Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes

Christopher Gerlach, Yann Gouttenoire, Antonio J. Iovino, Nicholas Leister · 2025

Read Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes by Christopher Gerlach, Yann Gouttenoire, Antonio J. Iovino, Nicholas Leister (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-08238.txt.

Introduction

Christopher Gerlach and co-authors close a loophole for the largest black holes anyone has proposed, in work from 2025. Primordial black holes of stupendously large mass, over a hundred billion times the Sun's mass, had been floated as a possible chunk of dark matter. The authors show that such giants would imprint unevenness on the early universe far beyond what the Planck satellite's map of the cosmic microwave background allows. Their result excludes these monsters as a significant share of dark matter.

Catalog record

CREATORChristopher Gerlach, Yann Gouttenoire, Antonio J. Iovino, Nicholas Leister
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-08238

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Closing the Mass Window for Stupendously Large Black Holes Preprint: MITP-25-053 Christopher Gerlach, Yann Gouttenoire, Antonio J. Iovino, Nicholas Leister Abstract We show that primordial black holes (PBHs) in the Stupendously Large Black Hole mass range ( M ≳ 10 11 ​ M ⊙ M\gtrsim 10^{11}\,M_{\odot} ) produce isocurvature perturbations exceeding current Planck Cosmic Microwave Background limits, thereby excluding them as a significant dark matter component. Introduction. Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) Zel’dovich and Novikov 1967 ; Hawking 1974 ; Chapline 1975 ; Carr 1975 have attracted significant attention in recent years, both as potential contributors to the dark matter (DM) content of the universe and as possible explanations for some of the black hole merger events observed by LIGO/Virgo/KAGRA Bird et al. 2016 ; Sasaki et al. 2016 ; Clesse and García-Bellido 2017 ; Mukherjee and Silk 2021 ; De Luca et al. 2021a ; De Luca et al. 2021b ; Franciolini et al. 2022a . A wide range of astrophysical and cosmological observations tightly constrain the present-day PBH dark matter fraction. For non-spinning PBHs, the only mass range in which they could constitute all of the DM is the asteroidal window , spanning 10^{-16} – 10^{-12}\,M_{\odot} . Another mass range that has recently attracted attention is that of stupendously large black holes (SLABs), defined by M_{\rm PBH}\gtrsim 10^{11}\,M_{\odot} Carr et al. 2021a . Being too massive to reside within galaxies, they cannot constitute the totality of the DM but, according to Ref. Carr et al. 2021a , could still comprise a significant DM fraction for M_{\rm PBH}\in[10^{14},10^{19}]\,M_{\odot} 1 1 1 Ref. Carr et al. 2021a also considered accretion-based bounds, but these are highly uncertain due to the limitations of the Bondi formalism in an expanding Universe, radiation drag, and uncertainties in accretion efficiency and spectral modeling Serpico et al. 2020 ; De Luca et al. 2020b ; Agius et al. 2024 . . In this Letter , we show that isocurvature perturbations from SLABs exceed current limits from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Baryonic Acoustic Oscillation (BAO), thereby ruling them out as a significant DM component. PBH Isocurvature Perturbations. We model the total cold DM as a mixture of PBHs and particle dark matter (PDM, such as WIMPs or ALPs), \rho_{\rm DM}=\rho_{\rm PBH}+\rho_{\rm PDM},\quad f_{\rm PBH}\equiv\frac{\rho_{\rm PBH}}{\rho_{\rm DM}}, (1) such that the total DM density contrast is \delta_{\rm DM}=f_{\rm PBH}\,\delta_{\rm PBH}+(1-f_{\rm PBH})\,\delta_{\rm PDM}. (2) Following the linear perturbation theory for a PBH–PDM mixture presented in Inman and Ali-Haïmoud 2019 , we assume that the primordial PDM perturbations are purely adiabatic, \delta_{\rm PDM}^{f}=\delta_{\rm ad}^{f} , where the superscript f denotes the epoch of PBH formation. The discreteness of PBHs induces an additional isocurvature component in their primordial perturbations 2 2 2 The presence of non-local non-Gaussianities in the statistics of the large fluctuations that produce PBHs can also source isocurvature perturbations Tada and Yokoyama 2015 ; Young and Byrnes 2015 . \delta_{\rm PBH}^{f}=\delta_{\rm ad}^{f}+\delta_{\rm iso}^{f}, (3) so that Eq. ( 2 ) provides the primordial DM contrast with an isocurvature component as well \delta_{\rm DM}^{f}=\delta_{\rm ad}^{f}+f_{\rm PBH}\,\delta_{\rm iso}^{f}. (4) Introducing the linear transfer functions for adiabatic and DM-isocurvature modes between epoch of PBH formation a_{f} and a later epoch a , T_{\rm ad}(a) and T_{\rm iso}(a) , the DM contrast evolves as \delta_{\rm DM}(a)=T_{\rm ad}(a)\,\delta_{\rm ad}^{f}+T_{\rm iso}(a)\,f_{\rm PBH}\,\delta_{\rm iso}^{f}. (5) The DM isocurvature perturbation is defined as the fluctuation in the DM to photon number density ratio n_{\rm DM}/n_{\gamma} Akrami et al. 2020 , \mathcal{I}_{\rm DM}\equiv\frac{\delta(n_{\rm DM}/n_{\gamma})}{n_{\rm DM}/n_{\gamma}}=\delta_{\rm DM}-\frac{3}{4}\,\delta_{\rm R}. (6) Substituting Eq. ( 5 ) into Eq. ( 6 ), using that the adiabatic contribution cancels, yields \mathcal{I}_{\rm DM}(a)=T_{\rm iso}(a)\,f_{\rm PBH}\,\delta_{\rm iso}^{f}. (7) We define the dimensionless cross–power spectrum of two observables X and Y as \mathcal{P}_{XY}(k)\equiv\frac{k^{3}}{2\pi^{2}}\int d^{3}\mathbf{r}\,e^{i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{r}}\left<X(0)\,Y(\mathbf{r})\right>, (8) where the prefactor k^{3}/2\pi^{2} ensures that \mathcal{P}_{XY}(k)\,d\ln k gives the contribution to the variance from modes in the logarithmic interval [k,\,k+dk] . For brevity, we denote \langle XY\rangle\equiv\mathcal{P}_{XY}(k) when no ambiguity arises. For poisson-distributed objects, the PBH density contrast at formation can be expressed as \displaystyle\delta_{\rm iso}^{f}(\mathbf{x})=\Theta_{\rm PBH}(\mathbf{x})\delta_{\rm S}-1, (9) where \delta_{\rm S}\equiv\rho_{\rm S}/\rho_{\rm PBH}=(n_{\rm PBH}V_{\rm S})^{-1} is the ratio of the average energy density inside a PBH to the average energy density of the PBH gas with n_{\rm PBH} the PBH number density, \rho_{\rm S}\equiv M_{\rm PBH}/V_{\rm S} , V_{\rm S}\equiv 4\pi R_{\rm S}^{3}/3 , and R_{\rm S}\equiv 2GM_{\rm PBH}\simeq 10^{-19}(M_{\rm PBH}/M_{\odot}) Mpc the density, volume and radius of a single PBH. The function \Theta_{\rm PBH} equals 1 if \mathbf{x} is contained inside a PBH and 0 otherwise. Its statistic average is \displaystyle\left<\Theta_{\rm PBH}(\mathbf{x})\right>=\delta_{\rm S}^{-1}. (10) Its 2-point function has two contributions, according to whether \mathbf{x}_{1} and \mathbf{x}_{2} belong to the same PBH or to two distinct PBHs. The first one is \left<\Theta_{\rm PBH}(\mathbf{x}_{1})\Theta_{\rm PBH}(\mathbf{x}_{2})\right>_{\rm 1}=\delta_{\rm S}^{-1}\Theta(R_{\rm S}-|\mathbf{x}_{1}-\mathbf{x}_{2}|). (11) The second one is \left<\Theta_{\rm PBH}(\mathbf{x}_{1})\Theta_{\rm PBH}(\mathbf{x}_{2})\right>_{\rm 2}=\delta_{\rm S}^{-2}. (12) Summing the two contributions, we get \left<\Theta_{\rm PBH}(\mathbf{x}_{1})\Theta_{\rm PBH}(\mathbf{x}_{2})\right>=\delta_{\rm S}^{-1}\Theta(R_{S}-|\mathbf{x}_{1}-\mathbf{x}_{2}|)+\delta_{\rm S}^{-2}. (13) Using Eqs. ( 9 ) and ( 13 ), we calculate 3 3 3 In presence of initial clustering, this relation is modified with the additional presence of the reduced PBH correlation function \xi Desjacques and Riotto 2018 ; Ali-Haïmoud 2018 ; Moradinezhad Dizgah et al. 2019 ; Matsubara et al. 2019 ; Crescimbeni et al. 2025 . \left<\delta_{\rm iso}^{f}(\mathbf{x}_{1})\delta_{\rm iso}^{f}(\mathbf{x}_{2})\right>=\delta_{S}\Theta(R_{S}-|\mathbf{x}_{1}-\mathbf{x}_{2}|). (14) Plugging Eq. ( 14 ) into Eq. ( 8 ) yields the isocurvature power spectrum \left<(\delta_{\rm iso}^{f})^{2}\right>=\frac{2}{3\pi}\left(\frac{k}{k_{\rm PBH}}\right)^{3}\frac{3j_{1}(k/k_{f})}{k/k_{f}}, (15) where k is defined as comoving and k_{\rm PBH} is the inverse comoving PBH interspacing Papanikolaou et al. 2021 , k_{\rm PBH}=\left(\frac{4\pi}{3}n_{\rm PBH}\right)^{1/3}=\left(\frac{4\pi f_{\rm PBH}\,\rho_{\rm DM,0}}{3M_{\rm PBH}}\right)^{1/3}, (16) with \rho_{\rm DM,0}\simeq 3\times 10^{10}\,M_{\odot}\,\textrm{Mpc}^{-3} denoting the present-day mean dark matter density Cirelli et al. 2024 . The spherical Bessel factor j_{1}(x) implements a cutoff for k\gtrsim k_{S}(a)\equiv R_{S}^{-1}a — assuming a=1 today — due to PBH exclusion effects. Unlike usual physical scales, e.g. k/a or k_{\rm PBH}/a , which redshift as \propto a^{-1} , the physical PBH radius R_{S} is constant, implying that its comoving inverse scales as k_{S}\propto a and is thus time-dependent. For a conservative estimate, we evaluate k_{S}(a) at PBH formation, where it coincides with the comoving horizon scale at PBH formation, k_{f}\equiv k_{S}(a_{f})\simeq 0.16\penalty\ {\rm Mpc^{-1}}\gamma_{\rm H}^{\frac{1}{2}}\!\left(\frac{3.38}{g_{\star}(T_{f})}\!\right)^{\!\frac{1}{12}}\!\!\left(\!\frac{10^{15}M_{\odot}}{M_{\rm PBH}}\!\right)^{\!\frac{1}{2}}\!\!\!, (17) with \gamma_{H} and g_{\star}(k) that denote, respectively, the PBH mass in unit of the horizon mass — we fix \gamma_{\rm H}=1 for definiteness — and the number of effective relativistic degrees of freedom, all evaluated at PBH formation. This explains the appearance of k_{f} in Eq. ( 15 ) instead of k_{S}(a) . The power spectrum of the DM isocurvature in Eq. ( 7 ) now reads \left<\mathcal{I}_{\rm DM}^{2}\right>(a)\simeq T_{\rm iso}^{2}(a)f_{\rm PBH}^{2}\left<(\delta_{\rm iso}^{f})^{2}\right>\Theta(k-k_{\rm UV}), (18) where we have introduced an ultraviolet (UV) cut-off k_{\rm UV} in order to avoid modes which go beyond the linear regime. We consider two cut-off prescriptions: \displaystyle(A)\quad k_{\rm UV}=k_{\rm NL}^{\rm PBH},\quad\textrm{and}\quad(B)\quad k_{\rm UV}=k_{\rm NL}^{\rm DM}, (19) according to whether the PBH fluctuations or the DM fluctuations becomes larger than unity. i) For case A , the UV cut-off is defined by \displaystyle\left<\delta_{\rm PBH}^{2}\right>(k_{\rm NL}^{\rm PBH};a_{\rm rec})\equiv 1, (20) where a_{\rm rec} is the scale factor at recombination. We now derive the evolution of \delta_{\rm PBH}(a) following Inman and Ali-Haïmoud 2019 . Assuming a negligible relative velocity between PDM and

Read the complete text