Abundance and phase-space distribution of subhalos in cosmological N-body simulations: testing numerical convergence and correction methods

Kun Xu · 2025

Read Abundance and phase-space distribution of subhalos in cosmological N-body simulations: testing numerical convergence and correction methods by Kun Xu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07678.txt.

Introduction

Kun Xu tests how trustworthy the small dark-matter clumps in cosmic simulations really are. These subhalos host satellite galaxies and anchor many galaxy-formation models, but inside big halos, tides tear at them and simulations may lose them artificially. Xu compares two huge simulations of the Jiutian suite that differ in particle mass, tracking clumps with a dedicated finder.

Counts of surviving clumps settle down only for the heftiest ones. Adding back orphan clumps, lost ones whose galaxies should live on by a merger-clock model, repairs the counts well. With orphans included, positions and speeds of clumps match between the two runs to within five to ten percent down to small scales. The finest scales still resist, and measures that fold in galaxy recession speeds are harder still to recover.

Catalog record

CREATORKun Xu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07678

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Abundance and phase-space distribution of subhalos in cosmological N-body simulations: testing numerical convergence and correction methods Kun Xu Abstract Subhalos play a crucial role in accurately modeling galaxy formation and galaxy-based cosmological probes within the highly nonlinear, virialized regime. However, numerical convergence of subhalo evolution is difficult to achieve, especially in the inner regions of host halos where tidal forces are strongest. I investigate the numerical convergence and correction methods for the abundance, spatial, and velocity distributions of subhalos using two 6144 3 6144^{3} -particle cosmological N-body simulations with different mass resolutions— Jiutian-300 ( 1.0 × 10 7 ​ h − 1 ​ M ⊙ 1.0\times 10^{7}\,h^{-1}M_{\odot} ) and Jiutian-1G ( 3.7 × 10 8 ​ h − 1 ​ M ⊙ 3.7\times 10^{8}\,h^{-1}M_{\odot} )—with subhalos identified by hbt+ . My study shows that the Surviving subhalo Peak Mass Function (SPMF) converges only for subhalos with m peak m_{\rm peak} above 5000 particles but can be accurately recovered by including orphan subhalos that survive according to the merger timescale model of Jiang et al., which outperforms other models. Including orphan subhalos also enables recovery of the real-space spatial and velocity distributions to 5%–10% accuracy down to scales of 0.1–0.2 h − 1 \,h^{-1} Mpc. The remaining differences are likely due to cosmic variance and finite-box effects in the smaller Jiutian-300 simulation. Convergence below 0.1 h − 1 \,h^{-1} Mpc remains challenging and requires more sophisticated modeling of orphan subhalos. I further highlight that redshift-space multipoles are more difficult to recover even at larger scales because unreliable small-scale pairs at r p < 0.1 ​ h − 1 r_{\rm p}<0.1\,h^{-1} Mpc in real space affect scales of tens of Mpc in redshift space due to elongated Fingers-of-God effects. Therefore, for redshift-space statistics, I recommend using modified or alternative measures that reduce sensitivity to small projected separations in subhalo-based studies. 1 Introduction In the standard \Lambda cold dark matter ( \Lambda CDM) cosmological model, as well as in many of its modifications, structure forms hierarchically [ 1 , 2 ] . Dark matter halos merge to form larger halos, with the smaller ones becoming substructures (subhalos). Galaxies form as gas cools and condenses at the centers of dark matter halos, while galaxies in smaller halos become satellite galaxies after mergers [ 3 , 4 ] . Therefore, substructures and their associated galaxies constitute an important component of the cosmic web. Understanding the formation and evolution of substructures is essential for a complete picture of cosmic structure formation and for accurately modeling galaxy formation and various cosmological probes. After infall, subhalos are primarily affected by dynamical friction [ 5 ] , tidal stripping, and tidal heating [ 6 ] , until they either merge with the central subhalo or are completely disrupted. Some studies have argued that the central cusp of a Navarro–Frenk–White (NFW) profile [ 7 ] subhalo is expected to survive tidal forces in most cases, even after intense and prolonged stripping [ 8 ] . The nonlinearity and chaotic evolution of subhalos within virialized host systems necessitate the use of semi-analytic [ 9 , 10 ] or numerical [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] methods to model their dynamics. However, recent work [ 15 ] has demonstrated that numerical limitations significantly influence subhalo evolution, artificially enhancing tidal disruption and impeding convergence in subhalo population statistics. Without properly accounting for subhalos affected by numerical disruption, simulations will underestimate their abundance by missing a significant fraction of the population [ 12 , 16 ] . A commonly adopted approach to recover the lost population is to trace their orbits using the most bound particle prior to disruption [ 16 , 17 ] or to model their subsequent trajectories semi-analytically [ 10 ] . Subhalos and the galaxies they host in such cases are typically referred to as“type-2 subhalos” and “orphans”. It has recently been shown that subhalos that fall in before z=2 and higher-order subhalos (i.e., sub-subhalos) experience extreme mass loss, are more susceptible to disruption, and constitute the majority of orphan subhalos [ 18 ] . Their mass loss is largely physical, causing them to contribute primarily to the low-mass end of the current subhalo population if they survive. Therefore, for studies related to the current mass of subhalos—such as gravitational lensing [ 19 ] and dark matter annihilation [ 20 ] —orphan subhalos may have little impact. However, in galaxy-related studies, stellar mass and luminosity show the strongest correlation with the maximum mass ever attained by a subhalo ( m_{\rm peak} ) or its highest circular velocity ( V_{\rm peak} ) [ 21 ] . This relationship exists because satellite galaxies experience mostly passive evolution after falling into their host system, and their stars are significantly more resistant to tidal stripping compared to the dark matter halos that surround them [ 22 ] . Therefore, numerical effects can impact subhalos hosting massive galaxies—typically observed in current galaxy surveys—and should be treated carefully. Orphans are typically tracked by following the trajectories of their most bound particles prior to disruption, with their survival determined using merger timescales from dynamical friction models [ 2 , 23 , 24 ] . This can be regarded as a leading-order correction, since the evolution of resolved subhalos can differ from that of individual particles, resulting in distinct phase-space distributions. Although more sophisticated semi-analytical approaches exist [ 9 , 10 ] , no widely accepted next-level treatment has yet emerged. The above method has already been adopted in empirical and semi-analytical galaxy formation models [ 25 , 26 , 27 ] . However, a comprehensive evaluation of these correction methods in cosmological simulations has not yet been performed, with only limited examinations in zoom-in simulations of individual Milky Way–like halos [ 16 , 17 ] . In this study, I compare subhalo abundance and phase-space distributions in two high-resolution cosmological simulations with different mass resolutions. I find that the surviving subhalo peak mass function converges only for subhalos with m_{\rm peak} exceeding 5000 particles, but can be accurately recovered by including orphan subhalos that survive according to the merger timescale model of Jiang et al. [ 24 ] , which outperforms alternative models. Including orphans also enables recovery of the real-space spatial and velocity distributions to 5–10% accuracy down to scales of 0.1–0.2 \,h^{-1} Mpc, though convergence below 0.1 \,h^{-1} Mpc remains challenging and likely requires more sophisticated orphan modeling. These results also contribute to the study and understanding of these fundamental properties of subhalos. The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes the simulations used in this work. The subhalo abundance, spatial distribution, and velocity distribution are analyzed in sections 3 , 4 , and 5 , respectively. A summary is provided in section 6 . 2 Simulation data In this work, I employ the primary runs of the Jiutian hybrid simulation suite [ 28 ] , developed for the extragalactic surveys of the China Space Station Telescope (CSST) [ 29 ] . The suite comprises three primary high-resolution \Lambda CDM simulations based on Planck 2018 cosmology [ 30 ] , 129 medium-resolution \nu w_{0}w_{a} CDM simulations from the Kun emulator [ 31 ] , nine high-resolution zoom-in hydrodynamical simulations centered on

Read the complete text