Understanding NFTs from EIP Standards

Minfeng Qi, Qin Wang, Guangsheng Yu, Ruiqiang Li, Victor Zhou, Shiping Chen · 2025

Read Understanding NFTs from EIP Standards by Minfeng Qi, Qin Wang, Guangsheng Yu, Ruiqiang Li, Victor Zhou, Shiping Chen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-07190.txt.

Introduction

Qi and co-authors study in 2025 the technical base of non fungible tokens, or NFTs, through the standards that define them. Past work looked at markets, user habits, and single security flaws. The rules that make NFTs work had not been mapped as a whole.

The team read 191 token linked proposals and over ten thousand forum posts up to July 2025. They parsed code interfaces, charted how standards inherit from each other, and profiled who writes them. Core standards split from new ones in their account. Poor fit across versions stood out, and growing feature load raised security risk, a warning for builders in this space.

Catalog record

CREATORMinfeng Qi, Qin Wang, Guangsheng Yu, Ruiqiang Li, Victor Zhou, Shiping Chen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-07190

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Understanding NFTs from EIP Standards Minfeng Qi, Qin Wang, Guangsheng Yu, Ruiqiang Li, Victor Zhou, Shiping Chen Abstract We argue that the technical foundations of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) remain inadequately understood. Prior research has focused on market dynamics, user behavior, and isolated security incidents, yet systematic analysis of the standards underpinning NFT functionality is largely absent. We present the first study of NFTs through the lens of Ethereum Improvement Proposals (EIPs). We conduct a large-scale empirical analysis of 191 NFT-related EIPs and 10K+ Ethereum Magicians discussions (as of July, 2025). We integrate multi-dimensional analyses including the automated parsing of Solidity interfaces, graph-based modeling of inheritance structures, contributor profiling, and mining of community discussion data. We distinguish foundational from emerging standards, expose poor cross-version interoperability, and show that growing functional complexity heightens security risks. I Introduction NFTs are foundation of the web3 ecosystem. Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) [ 1 ] have evolved from a niche technological novelty into a foundational component of the Web3 ecosystem [ 2 ] . NFTs represent verifiable ownership of unique digital or physical assets on the blockchain [ 3 ] , enabling a wide range of applications across digital art, gaming, virtual real estate, identity verification, and decentralized finance (DeFi). This innovation has spurred a multi-billion-dollar market. Industry projections [ 4 ] suggest that the global NFT market may expand from $60.01 billion in 2025 to as much as $247.41 billion by 2035, reflecting a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 41.9%. Within this landscape, collectibles constitute the largest segment, accounting for 32.6% of market activity, encompassing digital artworks, music, and video clips [ 5 ] . NFT also attracts the engagement of Web3 users. In 2025, the decentralized application (dApp) ecosystem experienced a 485% increase in unique active wallets (UAWs), reaching an average of 24.6 million UAWs per day by the end of the year [ 6 ] . Notably, approximately 2.1 million of these daily wallets interacted with blockchain-based games, accounting for 30% of all NFT-related activities [ 7 ] . What defines NFTs? Despite their economic and cultural significance, NFTs do not exist in isolation; they are governed by a technical backbone comprising Ethereum Improvement Proposals (EIPs). An EIP is a general design document that outlines new features or processes for the Ethereum ecosystem. Within this broader set, Ethereum Request for Comments (ERCs) constitute a specific category of EIPs 1 1 1 We use the terms EIP and ERC interchangeably throughout this work. focused on application-level standards for smart contracts. ERCs define how tokens, wallets, and decentralized applications should behave to ensure interoperability across the network. NFTs are defined by ERCs, which specify interfaces for unique asset representation, transfer semantics, and metadata handling [ 1 ] . Foundational proposals such as ERC-721 [ 8 ] established the blueprint for unique, indivisible tokens, while ERC-1155 [ 9 ] introduced a multi-token interface enabling both fungible and non-fungible assets within a single contract. Yet, we still have an insufficient level of understanding! Prior studies examined NFT markets from a variety of perspectives. A line of works have focused on economic valuation , employing multimodal data to estimate token prices [ 10 , 11 ] . Others have investigated social influence , such as the role of Twitter in shaping NFT value perception [ 12 ] , or the behavioral dynamics in NFT speculation and rug pulls [ 13 ] . Another line of research has explored security , identifying smart contract defects [ 14 ] , wallet hijacking [ 15 ] , and airdrop manipulation using graph-based learning [ 16 ] . In addition, cross-domain research has sought to investigate broader sociotechnical aspects of NFTs, including centralization risks [ 17 ] , NFT identity and provenance [ 18 ] . We argue that the underlying standard layer of NFTs received limited attention. Most existing works treat NFTs as black-box tokens deployed in markets, without dissecting how they are structured, which standards they implement, and how these standards evolve, overlap, or fragment (cf. Table I ). Table I: This work v.s. Prior NFT Studies refs Method Focus EIP-Level Scale [ 10 ] [ 11 ] ML models Price prediction ✗ < 10K tokens [ 12 ] [ 13 ] Behavioral analysis Social influence ✗ < 50K tweets / wallets [ 14 ] [ 16 ] Graph learning Contract defects Partial \sim 1K–500K contracts/wallets [ 15 ] [ 17 ] Case studies Wallet risks ✗ Dozens of cases [ 18 ] Qualitative analysis NFT provenance ✗ Dozens of stakeholders This EIP empirical NFT standards ✓ > 10K {EIPs + forum} The oversight hinders a deeper understanding of several key questions : What is the true scope of NFT-related EIPs? Which functionalities have become foundational versus rarely adopted? How are inheritance and interface structures organized across proposals? Who drives their development? What socio-technical patterns shape participation? What major vulnerability vectors persist across widely adopted and emerging standards, threatening the robustness of the NFT ecosystem? We open the black box of NFT standards and empirically mapping their structural and functional landscape. Our approach. We empirically evaluate NFT-related EIPs from multi-dimensions ( § IV ). We first construct a structured dataset by downloading the entire corpus of EIPs and applying keyword-based filtering to identify 213 NFT-related proposals, out of which 191 contain explicit Solidity interface definitions. We extract proposal metadata (stage, creation date, deadlines) and parse interface-level information (functions, parameters, return types) to map the functional design space of NFT standards and their inheritance relationships. We complement this technical analysis with contributor profiling, linking authors to publicly available GitHub data to characterize geographic and organizational participation patterns. Additionally, we collect community engagement data from Ethereum Magicians 2 2 2 https://ethereum-magicians.org/ , a long-standing open discussion forum where Ethereum community members propose, debate, and refine EIPs forum threads, capturing temporal dynamics of discussions and participation levels of NFT-related proposals. To extend our analysis beyond structural, functional, and sociotechnical aspects, we incorporate two complementary investigations ( § VI ). First, we compile a corpus of prominent academic studies on NFTs and cross-reference their scope, methods, and targeted standards against our dataset to assess the alignment between existing research efforts and the actual landscape of NFT-related EIPs. Second, we conduct a focused review of fundamental NFT standards (e.g., ERC‑721, ERC‑1155, ERC‑6551) and emerging proposals (e.g., ERC‑4907, ERC‑4675, ERC‑2981) to identify intrinsic security challenges and vulnerability vectors . This combined perspective provides a deeper understanding of how academic work connects to real-world standardization processes. Contributions. We provide a comprehensive and data-driven perspective on the evolution of Ethereum NFT standards. \triangleright A structural landscape of NFT standards ( § V-A - § V-D ). We provide the first systematic mapping of NFT-related EIPs, characterizing their distribution across proposal stages, their temporal evolution, and the diversity of functionalities they introduce. Our analysis identifies foundational proposals that have shaped the NFT ecosystem. \triangleright A socio-technical perspective on NFT standardization ( § V-E ). We examine the human and organizational dynamics driving NFT standardization, including contributor anonymity, geographic distribution, and community engagement levels in the EIP discussion process. This perspective highlights how institutional and collaborative factors influence the trajectory and adoption of NFT standards beyond purely technical considerations. \triangleright

Read the complete text