Grationality, with a Spoon
L. Jeneva Clark · 2025
Read Grationality, with a Spoon by L. Jeneva Clark (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-08267.txt.
Introduction
Clark introduces a new math idea called grationality in a 2025 paper, first shown at a 2025 meeting of a national math group. The idea mirrors rational numbers, but for shapes. A nice polygon is a regular shape whose side lengths are whole numbers. A number is grational if one nice shape has the same area as that many copies of a smaller nice shape.
Clark gives examples of numbers that are grational and numbers that are not. Theorems then link this trait to how numbers divide. The proofs use plain tools such as tiling, cutting shapes apart, and step by step descent, with many pictures. Readers see how simple tools, jokingly called math with a spoon, can still prove sharp results.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | L. Jeneva Clark |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-08267
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Grationality, with a Spoon L. Jeneva Clark Abstract . The introduction of Grationality at a 2025 sectional meeting of the Mathematical Association of America MAAtalk installed a handle on a concept akin to rationality of numbers, but in a geometric context. An nice n n -gon was defined to be a regular n n -gon with side lengths that are natural numbers, and a number n n was defined to be grational if and only if there exists a nice n n -gon such that its area equals the sum of areas of n n congruent nice n n -gons. This paper shows several examples of grational and non-grational numbers, followed by theorems about how the grationality of a number relates to its divisibility. Proofs of these theorems do not use high-powered tools, but rely on geometric constructions, proportional reasoning, tiling, dissection, the Carpets Theorem, and proof by descent. In keeping with this simplicity, a.k.a. “doing math with a spoon,” images are heavily leveraged. The benefits of choosing simplistic tools are discussed. 1. Introduction A wise egg once said, “When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less,” carroll1875through . Humpty Dumpty knew that providing a tabula rasa for new ideas can help open minds, impelling unbiased clarity in mathematical communication and logic. Grationality , a new word introduced at a 2025 Sectional Meeting of the Mathematical Association of America MAAtalk , helps approximate something akin to rationality of numbers, but based in a geometric context. In this paper, I attempt to use the stealth of geometry to sneak up on number theory, such as investigating the grationality of perfect-square integers. In doing so, I also radically advocate for “doing math with a spoon,” the art of using the simplest mathematical tools possible. This radically minimalist approach affords more opportunities for tangential discoveries, allows for broader participation, connects current ideas to math history, and leans into simplicity as one of the pillars of proof elegance. 2. Spoons and Carpets 2.1. Some Mathematical Background In the 1950s, Stanley Tennenbaum, a student of John H. Conway, executed a strinkingly elegant proof of the irrationality of the square root of two ( conway2006power ) , which will be described in Section 2.4 , and some have worked on generalizing its technique ( Miller01042012 ) . Building on this work, I wanted to move the goalpost, tackling grationality instead of rationality. The word grational is a loose blend of the words geometry and rational, hinting at a number-theoretical concept clothed in the intuition of geometry. By creating a few new words, I hoped to push forward mathematical thought with improved clarity, with a byproduct of empowering math students to similarly take ownership of mathematical ideas by coining new words. To this end, I define the following terms, within the context of Euclidean geometry: (1) A nice n -gon is a regular n -gon with side lengths that are natural numbers. (2) An integer n is grational if and only if there exists a nice n -gon such that its area equals the sum of areas of n congruent nice n -gons. 2.2. A Connection to Mathematics History The accessibility and simplicity of the Tennenbaum proof offers broad inspiration to mathematics education, as it can be understood by very young mathematics learners. It hinges only on the well-ordering axiom of positive integers and on the Carpets Theorem, which will be stated as Theorem 2.1 . Some suspect this simple strategy was connected to the early discovery of irrational numbers because of Plato’s writings, which reveal that a young person discovered irrationality with rudimentary mathematical tools ( conway2013extreme ) . According to Plato, the requisite knowledge could be taught to young students in just one lesson and rationality/irrationality had been determined for square roots of integers from 3 to 17. Math history is a long mathematical conversation between humanity and itself. I believe that intentional engagement with past mathematics rewards us with the fitness required (both mathematical strength and flexibility) to enjoy healthy strides into future mathematics. For this reason, I dust off this question: Why might have the case-by-case journey of early mathematicians been limited to the interval [3,17] ? One popular conjecture bears the namesake of Theodorus, which is the pseudonym Plato gave the mathematician in his writings. Despite its popularity, the Spiral of Theodorus, as shown in Figure 2.2 , fails to explain why early mathematicians would have begun with 3; it begins with one. What if rationality were adjusted to a more geometric interpretation? After all, the smallest polygon has 3 sides. Might we envision a closer guess of what mathematical reasoning might have looked like a few thousand years ago? Fig. 1. The Spiral of Theodorus. 2.3. Doing Math with a Spoon In this section, from the perspective of a mathematics educator, I strive to use simple tools of logic, rather than modern or high-powered techniques. This simplicity is like choosing to dig a swimming pool with a spoon, rather than with a shovel or a tractor. At first, this might sound foolish, but I am viewing mathematics through a lens of mathematics education. The heart of math itself beats only in the logic of the human mind. Thus, surprising simplicity both pleases aesthetic senses and ignites learning of mathematics, highly valued impacts in math education. Fig. 2. A 3-year-old using a simple tool, drawing by Courtenay Kimberling Figure 2.3 depicts one of my earliest endeavors – digging a swimming pool with a spoon at age 3. When I asked him for a swimming pool, my father, who often used tools like shovels and jackhammers around our estate, told me, “Sure! You can dig a hole with anything!” He handed me his cereal spoon and instantly recruited his littlest construction worker. The smallness of a spoon granted dirt-moving power to even the smallest of hands. My control and autonomy over the earth afforded me more discovery. What cool stuff I found in the dirt! For these reasons, autonomy, accessibility, and discovery, instead of doing mathematics that asks how big I can build a bulldozer, I favor the question, How small can I make my spoon? In this paper, I stubbornly rely on spoon-level mathematical techniques – geometric constructions, proportional reasoning, tiling, dissection, proof by descent, and only one additional theorem. The Carpets Theorem ( andreescu2011mathematical ) is low-hanging fruit for a young math learner. My 3-year-old self might have even been able to understand its statement and proof, as provided below, using both words and pictures to carry ideas. Theorem 2.1 (The Carpets Theorem) . Suppose that the floor of a room is completely covered by a collection of non-overlapping carpets such that the area of the room equals the combined areas of the carpets. If one were to move one or more of these carpets inside this room, then there may result region(s) where two carpets overlap each other and some region(s) that are not covered by any carpet. If so, the doubly carpeted area equals the uncarpeted area. Fig. 3. An example of conditions where the Carpets Theorem holds. Proof. Let a room be an arbitrary 2-dimensional shape with