Towards Lock Modularization for Heterogeneous Environments

Hanze Zhang Rong Chen Haibo Chen · 2025

Read Towards Lock Modularization for Heterogeneous Environments by Hanze Zhang Rong Chen Haibo Chen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07756.txt.

Introduction

Hanze Zhang and co-authors rethink how locks should work on mixed hardware in a 2025 paper. Modern systems blend fast and slow parts, such as regular processors, graphics chips, and smart network cards, each with uneven memory and computing power. A lock guards shared data, but a lock designed for one kind of part wastes the strengths of the others and can clog traffic.

The authors propose lock modularization: split a lock into independent pieces and place each piece on the hardware that suits it best. A piece needing quick atomic steps can sit on a fast core, while bookkeeping rests elsewhere. Matching each module's needs to each component's strengths should raise speed in heterogeneous systems. The principle offers a blueprint for system software that treats mixed machines as an asset, not a problem.

Catalog record

CREATORHanze Zhang Rong Chen Haibo Chen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07756

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Towards Lock Modularization for Heterogeneous Environments Hanze Zhang Rong Chen Haibo Chen Abstract Modern hardware environments are becoming increasingly heterogeneous, leading to the emergence of applications specifically designed to exploit this heterogeneity. Efficiently adopting locks in these applications poses distinct challenges. The uneven distribution of resources in such environments can create bottlenecks for lock operations, severely hindering application performance. Existing solutions are often tailored to specific types of hardware, which underutilizes resources on other components within heterogeneous environments. This paper introduces a new design principle: decomposing locks across hardware components to fully utilize unevenly distributed resources in heterogeneous environments. Following this principle, we propose lock modularization —a systematic approach that decomposes a lock into independent modules and assigns them to appropriate hardware components. This approach aligns the resource requirements of lock modules with the attributes of specific hardware components, maximizing strengths while minimizing weaknesses. Introduction Heterogeneity is an emerging trend in the evolution of both production and edge hardware architectures [ 31 , 12 , 32 ] . In the post-Moore era, the performance scaling of CPUs no longer meets the rapidly increasing demands for highly parallel and energy-efficient processing. Consequently, processing units and hardware architectures with domain-specific attributes are being widely adopted, creating various heterogeneous environments [ 25 , 4 , 5 , 19 , 39 ] . As a fundamental synchronization primitive, locks are commonly used in applications designed for heterogeneous environments. For instance, transactional databases empowered by programmable networks and memory disaggregation [ 8 , 36 , 35 ] adopt locks to serialize index updates [ 34 , 23 , 22 ] and enforce inter-transaction concurrency control [ 42 , 41 ] . XPU-accelerated applications require locks to coordinate between algorithm modules [ 13 , 6 ] and serialize updates to large-volume structural data [ 33 , 14 , 15 ] . Since lock operations are on the critical path of shared data access, they often play a crucial role in application performance. Despite their importance, efficiently adopting locks in heterogeneous environments is challenging due to the uneven distribution of processing, memory, and communication resources across hardware components. Heterogeneous hardware is typically strong in one type of resource but weak in others to meet specific workload requirements. For example, programmable switches offer high packet processing speed but have limited memory capacity [ 4 , 2 , 16 ] . Consequently, when adapting locks to specific hardware, bottlenecks in scarce resources often prevent the full utilization of advantageous resources, leading to suboptimal performance [ 40 ] . Existing hardware-specific lock designs improve performance in two main ways: 1) by customizing lock algorithms to reduce network contention [ 28 ] or optimize processing resource utilization [ 15 , 21 ] ; and 2) by caching frequently accessed locks on specific hardware to leverage high processing power [ 38 ] or low communication costs [ 11 , 34 ] . However, these solutions are usually tailored for individual hardware components based on specific observations, preventing them from fully exploiting resources across different components in a heterogeneous environment. Recent research [ 40 ] explores a new strategy called lock fission, which effectively utilizes both programmable switches and servers for efficient lock management. It decomposes lock operations into two phases, each with distinct resource requirements that match the attributes of switches and servers, respectively. By assigning these phases to the best-matched hardware components, this approach can accelerate operations on millions of locks, two orders of magnitude more than deploying undecomposed locks to the switch [ 38 ] . Unfortunately, this approach is tightly coupled with the attributes of programmable switches and cannot be directly applied to other heterogeneous environments. Design principle. Inspired by lock fission [ 40 ] , we propose a principle for designing locks for heterogeneous environments: decomposing lock operations and metadata across different hardware components. This principle fully exploits unevenly distributed hardware resources by assigning lock modules to hardware components with matching resource attributes. Our proposal. To facilitate the application of this design principle in diverse heterogeneous environments, we propose lock modularization —a systematic approach of decomposing locks and assigning lock modules to hardware components. This approach breaks the lock manager into smallest functional units, including managers for mode, holders, waiters, and lock granting. Developers can easily assign these units to appropriate hardware components by matching resource requirements with hardware characteristics, and subsequently merge units assigned to the same component. We offer preliminary solutions to address correctness and performance challenges in adopting this approach, including a grant counting mechanism that preserves the linearizability of lock operations and three module assignment heuristics to fully exploit the performance benefits of modularization. Furthermore, we show the effectiveness of lock modularization in two application scenarios—SmartNICs and disaggregated memory—where the modularized design achieves significantly higher throughput and lower latency than monolithic designs. Trends, Challenges, and Practices The Heterogeneous Trend To improve performance and energy efficiency when executing diverse tasks, both data centers and edge devices are increasingly incorporating heterogeneous processing units and hardware architectures. As shown in Fig. 1 , unlike traditional homogeneous environments, heterogeneous environments feature diverse capabilities and limitations that demand new system designs to leverage these attributes. We next discuss these attributes in three typical heterogeneous scenarios. Programmable networks. With advancements in high-speed networking, the performance bottleneck for network-intensive applications is shifting from network transmission to packet processing [ 17 , 27 , 40 ] . In response, programmable network devices, such as programmable switches [ 4 , 2 , 16 ] and SmartNICs [ 7 , 24 , 25 ] , have emerged. Programmable switches allow customization of packet processing and forwarding rules. They provide fast packet processing and short network paths, but their limited memory capacity—typically only a few MBs [ 4 ] —restricts their ability to accelerate large-scale data processing [ 40 , 18 ] . SmartNICs enhance traditional NICs by incorporating programmable units to offload simple application tasks. Although these units offer lower communication costs than CPUs due to their proximity to the network [ 9 ] , they suffer from either wimpy processing power [ 35 , 9 ] or small cache sizes [ 9 ] , which constrains their performance. Disaggregated memory. A recent trend in modern data centers is the separation of CPU and memory resources into disaggregated, network-attached compute nodes (CNs) and memory nodes (MNs) [ 29 , 5 , 1 ] . CNs possess strong processing power but limited memory capacity (usually a few GBs), whereas MNs have substantial memory capacity but negligible processing power. This architecture enhances resource utilization and flexibility by allowing applications to scale CPU and memory resources independently. Applications on disaggregated memory [ 36 , 34 , 23 , 22 , 41 , 30 ] typically run compute tasks on CNs, which retrieve and update data stored on MNs by directly accessing MN memory using technologies such as RDMA and CXL. Since multiple CNs often access shared data on MNs simultaneously, MNs commonly experience a much larger communication burden than CNs [ 23 , 30 , 22 ] . Figure 1: Heterogeneous environments and their attributes in processing (Proc.), memory (Mem.), and communication (Comm.) resources. Red boxes denote resource bottlenecks in hardware components. Heterogeneous computing. The increasing demand

Read the complete text