Maximal dilatation on nonorientable surfaces
Ji-Young Ham, Joongul Lee · 2025
Read Maximal dilatation on nonorientable surfaces by Ji-Young Ham, Joongul Lee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-08323.txt.
Introduction
Ji-Young Ham and Joongul Lee settle a question about stretching maps on one-sided surfaces in a 2025 math paper. Pseudo-Anosov maps stretch one set of curves and shrink another by a fixed factor, called the dilatation. For nonorientable surfaces of even genus from four upward, they prove a known polynomial gives the largest such factor. The proof shows the polynomial cannot be factored.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ji-Young Ham, Joongul Lee |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 14 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-08323
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Maximal dilatation on nonorientable surfaces Thanks: We thank Erwan Lanneau, Livio Liechti, Julien Marché, Alan Reid, and Darren Long. Thanks: The author is supported by Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology (No. NRF-2018005847). Thanks: The author was supported by 2017 Hongik University Research Fund. Ji-Young Ham, Joongul Lee Abstract . On each nonorientable surface of even genus g ≥ 4 g\geq 4 , we show that the Liechti-Strenner’s polynomial in [ LS20b ] gives a maximal dilatation among pseudo-Anosov diffeomorphisms with an orientable invariant foliation. This is proved by showing that this polynomial is irreducible. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification 37E30, 37B40, 57M60 1. Introduction In 1970’s, Thurston classified the mapping class group of a surface into periodic, pseudo-Anosov, and reducible [ Thu88 ] . The same content from a somewhat different point of view can be found in [ CB88 ] . In this paper, we adopt the Penner’s approach [ Pen88 , Pen91 ] . Penner made use of bigon tracks, a slight generalization of train track. Nice example of bigon tracks can be found in [ LS20a ] . Our paper is based on Liechti-Strenner’s pseudo-Anosov diffeomorphisms on nonorientable surfaces [ LS20b ] . Let \Sigma_{g} be a surface of finite type. A diffeomorphism h of \Sigma_{g} is called pseudo-Anosov if there is a pair of transversely measured foliations \mathcal{F}^{u} and \mathcal{F}^{s} in \Sigma_{g} and a real number \lambda>1 such that h(\mathcal{F}^{u})=\lambda\mathcal{F}^{u} and h(\mathcal{F}^{s})=1/\lambda\mathcal{F}^{s} [ Thu88 , CB88 ] . The number \lambda is called the dilatation of h and the logarithm of \lambda is called the topological entropy . A beginner-friendly example about the dilatation can be found in [ BRW16 ] . The set of dilatations of pseudo-Anosov diffeomorphisms of the group of isotopy classes \Sigma_{g} is discrete [ AY81 , Iva88 ] . In particular, there exists the minimal dilatation. Note that \lambda is an algebraic number and hence there exists the minimal polynomial of it. Denote by the degree of \lambda the degree of the minimal polynomial of it. Denote by a maximal dilatation on a set S of diffeomorphisms of \Sigma_{g} a dilatation that gives the maximal degree among S . Liechti and Strenner [ LS20b ] determined the minimal dilatation of pseudo-Anosov diffeomorphisms with an orientable invariant foliation on the closed nonorientable surfaces of genus 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18 and 20. Denote by N_{g} the closed nonorientable surface of genus g and by \delta^{+}(N_{g}) the minimal dilatation among pseudo-Anosov diffeomorphisms of N_{g} with an orientable invariant foliation. Liechti and Strenner conjectured that the largest root of x^{2k-1}-x^{k}-x^{k-1}-1 is the minimal dilatation of N_{2k} for k\geq 2 (Conjecture 1.1 ). Denote by Liechti-Strenner’s polynomials the odd degree polynomials in the conjecture 1.1 . Conjecture 1.1 . [ LS20b , Conjecture 1.2] For all k\geq 2 , \delta^{+}(N_{2k}) is the largest root of x^{2k-1}-x^{k}-x^{k-1}-1 . In [ HL20 ] , we showed that the Liechti-Strenner’s example for the closed nonorientable surface N_{2k} in [ LS20b ] minimizes the dilatation within the class of pseudo-Anosov diffeomorphisms with an orientable invariant foliation and all but the first coefficient of the characteristic polynomial of the action induced on the first cohomology nonpositive. The main purpose of this paper is the following two theorems. Theorem 1.2 . Denote by N_{2k} the closed nonorientable surface of genus 2k . For all k\geq 2 , the Liechti-Strenner's polynomial, x^{2k-1}-x^{k}-x^{k-1}-1, is irreducible. Theorem 1.3 . For all k\geq 2 , the Liechti-Strenner's polynomial, x^{2k-1}-x^{k}-x^{k-1}-1, gives a maximal dilatation on N_{2k} among pseudo-Anosov diffeomorphisms of N_{2k} with an orientable invariant foliation. It is known that this degree is possible [ Str17 ] , but there have been no concrete examples of this being realized. The well known conjecture is that this polynomial gives the minimal dilatation [ LS20b ] . Here we prove the maximality instead of the minimailty. On each orientable surface of genus g\geq 2 , a maximal dilatation among pseudo-Anosov diffeomorphisms with orientable invariant foliations is concretely presented in [ LL24 , Shi16 ] , but it doesn’t seem to be the minimal dilatation. Earlier work concerning the degree of dilatations can be found in [ AY81 ] and [ Lon85 ] . Some references related to minimal dilatations are [ Abi80 , AD10 , Bau92 , BH95 , Bir74 , Bri00 , Bri04 , CH08 , FM12 , FRW24 , FLPÌ79 , Ham06 , HS07 , Hir10 , HK06 , KT13 , HT24 , Lei04 , LT11a , LT11b , LS20b , LS21 , LLT25 , Lov19 , McM15 , PP87 , CDWo , SKL02 , Tsa09 , TZ24 , Val12 , Ven08 , Yaz20 , Zhi95 ] . The above references are neither exhaustive nor systematically assembled, so that their inclusion or noninclusion should not be taken as an indication of quality or relevance of the content. Nonetheless, we hope that you find them helpful. 2. Liechti-Strenner construction of nonorientable surfaces We will briefly introduce the Liechti-Strenner’s method of constructing the nonorientable surface \Sigma_{2k-1,2} of genus g=2k and the Liechti-Strenner’s polynomial. 2.1. The graph G_{2k-1,2} Let k\geq 2 be an odd natural number. Let G_{2k-1,2} be the graph whose vertices are the vertices of a regular (2k-1) -gon and every vertex v is connected to the 2 vertices that are the farthest away from v in the cyclic order of the vertices. Figure 1 shows the graph G_{3,2} . Figure 1. The graph G_{3,2} . 2.2. The surface \Sigma_{2k-1,2} For each G_{2k-1,2} , Liechti and Strenner constructed an nonorientable surface \Sigma_{2k-1,2} that contains a collection of curves with intersection graph G_{2k-1,2} [ LS20b , Subsection 2.2] . To construct \Sigma_{2k-1,2} , start with a disk with one crosscap. Next, we consider 4k-2 disjoint intervals on the boundary of the disk and label the intervals with integers from 1 to 2k-1 so that each label is used exactly twice. In the cyclic order, the labels are 1,s,2,s+1,...,2k,s+2k where s=k+2 and all labels are understood modulo 2k-1 . For each label, the corresponding two intervals are connected by a twisted strip. Figure 2 shows the surface \Sigma_{3,2} . Figure 2. The surface \Sigma_{3,2} and the curve c_{1} . Lemma 2.1 . [ LS20b , Proposition 2.3] The surface \Sigma_{2k-1,2} is homeomorphic to the nonorientable surface of genus 2k with 1 boundary components. 2.3. The curves Liechti and Strenner constructed a two-sided curve c_{i} for each label i=1,\ldots,2k-1 as follows. Each curve consists of two parts. One part of each curve is the core of the strip corresponding to the label. The other part is an arc inside the disk that passes through the crosscap and connects the corresponding two intervals. The curve c_{1} is shown in Figure 2 . We choose markings for the c_{i} which are invariant under the rotational symmetry See Figure 3 . Figure 3. A collection of filling inconsistently marked curves. Note that every pair of curves intersects either once or not at all. The curves c_{i} and c_{j} are disjoint if and only if the two i labels and the two j labels link in the cyclic order. In other words, if the