power system in terms of resilience enhancement by Huangbin Liang, Beatriz Moya, Francisco Chinesta, Eleni Chatzi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-10318.txt.
Introduction
Huangbin Liang and co-authors measure the value of earthquake sensors on power grid structures, in this 2025 paper. After a quake, crews often inspect damage by hand, which is slow and error prone, so repairs start in the wrong order. Sensors that report structural health at once could speed the work, but they cost money, and their grid-wide worth was unclear.
The team built a simulation that links quake damage, repair limits, and power flow, then varied the quality of damage news. Better news sped recovery and cut the total loss of service by up to about a fifth. The results give planners a firmer base for sensor spending.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Huangbin Liang, Beatriz Moya, Francisco Chinesta, Eleni Chatzi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-10318
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantifying the Value of Seismic Structural Health Monitoring for post-earthquake recovery of electric power system in terms of resilience enhancement Huangbin Liang, Beatriz Moya, Francisco Chinesta, Eleni Chatzi Abstract Post-earthquake recovery of electric power networks (EPNs) is critical to community resilience. Traditional recovery processes often rely on prolonged and imprecise manual inspections for damage diagnosis, leading to suboptimal repair prioritization and extended service disruptions. Seismic Structural Health Monitoring (SSHM) offers the potential to expedite post-earthquake recovery by enabling more accurate and timely damage assessment. However, the deployment of SSHM comes with a cost and the quantifiable benefit of SSHM in terms of system-level resilience remains underexplored. This study develops an integrated probabilistic simulation framework to quantify the system-level value of SSHM in enhancing EPN resilience. The framework incorporates damage simulations based on EPN configuration, seismic hazard, fragility function, and damage-functionality mapping models, along with recovery simulations considering repair scheduling, resource constraints, transfer and repair durations. System functionality is evaluated via graph-based island detection and optimal power flow analysis under electrical constraints. Resilience is quantified using the Lack of Resilience (LoR) metric derived from the time-evolution functionality restoration curve. The effect of SSHM is incorporated by altering the quality of damage information used to create repair schedules. Specifically, different monitoring scenarios (e.g., no-SSHM baseline, partial SSHM, and full SSHM with various assessing accuracy levels) are modelled using confusion matrices that simulate misclassification of component damage states. The results demonstrate that improved damage awareness enabled by SSHM significantly accelerates recovery and reduces LoR by up to 21% across various monitoring conditions. This study provides a quantitative foundation for evaluating the system-level resilience benefits of SSHM and guiding evidence-based sensor investment decisions for critical infrastructures. K eywords Electric power networks \cdot value of information \cdot seismic structural health monitoring \cdot post-earthquake recovery \cdot resilience enhancement. 1 Introduction Electric power networks (EPNs) are the backbone of modern society, providing essential energy services to residential, industrial, commercial, and emergency sectors. However, they are increasingly exposed to natural hazards, earthquakes in particular, due to the distributed nature of their components across wide geographical areas that often intersect active fault zones [ 1 ] . Earthquake-induced EPN component failures can lead to widespread outages and cascading malfunctions across other interdependent lifeline systems, posing threats to public safety and economic continuity [ 2 , 3 ] . Consequently, enhancing the seismic resilience of EPNs, by improving their ability to absorb disruptions and rapidly recover functionality, has become a critical priority in the domain of disaster risk management and infrastructure planning [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . However, post-earthquake recovery decisions are often hindered by limited situational awareness, resulting from delayed and inaccurate inspection-based assessment of component-level damage [ 7 ] . This challenge is particularly acute in large-scale power systems, where manual inspections are labor-intensive, time-consuming, and prone to errors in emergency settings [ 8 ] . Over the past two decades, numerous frameworks have been developed to assess and improve the seismic resilience of EPNs [ 6 , 9 , 10 ] , which integrate component-level fragility modeling, system-level functionality assessment, and post-event recovery simulation. Early studies primarily focused on evaluating physical vulnerabilities of individual components, such as power plants, transmission tower-lines [ 11 ] , or substations [ 12 ] , based on fragility curves and seismic hazard exposure. This component-level assessment approach was later extended to system-level frameworks, wherein the impact of localized damage on network-wide performance was evaluated via network connectivity methods or power flow models [ 4 , 10 , 13 ] . These approaches typically integrate ground motion prediction equations (GMPEs) and Monte Carlo simulations (MCS) to generate damage scenarios and quantify the expected functionality loss. Building on damage simulation models, recent research has further shifted toward the dynamic process of post-earthquake recovery. Agent-based models and optimization-based scheduling algorithms have been proposed to simulate and optimize repair schedules under constraints such as limited crews, access delays, and interdependencies with other infrastructures [ 6 , 10 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . Despite the progress in seismic resilience modeling, existing frameworks assume complete and accurate knowledge of component damage immediately after an earthquake [ 5 , 6 , 9 , 10 ] . However, in real-world post-earthquake scenarios, such information is rarely available. Component-level damage must typically be inferred from visual inspections conducted by field personnel, which are time-consuming and often subject to human judgment[8]. These subjective assessments often deviate significantly from the actual damage conditions, potentially leading to suboptimal or even erroneous recovery decisions. For instance, if a severely damaged substation is mistakenly assessed as functional due to oversight or limited access, it may be excluded from early repair efforts, resulting in prolonged outages and greater system-wide functionality loss. Conversely, misidentifying intact components as damaged can lead to inefficient resource allocation. Thus, the epistemic uncertainty associated with post-earthquake inspections must be explicitly accounted for in resilience modeling to ensure realistic evaluation of recovery performance. To address these limitations, Seismic Structural Health Monitoring (SSHM) has emerged as a promising solution for enhancing post-earthquake situational awareness [ 17 , 18 ] . These systems typically employ a network of sensors—including accelerometers, strain gauges, and displacement transducers—integrated into critical infrastructure components. By continuously collecting measurements of structural responses during and after earthquakes, SSHM enables rapid post-event damage detection through signal processing techniques such as modal identification, frequency shifts, and pattern recognition [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] . Recent advances in data assimilation and digital twinning technologies have further enhanced SSHM by delivering virtual replicas of physical assets that may be updated dynamically as new sensing data arrives, supporting timely diagnostics and scenario-based decision-making [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] , and thus reducing the reliance on subjective and delayed field inspections. Several studies have demonstrated the feasibility and advantages of SSHM for post-earthquake applications across various engineering structures. For instance, Zhang et al. [ 25 ] proposed a framework for quantifying structural damage and evaluating damage state in RC frame structures leveraging SSHM data. Giordano et al. [ 26 ] further evaluated the role of SSHM in informing building evacuation decisions and concluded that timely structural information can reduce uncertainty and enhance occupant safety. Similarly, Ge et al. [ 27 ] and Giordano & Limongelli [ 28 ] investigated sensing-based damage assessment and operational decisions for bridges. In the power system domain, Moya et al. [ 29 ] and Zhu et al. [ 30 ] explored the use of hybrid modelling based and pure data-driven anomaly detection approaches respectively for interconnected equipment in substations. But these studies remain largely confined to academic research and are decoupled from comprehensive post-disaster recovery contexts. On the other hand, the adoption of SSHM is not without cost. The deployment and maintenance of dense sensing infrastructure require significant financial investment. This raises a fundamental question in infrastructure management: under which condition is it worthwhile to invest in SSHM to support post-earthquake recovery of EPNs? Value of Information (VoI) analysis has emerged as a formal framework to address this question [ 31 ] . Rooted in Bayesian decision theory, VoI quantifies the expected gain from improved information provided by the SSHM when