Optimal trap cropping investments to maximize agricultural yield
Matthew H Holden · 2025
Read Optimal trap cropping investments to maximize agricultural yield by Matthew H Holden (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-05896.txt.
Introduction
Trap cropping plants a crop that pests love next to the main crop, luring pests away from the harvest. Matthew Holden, writing alone in 2025, asked how much land a grower should give to the trap plants. His framework balances trap attractiveness, the yield at risk, and how yield falls as pest numbers rise, using relations drawn from past studies.
For pests that move freely and choose plants only by attractiveness, the best share was usually five to twenty percent of the field. Very attractive traps need less land, while weak traps fail even when planted widely. Mid-level attractiveness called for the largest planting. Holden offers the model as a clear base for richer cases.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matthew H Holden |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-05896
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Optimal trap cropping investments to maximize agricultural yield Matthew H Holden Abstract Trap cropping is a pest management strategy where a grower plants an attractive “trap crop” alongside the primary crop to divert pests away from it. We propose a simple framework for optimizing the proportion of a grower’s field or greenhouse allocated to a main crop and a trap crop to maximize agricultural yield. We implement this framework using a model of pest movement governed by trap crop attractiveness, the potential yield threatened by pests, and functional relationships between yield loss and pest density drawn from the literature. Focusing on a simple case in which pests move freely across the field and are attracted to traps solely by their relative attractiveness, we find that allocating 5–20 percent of the landscape to trap plants is typically required to maximize yield and achieve effective pest control in the absence of pesticides. For highly attractive trap plants, growers can devote less space because they are more effective; less attractive plants are ineffective even in large numbers. Intermediate attractiveness warrants the greatest investment in trap cropping. Our framework offers a transparent and tractable approach for exploring trade-offs in pest management and can be extended to incorporate more complex pest behaviors, crop spatial configurations, and economic considerations. Keywords: ecological pest management, integrated pest management, inter-cropping, companion planting, organic agriculture, trap crop Recommendations for Resource Managers • Planting a highly attractive “trap crop” that lures pests away from the main crop in an agricultural field can control pests, improve yield, and lower reliance on chemical pesticides. • Because trap plants occupy precious space that could otherwise be used to grow harvestable crops, it is important to optimize their share of the field. • Our results suggest that allocating 5–20% of the field to trap crops may be required to maximize yield, depending on pest pressure and trap plant attractiveness. 1 Introduction Pests remain one of the most significant threats to agricultural productivity worldwide, reducing yields and increasing the need for chemical interventions ( Savary et al., 2019 ) . However, widespread pesticide use has led to well-documented issues, including the evolution of pest resistance ( Sparks and Nauen, 2015 ) , harm to non-target species and pollinators ( Tooker and Pearsons, 2021 ; Basu et al., 2024 ) , and environmental contamination ( de Souza et al., 2020 ) . These concerns have motivated a growing interest in ecologically based pest management approaches that reduce reliance on chemical controls while maintaining productivity ( Gurr et al., 2003 ; Cook et al., 2007 ; Angon et al., 2023 ; González-Chang et al., 2019 ) . Among these, trap cropping has emerged as a promising, environmentally friendly tactic for manipulating pest behavior to protect the main crop from pests ( Sarkar et al., 2018 ) . Trap cropping is a strategy where a more attractive plant species or variety is deliberately planted to draw pests away from the main crop, thereby reducing damage and improving overall yield ( Shelton and Badenes-Perez, 2006 ) . The effectiveness of trap cropping has been demonstrated in a variety of agricultural systems, including cotton, brassicas, cucurbits, and legumes ( Adams et al., 2017 ; Hokkanen, 1991 ; Cavanagh et al., 2009 ; Lu et al., 2009 ) . However, despite its widespread use, practical guidance on how much land to allocate to the trap crop is lacking. Many studies remain empirical, focusing on evaluating the attractiveness of candidate trap plants for specific crop–pest pairs or small-scale field trials, with limited generalization to broader agroecological conditions ( Shelton and Badenes-Perez, 2006 ; Edde and Phillips, 2006 ; Lee et al., 2009 ) . Moreover, quantitative theory linking system parameters to optimal spatial allocation remains underdeveloped. Mathematical and simulation models have played a critical role in advancing our understanding of trap cropping and related ecological interventions such as intercropping and companion planting. Early models focused on insect pest dispersal and behavioral responses to attractants or traps embedded within cropping systems ( Perry and Wall, 1984 ) . Since then, a range of modeling approaches have been used to explore how pest movement, crop attractiveness, and spatial layout interact to influence trap crop performance ( Hannunen, 2005 ; Holden et al., 2012 ; Fenoglio et al., 2017 ) . Simulation-based studies have shown that trap effectiveness depends not only on the strength of attraction but also on spatial configuration and pest mobility. For example, models incorporating biological control agents alongside trap crops reveal strong context dependence, with outcomes shaped by both natural enemy dynamics and landscape structure ( Banks and Laubmeier, 2024 ; Banks and Laubmeier, 2023 ; Knudsen et al., 2015 ) . Individual-based models (IBMs) have been used to account for fine-scale behavioral heterogeneity and movement biases in response to trap placement ( Vinatier et al., 2012 ; Simon and Fortin, 2020 ) , while recent work has examined how plant dispersion and patch shape influence trapping efficiency ( Banks and Ekbom, 1999 ; Ahmed et al., 2023 ) . A broader synthesis of movement modeling in cropping systems underscores the importance of aligning spatial designs with pest dispersal mechanisms and highlights trade-offs between model tractability and ecological realism ( Garcia et al., 2021 ) . While these studies provide rich insight into pest–crop dynamics and demonstrate the potential of spatially targeted interventions, they do not offer general analytic solutions for the optimal proportion of land to devote to trap cropping. Our work aims to fill this gap by proposing a stylized but tractable framework that captures key trade-offs and yields explicit recommendations for growers. We start by developing a simple mathematical framework to determine the optimal proportion of a grower’s field that should be allocated to a trap crop to maximize total yield. Our framework is intentionally stylized and analytically tractable. Analytic solutions are especially valuable because they (i) improve transparency by making a direct link between assumptions and outcomes easy to interpret and interrogate, (ii) their solutions serve as baselines for validating more complex future simulation models, and (iii) they allow for general insights to be computed and communicated efficiently. The model is built around two central parameters: the proportion of yield that would be lost to pests in the absence of trap cropping and the relative attractiveness of the trap crop, which determines the likelihood that pests are diverted away from the main crop. Both parameters can be estimated from experimental data, expert elicitation, or synthesis studies on pest behavior and damage functions ( Zehnder et al., 2007 ; Mitchell et al., 2000 ) . To illustrate the utility of the framework, we analyze a simplified scenario in which pests move freely across the field and select plants purely based on relative attractiveness. This assumption corresponds to highly mobile pests, such as adult moths that lay their eggs in batches over several days or weeks across multiple plants ( Jones et al., 2019 ) . The assumption of high mobility relative to crop area is especially plausible in smaller greenhouse environments, since pests can rapidly traverse the entire planting area ( Doehler et al., 2023 ) . Under these conditions, we derive explicit expressions for expected yield and characterize