A “Good Regulator Theorem” for Embodied Agents

Nathaniel Virgo, Martin Biehl, Manuel Baltieri, Matteo Capucci · 2025

Read A “Good Regulator Theorem” for Embodied Agents by Nathaniel Virgo, Martin Biehl, Manuel Baltieri, Matteo Capucci (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-06326.txt.

Introduction

Nathaniel Virgo and three co-authors prove a version of a classic regulation theorem for embodied agents in a paper from 2025. A famous claim says every good regulator of a system must contain a model of that system. Artificial life shows many agents that act well with no visible model, which seems to break the claim.

Their version shifts the ground: whenever an agent regulates well, an observer can read its behavior as holding beliefs about its world and updating them from its senses. The model then lives in the observer's reading, not in the agent's parts. Trivial readings explain the apparent counterexamples.

Catalog record

CREATORNathaniel Virgo, Martin Biehl, Manuel Baltieri, Matteo Capucci
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-06326

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A “Good Regulator Theorem” for Embodied Agents Nathaniel Virgo, Martin Biehl, Manuel Baltieri, Matteo Capucci Abstract In a classic paper, Conant and Ashby claimed that “every good regulator of a system must be a model of that system.” Artificial Life has produced many examples of systems that perform tasks with apparently no model in sight; these suggest Conant and Ashby’s theorem doesn’t easily generalise beyond its restricted setup. Nevertheless, here we show that a similar intuition can be fleshed out in a different way: whenever an agent is able to perform a regulation task, it is possible for an observer to interpret it as having “beliefs” about its environment, which it “updates” in response to sensory input. This notion of belief updating provides a notion of model that is more sophisticated than Conant and Ashby’s, as well as a theorem that is more broadly applicable. However, it necessitates a change in perspective, in that the observer plays an essential role in the theory: models are not a mere property of the system but are imposed on it from outside. Our theorem holds regardless of whether the system is regulating its environment in a classic control theory setup, or whether it’s regulating its own internal state; the model is of its environment either way. The model might be trivial, however, and this is how the apparent counterexamples are resolved. 1 Introduction The work of W. Ross Ashby had a profound impact on the development of Artificial Life, and of cognitive science more broadly. In particular, Ashby, 1960 led to the idea of the viability boundary of an organism, a notion of current interest in ALIFE ( McShaffrey and Beer, 2023 ; Beer et al., 2024 ; Egbert and Pérez-Mercader, 2018 ) and a foundational concept in enactivism and the evolutionary robotics approach to cognition ( Beer, 1995 ; Beer, 1997 ; Beer, 2004 ; Di Paolo, 2005 , e.g.) . In parallel, ( Conant and Ashby, 1970 ) claimed in its title that “every good regulator of a system must be a model of that system”, an idea that was taken up in control theory under the name ‘internal model principle’ ( Francis and Wonham, 1976 ) and whose influence on cognitive science can still be felt today, for example, in some works under the banner of the free energy principle (FEP) such as ( Friston, 2019 ; Da Costa et al., 2021 ) , or in the information-theoretic definition of ‘semantic information’ ( Kolchinsky and Wolpert, 2018 ) . Although the ideas in ( Ashby, 1960 ) and ( Conant and Ashby, 1970 , hereafter 14 ) are not dissimilar, the bodies of work descending from them appear to have reached disparate conclusions: Artificial Life has produced many examples of agents that apparently do not need an internal model in order to achieve their tasks ( Braitenberg, 1986 ; Beer, 2003 , e.g.) , apparently contradicting ( 14 ) . This is in part because ( 14 ) doesn’t strictly succeed, even in its own terms, in showing what its title claims. (This has been noted previously in blog posts: Baez, 2016 ; Wentworth, 2021 .) Its theorem doesn’t establish that every good regulator is a model but only that some of them are (those that are not “unnecessarily complex” in 14 ’s terminology). Although there have been several attempts to generalise it beyond its simple setup, they often seem to need strong assumptions that limit their validity. (See Baltieri et al., 2025 for a recent exposition of the assumptions behind the internal model principle in control theory, for example.) We claim, however, that these issues can be fixed in a way that removes the need for extra assumptions while also accounting for the apparent counterexamples. To do this, we need to use a different notion of ‘model’ than 14 ’s one. For Conant and Ashby, 1970 , for a system {X} to be a model of a system {Y} there should be a “ ‘-morphic’ relation”, i.e. a homomorphism of some kind from, {Y} to {X} . This means roughly that the model {X} behaves like a coarse-grained version of the thing it’s modelling, {Y}, with an intuition along the lines that a controller must behave like the system it’s controlling in order to predict it. In contrast, our notion of model builds on a recent notion of interpretation map ( Virgo et al., 2021 ; Biehl and Virgo, 2023 . The idea is that it must be possible for an observer to attribute belief states (priors) to the states of X that change consistently with the dynamics of model Y . In the terminology of Seth and Tsakiris, 2018 this is a version of “having a model” (as opposed to “being a model”) in that it is about states encoding priors, although see the comments on ‘as-if’ agency below. In the current work we consider “possibilistic” belief states, as in ( Baltieri et al., 2025 , section III) , which are simpler than Bayesian priors, though closely analogous. We show that this version of ‘has a model’ has its own “good regulator theorem” ( theorem 3.4 ), which doesn’t need any assumptions beyond a fairly minimal definition of regulation. Although this definition of regulation is minimal, it is flexible enough to apply to embodied agents. The theorem shows that every good regulator has a model, but it allows that the model might be trivial, and this is how the apparent counterexamples are accounted for. A related result is proved in ( Baltieri et al., 2025 ) in the context of the Internal Model Principle (IMP). Here we take a more first-principles approach, which doesn’t need the assumptions of the IMP and leads to a simpler yet stronger theorem. In particular, ( Baltieri et al., 2025 ) requires that the controller can fully observe the plant, which limits the extent to which it can be applied to embodied agents. Nevertheless, this prior work can be seen as showing that “being a model” implies “having a model” in senses similar to ours. The study of interpretation maps builds on a research programme of ‘as-if’ agency ( McGregor, 2016 ; McGregor, 2017 ; McGregor et al., 2025a ; McGregor et al., 2025b ) , which aims to formalise Dennett’s ideas about the intentional stance ( Dennett, 2006 , e.g.) . The idea of a stance is central to our work: our notion of model depends fundamentally on choices that an external observer must make about how to interpret the system’s internal state and behaviour. A model is part of a stance the observer can optionally take with respect to the system, rather than a property of the system alone. (In this respect our work could be characterised as “is a model” rather than “has a model” in Seth and Tsakiris, 2018 ’s terms, but we will continue to use the “has a model” terminology.) At the same time, the choice is not arbitrary: the patterns in a system’s dynamics that make an interpretation possible are a “real” property of that system ( Dennett, 1991 , c/f) . Our work could be seen as laying theoretical groundwork for similar ideas in machine

Read the complete text