Speciation by local adaptation and isolation by distance in extended environments
Lara D. Hissa, Flavia M. D. Marquitti, Marcus A. M. de Aguiar · 2025
Read Speciation by local adaptation and isolation by distance in extended environments by Lara D. Hissa, Flavia M. D. Marquitti, Marcus A. M. de Aguiar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-06719.txt.
Introduction
Lara Hissa and co-authors model how new species can form without a hard barrier in a 2025 study. Species often split when groups adapt to local conditions while mating stays local and movement is short. Their model joins both forces: a trait shaped by the local setting, and mating rules based on nearness and likeness.
The team compares a setting with two ideal trait values against a uniform one, under strong or weak selection and strict or loose mating rules. Selection can speed up splitting, but splitting can also begin without it. Twin-peaked trait patterns arose by more than one path, so they alone do not prove selection drove the split. The timing of splitting also shifted with the mix of forces.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lara D. Hissa, Flavia M. D. Marquitti, Marcus A. M. de Aguiar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-06719
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Speciation by local adaptation and isolation by distance in extended environments Lara D. Hissa, Flavia M. D. Marquitti, Marcus A. M. de Aguiar Abstract Speciation is often associated with geographical barriers that limit gene flow. However, species can also emerge in continuous homogeneous environments through isolation by distance. When the environment is not homogeneous, natural selection contributes to differentiation by local adaptation and tends to facilitate speciation. To explore how isolation by distance and adaptation combine to determine species diversity, we implemented a model regulated by these two components. The first is implemented via mating restrictions on spatial proximity and genetic similarity. The second is realized by an ecological phenotype subjected to adaption and natural selection. We consider scenarios where the environment is either homogeneous, with a single ecological optimum, or heterogeneous with two distinct optima. In homogeneous environments no speciation is observed under permissive mating restrictions, independent on the strength of natural selection. On the other hand, if reproduction requires close genetic similarity (strict mating restrictions), speciation occurs only under strong selection. In contrast, in environments with two local optima and strong selection, species well adapted to each of the niches emerge along the spatial structure, leading to the formation of groups with distinct phenotypes. Permissive mating restrictions leads to the formation of only two species, each occupying one of the niches; strong mating restriction leads to several species per niche, in a much faster speciation process. Interestingly, when selection is weak and reproduction requires strong genetic similarity, several species form, but the process is slow. Moreover, species average phenotypes do not remain constant over generations, causing the phenotypic distribution to oscillate, never reaching a stationary pattern. Introduction Geographic isolation has long been considered one of the main drivers of speciation coyne2004speciation , nosil2012ecological , mayr2013animal . It happens when sub-populations are separated by physical barriers, interrupting gene flow and allowing genetic and phenotypic differences to accumulate, eventually leading to reproductive isolation Manzo_Peliti_1994 , Yamaguchi-2013_first , princepe2022diversity . However, speciation with gene flow can emerge in various contexts. In parapatric speciation, neighboring populations experience different selective pressures while exchanging genes at a limited rate gavrilets1998rapid , gavrilets2000patterns , anceschi2019neutral , freitas2022speciation . Ecological speciation, in particular, has gained prominence as a mechanism whereby divergent selection across environmental gradients or habitat types leads to reproductive isolation schluter2009evidence , nosil2012ecological . This process depends on the interaction between local adaptation and barriers to gene flow, including pre- and post-zygotic barriers, assortative mating and reduced hybrid fitness nosil2012ecological . Recent empirical and theoretical evidence suggest that speciation can also result from the interplay of several other mechanisms, such as genetic incompatibilities gavrilets2002sympatric , nosil2011genes , johannesson2024diverse , competition for resources Dieckmann_1999 , Dieckmann_2003 , polechova2005speciation , schluter2009evidence , temporal separation cooley2003temporal , taylor2017role and partial barriers smadja2011framework , fitzpatrick2008if . Opposing the idea of geographic isolation, or allopatry, speciation can also occur for populations occupying a single habitat via2001sympatric , in sympatry, if gene flow is reduced by mating restrictions higgs1991stochastic , kondrashov1999interactions , caetano2020sympatric or by intense competition kisdi1999evolutionary , doebeli2000evolutionary . One important mechanism of differentiation in spatially distributed populations is isolation by distance white1968models . If mating occurs only between nearby individuals, spatial distance tends to correlate with genetic distance moritz1992evolutionary , irwin2005speciation , martins2013 , de2017barriers . Depending on the mating range, mutation rate and other population parameters, this process may lead to the break up of the population into reproductively isolated groups even in a homogeneous environment de2017barriers , de2009global . In heterogeneous habitats, local adaptation can contribute to differentiation and facilitate speciation lande1982rapid , rainey1998adaptive , schliewen2001genetic . Speciation by phenotypic adaptation has been explored in different contexts, such as temporal variations and climate change Kopp2014 , Otto2020 , interference of multiple optima Lenormand2015 and continuous spatial variations Dieckmann_2003 . Doebeli and Dieckmann Dieckmann_2003 , in particular, considered a model with uniform environmental gradient and demonstrated that branching of the population into clusters of similar phenotypes occur for intermediate slopes of the gradient. Here we also consider species formation in environments with local adaptation, but we add the component of isolation by distance. Unlike the model proposed in Dieckmann_2003 , relying on continuous environmental gradients and implicit reproductive isolation, our approach imposes explicit constraints on mating: individuals must be both spatially close and genetically similar to reproduce. This setup allows the identification of reproductively isolated groups and, therefore, species. Moreover, it allows us to study the effects of local adaptation in scenarios where isolation by distance alone is or is not enough to promote speciation. We show that speciation in homogeneous environments requires strong natural selection and robust isolation by distance. In environments with two local optima, ecologically different species, adapted to their respective niches, may arise. Strict mating restriction leads to the appearance of several species per niche. If selection is strong, speciation is fast; if it is weak, speciation is slow and phenotype distribution is not stable, oscillating in time. Speciation under permissive mating restrictions, on the other hand, requires strong selection and leads to only two species, one in each niche. Methods We propose a model to investigate speciation in sexually reproducing populations subjected to natural selection and mating by genetic similarity. We use an individual-based model (IBM) on a lattice L_{1}\times L_{2} with reflective (non-periodic) boundaries. Initially, individuals occupy the lattice randomly and, although typical population densities are small, multiple individuals can share the same site. The model explores how individuals can adapt and diversify between distinct environments, even in the absence of physical barriers. We assume that the total population is at its carrying capacity, resulting in nearly constant population size. Each individual i carries two chromosomes: one for reproductive compatibility, denoted by \gamma_{i}=(\gamma_{i}^{1},\gamma_{i}^{2},...,\gamma_{i}^{B}) , and one for environmental compatibility, \rho_{i}=(\rho_{i}^{1},\rho_{i}^{2},...,\rho_{i}^{C}) , with sizes B and C , respectively. The chromosomes are represented by binary sequences, so that \sigma_{i}^{k} and \rho_{i}^{k} can only assume the values 0 or 1 . The ecological phenotype P_{i} is determined by the additive effect of its loci, i.e., by the sum of the alleles in the environmental chromosome: P_{i}=\frac{1}{C}\sum_{k=1}^{C}\rho_{i}^{k} (1) The environment exerts selection pressure based on the match between an individual’s phenotype and the local environmental optimum, P_{E} . Individual fitness, w_{i} , is computed using a Gaussian function: w_{i}=e^{\frac{-(P_{i}-P_{E})^{2}}{2\sigma_{e}^{2}}}, (2) where \sigma_{e} defines the strength of selection, which is large when \sigma_{e} is small. In order to simplify our analysis we consider two cases. In the first, that works as a null model, the environment is homogeneous, with a single ecological optimum. In the second, the environment is heterogeneous with two distinct optima. In the case of two environments, we divided the lattice into E_{1} and E_{2} , with respective optima P_{E_{1}} and P_{E_{2}} . Individuals can select reproductive partners \markoverwith \ULon freely across the lattice, including across the boundary between environments. However, sexual partners are chosen only within a mating radius S centered on the focal individual. Moreover, mating is only possible if the genetic distance between the reproductive chromosomes of the mating pair is sufficiently small. The genetic distance D_{ij} between two individuals, i and j is defined by D_{ij}=\sum_{k}|\gamma_{i}^{k}-\gamma_{j}^{k}|, (3) and corresponds to the number of differing loci between their