Unconditional results for Artin-type problems over number fields

Pietro Sgobba · 2025

Read Unconditional results for Artin-type problems over number fields by Pietro Sgobba (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-08996.txt.

Introduction

Pietro Sgobba proves results on Artin-type problems over number fields without leaning on a famous unproven claim. His paper from two thousand twenty-five picks a number field and a finitely generated group of its nonzero elements. For most primes of the field, the group can be reduced modulo the prime, and its index in the residue group can be read.

Sgobba asks which primes give an index inside a fixed set of whole numbers. Under set growth rules on that set, he proves counting formulas for such primes with no appeal to the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis. The work links back to Artin's primitive root idea, proven only under that hypothesis in nineteen sixty-seven.

Catalog record

CREATORPietro Sgobba
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-08996

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unconditional results for Artin-type problems over number fields Pietro Sgobba Abstract . Let K K be a number field and let G G be a finitely generated subgroup of K × K^{\times} . For all but finitely many primes 𝔭 \mathfrak{p} of K K , the reduction ( G mod 𝔭 ) (G\bmod\mathfrak{p}) generates a well-defined subgroup of the multiplicative group of the residue field at 𝔭 \mathfrak{p} , and we may consider its index. We study the primes of K K for which this index lies in a given set of positive integers S S . In particular, we prove that under certain convergence conditions on series associated to S S this problem can be addressed without assuming the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis (GRH), and we provide asymptotic formulas for the corresponding prime-counting functions. Problems of this type are related to Artin’s primitive root conjecture, which has been proven under the assumption of GRH (Hooley, 1967). 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 11R45; Secondary: 11R44 1. Introduction Let K be a number field, and let G be a finitely generated and torsion-free subgroup of K^{\times} . Up to discarding finitely many primes \mathfrak{p} of K , the reduction (G\bmod\mathfrak{p}) is the subgroup of k_{\mathfrak{p}}^{\times} , where k_{\mathfrak{p}} is the residue field at \mathfrak{p} , generated by the reductions (\alpha\bmod\mathfrak{p}) for \alpha\in G . The multiplicative index of this subgroup, denoted by \ind_{\mathfrak{p}}(G) , is well-defined and we may consider the index map \Psi:\mathfrak{p}\longmapsto\Psi(\mathfrak{p}):=\ind_{\mathfrak{p}}(G). Given a set S of positive integers, we investigate the natural density of the preimage \Psi^{-1}(S) , if it exists. Under the assumption of the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis (GRH), it is known that given a positive integer t , the density of the set of primes of K given by \Psi^{-1}(t) exists and has an explicit formula, see [ 17 , Proposition 1] , namely \dens(\Psi^{-1}(t))=\sum_{n\geqslant 1}\frac{\mu(n)}{[K(\zeta_{nt},G^{1/nt}):K]}, where \zeta_{n} denotes a primitive n th root of unity and \mu is the Möbius function. Also, we consider all extensions of K in a fixed algebraic closure. Furthermore, again under GRH, the set \Psi^{-1}(S) admits a natural density given by the sum of the densities \dens(\Psi^{-1}(t)) for t\in S , i.e. \dens(\Psi^{-1}(S))=\sum_{t\in S}\sum_{n\geqslant 1}\frac{\mu(n)}{[K(\zeta_{nt},G^{1/nt}):K]}, see [ 10 , Corollary 2] . Taking t=1 , the set \Psi^{-1}(1) consists of all primes \mathfrak{p} such that G contains a primitive root modulo \mathfrak{p} , and taking K=\mathbb{Q} and G of rank 1 reduces to the problem of Artin’s primitive root conjecture, which was proven under GRH by Hooley [ 6 ] in 1967, and its analogue over number fields by Cooke and Weinberger [ 2 ] ; see [ 9 ] for an introduction to the research area around this conjecture. The map \Psi was studied in more generality, under GRH, in two recent articles by Järviniemi and Perucca [ 7 ] , and jointly with the author [ 8 ] . Here we investigate the condition \ind_{\mathfrak{p}}(G)\in S without assuming GRH. Instead, we impose an asymptotic bound on a certain series associated with S , and then we focus on sets S defined in terms of the \ell -adic valuations of their elements, obtaining unconditional partial extensions of the results in [ 8 ] . In fact, for some sets S it is well-known that the set of primes \Psi^{-1}(S) can be studied unconditionally. For instance, taking S=n\mathbb{N} for a given integer n , for a prime \mathfrak{p} of degree 1 the condition n\mid\ind_{\mathfrak{p}}(G) is equivalent to \mathfrak{p} splitting completely in K(\zeta_{n},G^{1/n}) , and by Chebotarev’s density theorem the corresponding natural density is 1/[K(\zeta_{n},G^{1/n}):K] . As a simple application, we may further obtain such examples if we only need to apply this result finitely many times, for instance for the index having a prescribed \ell -adic valuation for a fixed \ell , or for the index being coprime to a given integer. In 1995, over the rationals Pappalardi proved that the primes p for which \ind_{p}(2) is k -free, k\geqslant 2 , (i.e. not divisible by k th powers larger than 1 ) admit a natural density unconditionally, see [ 11 , Corollary 5] . Notice that differently from the previous examples, this one involves divisibility conditions on the index for infinitely many prime numbers. In fact, Pappalardi obtained this result as an application of Hooley’s method with weights [ 11 ] , which we introduce here in the context of number fields and with an additional condition on the Frobenius conjugacy classes. 1.1. Problem setup Let F/K be a finite Galois extension of K , and let C be a conjugacy-stable subset of \Gal(F/K) . For \mathfrak{p} a prime of K which does not ramify in F , we denote by (\mathfrak{p},F/K) the conjugacy class of the Frobenius elements at the primes of F above \mathfrak{p} . For a given function f:\mathbb{N}\to\mathbb{C} , we consider the sum (1) \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\mathfrak{p}:\ \N\mathfrak{p}\leqslant x\\ (\mathfrak{p},F/K)\subseteq C\end{subarray}}f(\Psi(\mathfrak{p})), where \N is the norm over K/\mathbb{Q} and the sum runs through all primes \mathfrak{p} of K except the finitely many primes such that v_{\mathfrak{p}}(\alpha)\neq 0 for some \alpha\in G or which ramify in F (we will implicitly discard these primes whenever we consider a condition on \ind_{\mathfrak{p}}(G) or on (\mathfrak{p},F/K) , respectively). Let \pi_{n,C}(x) be the number of primes \mathfrak{p} , with \N\mathfrak{p}\leqslant x , such that n\mid\ind_{\mathfrak{p}}(G) and (\mathfrak{p},F/K)\subseteq C , and write \pi_{n}(x) if the Frobenius condition is trivial. Hooley’s conditional proof of Artin’s conjecture is based on the inclusion-exclusion identity (2) \sharp\{\mathfrak{p}:\N\mathfrak{p}\leqslant x,\ind_{\mathfrak{p}}(G)=1\}=\sum_{n\geqslant 1}\mu(n)\pi_{n}(x). By the Möbius inversion formula we may write f(n)=\sum_{d\mid n}g(d),\quad\text{ with }\quad g(n)=\sum_{d\mid n}\mu(n/d)f(d). Then, the sum ( 1 ) equals \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\mathfrak{p}:\ \N\mathfrak{p}\leqslant x\\ (\mathfrak{p},F/K)\subseteq C\end{subarray}}\sum_{d\mid\Psi(\mathfrak{p})}g(d)=\sum_{d\leqslant x}g(d)\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\mathfrak{p}:\ \N\mathfrak{p}\leqslant x\\ d\mid\Psi(\mathfrak{p})\\ (\mathfrak{p},F/K)\subseteq C\end{subarray}}1=\sum_{d\leqslant x}g(d)\pi_{d,C}(x), yielding the identity (3) \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\mathfrak{p}:\ \N\mathfrak{p}\leqslant x\\ (\mathfrak{p},F/K)\subseteq C\end{subarray}}f(\Psi(\mathfrak{p}))=\sum_{n\geqslant 1}g(n)\pi_{n,C}(x), which is a generalization of ( 2 ); see also [ 11 , p.376] and [ 5 , Sec.1.3] . In view of ( 3 ) and since \pi_{n,C}(x) is given asymptotically by Chebotarev’s density theorem, we investigate under which conditions we may establish the asymptotic formula (4) \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\mathfrak{p}:\ \N\mathfrak{p}\leqslant x\\ (\mathfrak{p},F/K)\subseteq C\end{subarray}}f(\Psi(\mathfrak{p}))\sim\Li(x)\sum_{n\geqslant 1}\frac{g(n)c(n)}{[F(\zeta_{n},G^{1/n}):K]}, where c(n) is the number of K -automorphisms in C which fix F\cap K(\zeta_{n},G^{1/n}) (this coefficient arises when applying Chebotarev’s density theorem; we define it formally in Sec. 2.2 ), and where we assumed that the series multiplying \Li(x) is convergent. Asymptotic formulas of this form were studied by Felix and Ram Murty [ 5 ] over \mathbb{Q} for several arithmetic functions f under GRH, and later by Felix [ 3 ] for higher rank. Notice that the constants arising from ( 4 ) have been recently studied by Akbary and Fakhari [ 1 ] . If \chi_{S} denotes the characteristic function of S , then taking f=\chi_{S} the above sum is the counting function for the set of primes \mathfrak{p} such that \ind_{\mathfrak{p}}(G)\in S and (\mathfrak{p},F/K)\subseteq C . Namely, we have (5) \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\mathfrak{p}:\ \N\mathfrak{p}\leqslant x\\ (\mathfrak{p},F/K)\subseteq C\end{subarray}}\chi_{S}(\Psi(\mathfrak{p}))=\sharp\left\{\mathfrak{p}:\N\mathfrak{p}\leqslant x,\ \ind_{\mathfrak{p}}(G)\in S,\ \begin{pmatrix}\mathfrak{p}\\ F/K\end{pmatrix}\subseteq C\right\}. If ( 4 ) holds for f=\chi_{S} , from ( 5 ) we would then obtain an asymptotic formula and a density formula for the considered counting function. Under GRH this was achieved by Felix and Ram Murty [ 5 ] over \mathbb{Q} , and Felix [ 4

Read the complete text