Revisiting the access conductance of a charged nanopore membrane
Holly C. M. Baldock, David M. Huang · 2025
Read Revisiting the access conductance of a charged nanopore membrane by Holly C. M. Baldock, David M. Huang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07733.txt.
Introduction
Holly C M Baldock and David M Huang revisit how electric current flows into a tiny pore in a charged membrane. Their 2025 paper deals with field driven flow of electrolytes through nanoporous membranes, a topic tied to power from salt gradients, sensing, and ion based devices. The head gives the title with the pore set in a charged membrane, in slightly different words than the catalog.
The pair derive one exact style equation for weak charge and one semi-analytic equation for any surface charge. Their formulas predict how conductance scales with pore size and with the Debye length. Tests by computer simulation matched the theory across a wide range. The work extends a widely used older theory to more cases.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Holly C. M. Baldock, David M. Huang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07733
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Revisiting the access conductance of a charged nanopore membrane Holly C. M. Baldock, David M. Huang Abstract Electric-field-driven electrolyte transport through nanoporous membranes is important for applications including osmotic power generation, sensing and iontronics. We derive an analytical equation in the Debye–Hückel regime and a semi-analytical equation for arbitrary surface potentials for the electric-field-driven electric current through a pore in an ultrathin membrane, which predict scaling with fractional powers of the pore size and Debye length. We show that our theory for arbitrary electric potentials accurately quantifies the ionic conductance through an ultrathin membrane in finite-element method numerical simulations for a wide range of parameters, and generalizes a widely used theory for the access electrical conductance of a membrane nanopore to a broader range of conditions. Our theory predicts that fractional scaling of the ionic conductance with electrolyte concentration at low concentrations is a general property of charged ultrathin membranes and also occurs for thicker membranes for which the access contribution to the conductance dominates, which could explain experimental observations of this widely debated phenomenon. I Introduction Electric-field-driven transport through porous membranes underpins numerous applications of micro- and nanofluidics, including osmotic energy harvesting, Aluru et al. 2023 ; Zhang, Wen, and Jiang 2021 ; Siria, Bocquet, and Bocquet 2017 ; Rankin and Huang 2016 nanopore-based sensing and sequencing, Siwy, Bruening, and Howorka 2023 ; Ying et al. 2022 and emerging iontronic systems for signal processing and energy storage. Robin et al. 2023 ; Robin and Bocquet 2023 ; Kamsma et al. 2024 ; Gkoupidenis et al. 2024 Such technologies take advantage of the ability of electric fields to drive selective ion flow through confined geometries, Aluru et al. 2023 offering pathways to convert ionic gradients into power via reverse electrodialysis, Aluru et al. 2023 ; Zhang, Wen, and Jiang 2021 ; Siria, Bocquet, and Bocquet 2017 ; Rankin and Huang 2016 discriminate between analytes at the molecular scale, Siwy, Bruening, and Howorka 2023 ; Ying et al. 2022 and build biologically inspired information-processing devices. Robin et al. 2023 ; Robin and Bocquet 2023 ; Kamsma et al. 2024 ; Gkoupidenis et al. 2024 Two-dimensional (2D) membranes, such as those made from graphene, Rollings, Kuan, and Golovchenko 2016 molybdenum disulfide (MoS 2 ), Feng et al. 2016 and hexagonal boron nitride (hBN), Liu et al. 2024 offer exceptional promise for these applications due to their atomic thickness and large surface-area-to-volume ratios. Sahu and Zwolak 2019 The extreme confinement of 2D membranes results in large transmembrane gradients that can be orders of magnitudes greater than those achieved in conventional membranes, Macha et al. 2019 with exceedingly high osmotic power densities measured in single-layer MoS 2 membranes, Feng et al. 2016 single-layer hBN membranes, Liu et al. 2024 and a 2D nanoporous polymer membrane. Cheng et al. 2023 Moreover, single-layer graphene membranes, Cantley et al. 2019 as well as single- and few-layer MoS 2 membranes, Liu et al. 2014 have demonstrated remarkable sensitivity in detecting single-molecule translocation events, highlighting their potential for highly selective and low-concentration sensing applications. Cantley et al. 2019 Understanding fluid transport through 2D membranes has wider implications, as models of 2D membranes have been shown to accurately describe the influence of the pore ends on fluid transport through thicker membranes, Sisan and Lichter 2011 ; Sahu and Zwolak 2019 known as “entrance effects”. Rankin, Bocquet, and Huang 2019 Entrance effects can become significant as the membrane thickness approaches the pore size Mao, Sherwood, and Ghosal 2014 ; Melnikov, Hulings, and Gracheva 2017 and when the solid–fluid friction flow is low, Sisan and Lichter 2011 such as in carbon nanotubes. Manghi et al. 2021 ; Rankin and Huang 2016 Access resistance plays a central role in biological ion transport, where nanoscale confinement near membrane pores significantly limits electrical current and governs the rate of ion transport under certain conditions. Sahu and Zwolak 2018 ; Alcaraz et al. 2017 ; Aguilella-Arzo and Aguilella 2020 While theories have been derived to quantify the electric-field-driven access resistance in uncharged Hall 1975 and charged Lee et al. 2012 nanopores, many experimental phenomena observed in 2D membranes are not fully understood theoretically. Macha et al. 2019 For example, single-layer MoS 2 Feng et al. 2016 and single-layer graphene Rollings, Kuan, and Golovchenko 2016 membranes appear to have similar electric-field-driven ionic conductances at similar pore sizes and electrolyte concentrations, while the MoS 2 membrane exhibits a concentration-gradient-driven ionic conductance that is an order of magnitude greater than that of the graphene membrane. Feng et al. 2016 ; Rollings, Kuan, and Golovchenko 2016 ; Macha et al. 2019 Furthermore, scaling of the ionic conductance with fractional powers of the electrolyte concentration have been observed in 2D and thin membranes at low electrolyte concentrations, Liu et al. 2024 ; Cheng et al. 2023 ; Shan et al. 2013 ; Venkatesan et al. 2012 which differs to the saturation at low electrolyte concentration predicted by the existing theory of the access resistance of a charged membrane. Lee et al. 2012 Scaling of the ionic conductance with fractional powers of the electrolyte concentration at low concentrations has also been observed in longer nanopores, including carbon nanotubes, Secchi et al. 2016a ; Uematsu et al. 2018 ; Emmerich et al. 2022 biomimetic boron nitride nanotube porins, Li et al. 2024 and biological nanochannels, Queralt-Martín et al. 2018 which deviates from theoretical predictions and typical experimental behavior for long nanopores. Bocquet and Charlaix 2010 ; Siria et al. 2013 Various mechanisms have been proposed to explain this phenomenon, including a salinity-dependent surface charge, Secchi et al. 2016b ; Emmerich et al. 2022 ; Biesheuvel and Bazant 2016 ; Manghi et al. 2018 constant Manghi et al. 2018 and salinity-dependent Emmerich et al. 2022 solid–fluid friction, variable degrees of counter-ion binding at the surface, Uematsu et al. 2018 and electric potential “leakage” from the pore. Noh and Aluru 2020 Recently, concentration-gradient-driven ion fluxes through a 2D membrane have been shown by theory and simulation to scale with fractional powers of the pore size and average electrolyte concentration, which implies that similar scaling relationships could apply to the electrical access resistance given the similarities between concentration-gradient- and electric-field-driven transport. Baldock and Huang 2025 Thus, entrance effects could be responsible for some of the aforementioned experimental observations, although this hypothesis had been unverified until now. Here we derive an analytical equation in the Debye–Hückel regime and a semi-analytical equation for arbitrary surface potentials to describe the electric-field-driven electric current through a circular aperture in an infinitesimally thin planar (i.e. ultrathin) membrane, which predict scaling of the ionic conductance with fractional powers of the pore size and Debye screening length. The latter equation accurately quantifies the ionic conductance in finite-element method numerical simulations over a wide range of system parameters, and captures scaling of the ionic conductance with fractional powers of the electrolyte concentration observed in simulations at low bulk electrolyte concentrations. We thereby generalize an existing theory for the access electrical conductance of a membrane nanopore Lee et al. 2012 — which has been widely used to infer the surface charge densities of 2D and thicker membranes from experimental measurements Liu et al. 2024 ; Feng et al. 2016 ; Yazda et al. 2021 ;