Linear and nonlinear stability for the Bach flow, I

Eric Bahuaud, Christine Guenther, James Isenberg, Rafe Mazzeo · 2025

Read Linear and nonlinear stability for the Bach flow, I by Eric Bahuaud, Christine Guenther, James Isenberg, Rafe Mazzeo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-06633.txt.

Introduction

Eric Bahuaud and co-authors prove stability results for the Bach flow, a way of evolving a shape by its Bach curvature. Geometric flows smooth spaces the way heat smooths temperature. Their 2025 paper, the first of two parts, studies a gauge-adjusted form of the flow on spaces of constant curvature.

Linear stability holds on any complete constant-curvature space. The proof needs fresh spectral bounds and a higher-order version of the classic Koiso identity. Nonlinear stability follows for hyperbolic space, and for spaces near it of Poincaré-Einstein type. The compact and flat cases are saved for part two, since they need a center manifold argument. Geometers get firm ground under a fourth-order flow long handled by formal means.

Catalog record

CREATOREric Bahuaud, Christine Guenther, James Isenberg, Rafe Mazzeo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE116 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-06633

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Linear and nonlinear stability for the Bach flow, I Eric Bahuaud, Christine Guenther, James Isenberg, Rafe Mazzeo Abstract . In this paper we prove the linear stability of a gauge-modified version of the Bach flow on any complete manifold ( M , h ) (M,h) of constant curvature. This involves some intricate calculations to obtain spectral bounds, and in particular introduces a higher order generalization of the well-known Koiso identity. We also prove nonlinear stability for the Bach flow if ( M , h ) (M,h) is the hyperbolic space ℍ n \mathbb{H}^{n} , and more generally any Poincaré-Einstein space sufficiently close to ℍ n \mathbb{H}^{n} . In the forthcoming Part II of this project, we study the nonlinear stability question if M M is either compact or else noncompact and flat, since those cases require different considerations involving a center manifold. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification 58J35; 53E40; 35K 1. Introduction The search for canonical metrics in Riemannian geometry has a long and rich history, starting from the classical uniformization theorem for Riemann surfaces, with many significant milestones along the way. Canonical metrics often arise as critical points of an energy functional on some given space of metrics (e.g., all metrics in a conformal class, or all metrics in a Kähler class, or all metrics), and because of this, techniques from the calculus of variations have played a key role in many of these problems. Particularly if the critical points are (local or global) minima of their associated energy functionals, gradient flow techniques provide another important path to finding such metrics. Conversely, gradient flows, or modified versions of such flows, provide interesting settings for the development of techniques to study various stability questions around canonical metrics. One source of natural energy functionals is provided by the Chern-Gauss-Bonnet theorem on a 4 -dimensional compact manifold M [ 5 ] which states that: 8\pi^{2}\chi(M)=\int_{M}\left(\frac{1}{4}|\W|^{2}-\frac{1}{2}\left|\Ric-\frac{1}{4}\Scal g\right|^{2}+\frac{1}{24}\Scal^{2}\right)\dvol_{g}. Here \W , \Ric-\frac{1}{4}\Scal g and \Scal are the Weyl, traceless Ricci and scalar curvatures, and |\W| is the norm of the (0,4) tensor \W , all with respect to the metric g , and \chi(M) is the Euler characteristic. It is well known that any quadratic curvature functional in 4 dimensions is a linear combination of the following three quantities: \int|\W|^{2}\dvol_{g} , \int|\Ric|^{2}\dvol_{g} , and \int\Scal^{2}\dvol_{g} (see e.g., [ 5 , 11 ] ). One motivation for this paper comes from the Weyl energy functional \displaystyle g\longmapsto\mathcal{W}(g):=\int_{M}|\W(g)|^{2}_{g}\dvol_{g}. Specifically in dimension 4 , this integral is unchanged if we replace g by any conformally related metric. The first variation of \mathcal{W} along a curve of metrics g(s) with g(0)=h and g^{\prime}(0)=v is given by \displaystyle\left.\frac{d}{ds}\mathcal{W}(h+sv)\right|_{s=0}=\int_{M}\left\langle\nabla\mathcal{W}\,,\,v\right\rangle_{h}\dvol_{h}, where \nabla\mathcal{W}=-4\Ba(h) is a multiple of the Bach tensor of h , which is defined as follows: (1.1) \displaystyle\Ba_{ij}:={\mathrm{P}_{ij,k}}^{k}-{\mathrm{P}_{ik,j}}^{k}+\mathrm{P}^{kl}\W_{kijl}. Here \mathrm{P}:=\frac{1}{2}\left(\Ric-\frac{\Scal}{6}h\right) is the Schouten tensor. In this formula and throughout this manuscript, commas denote covariant derivatives, and the standard summation convention is used. The Bach tensor is traceless and divergence-free, and involves derivatives up to order four of the metric. The Schouten tensor \mathrm{P} has a relatively simple conformal transformation rule, and using this, the Bach tensor \Ba has conformal invariance property: g_{1}:=f^{2}g\Longrightarrow\Ba(g_{1})=f^{-2}\Ba(g). Metrics satisfying condition \Ba=0 are called Bach flat; examples include all Einstein and conformally Einstein metrics. Bach flat metrics are expected to be somewhat easier to find than Einstein metrics. The Bach tensor defined by equation ( 1.1 ) is extended to higher dimensions by the same formula with P:=\frac{1}{n-2}\left(\Ric-\frac{\Scal}{2(n-1)}h\right) . The Bach tensor loses several key properties if n\geq 5 : it is no longer conformally covariant, it is not the gradient of a Riemannian functional, and it is not divergence-free. The Bach tensor has an analogue in higher dimensions which retains these properties [ 8 ] . It is called the “ambient obstruction tensor”, and it involves higher order derivatives of the metric. In this paper we study a geometric flow associated to the Bach tensor. This flow decreases the Weyl energy functional in dimension 4 . Similar to the Ricci flow, this flow equation is quite degenerate because of the underlying diffeomorphism invariance. The first author and D. Helliwell [ 1 ] have introduced a modified system, hereafter called simply the “Bach flow”, which breaks this conformal invariance. The initial value problem for this Bach flow takes the form (1.2) \frac{dg}{dt}=\Ba(g(t))+\frac{1}{2(n-1)(n-2)}\Delta\Scal(g(t))\,g(t),\;\;g(0)=g_{0}. As explained in [ 3 ] , stationary points of this modified flow are Bach flat metrics for which the scalar curvature is harmonic; this extra condition on S provides a normalization within each conformal class. Below we also incorporate an analogue of the DeTurck gauge to counter the diffeomorphism invariance. Our interest in this paper is the long-time stability of the Bach flow, both at the linear and nonlinear levels, around a very special class of stationary points, namely the metrics with constant sectional curvature. To this end, a significant part of the work below involves the explicit computation of the linearization of the gauge-adjusted Bach flow at metrics of constant sectional curvature and the establishment of bounds on the L^{2} spectrum of the corresponding fourth order linear elliptic operator. These spectral bounds depend heavily on the choice of gauge fixing, and one of the important issues is to choose a gauge for which this linearization is self-adjoint. In our normalization, this L^{2} spectrum is unbounded below. The flow is linearly stable if this spectrum is nonpositive, and one expects particularly nice convergence properties of the nonlinear flow if this spectrum is bounded above by a negative constant, or even if it is just nonpositive with a spectral gap at 0 . If the spectrum is strictly negative, we can employ analytic semigroup techniques as in [ 4 ] to conclude that the nonlinear flow converges to the constant curvature metric at an exponential rate. Our first main result is the following: Theorem 1.1 (Linear Stability of the Gauge-Adjusted Bach Flow at Spaces of Constant Sectional Curvature) . Let (M^{n},h) be an orientable complete Riemannian manifold with constant sectional curvature c\in\{-1,0,+1\} . There is a choice of gauge for which the linearization L of ( 1.2 ) at h is self-adjoint, and for which the L^{2} spectrum of L is non-positive. More specifically: • If c=0 and M is compact, the kernel of L consists of the finite-dimensional space of parallel 2 -tensors. If M is noncompact, we conclude only that the spectrum of L is nonpositive, but there is no L^{2} kernel. • If c=1 and M=S^{n} , the kernel of L consists of the pure-trace symmetric 2 -tensors v=fh , where f satisfies \Delta_{h}f=-nf . • If c=-1 and M=\mathbb{H}^{n} , the spectrum is bounded above by a negative constant; if M is compact, however, the kernel of L consists of the symmetric 2 -tensors of the form v=K\alpha=\delta^{*}_{h}\alpha where \alpha is a harmonic 1 -form, along with the Codazzi-type tensors which are defined as tensors that satisfy v_{ij,k}-v_{jk,i}=0 . Here K is the conformal killing operator (see ( 2.5 ) for its definition). In particular, if M is compact, there is always a spectral gap at 0 . The choice of the gauge in Theorem 1.1 is different from the one proposed in [ 1 ] ; indeed, that one does

Read the complete text