The Effects of Sunspots on Spectral Line Shapes in the Visible
Claire Komori, John M. Brewer, Lily L. Zhao · 2025
Read The Effects of Sunspots on Spectral Line Shapes in the Visible by Claire Komori, John M. Brewer, Lily L. Zhao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-09030.txt.
Introduction
Claire Komori, John Brewer, and Lily Zhao test a shortcut for modeling sunspots in this 2025 paper. Planet hunters must subtract starlight noise, and sunspots bend spectral lines by amounts that swamp the wobble of an Earth like planet. A popular shortcut pretends a spot is just a patch of a cooler, otherwise identical star.
Comparing real sunspot spectra with that model, the team finds the shortcut fails. Coolness alone deepens atomic line cores. But spots also boost molecular lines that the model lists miss. And the spot's magnetic field strengthens, widens, blends, and splits lines in ways no temperature tweak reproduces. Better stellar models, they conclude, must treat magnetism head on.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Claire Komori, John M. Brewer, Lily L. Zhao |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-09030
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Effects of Sunspots on Spectral Line Shapes in the Visible Claire Komori, John M. Brewer, Lily L. Zhao Abstract We present a comparative spectral analysis to explore the ability of a cooler Sun model to accurately capture the spectral line shape changes caused by Sunspots. In the search for small Earth-like planets, the effects of stellar surface activity can overwhelm the ∼ \sim 10 cm/s planetary RV signal. This necessitates the development of new stellar modeling methods and a greater understanding of the impact of surface activity on stellar spectra. Some attempts to model out noise from Sunspot activity, in particular, have used a sum of a stellar model with a model of a cooler, but otherwise identical star. From our analysis, we find that a cooler effective temperature alone cannot capture the numerous spectral line shape variations seen in a Sunspot observation. The cooler temperature of a Sunspot not only deepens the cores of atomic lines, it also increases and strengthens molecular lines that are not fully represented in our line list. Furthermore, our LTE models and a comparison cool star also fail at capturing line strengthening, broadening, blending, and splitting induced by the magnetic field in the Sunspot. I Introduction The radial velocity (RV) method is one of the primary techniques for exoplanet detection, used in identifying over 1000 planets thus far ( Mayor & Queloz 1995 ; Lee et al. 2023 ; Li et al. 2024 ) . In the last few years a number of extreme-precision radial velocity (EPRV) instruments such as EXPRES ( Petersburg et al. 2020 ) , NEID ( Gupta et al. 2021 ) , ESPRESSO ( Pepe et al. 2021 ) , and MAROON-X ( Seifahrt et al. 2022 ) , have pushed down to \sim 30 cm/s precision, leading to many high resolution, high signal-to-noise time series spectra, and allowing for the discovery of lower-mass planets at longer orbital periods ( Faria et al. 2022 ; Basant et al. 2025 ) . Additionally, these spectra can be used to derive important information regarding the host-star itself such as its elemental abundance, surface gravity, magnetic field, and stellar activity. Correctly interpreting stellar spectra is crucial for characterizing host-stars and furthering planet detection. RV measurements are sensitive to not just the Doppler shift from reflex motions induced by the companion planet(s), but also to signals induced by the star itself ( Dumusque 2016 ; Siu-Tapia et al. 2017 ; Zhao et al. 2022 ) . At the \sim 30 cm/s stability typical of EPRV instruments, stellar surface variability is now the dominant source of error veiling potential low-mass planetary signals. The semi-major amplitude of the reflex velocity of the Sun due to the Earth in its one year orbit is only \sim 9.5 cm/s. Low-mass planets, and even sub-Neptunes on longer period orbits, are hidden by stellar surface variability requiring the mitigation of the stellar signals to below 10 cm/s. One origin for stellar variability are starspots. Saar & Donahue 1997 , in particular, showed that perturbations caused by Sunspots can increase with stellar rotation and level of activity. The combination of the star’s rotation with starspots can mimic periodic RV signals and potentially lead to false positive planet detection ( Boisse et al. 2011 ; Vanderburg et al. 2016 ; Robertson et al. 2020 ) , and these misinterpretations have occurred in the past in cases such as TW Hydrae ( Huélamo et al. 2008 ) and LkCa19 ( Huerta et al. 2008 ) . Surface features on the star may alter line shapes across the spectrum in a variety of ways. As we attempt to extract ever more precise RVs from these spectral lines, accurate knowledge of how individual lines are changing is needed. Activity indicators are often used to disentangle stellar signals, such as Sunspots, from RV measurements. Spectral line features such as emission in the core of Ca II H&K lines (3969.6Å and 3934.7Å respectively; Saar et al. 1998 ; Meunier & Lagrange 2013 ), the Ca infrared triplet (8498Å, 8542Å, and 8662Å respectively; Saar & Fischer 2000 ), and the H \alpha line (6562.8Å; Skelly et al. 2008 ; Robertson et al. 2014 ; Giguere et al. 2016 ) are used to gauge the presence and level of magnetic activity ( von Stauffenberg et al. 2024 ) . Attributes of a cross-correlation function (CCF) between the spectra and a binary line list are also often used. These attributes include CCF bisector asymmetry measurements and the full width half maximum (FWHM) of the CCF, which are used to trace asymmetrical line shape changes that are seen in most lines throughout the observed spectrum ( Lafarga et al. 2020 ; Lafarga et al. 2023 ) . However, these activity indicators are sensitive only to global changes or changes in specific spectral regions. There have been further developments regarding the use of activity indicators and methods of disentangling stellar variability signals from planetary RV signals in recent times. The use of the Gaussian processes (GPs) have allowed for the modeling of quasi-periodic signals that are potentially driven by stellar surface activity ( Jones et al. 2017 ; Gilbertson et al. 2020 ; Rajpaul et al. 2020 ) . GPs are used to construct flexible stellar activity models that trace RV signals that are also reflected in the time series of activity indicators. However, this will only be able to model stellar signals captured by the activity indicators. Additionally, the flexibility of such models may allow the activity model overfit the data, potentially fitting out small planet signals. A comparative test of different stellar activity modeling and mitigation methods showed a lack of agreement between returned planetary RVs after being cleaned of stellar activity signals ( Zhao et al. 2022 ) , which necessitates continued progress in this area. Furthermore, the spectroscopic data of stellar activity signals in itself can be a significant source of rich information regarding a star’s magnetic field which generates the photospheric and chromospheric activity. Local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) models are often used for interpreting integrated light spectra. However, it faces significant challenges when stars exhibit surface variation. Typical LTE spectral models ( Przybilla et al. 2011 , e.g.) are based on the assumption of a quiet star; they lack the ability to account for line shape changes caused by stellar activity. This can lead to incorrect inference of fundamental parameters such as temperature, surface gravity, and elemental abundances. Here, we investigate line shape changes seen in a Sunspot spectrum as a step towards improving spectral modeling methods. Sunspots are magnetic structures that appear dark on the Solar surface ( Solanki 2003 ) . The inner darker regions called the umbra are 1000-1900K cooler than the quiet Solar surface ( Solanki 2003 ) . Sunspots appear on points where there are strong magnetic fields. In these areas, the magnetic force suppresses convection from below the photosphere, making it difficult for the hot gas to rise ( Thomas & Weiss 1992 ) . This results in these areas having cooler temperatures in comparison to the rest of the Solar surface and appearing as dark Sunspots. One strategy used in an attempt to model stars with Spot activity is