Steady state properties of periodically driven quantum systems
Milan Šindelka, David Gelbwaser-Klimovsky · 2025
Read Steady state properties of periodically driven quantum systems by Milan Šindelka, David Gelbwaser-Klimovsky (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07674.txt.
Introduction
Milan Šindelka and David Gelbwaser-Klimovsky wrote this physics paper in 2025. Many devices push a system with a rhythm, driving it into a steady state it could never reach at rest. For open quantum systems, what that end state looks like is hard to pin down. Past work leaned on narrow kinds of drive and rough approximations. The pair study a broad case: a multi-level quantum system in a thin warm gas, pushed in a set rhythm.
Using a scattering frame built for rhythmic systems, they set broad rules that any end state and its jump rates must obey. At high heat, they find a surprise: the end state spreads evenly across levels, just as the old Boltzmann law would say, for any drive. A toy model run on a computer bears the theory out.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Milan Šindelka, David Gelbwaser-Klimovsky |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 83 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07674
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Steady state properties of periodically driven quantum systems Milan Šindelka, David Gelbwaser-Klimovsky Abstract Periodic driving is used to steer physical systems to unique stationary states or nonequilibrium steady states (NESS), producing enhanced properties inaccessible to non-driven systems. For open quantum systems, characterizing the NESS is challenging and existing results are generally limited to specific types of driving and the Born-Markov approximation. Here we go beyond these limits by studying a generic periodically driven N N -level quantum system interacting with a low-density thermal gas. Exploiting the framework of Floquet scattering theory, we establish general Floquet thermalization conditions constraining the nature of the NESS and the transition rates. Moreover, we examine theoretically the structure of the NESS at high temperatures, and find out that the NESS complies, rather surprisingly, with the Boltzmann law for any driving. Numerical calculations illustrate our theoretical elaborations for a simple toy model. I Introduction Periodic driving is used in a wide range of fields to modify quantum systems in an ad hoc manner and to enhance specific properties such as: tunneling suppresion in BEC Lignier et al. 2007 , inducing topological state in semiconductor quantum wells Lindner et al. 2011 and creating topological and a quantum spin Hall insulator in lattices Hauke et al. 2012 , reducing decoherence of a spin- \frac{1}{2} particle Chen et al. 2015 , creating quantum heat machines Gelbwaser-Klimovsky et al. 2013 . This approach is known as Floquet engineering and has been studied both for closed Bukov et al. 2015 ; Eckardt 2017 and open systems Mori 2023 . Periodically driven systems reach a periodic steady state or limiting cycle Yudin et al. 2016 . For systems interacting with a thermal bath, the periodic steady state can be mapped to a nonequilibrium steady state (NESS) Raz et al. 2016 . The NESS ultimately determines the steady physical properties of the system. In general, determining the NESS is a complex problem, but some progress has been made under some restrictions on the driving. For example, in Ikeda and Sato 2020 ; Ikeda et al. 2021 ; Martins et al. 2025 , the NESS of a high-frequency periodically driven system was found. To avoid the complexity of finding the NESS, an alternative approach can be taken: studying the conditions under which the NESS does not deviate from the thermal state or a thermal state with an effective Hamiltonian, also called the Floquet-Gibbs state (FGS). In these cases, all the novel properties or phases inaccessible in thermal equilibrium are lost, and therefore, these conditions should be avoided if any enhanced properties are desired. In particular, under the Born-Markov approximation or weak coupling limit Breuer et al. 2002 , detailed balance of the transition rates has been used to find conditions for a FGS Breuer et al. 2000 ; Shirai et al. 2016 ; Liu 2015 . These conditions are limited to specific driving Hamiltonians or frequencies, and, therefore, can not be universally applied. In this work, we study the NESS of a periodically driven N -level system interacting with a single thermal bath represented by a dilute gas. This allows us to employ a Lindblad equation beyond the weak coupling limit Dümcke 1985 , to study the NESS beyond the Born-Markov approximation, and to find conditions for it to be a FGS. Exploiting the framework of Floquet scattering theory Peskin and Moiseyev 1994 ; Lefebvre and Atabek 2005 , we establish general Floquet thermalization conditions constraining the nature of the NESS and the transition rates. These conditions generalize the usual detailed balance-like restriction commonly found for rates of periodically driven system under the Born-Markov approximation Kohn 2001 . Moreover, we examine theoretically the structure of NESS at high temperatures, and find out that the high temperature NESS approaches, rather surprisingly, to the FGS, independently of the driving strength, frequency or Hamiltonian. This happens despite the lack of compliance with detailed balance. As we show, the lack of deviation from a Boltzmann state is a consequence of the unitarity of the scattering operator, which at high temperatures precludes the rate asymmetries required for a non-thermal steady state. In contrast, for lower temperatures, the NESS deviates from the Boltzmann equilibrium state, requiring the injection of energy in order to produce it. Our theoretical elaborations are illustrated by numerical calculations for a simple toy model. II Theoretical outline II.1 Periodically driven \bm{N} -level system coupled to dilute thermal gas We consider an N -level quantum system that is subjected to a periodic driving with frequency \omega . Moreover, the quantum system interacts with a single thermal bath at an inverse temperature \beta=(k_{B}T)^{-1} . We furthermore assume that the bath is a d -dimensional low density gas composed of free particles that are scattered by the driven N -level system. This assumption allows to write the low density Lindblad master equation for the system evolution Dümcke 1985 . This equation is valid for any bath-system coupling strength even beyond the Born-Markov approximation. Periodic driving is described by exploiting the language of Floquet theory Peskin and Moiseyev 1994 ; Lefebvre and Atabek 2005 (see S.1 in the supplemental material). Due to driving, bare energy levels \{E_{j},1\leq j\leq N\} of the N -level system are converted into quasi-energies \{E_{j\nu}^{\rm QE}=E_{j0}^{\rm QE}+\nu\hbar\omega,1\leq j\leq N,\nu\in{\mathbb{Z}}\} , where E_{j0}^{\rm QE} reduces to E_{j} for zero driving, and the Floquet index \nu labels here different Brillouin copies of the same physical Floquet state j . Hereafter we shall assume non-degenerate setup, E_{j\nu}^{\rm QE}\neq E_{j^{\prime}\nu^{\prime}}^{\rm QE} for (j\nu)\neq(j^{\prime}\nu^{\prime}) . In such non-degenerate cases, the physical populations \wp_{j} of the driven N -level system are decoupled from coherences, and the latter decay to zero. From now on, we focus solely on the populations \wp_{j} of the physical Floquet states j , which evolve according to the Pauli rate equation Pauli 1928 : \displaystyle\dot{\wp}_{j} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt=1}^{N}\,a_{jj^{\prime}}\,\wp_{j^{\prime}}\;-\;\wp_{j}\,\sum_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt=1}^{N}\,a_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113ptj}; (1) with a_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113ptj}\;=\;\sum_{\nu=-\infty}^{\nu=+\infty}a_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113ptj}^{\nu} . Here a_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113ptj}^{\nu} refers to the rate of transition j\to j^{\prime} and the absorption of \nu Floquet quanta by the system from the driving field. These transition rates are obtained using the framework of the low-density limit Lindblad equation. They are based on scattering theory and are constructed from the Floquet \widehat{T}- matrix elements through the following formula, \displaystyle a_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113ptj}^{\nu}\;={\cal N}\,Z^{-1}\hskip-1.42262pt\int_{{\mathbb{R}}^{d}}\hskip-1.42262pt{\rm d}^{d}p\int_{{\mathbb{R}}^{d}}\hskip-1.42262pt{\rm d}^{d}p^{\prime}\;e^{-\beta\frac{\bm{p}^{2}}{2\,m}}\,\times (2) \displaystyle\delta\hskip-1.42262pt\hskip-1.42262pt\left(\frac{\bm{p}^{\prime 2}}{2\,m}+E_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\nu}^{\rm QE}-\frac{\bm{p}^{2}}{2\,m}-E_{j0}^{\rm QE}\right)\,\Bigl|\langle\hskip-1.42262pt\hskip-0.7113pt\langle\bm{p}^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\,(j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\nu)|\hskip-0.7113pt|\widehat{T}|\hskip-0.7113pt|\bm{p}\,(j0)\rangle\hskip-1.42262pt\hskip-0.7113pt\rangle\Bigr|^{2}. Here {\cal N} stands for the gas particle density, Z=\int_{{\mathbb{R}}^{d}}\hskip-0.7113pt{\rm d}^{d}p\,e^{-\beta\frac{\bm{p}^{2}}{2\,m}} and \langle\hskip-1.42262pt\hskip-0.7113pt\langle\bm{p}^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\,(j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\nu)|\hskip-0.7113pt|\widehat{T}|\hskip-0.7113pt|\bm{p}\,(j0)\rangle\hskip-1.42262pt\hskip-0.7113pt\rangle are the on-shell Floquet \widehat{T} -matrix elements, encoding all information about scattering of a single gas particle on the driven N -level system (see section S.1 on the supplemental material). |\hskip-0.7113pt|\bm{p}\,(j0)\rangle\hskip-1.42262pt\hskip-0.7113pt\rangle represents an asymptotic in-state corresponding to a gas particle of momentum \bm{p} which approaches the driven system residing in its in-Floquet state (j0) . Similarly \langle\hskip-1.42262pt\hskip-0.7113pt\langle\bm{p}^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\,(j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\nu)|\hskip-0.7113pt| refers to an asymptotic out-state corresponding to a gas particle of momentum \bm{p}^{\prime} which departs from the driven system residing in its out-Floquet state (j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\nu) . For \dot{\wp}_{j}=0 , we obtain from ( 1 ) the NESS, \wp^{\rm NESS}_{j} , of the driven N -level system. The corresponding stationarity condition, \displaystyle\sum_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt=1}^{N}\,a_{jj^{\prime}}\,\wp^{\rm NESS}_{j^{\prime}}\;-\;\wp^{\rm NESS}_{j}\,\sum_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt=1}^{N}\,a_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113ptj}\;=\;0, (3) together with \sum_{j}\wp^{\rm NESS}_{j}=1 , determine the NESS \{\wp^{\rm NESS}_{j}\}_{j=1}^{N} uniquely in terms of the rates \{a_{jj^{\prime}}\} . II.2 Floquet thermalization conditions We recall that the Floquet \widehat{S} -matrix elements take the form \displaystyle\langle\hskip-1.42262pt\hskip-0.7113pt\langle\bm{p}^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\,(j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt\nu)|\hskip-0.7113pt|\widehat{S}|\hskip-0.7113pt|\bm{p}\,(j0)\rangle\hskip-1.42262pt\hskip-0.7113pt\rangle=\delta^{d}\hskip-1.42262pt(\bm{p}^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113pt-\bm{p})\,\delta_{j^{\prime}\hskip-0.7113ptj}\,\delta_{\nu 0}- (4)