In-person, Online and Back Again - A Tale of Three Hybrid Hackathons
Abasi-amefon Obot Affia-Jomants, Alexander Serebrenik, James D. Herbsleb, Alexander Nolte · 2025
Read In-person, Online and Back Again - A Tale of Three Hybrid Hackathons by Abasi-amefon Obot Affia-Jomants, Alexander Serebrenik, James D. Herbsleb, Alexander Nolte (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07301.txt.
Introduction
Abasi-amefon Affia-Jomants and co-authors study hybrid hackathons in a 2025 paper. Hackathons mix in person and online participation more often now. That mix creates problems that neither format faces alone, such as communication split across rooms and screens. Research on the hybrid form remains fragmented.
Through case studies of three events, the team examine how organizers handled timing, physical spread, switching between modes, and technology. Events leaned toward in person, online, or balanced designs, and each lean shaped participant experience differently. The work offers guidance for designing hybrid events that serve both groups well.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abasi-amefon Obot Affia-Jomants, Alexander Serebrenik, James D. Herbsleb, Alexander Nolte |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 131 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07301
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
In-person, Online and Back Again - A Tale of Three Hybrid Hackathons Abasi-amefon Obot Affia-Jomants, Alexander Serebrenik, James D. Herbsleb, Alexander Nolte Abstract . Hybrid hackathons, which combine in-person and online participation, present unique challenges for organizers and participants. Although these events are increasingly conducted globally, research on them remains fragmented, with limited integration between hackathon studies and hybrid collaboration. Existing strategies for in-person or online-only events often fail to address the unique challenges of hybrid formats, such as managing communication across physical and virtual spaces and ensuring balanced participation. Our work addresses this gap by examining how hybrid hackathons function through the lens of hybrid collaboration theories, analyzing how organizers structure these events and how participants navigate hybrid-specific challenges. Drawing on established theories of hybrid collaboration, we examine key dimensions – synchronicity, physical distribution, dynamic transitions, and technological infrastructure – that shape collaboration in hybrid events. Through an exploratory case study of three hackathon events involving observations and interviews with organizers and participants, we analyze how these dimensions are implemented and their effects on participant experiences. Our findings reveal differing organizer considerations of the hybrid dimensions in the hackathon design, leading to distinct experiences for participants. Implementation styles – favoring in-person, online, or balanced participation – led to varied participant experiences, affecting access to resources, communication, and team coordination. Organizers in our study also often relied on technology to bridge hybrid interactions, but sometimes overlooked critical aspects like time-zone management, dynamic transitions, and targeted support for hybrid teams. Additionally, participants in their teams responded to gaps in event scaffolding by adapting collaboration strategies, underscoring that hybrid formats are still not fully integrated into hackathon planning and revealing gaps in organizers’ preparedness for hybrid events. Learning from our findings, we offer practical recommendations when organizing hybrid hackathon events and recommendations to participants when attending hybrid hackathon events. 1. Introduction Hackathons are a global phenomenon. They are time-bounded events, attracting participants with diverse backgrounds and expertise to work on a shared team project to create an artefact ( Falk et al. 2024 ) . Hackathons have grown popular because they create a unique environment that fosters rapid innovation and creativity ( Heller et al. 2023 ) , provide experiential learning opportunities ( Schulten and Chounta 2024 ; Affia et al. 2022 ) , and bring together diverse participants where individuals can connect with potential employers, collaborators, and mentors ( Warner and Guo 2017 ) . Hackathons have been commonly studied as in-person events, but during the global pandemic of 2020 and 2021, it became clear that online events can provide valuable collaboration spaces as well ( Mendes et al. 2022 ) . Moreover, they expanded collaboration opportunities ( Yokoi et al. 2021 ) , allowing individuals to participate who otherwise would not have had the chance due to financial, visa-related, scheduling, or other issues ( Wang et al. 2022 ; Falk et al. 2024 ; Mendes et al. 2022 ) . It was thus reasonable that after the pandemic, when there was a strong drive to go back to in-person events, hackathon organizers would start to experiment with hybrid setups that blend physical and virtual participation. Prior work on in-person ( Pe-Than and Herbsleb 2019 ) and online hackathon events ( Wang et al. 2022 ; Mendes et al. 2022 ) is valuable; still, hybrid events introduce distinct challenges. These include managing communication across physical and virtual spaces, ensuring equitable participation for both co-located and remote participants, and addressing the technical complexities of integrating multiple tools and platforms ( Neumayr et al. 2021 ) . Strategies developed for either in-person or online-only hackathon events overlook these hybrid-specific challenges, making them insufficient for fully addressing the demands of hybrid formats. While hybrid hackathons are being conducted globally, research on them remains limited. Existing studies have explored hybrid hackathons in relation to goals such as education and skill building ( Gama et al. 2023 ; Jonsson et al. 2022 ) , teamwork ( Porras et al. 2021 ) , and industry skills ( Skrupskaya et al. 2022 ) , but have not systematically examined how these events are designed and experienced in light of broader theories of hybrid collaboration. Our study addresses this gap by examining how organizers prepare for and run hybrid hackathons and how the event scaffolding can impact participants and their teams. RQ 1 . How do organizers prepare for and run hybrid hackathons? Since organizers already run hybrid hackathons, understanding how they plan and run them is essential to addressing the research gap, as it reveals the real-world strategies used to manage the hybrid format in their respective events. Although models of hybrid collaboration exist ( Neumayr et al. 2021 ) , it is unclear whether and how organizers take them into account when organizing their events. It is also unclear whether these approaches are sufficient since they have been developed in environments where collaboration is more controlled, such as workplace collaborations or long-term projects ( Neumayr et al. 2021 ; Wu et al. 2023 ; Buła et al. 2024 ; Deschênes 2024 ) . Hackathons, by contrast, are fast-paced events ( Than et al. 2018 ; Falk et al. 2024 ) where small, diverse teams work intensively over a short period, often without prior interaction or familiarity ( Than et al. 2018 ) . They present useful sites for studying hybrid work due to short-term goals and ad-hoc team formation. RQ 2 . How do the hybrid hackathons’ scaffolding impact participants and their teams? Organizer considerations of the hybrid format and the eventual hackathon design influence what happens during the hackathon ( Chau and Gerber 2023 ) and form the hackathon scaffolding. Participants who attend the hackathon engage in this hackathon scaffolding, thus impacting their experience ( RQ 1 ) ( Nolte et al. 2020 ; Chau and Gerber 2023 ) . Since hackathons are, by their nature, collaborative events ( Falk et al. 2024 ) , the impact of an event’s scaffolding will manifest itself in the way that teams collaborating across different modalities (remote, co-located, and hybrid) are formed, the way they collaborate, and the outcome of their collaboration ( Lyonnet 2021 ) . To answer our research questions, we conducted an exploratory case study ( Runeson et al. 2012 ) of three hybrid hackathon events. An exploratory case study is an appropriate research method for addressing our research questions because it allows for an in-depth investigation of organizer considerations and participant experiences in hybrid hackathons within their real-life context. The hybrid hackathon events were selected to represent a diversity of typologies ( Drouhard et al. 2016 ) , sizes ( Nolte et al. 2020 ) , duration ( Nolte et al. 2020 ) , audience ( Medina Angarita and Nolte 2020 ) , and goal/themes ( Nolte et al. 2020 ) . Our selection criteria ensure that the cases reflect common but varied hybrid hackathon formats, enabling us to explore overarching patterns and specific, context-dependent challenges or advantages. Our case study approach allows for the collection of rich qualitative data through interviews and event observations. We interviewed organizers before and after their event to understand how they planned it and how it eventually turned out