Comparing a Mass Shell Model for Compact Binaries with Observed Gravitational Waves

Noah M. MacKay · 2025

Read Comparing a Mass Shell Model for Compact Binaries with Observed Gravitational Waves by Noah M. MacKay (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07499.txt.

Introduction

Noah M MacKay presents a 2025 arXiv paper testing an alternative model of merging black holes and neutron stars against real gravitational wave data. The model treats a coalescing pair as one rotating, shrinking mass shell and derives its energy from Einstein's equations. MacKay computes predicted radiated energy for 45 events from the first four observing runs.

For 38 events, the predictions landed inside the observed uncertainty, with ratios near 0.94 on average. A few events fell short, one badly, and some lacked the data to judge. The author reads the match as evidence the simple shell captures the leading energy scaling, and names refinements to chase.

Catalog record

CREATORNoah M. MacKay
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07499

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparing a Mass Shell Model for Compact Binaries with Observed Gravitational Waves Preprint: PRD Noah M. MacKay Abstract A recent study modeled coalescing compact binaries as a spinning and contracting mass shell geometry, reinterpreting the effective one-body model. Besides obtaining the respective waveform profiles that include rates of change in binary separation and orbital frequency, an expression for the mass-shell surface energy was derived to compute the anticipated energy radiated as gravitational waves. In this study, we revisit the surface energy derivation using a variational method that was recently used, and we recover the energy’s dependence on the compact binary’s reduced mass, symmetric mass ratio, and the normalized rotational speed at merger. For 31 out of 93 cataloged GW events within the O1, O2 and O3 observation runs, we compute the anticipated energy radiated as gravitational waves and compare these values with the observed energy, either directly measured or extracted from the total-minus-remnant mass difference. It is shown that the model presented in this work agrees well with observed energy measurements, within the error range and via 1:1 ratios spanning from 0.828 0.828 to 0.997 0.997 across 29 example events (the mean value of these 29 ratios being 0.941 0.941 ), with GW190403_051519 serving as an outlier with the 1:1 ratio of 0.462 0.462 , demonstrating the precision and universality of the energy expression to be applied to current and future detections. I Introduction Since their discovery on 14 September 2015, gravitational waves (GWs) have been observed by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) collaboration LIGOScientific:2018mvr ; LIGOScientific:2021usb ; KAGRA:2021vkt . GW sources are well understood to be coalescing compact binaries (CCBs), which are treated as non-zero quadrupolar sources in the linearized Einstein field equations (EFEs) when obtaining the respective waveforms. Analytical efforts to describe CCB dynamics include the effective one-body (EOB) approach Buonanno:1998gg ; Buonanno:2005xu , which views a CCB as the reduced mass \mu=m_{1}m_{2}/M ( M=m_{1}+m_{2} is the total mass) spiraling inward, towards the total mass innermost stable circular orbital (ISCO) radius, until it plunges into the total mass horizon with radius r_{S}=2GM , with c=1 . The largeness of the symmetric mass ratio \alpha:=\mu/M\in(0,1/4] directly influences the duration of nearly-circular orbital paths and how soon they become inspiraling plunge paths Buonanno:1998gg . A more recent study MacKay:2024qxj reinterpreted the EOB model, by describing a CCB as a spinning and shrinking hollow mass shell. In this framework, the CB masses m_{1} and m_{2} are distributed along a mass ring on the equatorial plane; inclination angles \iota\in[0,\pi] are “integrated” over by distributing the mass ring into a mass shell. The measure of the mass shell remains the reduced mass \mu – a logical choice for binary systems and staying in alignment with EOB –, and the rate of change in CCB separation -\dot{L} illustrates the rate of change in the shell diameter -\dot{S} . At the merger time t=t_{C} , coalescence ends where the masses touch surfaces: L(t_{C})=r_{1}+r_{2} , relating the shell diameter to the total mass horizon: S(t_{C})=4GM . Via -\dot{L}=-\dot{S} , the dynamic shell diameter is expressed as S(t)=L(t)-r_{1}-r_{2}+4GM (c.f. Ref. MacKay:2024qxj ). When the shrinking shell geometry (assumed to be a point mass under a luminosity distance D\gg S ) is put in the quadrupole-sourced GW equation, the resulting waveform is readily transverse-traceless (TT) gauged, with rates of change in shell diameter and orbital frequency \Omega influencing the wave amplitude and envelope MacKay:2024qxj : \displaystyle h_{+}^{\mathrm{TT}}=-\frac{G\mu S^{2}}{D}\left[\sin(2\Omega t)\left(\frac{2\dot{S}}{S}\left(\Omega+t\dot{\Omega}\right)+\dot{\Omega}+\frac{t}{2}\ddot{\Omega}\right)-\cos(2\Omega t)\left(\frac{\dot{S}^{2}}{2S^{2}}+\frac{\ddot{S}}{2S}-\left(\Omega+t\dot{\Omega}\right)^{2}\right)+\frac{\dot{S}^{2}}{2S^{2}}+\frac{\ddot{S}}{2S}\right], (1a) \displaystyle h_{\times}^{\mathrm{TT}}=-\frac{G\mu S^{2}}{D}\left[\sin(2\Omega t)\left(\frac{\dot{S}^{2}}{2S^{2}}+\frac{\ddot{S}}{2S}-\left(\Omega+t\dot{\Omega}\right)^{2}\right)+\cos(2\Omega t)\left(\frac{2\dot{S}}{S}\left(\Omega+t\dot{\Omega}\right)+\dot{\Omega}+\frac{t}{2}\ddot{\Omega}\right)\right]. (1b) Under a mass shell model for CCBs, one can employ Newtonian postulates for a gravitating mass shell, which state: (i) the internal gravitational field lines cancel out, and (ii) the external gravitational field resembles that of a point mass. In the logic of the second postulate, the emission of GWs via their waveforms can be idealized as the quadrupolar radiation transporting energy from the mass shell surface. Ref. MacKay:2024qxj also obtained an expression for this surface energy, which serves to calculate the anticipated energy radiated as quadrupole-sourced GWs. The derivation employed a variational methodology on the EFEs, in the similar philosophy as quantum mechanical variational method: using the Laplace-Beltrami formulation for the Ricci tensor Chow:2004 and a Kerr metric Ansatz for a spinning, compact system, an expression for the energy density T_{00}\propto G_{00} was obtained by only evaluating the geometric contributions of the g_{00} Kerr element. Under simple assumptions, the expression for the surface energy at coalescence E(t_{C})\equiv T_{00}V(t_{C}) ( V(t)\propto\rho(t)^{3} , with \rho=S/2 being the shell radius) readily depends on the symmetric mass ratio \alpha , the reduced mass \mu , and a quadratic spin term encoding the normalized rotational velocity at merger: E(t_{C})\simeq\frac{\pi}{6}\alpha\mu(1-5\beta_{C}^{2}). (2) In Eq. ( 2 ), \beta_{C}=v_{C}/c in SI units is the speed ratio entailing the normalized rotational velocity, which has the anticipated coalescence value of v_{C}=GMf_{\text{GW,peak}} (i.e. the peak orbital frequency times the total mass horizon radius). Two representative examples: GW150914 LIGOScientific:2016aoc and GW170817 LIGOScientific:2017vwq ; were chosen mainly for their CB type – respectively binary black holes (BBHs) and binary neutron stars (BNSs) – and to test for invariance in CB type. The respective energy values anticipated via Eq. ( 2 ), using center parameter values (low-spin prior for GW170817) in the GWTC papers LIGOScientific:2018mvr ; LIGOScientific:2021usb , are 2.075M_{\odot}c^{2} and 0.0885M_{\odot}c^{2} . This is compared to the respective cataloged values of E_{\mathrm{rad}}=3.1^{+0.4}_{-0.4}M_{\odot}c^{2} and E_{\text{rad}}\geq 0.04M_{\odot}c^{2} LIGOScientific:2018mvr . Constraining the GW energy for GW170817 can also be set by the ad hoc “rule-of-thumb” of roughly one-tenth of the chirp mass \mathcal{M}\equiv\alpha^{3/5}M (see the comparison between M-M_{f} and \sim\mathcal{M}/10 listed in Refs. LIGOScientific:2018mvr ; LIGOScientific:2021usb ; KAGRA:2021vkt ), which is \sim 0.1186M_{\odot}c^{2} via the spin-prior-mutual chirp mass \mathcal{M}=1.186^{+0.001}_{-0.001}M_{\odot} LIGOScientific:2018mvr . Addressing the scaling discrepancy between the model and the cataloged values rest in the assumptions taken to derive Eq. ( 2 ). A rigorous method in comparison, discussed in-text in Ref. MacKay:2024qxj but further analyzed in Section II of this work, utilized the non-vanishing Kerr-metric Kretschmann scalar K=R_{\alpha\beta\mu\nu}R^{\alpha\beta\mu\nu} as a surrogate for the Ricci scalar. More specifically, R_{\text{eff}}=-\sqrt{K}/6 , which contributes to the new anticipated values for GW150814 and GW170817, respectively, to be E(t_{C})\simeq 3.26M_{\odot}c^{2} and E(t_{C})\simeq 0.14M_{\odot}c^{2} . Again, these values used center values for the parameters, and they are closer to the catalog (“rule-of-thumb” for GW170817) energy values. In this work, we revisit the energy density expression that was first derived under simple assumptions in Ref. MacKay:2024qxj . However, we will use the Kretschmann scalar surrogate for the Ricci scalar, as the representative examples showed a closer approximation than the simplified values. To test its validity and universality, we compare energy calculations (anticipated values) with the catalog values over 31 examples of the 93 cataloged GW events as of 10 August, 2025. This is presented in Section III.2 ; after a discussion of our findings and methods in Section IV , we conclude in Section IV.3 . II Methods The Einstein field equations (EFEs) describe gravity as the response to geometric warpings caused by a source: G_{\mu\nu}:=R_{\mu\nu}-\frac{1}{2}Rg_{\mu\nu}=8\pi G\,T_{\mu\nu}. (3) The Einstein tensor G_{\mu\nu} on the left-hand side encodes the geometric effects caused by the source T_{\mu\nu} via the Ricci R_{\mu\nu} and metric g_{\mu\nu} tensors and the Ricci scalar R=g^{\mu\nu}R_{\mu\nu} . The additive cosmological contribution \Lambda

Read the complete text