An Empirical Inquiry into Surveillance Capitalism: Web Tracking DOI: 10.48550/arXiv.2508.07454 Conference: 11th Workshop on Computing Within Limits; June 26–27, 2025; Online
Nils Bonfils · 2025
Read An Empirical Inquiry into Surveillance Capitalism: Web Tracking DOI: 10.48550/arXiv.2508.07454 Conference: 11th Workshop on Computing Within Limits; June 26–27, 2025; Online by Nils Bonfils (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07454.txt.
Introduction
Nils Bonfils wrote a 2025 paper measuring surveillance capitalism through the web tracking of the five tech giants. Google, Apple, Facebook, Amazon, and Microsoft blanket the web with trackers that harvest behavior as a business model. The study tests that claim with data rather than theory alone.
Tracking records from WhoTracks.Me, spanning 2017 to 2025, were set against the companies' public financial filings. Google emerged as omnipresent across the web. The five firms sorted into a three-tier hierarchy in the surveillance space. Tracking techniques also appeared to evolve in ways that dodge detection. The paper weighs the social and environmental costs of this extraction. It closes by pointing to alternatives like the Gemini protocol as a challenge to the model.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nils Bonfils |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07454
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An Empirical Inquiry into Surveillance Capitalism: Web Tracking DOI: 10.48550/arXiv.2508.07454 Conference: 11th Workshop on Computing Within Limits; June 26–27, 2025; Online Nils Bonfils Abstract . The modern web is increasingly characterized by the pervasiveness of Surveillance Capitalism. This investigation employs an empirical approach to examine this phenomenon through the web tracking practices of major tech companies — specifically Google, Apple, Facebook, Amazon, and Microsoft (GAFAM) — and their relation to financial performance indicators. Using longitudinal data from WhoTracks.Me spanning from 2017 to 2025 and publicly accessible SEC filings, this paper analyzes patterns and trends in web tracking data to establish empirical evidence of Surveillance Capitalism’s extraction mechanisms. Our findings reveal Google’s omnipresent position on the web, a three-tier stratification among GAFAM companies in the surveillance space, and evidence suggesting an evolution of tracking techniques to evade detection. The investigation further discusses the social and environmental costs of web tracking and how alternative technologies, such as the Gemini protocol, offer pathways to challenge the extractive logic of this new economic order. By closely examining surveillance activities, this research contributes to an ongoing effort to better understand the current state and future trajectory of Surveillance Capitalism. 1. Introduction Contemporary society is increasingly characterized by the pervasiveness of Surveillance Capitalism, a new economic order where human experience is claimed as free raw material for hidden commercial practices of extraction, prediction, and sales. While fundamentally reshaping digital interactions, this phenomenon remains conceptually elusive and difficult to grasp in concrete terms. This elusiveness calls for empirical investigation to understand its actual mechanisms and impact. Surveillance Capitalism originated at Google, when the corporation discovered that users’ seemingly inconsequential digital traces, also called “data exhaust”, could be algorithmically processed and analyzed to predict future behavior and monetized through targeted advertising ( Zuboff 2015 ) . The internet, particularly the World Wide Web, provided the essential infrastructure for this new economic logic to flourish. The web’s client-server architecture, coupled with lagging regulatory frameworks, created optimal conditions for surveillance operations to take root without restraints. The growing trends towards the use of web applications over more traditional “native” applications has accelerated this transformation. With individuals increasingly migrating daily activities to web applications, the web has evolved from a document-sharing medium to an application platform. This consolidation of activity on the web provides an ideal environment for surveillance operations, enabling tech companies to monitor user behavior across various services through web tracking. This surveillance power is further concentrated as these same companies provide access to the web platform through their browsers, with Google, Apple, and Microsoft’s web browsers representing approximately 90% of all browser usage. Web tracking refers to the collection of data about users’ online activities, including pages visited, clicks made, time spent on sites, and numerous other behavioral signals. These collection mechanisms range from simple cookies to sophisticated fingerprinting techniques capable of identifying users across multiple devices and sessions. While some tracking serves legitimate purposes like authentication and site functionality, the vast majority enables the surveillance apparatus that powers contemporary Surveillance Capitalism. Both direct outcomes (targeted advertising) and indirect outcomes (product improvement) of this surveillance enable the creation of “behavioral prediction products” that have tangible monetary value. Web tracking data offers researchers a valuable opportunity to investigate the materialization of Surveillance Capitalism. By analyzing patterns and evolution in tracking technologies, we can begin to map the actual extent and mechanisms of surveillance on the web, moving beyond theoretical frameworks to empirical evidence. This methodological approach allows for critical assessment of surveillance practices across digital ecosystems and their relationship to corporate financial performance. This investigation will seek to establish empirical evidence of Surveillance Capitalism by analyzing web tracking practices of major tech companies — specifically Google, Apple, Facebook, Amazon, and Microsoft (GAFAM) — and their relation to financial performance indicators. Three primary research questions will be addressed: • RQ1 : Within GAFAM, which entities demonstrate the highest engagement in surveillance practices? • RQ2 : Do web tracking metrics correlate with the entity’s advertising revenue? • RQ3 : Can web tracking provide quantitative evidence of Surveillance Capitalism activity? 2. Background This work builds on the theoretical framework of Surveillance Capitalism established by Zuboff ( Zuboff 2015 ; Zuboff 2019 ) . Most contributions based on this framework are predominantly qualitative in nature ( Landwehr et al. 2023 ; Power 2022 ) . Few empirical studies directly reference Surveillance Capitalism ( Amiel et al. 2023 ) . The dearth in empirical studies can be attributed to the active concealment of activities and practices by corporations partaking in Surveillance Capitalism. Entities that surveil also actively conceal their data collection practices to maintain this asymmetrical access to information that is essential for Surveillance Capitalism to function. In Zuboff’s seminal book, she defines Surveillance Capitalism as an economic order, an economic logic, a mutation of capitalism, a foundational framework, a threat, the origin of a new power, a movement and an expropriation of human rights. ( Zuboff 2019 ) Despite this rich definition, such a concept remains difficult to operationalize, making it challenging to identify empirically. Additional work is needed on defining Surveillance Capitalism, but more importantly on identifying ways to evaluate and measure its different aspects. However, empirical researchers investigating this topic implicitly place themselves in opposition to the dominant entities of this new economic order. Nonetheless, there has been a wealth of empirical research examining web trackers, ad blockers, and privacy enhancing technologies outside of the Surveillance Capitalism theoretical framework. Previous research on web tracking has focused on specific countries ( Bailey et al. 2019 ) , continents ( Helles et al. 2020 ) , or regulatory landscapes ( Johnson et al. 2023 ) . Some studies adopt a more global perspective ( Samarasinghe and Mannan 2019 ) . However, most of those studies only provide static snapshots of the web tracking landscape. Few studies conduct longitudinal analyses ( Lerner et al. 2016 ; Lukic et al. 2024 ) and fewer systematically link trackers to their parent corporate entities. This investigation uses data from a long-standing open source database that allows investigation of web-tracking over multiple years ( Karaj et al. 2019 ) . This study presents a significant opportunity for interdisciplinary research that bridges empirical research of privacy-enhancing technologies with the theoretical framework of Surveillance Capitalism. 3. Approach This investigation employs an empirical approach to examine the role of GAFAM companies in the web tracking space. Two primary data sources were used: (1) WhoTracks.Me: an open source database of web trackers. (2) GAFAM’s publicly accessible U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filings. Both datasets were integrated to examine the interplay between tracking practices and financial performance. 3.1. WhoTracks.Me Dataset WhoTracks.Me is a website and database that document web tracking activities ( Karaj et al. 2019 ) . It originated within the Cliqz company in 2017 after the acquisition of the Ghostery web browser extension 1 1 1 https://www.ghostery.com/ghostery-ad-blocker . While Cliqz, a company focused on creating both a privacy-oriented web browser and search engine, discontinued operations, the work on Ghostery extension and associated database continues to receive monthly updates. Data collection occurs through “real” web browsing by Ghostery users who have consented to share their tracking data during their browsing. This