Visualization Vibes: The Socio-Indexical Function of Visualization Design

\authororcid Michelle Morgenstern*0000-0002-6321-6613 \authororcid Amy Rae Fox*0000-0003-0995-7899, \authororcid Graham M. Jones0000-0001-6435-7066, \authororcid Arvind Satyanarayan0000-0001-5564-635X · 2025

Read Visualization Vibes: The Socio-Indexical Function of Visualization Design by \authororcid Michelle Morgenstern*0000-0002-6321-6613 \authororcid Amy Rae Fox*0000-0003-0995-7899, \authororcid Graham M. Jones0000-0001-6435-7066, \authororcid Arvind Satyanarayan0000-0001-5564-635X (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-06775.txt.

Introduction

Michelle Morgenstern and co-authors argue that charts speak socially as well as statistically, in a 2025 paper. In an information landscape thick with distrust, why one chart persuades and another provokes attack cannot be explained by accuracy alone. Borrowing from linguistic anthropology, the authors propose that design choices send indexical signals, hints about who made the chart and whose side they are on.

Through interview studies, they document readers judging a visualization's vibes: its polish, style, and quirks read as social provenance. Those judgments then color whether the data get a hearing at all. The paper urges visualization research to widen its criteria beyond speed and precision of decoding. For scientists and journalists, the lesson is that trust is designed, or lost, in the details of presentation.

Catalog record

CREATOR\authororcid Michelle Morgenstern*0000-0002-6321-6613 \authororcid Amy Rae Fox*0000-0003-0995-7899, \authororcid Graham M. Jones0000-0001-6435-7066, \authororcid Arvind Satyanarayan0000-0001-5564-635X
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-06775

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Visualization Vibes: The Socio-Indexical Function of Visualization Design \authororcid Michelle Morgenstern*0000-0002-6321-6613 \authororcid Amy Rae Fox*0000-0003-0995-7899, \authororcid Graham M. Jones0000-0001-6435-7066, \authororcid Arvind Satyanarayan0000-0001-5564-635X Abstract In contemporary information ecologies saturated with misinformation, disinformation, and a distrust of science itself, public data communication faces significant hurdles. Although visualization research has broadened criteria for effective design, governing paradigms privilege the accurate and efficient transmission of data. Drawing on theory from linguistic anthropology, we argue that such approaches—focused on encoding and decoding propositional content—cannot fully account for how people engage with visualizations and why particular visualizations might invite adversarial or receptive responses. In this paper, we present evidence that data visualizations communicate not only semantic, propositional meaning—meaning about data—but also social, indexical meaning—meaning beyond data. From a series of ethnographically-informed interviews, we document how readers make rich and varied assessments of a visualization’s “vibes”—inferences about the social provenance of a visualization based on its design features. Furthermore, these social attributions have the power to influence reception, as readers’ decisions about how to engage with a visualization concern not only content, or even aesthetic appeal, but also their sense of alignment or disalignment with the entities they imagine to be involved in its production and circulation. We argue these inferences hinge on a function of human sign systems that has thus far been little studied in data visualization: socio-indexicality , whereby the formal features (rather than the content) of communication evoke social contexts, identities, and characteristics. Demonstrating the presence and significance of this socio-indexical function in visualization, this paper offers both a conceptual foundation and practical intervention for troubleshooting breakdowns in public data communication. \onlineid 1005 \vgtccategory Research \vgtcpapertype Theoretical & Empirical \authorfooter * indicates equal contribution. Morgenstern & Jones are affiliated with MIT Department of Anthropology. Fox & Satyanarayan are affiliated with MIT CSAIL. Email: [mjmorgen, amyfox, gmj, arvindsatya] @mit.edu \teaser Socio-Indexical Inferences from Message-Obscured Visualizations Four images of "message-obscured" visualizations, followed by examples of socio-indexical inferences made by participants in response to open-ended interview prompts. Introduction keywords Semiotics, Socio-indexicality, Attitudes, Reception, Engagement, Visualization Psychology, Public Data Communication. Communication breakdown characterizes much of our contemporary information ecology. Public data communication faces urgent challenges in reaching polarized media environments with adversarial audiences that increasingly disavow the validity of science itself. At the same time, visualization (and visual media, more broadly) is being harnessed to propagate misinformation and disinformation. [ 60 , 73 ] . However, the governing paradigm of visualization [ 14 ] —that visualizations function as a conduit for transmitting propositional information or insights about data—offers inadequate explanations for these challenges. This paradigm predisposes researchers, designers, and readers alike to diagnose communication breakdowns as essentially a problem of the encoding-decoding process [ 79 ] . Therefore, to combat failures in public data communication, we primarily look for solutions that intervene in that process: either developing design guidelines to more clearly and efficiently represent the data (the visualization’s propositional meaning), or improving data and visualization literacy to increase readers ability to quickly and accurately extract propositional information. While accurately communicating propositional meaning is undeniably important, a wealth of research in linguistic anthropology and sociolinguistics shows that natural language does more than just communicate semantic, propositional meaning (i.e. the content of the utterance, what it is about). A substantial body of evidence demonstrates that language also has a socio-indexical function : any utterance also conveys ideas about the identities of, and therefore social relationships between, speakers and listeners, because formal features of language (e.g. aspects of accent, dialect, register, and choice of particular jargon or slang) point to—that is, index —social categories, contexts, and characteristics. As a simple example, in spoken North American Englishes, the deletion of the ’t’ and ’d’ sounds at the end of words (e.g., firs’ chil’ instead of first child ) signals informality and, therefore, can mark a social situation as a relaxed encounter between peers. Similarly, people often view popular styles of digital communication (so-called “txt speak”) as indicating youthfulness and ignorance or laziness, despite evidence that these stylistic choices involve skill, creativity, and added effort [ 46 , 71 ] . Drawing such social inferences, even when faulty, is not a failure of communication, but rather reflects a central feature of how language connects people as social beings, allowing them to perceive and navigate similarities and differences with others. Moreover, socio-indexical inferences can have profound implications for how propositional content is interpreted. For example, studies have demonstrated that when transcribing recordings of speech they infer to be "Black", court reporters in Philadelphia interpreted utterances as having underlying criminal meaning [ 47 ] . While socio-indexical meaning—and how it affects communication—is a well-documented phenomenon in spoken and written language, its presence, consequence, and significance has thus far been little studied in data visualization. Although a nascent body of work has productively begun to broaden the field’s definition of effectiveness beyond affording fast and accurate decoding of propositional meaning to account for contextual factors (including framing, affect, and personal background or disposition), little attention has been paid to how visualizations may communicate an entirely different type of meaning that goes beyond the depicted data values and takeaway messages. In this paper, we offer empirical evidence that, akin to natural language, visualization has a socio-indexical function: beyond communicating propositional insights about data, visualizations convey ideas about their social provenance because formal features of a visualization (e.g., typography, colour, chart type, and data complexity) can index types of people, situations, and qualities. Through a series of semi-structured interviews, we show that readers make rich and varied social attributions: value-laden socio-indexical inferences about the identities and characteristics of the actors—human and nonhuman—involved in a visualization’s production and circulation. For example: “Whoever made this is not a researcher, not a scientist. They’re not necessarily going to know the difference between a study published by Dr. Oz and a study published by like Yale Medical.” “Naïve. I feel like the person who made this has the least idea data could be presented differently to convey the story they want to tell […] so it makes it feel like the person has better intentions. ” In our interviews, participants discussed both real-world visualizations gathered from a variety of sources as well as “message-obscured” visualizations (the same images with the text altered to obscure its propositional content). Through this, we demonstrate that readers can make social attributions based not only on content (i.e., data topic or takeaway message) but on design features alone (e.g. chart type, font, etc.). From the design features of a visualization, readers draw indexical inferences about dimensions of identity such as the designer’s age, gender, profession, and political orientation, as well as design tools used and likely publication venues. Depending on the reader’s own identity and social positioning—which informs their attitudes toward those people, tools, and contexts—these attributions give rise to further inferences about character traits such as personality, competency, intentions, and trustworthiness. Together, these constellations of social attributions have the power to frame how visualizations are received independent of the specific data values and takeaway message they depict. We synthesize these results into a conceptual model ( Figure 4 ) summarizing the relationship between the concepts we introduce as central to the socio-indexical function of

Read the complete text