Shaping a Profession, Building a Community: A Practitioner-Led Investigation of Public Interest Technologists in Civil Society

Mallory Knodel, Mallika Balakrishnan, Lauren M. Chambers · 2025

Read Shaping a Profession, Building a Community: A Practitioner-Led Investigation of Public Interest Technologists in Civil Society by Mallory Knodel, Mallika Balakrishnan, Lauren M. Chambers (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07230.txt.

Introduction

Mallory Knodel, Mallika Balakrishnan, and Lauren Chambers, practitioners themselves, study the people who do tech work for the public good. Their paper appeared in two thousand twenty-five. Public interest technology is a rising label in civil society. Its workers serve nonprofits, civil rights groups, and advocacy causes. The field spans many domains, yet research on it is thin. The study was run from the Center for Democracy and Technology.

Interviews with civil society leaders probe how these technologists see their field. A roundtable then brought varied voices together to make shared meaning. The scope covers North America and Western Europe. Findings sketch a profession still defining itself. Community building emerges as part of the work itself.

Catalog record

CREATORMallory Knodel, Mallika Balakrishnan, Lauren M. Chambers
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07230

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Shaping a Profession, Building a Community: A Practitioner-Led Investigation of Public Interest Technologists in Civil Society Mallory Knodel, Mallika Balakrishnan, Lauren M. Chambers Abstract . The label ‘public interest technology’ (PIT) is growing in popularity among those seeking to use ‘tech for good’ - especially among technical practitioners working in civil society and nonprofit organizations. PIT encompasses a broad range of sociotechnical work across professional domains and sectors; however, the trend remains understudied within sociotechnical research. This paper describes a mixed-methods study, designed and conducted by PIT practitioners at the Center for Democracy and Technology, that characterizes technologists within the specific context of civil society, civil rights, and advocacy organizations in North America and Western Europe. We conducted interviews with civil society leaders to investigate how PIT practitioners position the field and themselves, and we held a roundtable discussion bringing diverse voices together to make meaning of this growing phenomenon. Ultimately, we find that PIT remains both defined and plagued by its expansiveness, and that today’s civil society public interest technologists see a need for both (a) more robust professionalization infrastructures, including philanthropic attention, and (b) more engaged, coherent community. This study illuminates a nascent intersection of technology and policy on-the-ground that is of growing relevance to critical sociotechnical research on the shifting relationship between computing and society. 1. Introduction Critical sociotechnical research offers a long history of studying policymaking around technology ( Yang et al. 2023 ; Jackson et al. 2014 ; Spaa et al. 2019 ; Bell et al. 2022 ) , civic and public sector technologies ( Johnson et al. 2016 ; Le Dantec and Edwards 2010 ; Scott et al. 2022 ) , and the role of technology in advocacy ( Asad and Le Dantec 2017 ; Bennett 2010 ; Krafft et al. 2021 ) . Today, these concepts are being explored, refined, and operationalized on the ground by a broad group of practitioners aligning under the label “public interest technology” (PIT). Indeed, due to PIT’s increasingly central role as a hub for interdisciplinary professionals pioneering technologically-driven solutions to sociotechnical challenges ( Stapleton et al. 2022 ; McGuinness and Schank 2021 ) , it is crucial to develop a more comprehensive grasp of what public interest tech is - and who public interest technologists are - as a specific and growing phenomenon. Such understanding is imperative for mapping the landscape and progress of technological movements towards justice beyond the ivory tower: a key priority of critical sociotechnical researchers. What do these practitioners mean by public interest technology ? Most simply, a public interest technologist does exactly what one might expect: work that involves technology, often bringing technological expertise to bear, in the service of the public interest ( Costanza-Chock et al. 2018 ; McGuinness and Schank 2021 ) . Technology here might mean one or all of: communication technology, information technology, internet technology, or digital technology ( Schneier 2022 ) . The scope of public interest technology is intentionally broad, ranging from building new technology, to helping a team leverage existing digital tools, to leading tech policy discussions with a focus on rights preservation ( Freedman et al. 2016a ; Freedman et al. 2016b ) . Certainly, much fundamental boundary work remains to be done regarding who are the affected “publics,” what constitutes those publics’ “interests,” and which “technologies” are involved ( Stapleton et al. 2022 ) . Depending on how boundaries are drawn, public interest technology may be inclusive of or distinctive from: civic technology, participatory design, tech policy, public science, open source, digital civics, ‘tech for good’, nonprofit IT, public interest cybersecurity, global internet standards, and more ( Costanza-Chock et al. 2018 ; Olivier and Wright 2015 ; Hackler and Saxton 2007 ) . (We note that claims or debates concerning where the boundaries of PIT ought to be drawn are out of scope for this work.) What is a technologist ? This term, too, is intentionally broad: a label that we authors use to self-identify and that we see widely adopted by colleagues and peers (in both casual settings and in formal job titles) as an explicit result of its breadth. A technologist might be a software developer, a data analyst, a systems designer, a digital privacy consultant, or a technology policy lobbyist. Crucially, within civil society models, an individual technologist’s work often includes multiple - or sometimes all - such roles as they serve different needs within and across organizations and sectors ( Chambers ming ) . However, while this work chooses as its focus public interest technologists employed by civil society organizations, others ’doing PIT work’ may operate in public interest-focused roles within technology companies, in government bodies, or at organizations producing research and journalism about technology. Despite its ongoing semantic indeterminism, ’public interest technology’ has undoubtedly grown in popularity as a label among professionals in the past six years, driven by investment from philanthropic organizations and its adoption by New America’s Public Interest Tech University Network (PIT-UN). Yet, as the label proliferates and the proto-sector grows, we worry insufficient attention has been paid to the role of so-called public interest technologists within civil society organizations such as our own: the Center for Democracy and Technology (CDT). 1 1 1 CDT is based in the United States and in Europe and focuses primarily on shaping technology policy in the public interest. As public interest tech practitioners ourselves, we are motivated by a desire to foster intentionality, clarity, and structure around the forward direction of professional public interest technology at CDT and beyond. This concern pervades all stages of a career that might be labeled as PIT, but is particularly acute for senior technologists in leadership roles. Via a two-phase iterative methodology integrating qualitative interviews and a roundtable discussion with PIT practitioners, this study characterizes the experiences, challenges, and needs of technologists who work within the specific context of civil society, civil rights, and advocacy organizations over the last two decades. While public interest technologists have been doing the work, by one name or another, for years, the continuing growth of the field introduces an urgent need - and opportunity - for technologists to be active in shaping its future. Critically, this paper is both by and for public interest technologists, uniquely taking place within a tech policy-oriented nonprofit and being undertaken by practitioner-researchers. As such, this work maintains an explicit focus towards shaping a future of PIT for ourselves and those who come after. Our paper contributes to the ongoing discourse surrounding technology, civil society, and societal change in three ways: (1) by bringing PIT professionals explicitly into the fold of academic discussions; (2) by identifying challenges faced by those working at the direct intersection of technology and civil society; and (3) by offering priorities for future research and projects examining and supporting public interest technology within civil society, as determined by PIT practitioners themselves. The paper is organized as follows: we present related literature and studies of PIT-related work in Section 2 . We describe our study methods and limitations in Section 3 , before presenting our results in Section 4 . Finally, we discuss the implications of our findings in Section 5 and offer conclusions and directions for future

Read the complete text