c eff c_{\rm{eff}} from Surgery and Modularity
Shimal Harichurn, Mrunmay Jagadale, Dmitry Noshchenko, Davide Passaro · 2025
Read c eff c_{\rm{eff}} from Surgery and Modularity by Shimal Harichurn, Mrunmay Jagadale, Dmitry Noshchenko, Davide Passaro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-10087.txt.
Introduction
Shimal Harichurn and three co-authors compare two proposals for extending a family of three manifold invariants to all closed oriented manifolds. The invariants, known as Z-hat, are firmly defined only for negative definite plumbed manifolds. Physical reasoning suggests they should exist far more broadly, and two rival extensions have been proposed.
The test class is a family of Brieskorn homology spheres. The diagnostic is the effective central charge, which governs how fast the invariant coefficients grow. The authors prove an upper bound for one proposal tied to a classic theta function. For the other, they build numerical and modular tools that give lower bounds and exact values. The two proposals prove incompatible in general.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shimal Harichurn, Mrunmay Jagadale, Dmitry Noshchenko, Davide Passaro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 111 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-10087
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
c eff c_{\rm{eff}} from Surgery and Modularity Shimal Harichurn, Mrunmay Jagadale, Dmitry Noshchenko, Davide Passaro Abstract Z ^ \widehat{Z} invariants, rigorously defined for negative definite plumbed 3-manifolds, are expected – on physical grounds – to exist for every closed, oriented 3‑manifold. Several prescriptions have been proposed to extend their definition to generic plumbings by reversing the orientation of a negative definite plumbing, thus turning it into a positive definite one. Two existing proposals are relevant for this paper: (i) the regularized + 1 / r +1/r -surgery conjecture combined with the false–mock modular conjecture, and (ii) a construction based on resurgence and a false theta function duality. In this note, we compare these proposals on the class of Brieskorn homology spheres Σ ( s , t , r s t ± 1 ) ¯ \overline{\Sigma({s},{t},{rst\pm 1})} and find that they are incompatible in general. Our diagnostic is the effective central charge, c eff c_{\rm eff} , which governs the asymptotic growth of coefficients of Z ^ \widehat{Z} . First, we prove that the upper bound on c eff c_{\rm{eff}} from prescription (i) is governed by the Ramanujan theta function, which regularizes the surgery formula. Second, we develop numerical and modular tools that deliver the lower bounds as well as exact values via mixed mock‑modular analysis. Complementing this, we also study c eff c_{\rm{eff}} for negative definite plumbed 3-manifolds which allow for a better comparison of pairs of 3-manifolds related by orientation reversal. As a result, we find that for some Brieskorn spheres the surgery and false‑mock prescriptions violate the expected relation between c eff c_{\rm eff} , Chern–Simons invariants and non‑abelian flat connections. These findings underscore c eff c_{\rm eff} as a sensitive probe of the “positive side” of Z ^ \widehat{Z} ‑theory. DIAS-STP-25-20 1 Introduction \widehat{Z} invariants are quantum q -series invariants for closed, oriented 3 -manifolds. They were originally introduced by Gukov, Pei, Putrov and Vafa [ 1 ] . The \widehat{Z} invariants were shown to enjoy two complementary realizations: one physical and one mathematical. The physical perspective starts with a six‑dimensional \mathcal{N}=(2,0) theory on D^{2}\!\times\!S^{1}\!\times\!M_{3} . Compactifying this theory over M_{3} yields a three‑dimensional \mathcal{N}\!=\!2 theory T[M_{3}] on the solid torus D^{2}\times S^{1} ; the half–index of T[M_{3}] on D^{2}\!\times_{q}\!S^{1} with boundary condition b\in\operatorname{Tor}H_{1}(M_{3})/\mathbb{Z}_{2} is precisely \widehat{Z}_{b}(M_{3};\tau) . Compactifying instead over D^{2}\!\times\!S^{1} gives complex Chern–Simons theory on M_{3} . The defining relation between the level‑ k partition function, a.k.a. Witten–Reshetikhin–Turaev (WRT) invariant, and \widehat{Z} ’s can then be seen as a finite‑dimensional S –transform: Z_{\text{CS}}(M_{3};k)=(i\sqrt{2k})^{\,b_{1}(M_{3})-1}\sum_{a,b\in\operatorname{Tor}H_{1}(M_{3})/\mathbb{Z}_{2}}\mathrm{e}^{2\pi ik\,\ell k(a,a)}\,S_{ab}\,\widehat{Z}_{b}(M_{3};q)\Big|_{q=\mathrm{e}^{\frac{2\pi i}{k}}}\,. (1) Here b_{1}(M_{3}) is the first Betti number, and the summation on the right side is over abelian flat connections on M_{3} , which are one-to-one with the boundary conditions of T[M_{3}] . The authors of [ 1 ] also supplied a purely mathematical construction of \widehat{Z}_{b} whenever M_{3} is a negative definite plumbed manifold, i.e. it is presented by a weighted graph \Gamma whose adjacency plumbing matrix M , obtained by adding the weights of the nodes of \Gamma to the diagonal, is negative definite. Various structural properties of \widehat{Z} invariants (as well as generalizations thereof) for such manifolds were further studied in [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] . Let L=\#\!\operatorname{Vert}(\Gamma) and \deg(v) degree of a vertex v\in\operatorname{Vert}(\Gamma) ; one obtains for each boundary condition b\simeq(2\operatorname{Coker}M+\delta)/\mathbb{Z}_{2} the convergent q -series \;\widehat{Z}_{b}(M_{3};q)=q^{-\frac{3L+\sum_{v}a_{v}}{4}}\,\underset{\text{v.p.}}{\oint_{|z_{v}|=1}}\;\prod_{v}\frac{dz_{v}}{2\pi iz_{v}}\,(z_{v}-z_{v}^{-1})^{\,2-\deg(v)}\;\Theta_{-M,b}(z;q)~,\; (2) where the lattice theta–function is \Theta_{-M,b}(z;q)=\sum_{\ell\in 2M\mathbb{Z}^{L}+b}q^{-\frac{(\ell,M^{-1}\ell)}{4}}\prod_{i=1}^{L}z_{i}^{\ell_{i}} , a_{v} is the weight associated with vertex v and q=\mathrm{e}^{2\pi i\tau} . Crucially, this series is not convergent when the manifold in question is a positive definite plumbed manifold. \widehat{Z} invariants can thus be thought of as a q -series refinement of WRT invariants. In particular, when M_{3} is a negative definite plumbed homology sphere, the linear combination of radial limits of \widehat{Z}_{b}(M_{3};\tau) at roots of unity recovers the corresponding WRT invariant (in other words, the equation ( 1 ) holds, as shown in [ 8 ] ). One motivation for this refinement is due to the search for a categorified invariant of a 3 -manifold, rooted in the categorification programme initiated by Crane–Frenkel in four‑dimensional TQFT [ 9 ] . Since the discovery of \widehat{Z}_{b} , notable progress on categorified invariants of 3-manifolds has been achieved (e.g. in [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] ) where new categorified invariants have arisen from certain deformations of \widehat{Z}_{b} . The construction of a proper mathematical definition for the \widehat{Z}_{b} for a general 3-manifold remains an open problem and serves as a broader motivation for our work. Continuing the line of research of [ 1 ] , Cheng, Chun, Ferrari, Gukov and Harrison [ 2 ] approached the positive‑plumbing problem by combining results from modularity and intuition coming from the relation between the \widehat{Z}_{b} and Chern-Simons theory. From the modularity point of view, the authors of [ 2 ] show that for the simplest non‑trivial negative plumbings – star‑shaped graphs giving Seifert homology spheres with three singular fibers – the \widehat{Z}_{b} is explicitly written as a linear combination of false theta‑functions, Eichler integrals of unary theta functions. These functions are known to be quantum modular forms, modern extensions of classical modularity [ 14 ] . In Chern–Simons theory orientation reversal sends the level k to its negative Z_{\text{CS}}(M_{3};k)=Z_{\text{CS}}(\overline{M_{3}};-k)~. Therefore, via q\;=\;\mathrm{e}^{2\pi i\tau}=\mathrm{e}^{2\pi i/k}, orientation reversal should implement the inversion q\leftrightarrow q^{-1} . However, applying this transformation naively to the plumbing formula ( 2 ) generically leads to divergent series. Nonetheless, the authors of [ 2 ] show that for some manifolds the \widehat{Z} invariants can be rewritten as q -hypergeometric sums that converge on both sides of the unit circle, thus admitting a well-defined q\leftrightarrow q^{-1} transformation. Consider, for example, the Poincaré homology sphere \Sigma(2,3,5) . Its \widehat{Z} invariant can be shown to be equal (up to a factor of q ) to a linear combination of false theta functions: \widehat{Z}_{0}(\Sigma(2,3,5);\mathrm{e}^{2\pi i\tau})\sim\tilde{\theta}^{1}_{30,1}(\tau)+\tilde{\theta}^{1}_{30,11}(\tau)+\tilde{\theta}^{1}_{30,19}(\tau)+\tilde{\theta}^{1}_{30,29}(\tau)\,. The authors of [ 2 ] show that this can also be written in a q -hypergeometric form \widehat{Z}_{0}(\Sigma(2,3,5);q)\sim q^{\frac{1}{120}}\left(2-\sum_{n\geq 0}\frac{(-1)^{n}q^{\frac{n(3n-1)}{2}}}{(q^{n+1};q)_{n}}\right)~. The hypergeometric series converges for both \absolutevalue{q}<1 and \absolutevalue{q}>1 . Therefore, following the physical expectation from Chern-Simons theory, we can apply q\leftrightarrow q^{-1} transformation. Remarkably, it leads to a relation to the order 5 mock theta function of Ramanujan \chi_{0}(q) q^{\frac{1}{120}}\left(2-\sum_{n\geq 0}\frac{(-1)^{n}q^{\frac{n(3n-1)}{2}}}{(q^{n+1};q)_{n}}\right)\xleftrightarrow{\ \ q\leftrightarrow q^{-1}}q^{-\frac{1}{120}}\left(2-\sum_{n\geq 0}\frac{q^{n^{2}}}{(q^{n+1};q)_{n}}\right)=q^{-\frac{1}{120}}(2-\chi_{0}(q)). Examples like these, where linear combinations of false theta functions are exchanged by mock theta functions, shed light on the modular structure of the q -series associated to a 3-manifold upon orientation reversal. The above had motivated the false-mock conjecture for \widehat{Z} invariants: Conjecture 1 (The False-Mock Conjecture, [ 15 , 7 ] ) . Let M_{3} be a 3-manifold for which the \widehat{Z} invariants take the form \widehat{Z}_{b}(M_{3};\mathrm{e}^{2\pi i\tau})=\mathrm{e}^{2\pi i\tau c}\left(\tilde{\vartheta}(\tau)+p(\tau)\right), (3) where \tau\in\mathbb{H}^{+} , c\in\mathbb{Q} , \tilde{\vartheta}(\tau) is the Eichler integral of a unary theta function \vartheta(\tau) of weight 3/2 and p(\tau) is a polynomial in q=\mathrm{e}^{2\pi i\tau} . Then the \widehat{Z} invariant of the manifold with reversed orientation is \widehat{Z}_{b}(\overline{M_{3}};\mathrm{e}^{2\pi i\tau})=\mathrm{e}^{-2\pi i\tau c}\left(f(\tau)+p(-\tau)\right), (4) where f(\tau) is a weight 1/2 weakly holomorphic (mixed) mock modular form. Moreover, its completion \hat{f} , transforming as a modular form of weight 1/2 under a certain congruence