Constraints on the Variation of the QCD Interaction Scale Λ QCD \Lambda_{\text{QCD}}

V. V. Flambaum, A. J. Mansour · 2025

Read Constraints on the Variation of the QCD Interaction Scale Λ QCD \Lambda_{\text{QCD}} by V. V. Flambaum, A. J. Mansour (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07266.txt.

Introduction

Flambaum and Mansour present a 2025 study of whether the strong force scale, a base quantity in particle physics, can drift over time. Past tests chased drift in the fine-structure constant or in mass ratios, while holding this scale fixed. Some dark sector theories would let the scale itself drift through a field tied to gluons.

The authors recast top atomic clock data into a tight drift bound for the scale. Records from an ancient natural reactor in Oklo give a far tighter bound over its long life. A planned thorium clock would sharpen the hunt by orders of magnitude.

Catalog record

CREATORV. V. Flambaum, A. J. Mansour
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07266

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constraints on the Variation of the QCD Interaction Scale Λ QCD \Lambda_{\text{QCD}} V. V. Flambaum, A. J. Mansour Abstract Laboratory and astrophysical tests of “constant variation” have so far concentrated on the dimensionless fine-structure constant α \alpha and on the electron or quark mass ratios X e , q = m e , q / Λ QCD X_{e,q}=m_{e,q}/\Lambda_{\text{QCD}} , treating the QCD scale Λ QCD \Lambda_{\text{QCD}} as unchangeable. Certain beyond Standard Model frameworks, most notably those with a dark matter or dark energy scalar field ϕ \phi coupling with the gluon field, would make Λ QCD \Lambda_{\text{QCD}} itself time dependent while leaving α \alpha and the electron mass untouched. Under the minimal assumption that this gluonic channel is the sole ϕ \phi interaction, we recast state-of-the-art atomic clock comparisons into Λ ˙ QCD / Λ QCD = ( 3.2 ± 3.5 ) × 10 − 17 ​ yr − 1 \dot{\Lambda}_{\text{QCD}}/\Lambda_{\text{QCD}}=(3.2\pm 3.5)\times 10^{-17}\ \text{yr}^{-1} limits, translate the isotope yields of the 1.8-Gyr-old Oklo natural reactor into a complementary geophysical limit of | δ ​ Λ QCD / Λ QCD | < 2 × 10 − 9 |\delta\Lambda_{\text{QCD}}/\Lambda_{\text{QCD}}|<2\times 10^{-9} over that time span, corresponding to the linear drift limit | Λ ˙ QCD / Λ QCD | < 1 × 10 − 18 ​ yr − 1 |\dot{\Lambda}_{\text{QCD}}/\Lambda_{\text{QCD}}|<1\times 10^{-18}\text{yr}^{-1} , and show that the proposed 8.4 8.4 eV 229 Th nuclear clock would amplify a putative Λ QCD \Lambda_{\text{QCD}} drift by four orders of magnitude compared with present atomic clocks. We also obtain constraints from quasar absorption spectra and Big Bang Nucleosynthesis data. Introduction The search for the variation of fundamental constants is a well-established area of research motivated by theories beyond the Standard model that unify gravity with the other fundamental forces, as well as cosmological models involving scalar fields which predict a space-time variation of these constants. Constraints on such variation have been derived from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), quasar absorption spectra, the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the Oklo natural nuclear reactor, see e.g. the review Uzan 2011 and references therein. The stringent bounds on the linear drift of the fundamental constants have been obtained using measurements of the temporal drift of atomic clock transition frequencies. These experiments measure the variation of the dimensionless ratio of two transition frequencies \nu_{1} and \nu_{2} \delta\left(\frac{\nu_{1}}{\nu_{2}}\right)\,, (1) which have different dependencies on the fundamental constants. As a result, these measurements may be used to place constraints on the variation of these constants. Experimental results have been obtained by measuring the oscillating frequency ratios of electron transitions in a range of systems, including Dy/Cs Van Tilburg et al. 2015 , Rb/Cs Hees et al. 2016 , Yb/Cs Kobayashi et al. 2022 , Sr/H/Si cavity Kennedy et al. 2020 , Cs/cavity Tretiak et al. 2022 , Cs/H Fischer et al. 2004a , Al + /Hg + Rosenband et al. 2008 and Yb + /Yb + /Sr Banerjee et al. 2023 ; Filzinger et al. 2023 . The results of these experiments have been used to place constraints on the variations of fundamental constants using the sensitivity calculations performed in Refs. Dzuba et al. 1999a ; Dzuba et al. 1999b ; Flambaum and Dzuba 2009 ; Flambaum et al. 2004 ; Flambaum and Tedesco 2006 ; Flambaum and Munro-Laylim 2023 ; Pašteka et al. 2019 and several other papers referenced there. It is important to note that if the absolute measurement of a transition frequency is performed, the dimensionless ratio of this frequency to the Cs hyperfine transition frequency, which defines the units of frequency and time, is being measured. The Cs transition frequency has a complicated dependence on the fundamental constants Flambaum and Tedesco 2006 . This principle applies to any measurement of variations of fundamental constants in any field of physics and astrophysics. Any measurement of a dimensionful parameter is, in fact, a measurement of the dimensionless ratio of that parameter to the unit used to measure it, which itself depends on the fundamental constants. Because any measurable quantity is ultimately a dimensionless ratio, it can always be written solely in terms of dimensionless fundamental constants. To do so, one first identifies the particular dimensionless constants that enter a given experiment. By contrast, many papers discuss variations of dimensionful parameters, such as the speed of light c , Planck’s constant \hbar , Newton’s gravitational constant G_{N} , the QCD scale \Lambda_{\text{QCD}} , or particle masses. The problem is that the numerical values of these quantities depend on the system of units: in natural units, for example, c=1 by definition, so it cannot ”vary.” Any apparent change can be absorbed by a re-definition of units. Consequently, interpreting experimental results in terms of changing dimensionful constants is not model-independent; one must instead identify a set of dimensionless fundamental constants relevant to this measurement and calculate the dependence of an observed effect on these constants 1 1 1 It was noted in Refs. Antypas et al. 2020 ; Antypas et al. 2021 , that the number of possible ”dimensionless” constants may increase when we allow for fast variations of the constants, where ”fast” is determined by the time scale of the response of the studied species or experimental apparatus used. In this case, the relevant dimensionless quantity is, for example, the ratio m_{e}/\expectationvalue{m_e} , and \expectationvalue{m_e} is the time average. In this sense, one may say that the experimental signal depends on the variation of dimensionful constants (the electron mass m_{e} in this example). Sensitivity to such variations requires two systems, one which has a faster response (such as an atom) and another which is more inertial (such as a cavity). That said, fundamental Lagrangians are often written with dimensionful constants. To be consistent, one must include every relevant term in the Lagrangian when deriving how the dimensionless ratios of fundamental constants vary for a given measurement. Alternatively, one may speak about the apparent variation of the fundamental constants, which may be just a convenient way to calculate the effects of specific terms in the interaction of Standard model particles with a dark matter (or dark energy Barrow and Magueijo 1998 ; Barrow 2005 ; Barrow et al. 2002 ; Wetterich 2003 ; Uzan 2011 ) scalar or pseudoscalar field \phi . For example, the interaction of fermions with \phi , which may be presented in the form g\phi^{n}m\bar{f}f , is similar to the fermion mass term m\bar{f}f . This means that one may define a variable fermion effective mass m_{eff}=m(1+g\phi^{n}) , which depends on the field \phi . Here, n=1,2 for scalars and n=2 for pseudoscalars. Similarly, the interaction of \phi with the electromagnetic field may be incorporated as a variable fine structure constant \alpha_{eff}=\alpha(1+g\phi^{n}) . The effects of the variation of fermion masses and the variation of \alpha have been calculated; see, e.g. Dzuba et al. 1999a ; Dzuba et al. 1999b ; Flambaum and Dzuba 2009 ; Flambaum and Shuryak 2002 ; Flambaum and Shuryak 2003 ; Flambaum et al. 2004 ; Flambaum and Tedesco 2006 ; Flambaum and Munro-Laylim 2023 ; Pašteka et al. 2019 . Note that in this approach, the variation of measurement units is still a relevant issue if one considers measurements of dimensionful parameters. We note that

Read the complete text