Probing the limits of effective temperature consistency in actively driven systems

Dima Boriskovsky, Rémi Goerlich, Benjamin Lindner, Yael Roichman · 2025

Read Probing the limits of effective temperature consistency in actively driven systems by Dima Boriskovsky, Rémi Goerlich, Benjamin Lindner, Yael Roichman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07362.txt.

Introduction

Temperature is a clear idea for systems at rest in balance, but driven, restless systems are murkier. Dima Boriskovsky and three co-authors test the idea in a 2025 study where a heavy probe sits in a trap and is buffeted by self-propelled walkers. They measure the probe's effective temperature three independent ways, using response rules, motion energy, and work patterns.

Under the right conditions, all three readings agreed closely across many setups, which supports the idea. In other regimes the readings split apart. The authors map that split as the true limit of stretching temperature talk to systems far from balance.

Catalog record

CREATORDima Boriskovsky, Rémi Goerlich, Benjamin Lindner, Yael Roichman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07362

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Probing the limits of effective temperature consistency in actively driven systems Dima Boriskovsky, Rémi Goerlich, Benjamin Lindner, Yael Roichman Abstract We investigate the thermodynamic properties of a single inertial probe driven into a nonequilibrium steady-state by random collisions with self-propelled active walkers. The probe and walkers are confined within a gravitational harmonic potential. We evaluate the robustness of the effective temperature concept in this active system by comparing values of distinct, independently motivated definitions: a generalized fluctuation-dissipation relation, a kinetic temperature, and a work fluctuation relation. Our experiments reveal that, under specific conditions, these independent measurements yield a remarkably consistent effective temperature over a wide range of system configurations. Furthermore, we also identify regimes where this consistency breaks down, which delineates the fundamental limits of extending equilibrium-like thermodynamic concepts to athermal, actively driven systems. I Introduction A single colloidal particle confined within a harmonic potential and immersed in a thermal fluid offers a fundamental realization of a microscopic statistical thermometer Uhlenbeck and Ornstein 1930 ; Wang and Uhlenbeck 1945 . In thermal equilibrium, the particle’s random displacements follow a Boltzmann (Gaussian) distribution, allowing the thermodynamic temperature, T , of the surrounding environment to be directly determined by its mean potential energy via the principle of equipartition Risken 1996 . Near and at equilibrium, T can be equivalently defined through various thermodynamic relations, which can be applied to and measured by a colloidal thermometer. Static relations, measured at stationary states, include canonical distributions and energy equipartition, as well as configurational definitions of temperature Han and Grier 2004 ; Rugh 1997 . Dynamic relations, measured by probing the system’s response properties, are given by the fluctuation-dissipation theorem Einstein 1905 ; Langevin 1908 ; Callen and Welton 1951 ; Kubo 1966 ; Kubo 1986 , which rigorously connects the effects of thermal noise and energy dissipation. In addition, fluctuation theorems also relate temperature to fluctuations in thermodynamic quantities such as heat, work, and entropy Gallavotti and Cohen 2004 ; Jop et al. 2008 ; Gomez-Solano et al. 2010 . Colloidal thermometers have thus been widely employed in experiments, both to validate theoretical measures of equilibrium temperature and to identify deviations from it Leptos et al. 2009 ; Maggi et al. 2014 ; Ciliberto 2017 ; Goerlich et al. 2022 . Crucially, various definitions of absolute temperature must yield consistent, measurement-independent values in accord with the zeroth law of thermodynamics. In stark contrast, no universal definition for temperature exists for many natural and engineered systems that operate far from thermal equilibrium. Nonetheless, the notion of effective temperature has frequently arisen as a heuristic extension of equilibrium statistical mechanics to diverse systems operating far from equilibrium, including glassy materials Cugliandolo et al. 1997 ; Berthier and Barrat 2002 ; Joubaud et al. 2009 ; Bouchbinder and Langer 2011 , biological suspensions Wu and Libchaber 2000 ; Leptos et al. 2009 ; Maggi et al. 2014 ; Argun et al. 2016 ; Maggi et al. 2017 ; Wiese et al. 2024 ; Di Bello et al. 2024 , driven granular media Puglisi et al. 1999 ; Pöschel and Luding 2001 ; Van Zon and MacKintosh 2004 ; Ojha et al. 2004 ; Villamaina et al. 2008 ; Villamaina et al. 2009 ; Shokef and Levine 2006 ; Bunin et al. 2008 ; Puglisi et al. 2002 ; Feitosa and Menon 2004 ; Abate and Durian 2008 ; Joubaud et al. 2012 ; Gnoli et al. 2014 ; Chastaing et al. 2017 ; Zeng et al. 2022 , and active matter Palacci et al. 2010 ; Martinez et al. 2013 ; Levis and Berthier 2015 ; Dieterich et al. 2015 ; Ginot et al. 2015 ; Petrelli et al. 2020 ; Flenner and Szamel 2020 ; Fodor et al. 2016 ; Han et al. 2017 ; Solon and Horowitz 2022 ; Ye et al. 2020 ; Park et al. 2020 ; Boudet et al. 2022 ; Shea et al. 2022 ; Goerlich et al. 2022 ; Geva et al. 2025 . In particular, under well-separated timescales, an equilibriumlike fluctuation-dissipation relation (FDR) can become applicable, leading to a definition of an effective temperature, T_{\text{eff}} . While the FDR-based T_{\text{eff}} has proven useful in various fields of physics Marconi et al. 2008 ; Baiesi et al. 2009 ; Ciliberto 2017 ; Maes 2020a ; Baldovin et al. 2022 , its thermodynamic interpretation and range of applicability remain subjects of ongoing research Martens et al. 2009 ; Cugliandolo 2011 ; Puglisi et al. 2017 ; Sorkin et al. 2024 . A remaining key challenge lies in identifying under which conditions distinct theoretical definitions of effective temperatures yield mutually consistent values far from equilibrium Casas-Vázquez and Jou 2003 ; Hecht et al. 2024 . Although numerous thermodynamic-like criteria have been proposed to establish a meaningful T_{\text{eff}} for nonequilibrium steady-states (NESS), consistency across measurements remains largely supported by empirical evidence Maggi et al. 2014 ; Chastaing et al. 2017 . Figure 1: The system: A. Experimental setup: A Styrofoam ball (diameter \sim 4 cm, 1 gr) is trapped in a gravitational harmonic potential, a plastic bowl (diameter 38cm, depth 5cm), and subjected to collisions with N_{b}=10 self-propelled bbots (inset: standard bbot, 4\times 1 cm, 7.1 gr). The ball is repeatedly perturbed with a uniform air stream created by an external fan along the x -axis (white arrow) to test a fluctuation-response relation. To enforce an abrupt onset and release of the perturbation, a mechanical shutter is used (denoted by ’S’). B. Velocity distributions of bbot assemblies with different N_{b}=3,4, and 10. Instantaneous velocities were extracted from 30 fps recordings of bbot trajectories tracked over 40 minutes. C. Spatial distribution of 10 bbots within the harmonic trap, with a soft boundary (steep curvature) indicated by a dashed circle of radius 10 cm. D, E. Typical 20 second trajectories of a single bbot in systems with N_{b}=3 (D) and N_{b}=10 (E) (upper panels), alongside the corresponding tracer trajectories (lower panels). In this work, a statistical thermometer is realized experimentally, based on a macroscopic tracer particle confined in a harmonic trap and driven into a NESS by random inelastic collisions with self-propelled walkers (see Section 2 and Fig. 1 ). Previously Boriskovsky et al. 2024 , it was shown that this system satisfies a linear (dynamic) FDR, with a large enough number of walkers. Here, we assess the consistency of the FDR-based T_{\text{eff}} by comparing it to three independent measures: the tracer’s potential energy and modified kinetic energy (at an unperturbed NESS), and a temperature based on a steady-state work fluctuation relation (FR), in a strongly perturbed NESS. Our main result is displayed in Fig. 2 : all three independent measurements of T_{\text{eff}} agree across a range of active bath parameters. We further compare our results with theoretical predictions and discuss conditions under which the consistency of T_{\text{eff}} breaks down. II Experimental setup and basic characterization Our experimental setup is illustrated in Fig. 1 A : A lightweight styrofoam ball (the tracer) is confined within a parabolic plastic arena and is subjected to random collisions with an assembly of vibration-driven self-propelled particles (bristlebots, or bbots , specifically Hexbug {}^{\text{TM}} ). The system is imaged from above using a standard webcam (Brio 4k, Logitech), and particle

Read the complete text