Singular zero-temperature system

Q. H. Liu, S. F. Xiao, Di Guo, K. J. Yin · 2025

Read Singular zero-temperature system by Q. H. Liu, S. F. Xiao, Di Guo, K. J. Yin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07389.txt.

Introduction

QH Liu and three co-authors argue that a second kind of system can exist near absolute zero. It would stand apart from the normal kind that fits all forms of the third law of heat science. The usual view holds that heat capacity must fade to zero as cold nears its limit. Their work came out in twenty twenty-five.

The authors note that the law's forms are not fully the same once that quiet premise is dropped. A system might fit one or two forms but not all, and still be fit for the real world. They call such a case a singular zero temperature system. Past models from other authors are checked and found to belong to this new class.

Catalog record

CREATORQ. H. Liu, S. F. Xiao, Di Guo, K. J. Yin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07389

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Singular zero-temperature system Q. H. Liu, S. F. Xiao, Di Guo, K. J. Yin Abstract It has long been taken for granted that there is only one type of thermodynamic system near absolute zero temperature: the ordinary one compatible with all statements of the third law, with a fundamental yet tacit assumption that all heat capacities in the system vanish as absolute temperature approaches zero. However, in the strict sense, the statements are not mutually equivalent. Once the tacit assumption is released, the inequivalence must remain, and we may have some systems that are only compatible with one or two statements but not all, defining a singular zero-temperature system which can never be excluded from physical feasibility. We revisit some previously proposed theoretical models and identify that they belong to the singular system. I Introduction The third law of thermodynamics imposes the boundary conditions at T=0 on thermodynamics, which is a collection of three inequivalent statements: Landsberg ; comment Nernst statement, Planck statement and Unattainability statement. By Nernst statement, we mean that the T=0 isotherm is also an isentrope (or ”adiabat”), callen \underset{T\rightarrow 0}{\lim}\left(\Delta S\right)_{T}=0, (1) where we define the constant-temperature entropy change \left(\Delta S\right)_{T} , with a set of independent external variables \left\{x\right\} , \left(\Delta S\right)_{T}\equiv S\left(T,\left\{x_{f}\right\}\right)-S\left(T,\left\{x_{i}\right\}\right) (2) for two equilibrium states (T,\left\{x_{i}\right\}) and \left(T,\left\{x_{f}\right\}\right) \left(\left\{x_{f}\right\}\neq\left\{x_{i}\right\}\right) which are connected by a thermodynamic process from initial values \left\{x_{i}\right\} to final one \left\{x_{f}\right\} under constant temperature T . By Planck statement, we mean that the entropy of any pure substance is zero at absolute zero, comment i.e., S\left(0,V\right)=0, (3) which is sometimes called as stronger version of the Nernst statement. In the Nernst statement ( 1 ), the temperature T is made to approach absolute zero but does not necessarily have to be zero, while in the Planck statement, the zero-point entropy is presupposed to exist. Once S\left(0,V\right) exists, we have an extremely simple argument to prove why and how ( 3 ) holds true in general. For two different volumes, Nernst statement implies S\left(0,V_{1}\right)=S\left(0,V_{2}\right) , i.e., V_{1}s\left(0,V_{1}\right)=V_{2}s\left(0,V_{2}\right) with s\left(0,V\right) being entropy density per volume s\left(0,V\right)\equiv S\left(0,V\right)/V . Since the entropy density is the same while V_{1} and V_{2} are arbitrarily, we thus must have ( 3 ). From this manner of proof, we see that there is a special case S\left(0,V\right)=Ns with s\left(0,V_{1}/N_{1}\right)=s\left(0,V_{2}/N_{2}\right)=const. Thus Planck statement permits a special case S\left(0,V/N\right)=const.\neq 0. (4) We refer to either ( 3 ) or ( 4 ) as the Planck statement. By the Unattainability statement, we mean that it is impossible by means of any process, no matter how idealized, to reduce the temperature of a system to the absolute zero, in a finite number of steps. comment As the inequivalence of these statements we refer to Reiss, comment Callen callen and also Landsberg (who notes that it has not proved possible to deduce the unattainability of the absolute zero from the Nernst statement, since the universe of possible operations of lowering temperatures can never be fully known.) Landsberg For our purposes, it is beneficial to take these statements as independent statements that serve different aspects of a system at extremely low temperatures, and by an ordinary zero-temperature system, we mean that it obeys all statements. For a second order ordinary differential equation, we usually have two types of solution, one is analytical in whole domain of the variables and another is singular at some points, and both solutions are meaningful. Since entropy S is not directly measurable, there is no principle to exclude the possibility of finiteness of S(0) even S(T=0)=\infty . comment1 ; comment2 A system with S(T=0)\neq 0 , partially compatible with the third law and fully permissible under other laws, is coined a singular zero-temperature system . In both mathematics and physics, we have well-established manners to deal with the singular situations, e.g. making a singular integral finite, rendering a singular solution of a differential equation meaningful and renormalizating a divergent series to be convergent, etc.. Similarly, the singular zero-temperature system can in principle be physically feasible. It is seldom emphasized, even mentioned (probably only once explicitly stated in a note in the literature comment ) that there is a separate postulate underlying the current formulation of the third law of thermodynamics: all heat capacity for a thermodynamic system is zero when T=0 (all-heat-double-zero (AHDZ), here H, DZ are abbreviated of h eat capacity, and d ouble z eros in both heat capacity and temperature, respectively). In fact, AHDZ can be taken as a statement of the experimental fact, but far from qualifiable to express a fundamental law for it is neither sufficient nor necessary for the third law to be held, as we will discuss in section II and III. The key purpose of the present study is the introduction of the singular zero-temperature system and its simple criteria, as well as its illustrations, which will be done in sections II and III, respectively. Section IV is the discussion and conclusion. The present study is confined ourself to thermodynamics without care for the statistical mechanics. For sake of simplicity, we consider a simple closed, one-component, one-phase system and choose temperature, T , and volume, V , as our independent variables, and the general form of the equation of state is p=p(T,V) , in which the number of particles N is a parameter with a fixed value. Our treatment is easily generalized to the complicated systems. II The singular zero-temperature system: Criteria First of all, it is stressed that the precise meaning of AHDZ in standard discussion of third law is in what follows. The entropy S\left(T,V\right) determined from the constant-volume heat capacity C_{V}(V,T) is given by, S\left(T,V\right)-S\left(0,V\right)=\int_{0}^{T}\frac{C_{V}(T^{\prime},V)}{T^{\prime}}dT^{\prime}. (5) The ordinary zero-temperature system requires that the entropy at any finite temperature is to be finite and continuous, which implies both S\left(0,V\right)=\text{finite value,} (6) and 0\prec\int_{0}^{T}\frac{C_{V}(T^{\prime},V)}{T^{\prime}}dT^{\prime}\prec\infty\text{ for finite T,} (7) simultaneously, rather than \underset{T\rightarrow 0}{\lim}C_{V}(T,V)=0 along. Otherwise we have counterexample, the so-called Mattis ”electron gas” system which will be discussed in section III. Secondly, breakdown of either ( 6 ) or ( 7 ) but agreement with the consistently modified form of ( 1 ) leads to the singular zero-temperature system. The so called consistently modified form of ( 1 ) means that once relation ( 7 ) breaks, and we are forced to deal following singular integral \underset{\varepsilon\rightarrow 0}{\lim}\int_{\varepsilon}^{T}\frac{C_{V}(T^{\prime},V)}{T^{\prime}}dT^{\prime}\rightarrow\infty\text{. } (8) Thus relation ( 5 ) must be modified into following one with \varepsilon being very close to zero, S\left(T,V\right)-S\left(\varepsilon,V\right)=\int_{\varepsilon}^{T}\frac{C_{V}(T^{\prime},V)}{T^{\prime}}dT^{\prime}. (9) For guaranteeing that at finite temperature T the entropy S\left(T,V\right)\ is finite, we must have from ( 9 ) \underset{\varepsilon\rightarrow 0}{\lim}S\left(\varepsilon,V\right)\rightarrow-\infty. (10) The constant-temperature entropy change \left(\Delta S\right)_{T} ( 2 ) must be generalized to be \left(\Delta S\right)_{T}\equiv S\left(T,V_{f}\right)-S\left(\varepsilon,V_{f}\right)-\left(S\left(T,V_{i}\right)-S\left(\varepsilon,V_{i}\right)\right). (11) Special case of the constant-temperature entropy change \left(\Delta S\right)_{T} is that there is no parameter \varepsilon , the definition of \left(\Delta S\right)_{T} is \left(\Delta S\right)_{T}\equiv S\left(T,V_{f}\right)-S\left(T,V_{i}\right) (12) The modified Nernst statement is \underset{\varepsilon\rightarrow 0}{\lim}\underset{T\rightarrow 0}{\lim}\left(\Delta S\right)_{T}=0,\text{or}\underset{T\rightarrow 0}{\lim}\left(\Delta S\right)_{T}=0 (13) where in the first expression we firstly let T\rightarrow 0 while \varepsilon is given a fixed value and secondly let \varepsilon\rightarrow 0 . For an ordinary zero-temperature system, the order of taking two limits is interchangeable, but for the singular one, it is not. Lastly, we give the criteria

Read the complete text