Independence relations in the Solovay model I 2020 AMS subject classification 03E25, 03E30.

Jindřich Zapletal · 2025

Read Independence relations in the Solovay model I 2020 AMS subject classification 03E25, 03E30. by Jindřich Zapletal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-06449.txt.

Introduction

Jindrich Zapletal offers a new geometric way to build the Solovay model, a classic setting in set theory. The paper lays out the model's axioms through geometry rather than through the forcing machinery usually used to construct it. That shift matters, because forcing proofs can be long and technical, and the geometric view promises a cleaner path to the same ground.

With that framing, Zapletal gives short, forcing-free proofs of the model's classical results. The same framing also serves as a tool for developing the theory of balanced forcing in purely geometric terms. The work opens a series on independence relations inside this model, relations that record which statements the model leaves open rather than deciding.

Catalog record

CREATORJindřich Zapletal
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-06449

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Independence relations in the Solovay model I 2020 AMS subject classification 03E25, 03E30. Jindřich Zapletal Abstract I provide a novel axiomatization of the Solovay model as a tool for a purely geometric treatment of the theory of balanced forcing. 1 Introduction The Solovay model [ 11 ] [ 1 , Chapter 26] [ 9 , Chapter 8] is one of the most thoroughly studied objects in set theory. It was developed by Solovay as a model of choiceless set theory in which all sets of reals are Lebesgue measurable. Its usual construction provides a way of analyzing its theory in great detail. However, this approach uses forcing in a way which makes proofs rather complex and repetitive at the same time. In [ 7 ] , Paul Larson and the present author developed a flexible theory of forcing extensions of the Solovay model called balanced forcing. The theory uses the standard approach to the Solovay model and results in rather repetitive and unwieldy proofs. The purpose of this series of papers is to provide a “geometric” axiomatization of the Solovay model, and then develop a novel presentation of the theory of balanced forcing in the Solovay model in a similar spirit. The word“geometric” here is to suggest a parallel with geometric model theory and the use of independence relations between models as in [ 6 ] . The axiomatization provided is in no sense complete, but it enables a novel and nearly forcing-free style of arguments. In this paper, I prove older results about the Solovay model such as measurability of all sets of reals ( [ 11 ] , Corollary 5.5 ), the Ramsey property of subsets of [\omega]^{\aleph_{0}} ( [ 8 ] , Corollary 5.6 ), nonexistence of MAD families ( [ 13 , 8 ] , Theorem 4.2 ), nonexistence of uncountable sequences of Borel sets of bounded complexity ( [ 12 ] , Theorem 4.7 ) or a version of the Silver dichotomy ( [ 12 ] , Theorem 6.3 ) from this axiomatic basis, all with short, forcing-free and even descriptive set theory-free arguments. In the continuation, I provide a geometric presentation of balanced forcing which is methodologically much simpler than that of [ 7 ] ; in addition, it applies to much broader class of posets and does away with the needless complexity calculations which plague most of that book. As for the structure of this paper, in Section 2 I discuss the language of definability. Section 3 isolates the properties of an independence relation needed for the analysis of the Solovay model, remarkably similar to forking independence. In Section 4 , I isolate the inaccessibility axiom and show that in conjunction with the independence axiom, it has many mathematical consequences; in particular, it implies that no MAD families exist. In Section 5 , I consider the axiom stating that every set of reals has the Baire property. In the presence of the independence relation, this is a strong statement, implying in particular that all sets of reals are Lebesgue measurable, and that the independence relation is essentially mutual genericity. In Section 6 , I consider a Gandy–Harrington type of a game and use the associated axiom to prove the Silver dichotomy. This is one axiom which is not geometric in nature, but it provides quick and clutter-free proofs of several dichotomy theorems. Finally in Section 7 , I discuss various slightly different types of the Solovay model and show that the (usual version of the) Solovay model satisfies all axioms on the list. The terminology and notation used in the paper follows the set theoretic standard of [ 1 ] . During the work on this paper, the author was partially supported by NSF grant DMS 2348371. 2 The definability axiom The basic axiomatic framework for this paper is ZF+DC, where DC stands for the axiom of dependent choices. The first additional axiom, without which the independence axiomatization has no teeth, is the definability axiom. Definition 2.1 . The definability axiom is the statement that every set is definable from a set of ordinals. By “definable”, I mean definable in the universe of sets using the first order language with the membership relation. I use this opportunity to set up some notation. If x is a set of ordinals then the symbol \mathrm{OD}_{x} denotes the class of all sets which are definable from x and an additional finite tuple of ordinals. The symbol \mathrm{HOD}_{x} denotes the transitive part of \mathrm{OD}_{x} ; that is, the class of all sets z such that the transitive closure of z is a subset of \mathrm{OD}_{x} . The following are standard facts. Fact 2.2 . Let x be a set of ordinals. 1. there is a class well-ordering on \mathrm{OD}_{x} definable from x ; 2. \mathrm{HOD}_{x} is a model of ZFC. I will abuse the above notation a bit. I will identify sets of ordinals and finite tuples of sets of ordinals. Thus, if x and y are sets of ordinals, then \mathrm{OD}_{xy} stands for the class of all sets definable from x , y , and an additional finite tuple of ordinals. Also, if y\subset\mathrm{OD}_{x} , I will write \mathrm{OD}_{xy} as if y is a set of ordinals: y can be identified with the set of the indexes of its elements in the canonical definable well-order of \mathrm{OD}_{x} . Another similar shorthand appears when Z is a Hausdorff space with a well-orderable basis \mathcal{B} , and z\in Z is a point. If x is a set of ordinals such that Z,\mathcal{B}\in\mathrm{OD}_{x} , then \mathcal{B}\subset\mathrm{OD}_{x} will hold as well, by Corollary 3.7 below. In such a situation, the point z can be identified with the set \{O\in\mathcal{B}\colon z\in O\}\subset\mathrm{OD}_{x} , and in this sense I will use the notation \mathrm{OD}_{xz} . The following easy proposition will be used to compactify notation in many arguments of this paper. Proposition 2.3 . Let x be a set of ordinals and A be a set. The following are equivalent: 1. A\in\mathrm{OD}_{x} ; 2. there is a function F definable from a finite tuple of ordinals such that x\in\mathrm{dom}(F) and F(x)=A . Proof. The (2) \to (1) implication does not need an argument. For the opposite direction, suppose that \phi(v,x,\bar{\alpha}) is a formula with one free variable displayed and additional parameters x and a finite tuple \bar{\alpha} of ordinals, such that \phi has only one solution and the solution is A . Define the (class) function F by F(y)=B if the formula \phi(v,y,\bar{\alpha}) has only one solution and the solution is B , and F(y)=0 if the formula \phi(v,y,\bar{\alpha}) has no solutions or more than one solutions. It is clear that F works as desired. ∎ 3 The independence axiom The most important contribution of this paper is the axiomatization of set theoretic independence and its uses. It will turn out much later that the independence relation is necessarily essentially equal to mutual genericity (Corollary 5.8 ), but one can use the independence relation successfully in arguments axiomatically without ever considering any forcing language. Definition 3.1 . A (set theoretic) independence relation is a ternary class relation \mathrel{\mathop{\vbox{\hbox{\vtop{\halign{#\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr\hfil$|$\hfil\cr\kern-3.01385pt\cr$\smile$\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr}}}}}\displaylimits} on sets of ordinals satisfying the following properties: 1. (symmetry) y_{0}\mathrel{\mathop{\vbox{\hbox{\vtop{\halign{#\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr\hfil$|$\hfil\cr\kern-3.01385pt\cr$\smile$\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr}}}}}\displaylimits_{x}}y_{1} implies y_{1}\mathrel{\mathop{\vbox{\hbox{\vtop{\halign{#\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr\hfil$|$\hfil\cr\kern-3.01385pt\cr$\smile$\cr\kern-1.29167pt\cr}}}}}\displaylimits_{x}}y_{0} ;

Read the complete text