The reflex instability: exponential growth of a large-scale m = 1 m=1 mode in astrophysical discs
Aurélien Crida, Clément Baruteau, Jean-François Gonzalez, Frédéric Masset, Paul Segretain, Philippine Griveaud, Héloïse Méheut, Elena Lega · 2025
Read The reflex instability: exponential growth of a large-scale m = 1 m=1 mode in astrophysical discs by Aurélien Crida, Clément Baruteau, Jean-François Gonzalez, Frédéric Masset, Paul Segretain, Philippine Griveaud, Héloïse Méheut, Elena Lega (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07859.txt.
Introduction
Aurelien Crida and co-authors report a new instability in gas discs around stars in 2025. The pattern takes a one-sided form and grows steadily over time. The star's distance from the center of mass grows with it, on a scale far longer than an orbit.
Runs with several codes and methods all showed the same growing mode. The mode vanished only when the star's wobble from the disc's lopsided pull was left out. The team traces a feedback loop: the star's motion stirs the disc, which then pulls the star further. Growth speeds up for heavier discs, taking a few hundred orbits at a few percent of the star's mass.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aurélien Crida, Clément Baruteau, Jean-François Gonzalez, Frédéric Masset, Paul Segretain, Philippine Griveaud, Héloïse Méheut, Elena Lega |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07859
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The reflex instability: exponential growth of a large-scale m = 1 m=1 mode in astrophysical discs Aurélien Crida, Clément Baruteau, Jean-François Gonzalez, Frédéric Masset, Paul Segretain, Philippine Griveaud, Héloïse Méheut, Elena Lega Abstract We report the finding of a linear, non-axisymmetric, global instability in gas discs around stars, which may be relevant to other astrophysical discs. It takes the form of an m = 1 m=1 mode that grows in the disc density distribution while the star-barycentre distance rises exponentially with a characteristic timescale that is orders of magnitude longer than the orbital period. We present results of hydrodynamical simulations with various codes and numerical methods, using either barycentric or stellocentric reference frames, with or without the disc’s self gravity: all simulations consistently show an unstable mode growing exponentially. The instability disappears if, and only if, the reflex motion of the star due to the disc’s asymmetry is not taken into account in the simulations. For this reason we refer to this instability as the reflex instability . We identify a feedback loop as a possible origin, whereby the acceleration of the star excites the eccentricity of the disc, yielding an m = 1 m=1 mode in the density distribution which, in turn, pulls the star. The growth timescale of the instability decreases with increasing disc mass and is a few hundred orbits for disc-to-star mass ratios of a few percent. If truly physical, and not due to a numerical artifact that would be common to all the codes we have employed, the reflex instability could have a dramatic impact on protoplanetary discs evolution and planetary formation. The reflex instability keywords accretion, accretion discs — hydrodynamics — methods: numerical — planetary systems: formation — planetary systems: protoplanetary discs 1 Introduction Gravitational systems in astrophysics often comprise a body – the primary – that far outweighs the others. A typical example is protoplanetary discs (with or without planets) around single stars. In this Letter, we show that such a situation leads to an instability which had so far not been reported (to our knowledge), probably because its growth time was too long for the simulations times and disc masses considered usually, or because the strange behaviour of the gas disc was attributed to some other phenomenon. However, when running simulations on thousands of orbits with disc-to-star mass ratios larger than 10^{-3} , its appearance is inevitable. We argue that this instability is of physical, not numerical, origin, and occurs as soon as the disc’s axisymmetry is broken. The key ingredient is the reflex motion of the star in reaction to an asymmetry in the disc, often called the Indirect Term in stellocentric codes (and sometimes discarded). A complete discussion of the meaning, the role, and the relevance of the Indirect Terms in general is proposed in our companion paper ( Crida et al. 2025 , hereafter Paper I) . Our physical setup and the various codes we use are presented in Sect. 2 , before the results of our simulations and a description of the instability are reported in Sect. 3 . A physical interpretation is proposed and the role of the different ingredients is analysed in Sect. 4 . Finally we discuss the implications of our work and compare with other results in the literature in Sect. 5 , notably in the field of N-body problems and galactic dynamics, where similar results have been found. 2 Physical model and numerical setup 2.1 Physical equations and reference values for the disc parameters The physical system that we consider is comprised of a protoplanetary gaseous disc orbiting around a star. Our fiducial disc model is deliberately simple: razor-thin (two-dimensional), unmagnetized, inviscid/non-turbulent, isothermal. The disc is described by polar coordinates ( R,\varphi ) and its evolution is modelled by the continuity equation, Euler’s equation and the ideal gas law, with a temperature both uniform and stationary. The choice of a globally isothermal disc allows to avoid the Vertical Shear Instability when examining the onset of our instability in supplementary 3D simulations ( Nelson et al. 2013 ) . The disc’s self-gravity is included in some of our 2D simulations, which further solve Poisson’s equation. Our disc model assumes a uniform initial radial profile for the Toomre-Q parameter ( Toomre 1964 , see also footnote 7 in Paper I) . Since the disc is assumed to be isothermal, the aspect ratio h(R)\propto R^{1/2} so a uniform Q implies that the initial disc’s surface density profile scales as R^{-3/2} . The instability mechanism examined in this Letter being non-axisymmetric, white noise is added to the initial density profile at the 0.1% level in order to break the initial symmetry. Our simulations adopt the following code units: a reference radius R_{0} as the length unit, the stellar mass M_{\star} as the mass unit, and the inverse Keplerian frequency at R_{0} as the time unit. In the results shown in Sect. 3 , time is expressed in orbital periods at R_{0} : T_{0}=2\pi(GM_{\star}/R_{0}^{3})^{-1/2} . Our reference model has \Sigma(R_{0})=4\times 10^{-3} and h(R_{0})=0.05 , thus Q\sim 4 initially. The disc extends from 0.32 R_{0} to 3.125 R_{0} , so our fiducial value for \Sigma(R_{0}) implies an initial disc-to-star mass ratio of \sim 0.06. We stress that such a physical set-up should be stable according to the present common knowledge on Keplerian discs. 2.2 Numerics We have used several codes to study the linear growth stage of the instability: Figure 1: Results of our reference setup for the fargo-2d1d simulation which uses a barycentric frame. The left panel shows the position of the star in the barycentric frame. The open square symbols mark the star’s position in the middle and right panels, and the arrows display the acceleration exerted by the disc on the star (arbitrary magnitude). The middle and right panels display the perturbation of the surface density of the disc relative to its azimuthally-averaged initial density, at two times separated by about half a pattern period. The solid curve shows the inner edge of the computational grid, the dashed curves show the edges of the inner and outer wave-damping zones. fargo-2d1d ( Crida et al. 2007 ) , a sibling of the original fargo code ( Masset 2000 ) which solves the governing equations in the barycentric frame. We did not make use of the 1D grid in the simulations presented here. fargo-adsg ( Baruteau & Masset 2008a ; Baruteau & Masset 2008b ) , an extension of fargo used to study the impact of self-gravity on the growth of the instability. Contrary to fargo-2d1d , fargo-adsg solves the governing equations in the stellocentric frame. fargo3d ( Benítez-Llambay & Masset 2016 ) , the 3D successor of fargo , which is used to examine the instability in 3D (the code also employs a stellocentric frame). idefix ( Lesur et al. 2023 ) , which, contrary to the fargo family codes, is a code based on a higher order Godunov scheme that uses a second-order Runge-Kutta time integrator to solve the governing equations in the stellocentric frame. phantom ( Price et al. 2018 ) , a 3D SPH (Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics) code which, like fargo-2d1d , employs a barycentric frame but, unlike all previous grid-based codes, has the