Designing with Deception: ML- and Covert Gate-Enhanced Camouflaging to Thwart IC Reverse Engineering

Junling Fan, David Koblah, Domenic Forte · 2025

Read Designing with Deception: ML- and Covert Gate-Enhanced Camouflaging to Thwart IC Reverse Engineering by Junling Fan, David Koblah, Domenic Forte (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-08462.txt.

Introduction

Junling Fan, David Koblah, and Domenic Forte disguise computer chips so stolen layouts reveal false designs in a 2025 security study. Reverse engineers can photograph a chip layer by layer and recover its logic, stealing intellectual property. Camouflage gates that look alike but act differently are the standard defense, yet most designs camouflage only small local spots.

Their machine learning driven method plans deception across the whole design, mixing cryptic structures that hide function with mimetic ones that imitate a different function. Covert gates reinforce the trick. Comprehensive camouflage raises the cost of chip piracy for commercial and defense hardware.

Catalog record

CREATORJunling Fan, David Koblah, Domenic Forte
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-08462

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Designing with Deception: ML- and Covert Gate-Enhanced Camouflaging to Thwart IC Reverse Engineering Junling Fan, David Koblah, Domenic Forte Abstract Integrated circuits (ICs) are essential to electronic systems, yet they face significant risks from physical reverse engineering (RE) attacks that compromise intellectual property (IP) and overall system security. While IC camouflaging has emerged to mitigate these risks, existing approaches largely focus on localized gate modifications, neglecting comprehensive deception strategies. To address this gap, we present a machine learning (ML)-driven methodology – IP Camouflage – that integrates cryptic and mimetic deception principles to enhance IC security against RE. Our approach leverages a novel And-Inverter Graph Variational Autoencoder (AIG-VAE) to encode circuit representations, enabling dual-layered camouflage through functional preservation and appearance mimicry. By introducing new variants of covert gates – Fake Inverters, Fake Buffers, and Universal Transmitters – our methodology achieves robust protection by obscuring circuit functionality while presenting misleading appearances. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our strategy in maintaining circuit functionality while achieving strong resistance to SAT-based attacks with low structural overhead. Additionally, we validate the robustness of our method against advanced artificial intelligence (AI)-based RE attacks. I Introduction As integrated circuits (ICs) continue to serve as the backbone of modern electronic systems, the threat of reverse engineering (RE) has become increasingly consequential. Physical RE enables adversaries to extract sensitive information from hardware designs, including intellectual property (IP), underlying algorithms, and security features. By physically probing, delayering and imaging, and analyzing the results, attackers can reconstruct an IC’s gate-level representation, enabling replication, cloning, vulnerability analysis, and/or tampering [ 1 ] . This poses substantial risks, particularly in critical domains such as defense, healthcare, and finance, where IP theft or hardware tampering could have catastrophic consequences to national security, public health and economic security, respectively. With the continuous advancement of RE tools and techniques, safeguarding ICs from these threats has become increasingly challenging [ 2 , 3 ] . IC camouflaging has emerged as a technique to protect hardware IPs from RE attacks. This approach leverages fabrication-based technologies to intentionally obscure the true functionality of the circuit, deliberately confusing adversaries [ 4 , 5 ] . Camouflaged sections are designed to mislead attackers during the IC RE process, resulting in incorrect or incomplete reconstructions. While this may be the intention, current methods primarily focus on localized gate layouts or interconnections, neglecting a holistic camouflage of the overall circuit’s functionality. This narrow focus limits their ability to achieve broader, system-level deception, which could significantly hinder adversarial efforts during RE in real-world applications. Cyber deception offers a proactive and versatile defense strategy for addressing these limitations. The taxonomy proposed by Pawlick et al. [ 6 ] categorizes cyber deception into six distinct strategies: perturbation, moving target defense (MTD), obfuscation, mixing, honey-x, and attacker engagement. These are classified broadly into two categories: cryptic deception, which obscures the existence or nature of “assets”, and mimetic deception, which simulates realistic but misleading appearances [ 6 ] . According to this definition, existing camouflage strategies against IC RE focus on cryptic deception while mimetic deception remains unexplored. Our work addresses this through the following contributions: • Filling the Mimetic Deception Gap: We introduce mimetic deception, complementing cryptic deception by simultaneously hiding the true functionality of circuits and presenting a misleading outward appearance. Figure 1 shows a toy example where a camouflaged Half Adder (HA) looks similar to a Full Adder (FA) in appearance. We also create new variants of covert gates [ 7 ] which would appear as inverters, buffers, etc. under SEM but may function differently. Figure 1 : Illustration of mimetic deception for: (a) a Half Adder (HA), (b) an HA camouflaged deceptively to appear as a Full Adder (FA) using covert gates [ 7 ] , and (c) a standard FA. The pink gates are covert gates that appear as the logic gate under SEM imaging but are actually buffers or inverters that only operate on the non-dashed input signal. Dashed lines are dummy inputs unbeknownst to attackers. • Machine Learning-Based Implementation: We employ an ML-based strategy using a variational autoencoder (VAE) model to achieve “dual-layered” camouflage with and-inverter graphs (AIGs); that is, it ensures efficient and systematic implementation of both cryptic and mimetic deception, overcoming the limitations of traditional approaches. Note that the proposed AIG-VAE is also a unique contribution which can be used in other EDA/CAD applications. • Demonstrated Robustness Against AI-Enhanced RE Tools: Through experiments, we demonstrate how our strategy effectively thwarts advanced RE methods, including those leveraging AI, underscoring its practical security improvements. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: Section II offers background on threats against ICs and discusses how they may be impacted by the proposed camouflaging. In Section III , we provide background on the main sub-components of the proposed approach: covert gates, VAEs, and cyber deception. The section concludes with a few motivational examples, highlighting the vast potential of hardware security that arises from combining IC camouflaging with deception principles. The overall methodology (IP Camouflage) and main contributions are discussed in Section IV . Experimental results that demonstrate the effectiveness of the AIG-VAE and IC camouflage are provided in Section V . Finally, Section VI concludes the paper and highlights directions for future research. II Attacks and Threat Model The landscape of hardware security has rapidly evolved in the last few decades, driven by the changing nature of attacks and the corresponding development of countermeasures. The constant theme in this field is that there is no one-size-fits-all solution for all adversaries. However, our methodology improves IP security against a few distinct physical attacks. II-A Reverse Engineering Reverse Engineering (RE) is a process that involves systematically analyzing electronic devices to extract design information at the chip, board, or system levels. It involves dissecting hardware designs to uncover vulnerabilities or proprietary information [ 8 ] . A typical process of IC RE includes: 1. Remove the chip packaging to expose the die for further analysis. 2. Sequentially remove individual chip layers for examination. 3. Capture high-resolution images of the exposed layers. 4. Annotate the captured images and extract the circuit’s netlist using hardware assurance tools. Adversaries can use RE for cloning, counterfeiting, and IP theft. Techniques like SEM imaging, dry or wet etching, and annotation tools are employed for accurate extraction and analysis of device designs [ 2 , 1 ] . Given the complexity of modern hardware, the process requires significant resources. Although it has utility in security and assurance applications, such as hardware Trojan detection [ 9 , 10 ] , it is viewed as an attack in this paper. II-B SAT-based Attack The SAT problem asks whether a given Boolean formula F(x_{1},x_{2},x_{3},\ldots,x_{n}) is satisfiable, i.e., whether there exists an assignment of variables x_{i}\,\forall\,i that makes F evaluate to true. While SAT is NP-complete, modern SAT solvers are highly efficient and have been successfully applied in various domains such as equivalence checking, formal verification, and automatic test pattern generation (ATPG) [ 11 , 12 ] . By leveraging the power of SAT solvers [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] , circuit obfuscation, including logic locking and camouflaged circuits has been broken. Such attacks assume that a locked/camouflaged netlist is available along with a

Read the complete text