Reducing Cartel Violence: The Mexican Dilemma Between Social and Security Spending

Rafael Prieto-Curiel, Dieter Grass, Stefan Wrzaczek, Gian Maria Campedelli, Gernot Tragler, Gustav Feichtinger · 2025

Read Reducing Cartel Violence: The Mexican Dilemma Between Social and Security Spending by Rafael Prieto-Curiel, Dieter Grass, Stefan Wrzaczek, Gian Maria Campedelli, Gernot Tragler, Gustav Feichtinger (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-06509.txt.

Introduction

Rafael Prieto-Curiel and co-authors model cartel violence in Mexico in a 2025 paper. Organized crime strains public safety and the economy, despite spending on both policing and social programs. The team asks how a fixed budget should be split between those two paths.

Using control theory, they trace how cartel size and harm shift with each split. The largest cartel alone costs the country more than nineteen billion dollars a year, they estimate. The current split is close to the best possible, yet too small to cut violence much. Real harm cuts would need a far larger budget and more than a decade.

Catalog record

CREATORRafael Prieto-Curiel, Dieter Grass, Stefan Wrzaczek, Gian Maria Campedelli, Gernot Tragler, Gustav Feichtinger
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE126 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-06509

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reducing Cartel Violence: The Mexican Dilemma Between Social and Security Spending Rafael Prieto-Curiel, Dieter Grass, Stefan Wrzaczek, Gian Maria Campedelli, Gernot Tragler, Gustav Feichtinger Abstract 1 Abstract Organised crime in Mexico threatens societal stability and public safety, driving pervasive violence and economic disruption. Despite security investments and social programs designed in part to reduce involvement in crime, cartel power and violence continue to persist. This study evaluates existing policies and introduces a novel framework using optimal control theory to analyse cartel dynamics. Specifically, by modelling resource allocation between security measures and social programs, we identify optimal strategies to mitigate the impacts of cartels. Findings reveal that Mexico’s largest cartel imposes an annual economic burden exceeding US$ 19 billion, 2.5 times the government’s investment in science and technology. We further demonstrate that current budget allocations between social and security programs are nearly optimal yet insufficient to reduce cartel violence significantly. In light of these findings, we demonstrate that achieving meaningful harm reduction would require a significantly larger budget and would take over a decade, even with increased funding. 2 Introduction Approximately one in three intentional homicides worldwide occurs in Latin America, despite the region representing only 8% of the global population [ 1 ] . Beyond the human toll, organised crime generates pervasive fear and displacement, affecting millions across the region [ 2 , 3 ] . Mexico, in particular, has been severely impacted, with homicides increasing by over 300% between 2007 and 2021, making it one of the most violent countries globally that is not at war [ 1 ] . The economic impact of violence is staggering, estimated at almost 20% of Mexico’s GDP [ 4 ] . Violence remains the country’s top concern, with nearly half of the population blaming cartels [ 5 ] . Yet, the burden of cartels is not exclusive to Latin America. Mexican cartels have also established transnational networks, fueling a global public health crisis by supplying illicit drugs. In the US, their largest market, drug overdoses claim approximately 100,000 lives annually, a figure that has doubled in a decade [ 6 , 7 ] . Given the far-reaching societal costs posed by organised crime groups, institutions in Mexico attempt to curb their. The economic investment made by Mexico in terms of national security programs each year amounts to US$ 9.88 billion [ 8 ] , seeking to increase the strength of the army, marines, police, and other bodies aimed at targeting crime (see the Supplementary Material SM - A). However, existing strategies have failed to contain violence, reduce the power of cartels, block the flow of weapons, or prevent access to illicit substances [ 9 ] . Targeting criminal leaders [ 10 , 11 ] , antigang crackdowns [ 12 , 13 ] , gun and drug seizures [ 14 ] , mass incarcerations [ 15 ] and the destruction of illegal structures have been central elements of the security strategy of both countries for decades [ 16 , 17 ] . In parallel, Mexico has also deployed a broad set of social programs, including community centres [ 18 ] , sports programs [ 19 ] , and cash transfers for all adults above a certain age, single mothers, students, farmers and more [ 20 ] . Although the core objective of social policies is to improve social welfare (reduce inequality, increase school enrollment rates, and reduce poverty), they are often portrayed as part of the government’s strategy to deter young men from joining criminal gangs [ 21 ] . Social programs are an instrument to indirectly counter involvement in criminal activities because, with a higher monetary value of a social program, there exist fewer relative gains and, thus, motivations to join cartels [ 22 , 23 ] . Each year, US$ 8.84 billion is invested in these social programs [ 8 ] , reaching millions of beneficiaries (SM - A). Despite the vast economic costs of security and social programs, violence is rising in Mexico, while drug overdose deaths in the US have been a national emergency [ 24 ] . In this evolving landscape, and despite the impact cartels have within and well beyond Mexico, we lack information on how to allocate expenditures efficiently. Are social programs effective in preventing cartel recruitment and, therefore, future violence? If so, should portions of the security budget be reallocated to social programs? Alternatively, if security programs effectively reduce violence, should parts of the social budget be allocated to security programs? Should more resources be spent on both security and social programs? Here, we attempt to address these questions by analysing cartel dynamics in Mexico and forecasting cartel violence across a set of policy scenarios within an optimal control framework. Optimal control theory has been widely applied to investigate phenomena such as attitudes towards crime reporting [ 25 ] , terrorist behaviours [ 26 ] , and illicit drug demand [ 27 ] . The intuition behind this approach is that the outcome of policies (or controls) and their associated costs can be expressed in the form of an optimisation problem. Optimal control theory enables the examination of dynamic policy solutions that evolve in response to the system’s internal dynamics as its state changes. Here, the optimisation problems are formalised such that the budget can be allocated to social programs or used to counter different cartels through security expenditures. Considering the limited budget of Latin American countries, detecting how much to spend and how to allocate economic resources is a critical issue [ 28 ] . By assigning a monetary cost to future casualties and the harm of cartels and by considering the budget for social programs and security, those outcomes can be regarded as alongside and balanced against the budgetary costs for social programs and security, and so shed light on how resources should be best allocated to counter the influence and violence generated by cartels effectively. 2.1 Modelling cartel dynamics and countermeasures The total number of cartel-affiliated individuals in Mexico has recently been estimated at 175,000 [ 29 ] . Approximately, they recruit 19,000 new members and experience about 6,000 incapacitations and 7,000 losses due to inter-cartel killings, disappearances, or retirements each year, resulting in a net annual increase of around 6,000 members [ 29 ] . Building on those estimates, we determine the optimal strategy through a cost-benefit analysis, balancing the expenditure on social programs against security. While cartel size and the number of homicides are correlated, they conceptually refer to distinct objectives from the state’s standpoint. Cartel conflicts often involve terrorist tactics and advanced weaponry, driven by retaliatory cycles that escalate until one group is defeated, displaced, or fragmented into smaller cells [ 30 , 31 ] . Many cartel-related homicides occur when cartels fight against each other. Therefore, this first indicator is modelled as being proportional to the product of the two cartels’ sizes. We refer to it as homicides of cartel members by other cartels , but it also includes the kidnapping, torture, and killing of members of the opposing cartel (not of the general public). If the objective is to reduce the number of homicides, having a single, but large, cartel may be theoretically more desirable than having

Read the complete text