ClimateSOM: A Visual Analysis Workflow for Climate Ensemble Datasets

\authororcid Yuya Kawakami0000-0002-8621-301X, \authororcid Daniel Cayan0000-0002-2719-6811, \authororcid Dongyu Liu0000-0002-8915-2785, and \authororcid Kwan-Liu Ma0000-0001-8086-0366 · 2025

Read ClimateSOM: A Visual Analysis Workflow for Climate Ensemble Datasets by \authororcid Yuya Kawakami0000-0002-8621-301X, \authororcid Daniel Cayan0000-0002-2719-6811, \authororcid Dongyu Liu0000-0002-8915-2785, and \authororcid Kwan-Liu Ma0000-0001-8086-0366 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-06732.txt.

Introduction

Yuya Kawakami, Daniel Cayan, Dongyu Liu, and Kwan-Liu Ma build a visual workflow to sort climate model ensembles, in a paper from 2025. Each run in an ensemble gives a like yet distinct future, and the spread among runs is the key fact to grasp.

Their workflow maps runs onto a self sorting grid that shows how the spread falls out in two dimensions. Language models help users read what each grid zone means. A case on rain forecasts for California and the Northwest shows the flow at work. Six climate experts judged the tool and its insights in review talks.

Catalog record

CREATOR\authororcid Yuya Kawakami0000-0002-8621-301X, \authororcid Daniel Cayan0000-0002-2719-6811, \authororcid Dongyu Liu0000-0002-8915-2785, and \authororcid Kwan-Liu Ma0000-0001-8086-0366
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-06732

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

ClimateSOM: A Visual Analysis Workflow for Climate Ensemble Datasets \authororcid Yuya Kawakami0000-0002-8621-301X, \authororcid Daniel Cayan0000-0002-2719-6811, \authororcid Dongyu Liu0000-0002-8915-2785, and \authororcid Kwan-Liu Ma0000-0001-8086-0366 Abstract Ensemble datasets are ever more prevalent in various scientific domains. In climate science, ensemble datasets are used to capture variability in projections under plausible future conditions including greenhouse and aerosol emissions. Each ensemble model run produces projections that are fundamentally similar yet meaningfully distinct. Understanding this variability among ensemble model runs and analyzing its magnitude and patterns is a vital task for climate scientists. In this paper, we present ClimateSOM , a visual analysis workflow that leverages a self-organizing map (SOM) and Large Language Models (LLMs) to support interactive exploration and interpretation of climate ensemble datasets. The workflow abstracts climate ensemble model runs—spatiotemporal time series—into a distribution over a 2D space that captures the variability among the ensemble model runs using a SOM. LLMs are integrated to assist in sensemaking of this SOM-defined 2D space, the basis for the visual analysis tasks. In all, ClimateSOM enables users to explore the variability among ensemble model runs, identify patterns, compare and cluster the ensemble model runs. To demonstrate the utility of ClimateSOM , we apply the workflow to an ensemble dataset of precipitation projections over California and the Northwestern United States. Furthermore, we conduct a short evaluation of our LLM integration, and conduct an expert review of the visual workflow and the insights from the case studies with six domain experts to evaluate our approach and its utility. \onlineid 1773 \vgtccategory Research \vgtcpapertype application \authorfooter Yuya Kawakami, Dongyu Liu, and Kwan-Liu Ma are with University of California, Davis. E-mails: {ykawakami, dyuliu, klma}@ucdavis.edu Danial Cayan is with Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of California, San Diego. E-mail: [email protected] Introduction keywords Climate visual analytics, ensemble visualization, self-organizing maps Ensemble datasets are increasingly integral to scientific research as computing resources have increased in power [ 66 , 34 ] . Many disciplines, from computational fluid dynamics [ 48 ] to material science [ 66 ] , rely on ensemble datasets to capture and predict variability by running their models under different conditions and parameters. The result is a collection of model runs—an ensemble dataset—that supports exploration of possible outcomes, sensitivity analysis, and uncertainty quantification. However, working with ensemble datasets remains difficult due to their sheer size and complexity [ 66 ] . Climate science in particular relies on ensemble datasets to examine plausible climate futures under varying conditions, such as greenhouse gas and aerosol emissions or land use changes [ 47 , 17 , 44 ] . Each model run often represents a spatiotemporal time series, where each time step is a climate outcome (e.g., precipitation) over some spatial regions. These model runs may come from different global climate models [ 17 , 44 ] and use varying input assumptions, producing a broad set of outcomes. Understanding and communicating the resulting variability and patterns remains a major challenge. Although existing analyses in climate science provide valuable insights—often through statistical summaries like spatial means and variances across model runs—they may overlook key spatial and temporal structures [ 31 ] . Visual analytics techniques have been developed to support interpretation of ensemble data [ 8 , 31 , 15 ] , but many struggle to provide both interpretability and robustness when dealing with highly complex, chaotic model behavior. In this context, even summarizing a single model run clearly is difficult, and comparing or clustering multiple runs poses a greater challenge. To overcome these limitations, we introduce, ClimateSOM , a new visual analysis workflow that equips climate scientists with an intuitive tool and visual language for exploring and analyzing ensemble climate projection datasets. In line with findings by Wang et al. in their comprehensive survey of ensemble data visualization [ 66 ] , we identify three essential tasks when working with such datasets: (1) exploring a single set of model run(s) , (2) comparing the behavior across two sets of model runs , and (3) clustering the behavior of multiple model runs . These tasks are crucial for uncovering insights into climate variability and making meaningful inferences about these projections. These tasks along with its interpretability serves as our guiding principle. The overarching goal for ClimateSOM is data abstraction by transforming spatiotemporal time series into a distribution over a user-steerable 2D space. Central to ClimateSOM is a self-organizing map (SOM) [ 35 ] , a widely recognized analytical tool in climate science, along with steerable dimensionality reduction and annotations. Through this transformation, ClimateSOM enables flexible, interpretable exploration of diverse model behavior, helping researchers detect patterns and relationships that would otherwise be difficult to uncover. We further integrate LLMs to assist in sensemaking of the SOM-defined 2D space. ClimateSOM introduces an LLM-empowered bidirectional query methods that allows users to (1) locate regions of interest in the 2D space based on natural language queries and (2) generate textual summaries of selected regions. We demonstrate the utility of ClimateSOM through case studies using LOCA-downscaled CMIP6 climate projections [ 49 ] across two regions in the western United States. In addition, we conduct an expert review with six domain scientists to assess the system’s usability and its ability to support scientific insight. In short, the contributions of this work are the following: • A novel workflow for visual analysis of a spatiotemporal ensemble that abstracts the ensemble members as a distribution over a steerable 2D space framed by a self-organizing map. • Integration of LLMs to assist in sensemaking of the SOM-defined 2D space in which ClimateSOM operates. • ClimateSOM , a visualization interface that supports this workflow end-to-end, enabling users to explore, compare, and cluster ensemble model runs. 1 Related Works 1.1 Visual Analytics for Climate Ensemble Data The increasing availability of ensemble data from large-scale climate simulations has led to the development of a range of visual analytics methods designed to manage and interpret uncertainty, spatial-temporal patterns, and inter-model variability [ 33 , 9 , 18 , 67 , 8 , 31 , 6 , 25 ] . Past works have considered topology-based methods, where isocontours, spaghetti plots or similar methods are employed to encapsulate prominent spatial features while encoding ensemble variability [ 32 , 30 , 38 , 59 , 43 ] . Others have proposed graph-based representations of ensemble relationships [ 62 , 29 ] or treated ensemble members as collections of images to facilitate comparative analysis [ 26 ] . Kappe et al. introduced a Sankey-diagram-based visualization using k -means clustering on the entire climate field to summarize variability in decadal predictions [ 31 ] , while Evers et al. employed spatial correlation measures and multidimensional scaling (MDS) to embed ensemble members for comparative visualization [ 16 ] . However, in the context of visualizing the overall behavior of a single climate ensemble model run or its comparison, past works have mostly relied on summary statistics of the climate field interest or what Kappe refers to the as the mean field approach [ 28 ] . Such approaches, as well as topology-based methods that often select most prominent spatial features to represent ensemble members for analysis and comparison [ 18 ] , may crucially miss out of the different distributional nature of the ensemble

Read the complete text