Automated Creation of the Legal Knowledge Graph Addressing Legislation on Violence Against Women: Resource, Methodology and Lessons Learned

Claudia d’Amato, Giuseppe Rubini, Didio Franceso, Francioso Donato, Fatima Zahra Amara, Nicola Fanizzi · 2025

Read Automated Creation of the Legal Knowledge Graph Addressing Legislation on Violence Against Women: Resource, Methodology and Lessons Learned by Claudia d’Amato, Giuseppe Rubini, Didio Franceso, Francioso Donato, Fatima Zahra Amara, Nicola Fanizzi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-06368.txt.

Introduction

Claudia d'Amato and five co-authors build a legal knowledge graph on violence against women, in a 2025 paper. Lawyers need detailed, current case knowledge to decide well. Knowledge graphs can supply that base for search and reasoning tools. Few exist in law, so the team built one from court sentences. Source texts came from a European court database.

Two construction routes were compared. One is a systematic bottom-up pipeline tuned for legal text. The other leans on large language models for extraction. Both routes add structure, ontology design, and semantic enrichment. Test questions validated the finished graphs. Machine learning tools for predictive justice could draw on such a base. The authors also report lessons from the build. Access to legal information improves for people and machines alike, they argue.

Catalog record

CREATORClaudia d’Amato, Giuseppe Rubini, Didio Franceso, Francioso Donato, Fatima Zahra Amara, Nicola Fanizzi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-06368

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Automated Creation of the Legal Knowledge Graph Addressing Legislation on Violence Against Women: Resource, Methodology and Lessons Learned Claudia d’Amato, Giuseppe Rubini, Didio Franceso, Francioso Donato, Fatima Zahra Amara, Nicola Fanizzi Abstract Legal decision-making process requires the availability of comprehensive and detailed legislative background knowledge and up-to-date information on legal cases and related sentences/decisions. Legal Knowledge Graphs (KGs) would be a valuable tool to facilitate access to legal information, to be queried and exploited for the purpose, and to enable advanced reasoning and machine learning applications. Indeed, legal KGs may act as knowledge intensive component to be used by predictive machine learning solutions supporting the decision process of the legal expert. Nevertheless, a few KGs can be found in the legal domain. To fill this gap, we developed a legal KG targeting legal cases of violence against women, along with clear adopted methodologies. Specifically, the paper introduces two complementary approaches for automated legal KG construction; a systematic bottom-up approach, customized for the legal domain, and a new solution leveraging Large Language Models. Starting from legal sentences publicly available from the European Court of Justice, the solutions integrate structured data extraction, ontology development, and semantic enrichment to produce KGs tailored for legal cases involving violence against women. After analyzing and comparing the results of the two approaches, the developed KGs are validated via suitable competency questions. The obtained KG may be impactful for multiple purposes: can improve the accessibility to legal information both to humans and machine, can enable complex queries and may constitute an important knowledge component to be possibly exploited by machine learning tools tailored for predictive justice. Resource type: Knowledge Graphs License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15270173 URL: https://lod-cloud.net/dataset/PREJUST4WOMAN_PROJECT 1 Introduction In recent years, the legal domain has been interested by an increasing usage of Artificial Intelligence (AI) solutions [ 5 , 12 ] to effectively manage and mine legal consultation and decision process. Despite advancement in legal technologies [ 8 ] , a significant gap exists in the availability of structured and easy to query resources tailored to the legal domain such as Knowledge Graphs (KGs) [ 9 ] . Existing KGs in the legal domain often fail to address nuanced and domain-specific challenges, including the need for interoperability, semantic richness, and adaptability to predictive justice applications [ 20 , 21 ] . A legal KG needs to be able to cope with the specific and intricate writing style of laws and sentences, and keeping track of the evolution of laws, including exceptions and applicability. We specifically focus on the widespread and urgent issue of violence against women 1 1 1 https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/violence-against-women that leads to physical and mental health problems, economic losses and social instability [ 4 ] and that impacts societies around the world. Manifesting in physical and emotional forms, it constitutes a grave violation of human rights, threatening the safety, dignity, and well-being of countless women. Actually, a multifaceted approach involving governments, civil society and individuals is essential to counter this pervasive problem and promote healthier and more equitable societies. Our work aims to contribute to this effort by developing advanced instruments and knowledge components to assist in the legal handling of cases related to violence against women. This goal requires robust tools capable of supporting legislative interpretation, judicial decision-making, policy formulation and access to structured resources, in the form of KGs, tailored to cases of gender-based violence. For this purpose, we introduce a novel Legal KG, specifically designed to address legislation and judicial cases related to violence against women, jointly with methodologies adopted for its development. The Legal KG is automatically derived from the jurisprudence of sentences of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR 2 2 2 https://www.echr.coe.int/ ), targeting cases of gender-based violence, and it adheres to the FAIR ( Findable , Accessible , Interoperable , Reusable ) data principles. The resource is built upon two methodologies: a customization to the legal domain of the general KG development process [ 18 ] (that is a bottom-up solution combining data extraction, ontology development, and semantic enrichment via alignment to domain-specific ontologies), and a new approach for automated KG generation, grounded on the exploitation of Large Language Models (LLMs) as the recent advancements have opened up new possibilities for automating and improving various phases of ontology development [ 11 ] , and customized to the legal domain. The two methodologies resulted complementary: the former providing more precise outcomes but more time-consuming, the latter more scalable but limited in accuracy. The obtained resource has been also validated via suitable competency questions [ 13 ] . Besides the Legal KG being the first result addressing legislation, particularly concerning violence against women, this resource may act as proxy for broader applications. In the context of predictive justice, sentence prediction may be regarded as a link prediction problem on (a subset of) the Legal KG. This approach may be generalized to other domains in addition to the one of violence against women, provided the availability of legal KGs generated by adopting the proposed methodologies. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows: Section 2 review the state of the art on legal informatics, KGs and ontologies in law. Section 3 presents a customization to the legal domain of the bottom-up KG development process and the obtained Legal KG. Section 4 presents a new approach for automated KG generation, grounded on the exploitation of Large Language Models (LLMs) and customized to the legal domain, the obtained Legal KG. Section 5 discusses the results and the effectiveness of the adopted methodologies. Section 6 conclude the paper and delineate future research directions. 2 Related Work In this section, we survey the state of the art at the intersection of legal informatics, usage of KGs for the legal domain and development of ontologies and legal thesaurus initiatives. These studies explore methods for structuring legal data, applying automated reasoning, and extracting insights from legal texts. Legal knowledge extraction and presentation of the Joint Knowledge Enhancement Model (JKEM), which refines LLMs using a prefix-based strategy to improve knowledge extraction accuracy is proposed in [ 12 ] . Using this paradigm, the authors created the Chinese Legal Knowledge Graph (CLKG), which has 3480 knowledge triples but does not exploit any existing domain ontology. Similarly, in [ 23 ] a judicial case KG centered mostly on event elements, employing a joint event extraction model to mine entity and event information from digital case records is presented. Using the Dgraph graph database for storage and GraphQL for querying, this approach facilitates retrieval, case analysis, and knowledge discovery but does not push on interlinking the resource with other existing resources. Analogously, in [ 17 ] the ManyLaws platform is presented, a Big Open Legal Data (BOLD) platform that provides advanced and customizable access to legal information across the EU. The platform offers services such as legal corpus research, law comparison, legislative alignment analysis, and legislative timelines visualization. By leveraging data analytics, text mining, and interactive visualization, the platform enhances accessibility and understanding of legal data for a wide range of users but it does not focus on data interlinking and semantic querying. An approach for automatic legal document generation based on KGs is presented in

Read the complete text