Classical fracton spin liquid and Hilbert space fragmentation in a 2D spin- 1 / 2 1/2 model
Nils Niggemann, Meghadeepa Adhikary, Yannik Schaden-Thillmann, Johannes Reuther · 2025
Read Classical fracton spin liquid and Hilbert space fragmentation in a 2D spin- 1 / 2 1/2 model by Nils Niggemann, Meghadeepa Adhikary, Yannik Schaden-Thillmann, Johannes Reuther (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-06606.txt.
Introduction
Nils Niggemann and co-authors build one of the simplest possible homes for fractons, exotic excitations that can barely move. In a fracton spin liquid, the ground state comes in a huge number of versions and the rules resemble a tensor version of Gauss's law. Their model discretizes that gauge theory directly on a square lattice of spin-half particles.
The simple build exposes the state's anatomy: real-space fracton patterns, a height-field picture of the ground states, and the ripples allowed inside the fracton-free sector. Sampling the classical ground states shows the tensor law survives the strict spin length rule, so a classical Ising fracton liquid exists. Quantum nudges, though, fail to tunnel between ground states, and the state space shatters into fragments. Simulations then find either magnetic order or the classical liquid, never the quantum one. A companion paper tries larger spins as an escape.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nils Niggemann, Meghadeepa Adhikary, Yannik Schaden-Thillmann, Johannes Reuther |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 127 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-06606
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Classical fracton spin liquid and Hilbert space fragmentation in a 2D spin- 1 / 2 1/2 model Nils Niggemann, Meghadeepa Adhikary, Yannik Schaden-Thillmann, Johannes Reuther Abstract Classical U(1) fracton spin liquids feature an extensive ground state degeneracy and follow an effective description in terms of a tensor Gauss’ law where charges, so-called fractons, have restricted mobility. Here we introduce a simple spin model that realizes such a state by straightforward discretization of the higher-rank gauge theory on a square lattice. The simplicity of this construction offers direct insights into the system’s fundamental fractonic properties, such as real-space fracton configurations, height-field representation of the classical ground state manifold as well as properties of local and non-local fluctuations within the fracton-free subspace. By sampling classical Ising states from the extensive ground state manifold, we show that the effective tensor Gauss’ law remains intact when explicitly enforcing the spin-1/2 length constraint, demonstrating the existence of a classical Ising fracton spin liquid. However, we observe that perturbative quantum effects are insufficient to efficiently tunnel between classical ground states, leading to severe Hilbert space fragmentation which obscures fractonic quantum behavior. Specifically, by simulating the spin-1/2 quantum model with Green function Monte Carlo as a function of the Rokhsar-Kivelson potential, we find that the system supports either magnetic long-range order or a classical spin liquid. Our findings highlight the crucial role of Hilbert-space fragmentation in fractonic spin systems but also indicate ways to mitigate such effects via increasing the spin magnitude to S = 1 S=1 , investigated in a companion paper. I Introduction In condensed matter physics, rich phenomena occur when the elementary degrees of freedom of a system are subject to local constraints. Well-known examples are the Hubbard model at strong coupling (no double occupancies), quantum dimer models (one dimer attached to each site) and pyrochlore spin ice (two-in-two-out spin configurations in each tetrahedron). In the latter case, the local constraints, also called ice-rules Moessner and Chalker 1998 ; Isakov et al. 2004 , are a direct manifestation of the system’s strongly frustrated interactions. Importantly, the dimension of the solution-space of the ice rules scales exponentially with the number of spins, a necessary condition for the emergence of a classical spin liquid Garanin and Canals 1999 ; Moessner and Chalker 1998 ; Yan et al. 2023a ; Yan et al. 2023b ; Fang et al. 2024 ; Davier et al. 2023 at low temperatures, where the system can fluctuate freely between the available configurations. Such a state may be efficiently described by a U(1) gauge theory , where the constraints become equivalent to a discrete form of a Gauss’ law \nabla\cdot\bm{E}=\rho . Here, the charges \rho (defect tetrahedra) are created in pairs by single spin flips which fractionalize and may propagate through the system. Taking quantum effects into account, the system can tunnel between different spin ice configurations, giving rise to a quantum spin liquid , described by a compact quantum electrodynamics theory with emergent photon quasiparticles and magnetic monopoles, the latter not present in conventional continuum electrodynamics Balents 2010 ; Savary and Balents 2016 ; Benton et al. 2012 ; Gingras and McClarty 2014 ; Pace et al. 2021 ; Taillefumier et al. 2017 ; Pan et al. 2016 . The immense potential of local constraints in spin systems to realize fascinating particles that otherwise cannot be found in nature, has motivated recent attempts to engineer even more exotic particles. One such attempt aims to realize a generalization of Gauss’ law to a rank-2 gauge theory, where the electric field becomes a rank-2 tensor satisfying \partial_{\mu}\partial_{\nu}E^{\mu\nu}=\rho Rasmussen et al. 2016 ; Pretko 2017a ; Pretko 2017b ; Xu 2006 . Due to the conservation of charge and dipole moments in such a theory, charges, called fractons become fully immobile, while dipoles, formed by bound pairs of charges, may move only in a direction perpendicular to their dipole moment Nandkishore and Hermele 2019 ; Gromov and Radzihovsky 2024 ; Pretko et al. 2020 ; You 2024 . Fracton phases, originally discovered in lattice models extending Kitaev’s \mathbb{Z}_{2} toric code to higher dimensions, are of significant interest for quantum information processing due to the restricted mobility of excitations, which naturally protects encoded quantum information Kitaev 2003 ; Chamon 2005 ; Bravyi et al. 2011 ; Vijay et al. 2015 ; Fontana et al. 2025 . While higher-rank U(1) theories, unlike their \mathds{Z}_{2} counterparts, have gapless photon modes Hermele et al. 2004 ; Huse et al. 2003 ; Benton et al. 2012 and thus do not possess a robust ground state degeneracy, they can share other important properties such as violations of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis via Hilbert space fragmentation as well as subsystem symmetries. Moreover, while \mathds{Z}_{2} fracton liquids such as the X-Cube model, Haah’s Code or Chamon’s code require highly artificial multi-spin interactions that are difficult to realize Vijay et al. 2015 ; Vijay et al. 2016 ; Haah 2011 ; Chamon 2005 ; Castelnovo and Chamon 2012 ; Wu et al. 2023 , higher-rank spin liquids have recently been constructed at the classical level via two-body interactions enforcing generalized ice rules Benton and Moessner 2021 . While it was theorized that quantum fluctuations — in analogy to quantum spin ice — can elevate these models to hosts quantum fracton liquids, no microscopic quantum Hamiltonian has so far been found to realize this exciting prospect Hart and Nandkishore 2022 ; Niggemann et al. 2023 . In this paper, we demonstrate that this challenge is intimately linked to the occurrence of Hilbert space fragmentation in fracton models Sala et al. 2020 ; Khudorozhkov et al. 2022 ; Adler et al. 2024 ; Feng and Skinner 2022 ; Stahl et al. 2025 ; Will et al. 2024 . Specifically, we introduce a particularly simple spin model with emergent fractonic properties, dubbed the spiderweb model , which is obtained by directly discretizing the higher-rank gauge theory on a square lattice. We demonstrate that this model is ideally suited to showcase fractonic behavior on a lattice and to establish the connection between the spin model and the continuum field theory. Starting with an investigation of the classical spiderweb model in simple Gaussian approximation where the local spin-length constraint is relaxed, we develop a formalism to enumerate fracton-free states via the introduction of a height field. This enables us to identify different types of local and non-local fluctuations within the fracton-free subspace whose properties are fundamentally connected to the occurrence of Hilbert space fragmentation. A specific focus is on the spin- 1/2 case of the spiderweb model. Sampling states from the exponentially large classical Ising ground state manifold, we demonstrate that the spiderweb model realizes a classical fracton liquid, evident from the presence of non-analyticities in the spin structure factor, commonly referred to as fourfold pinch points Prem et al. 2018 . Quantum fluctuations are then introduced perturbatively, by allowing for the lowest order tunneling process between the classically degenerate states. Because of the strong Hilbert space fragmentation in the spin- 1/2 model, the quantum dynamics induced by these tunneling processes is found to be insufficient to induce any liquid-like quantum behavior. As we demonstrate via the error-controlled Green function Monte Carlo approach, this holds in the ground-state sector,