Evidence For Turbulent Concentration In Particle-Laden Midplane Layers of Planet-Forming Disks. Journal: Astrophysical Journal

Orkan M. Umurhan, Debanjan Sengupta, Paul R. Estrada · 2025

Read Evidence For Turbulent Concentration In Particle-Laden Midplane Layers of Planet-Forming Disks. Journal: Astrophysical Journal by Orkan M. Umurhan, Debanjan Sengupta, Paul R. Estrada (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-05858.txt.

Introduction

Orkan Umurhan and co-authors find a quieter way dust clumps in planet-forming disks, besides the famous streaming instability, in a 2025 paper. Before planets form, dust settles into a thin midplane layer in the gas disk around a young star. Clumping there is the first step toward planetesimals, and the streaming instability is the usual suspect.

In their simulations of the settled layer, filaments of the instability had not formed — yet small-scale clumping still appeared. Particle-rich strands lined up with zones where the gas strains hardest, wrapping gas-only voids that swirl coherently: the signature of turbulent concentration. A scaled particle measure collapsed neatly across settings. Planet building may start earlier and more gently than thought.

Catalog record

CREATOROrkan M. Umurhan, Debanjan Sengupta, Paul R. Estrada
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-05858

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evidence For Turbulent Concentration In Particle-Laden Midplane Layers of Planet-Forming Disks. Journal: Astrophysical Journal Orkan M. Umurhan, Debanjan Sengupta, Paul R. Estrada Abstract In this study we investigate the axisymmetric, weakly turbulent state of settled particle layers in a localized model of a protoplanetary disk. We focus on conditions in which the large-scale axisymmetric filaments typically associated with the streaming instability (SI) either cannot form or have not yet developed. Under these circumstances, we observe small-scale particle clumping consistent with turbulent concentration (TC), in which short particle filaments collect along regions of high gas strain rate and enclose gas-only voids exhibiting coherent vorticity. Despite varying particle Stokes numbers St K {\rm{St}}_{K} which are defined relative to the Keplerian frequency – the most widely used definition in protoplanetary disk modeling – the effective Stokes numbers within voids, St ω {\rm{St}}_{\omega} – defined instead relative to the local gas vorticity – consistently center around 0.3 0.3 . This situation reproduces the special regime identified in prior statistical studies of TC as the combination of particle size and fluid properties where particle clustering is most intermittent. A timescale comparison reveals that in simulations with midplane particle-to-gas density ratios below unity and St K ≪ 1 {\rm{St}}_{K}\ll 1 , SI growth rates are 1–2 orders of magnitude slower than the turbulent overturn frequencies at the large-eddy scale. This disparity appears to effectively rule out SI as the primary driver of turbulence in these cases. Instead, we suggest the Symmetric Instability (SymI) may be responsible. We further observe that for St K ≪ 1 {}_{K}\ll 1 , TC is a persistent feature of turbulent particle layers , and conclude that small scale particle density fluctuations exceeding the Roche density within large-scale axisymmetric SI filaments reported in the literature are probably not SI, but expressions of TC amplified by the elevated background particle densities within those large-scale structures. I Introduction When inertial particles are present in a turbulent carrier fluid, the particles tend to cluster in regions with low vorticity and high strain rate in a size-dependent way ( Squires & Eaton 1991 ; Balachandar & Eaton 2010 ; Bragg & Collins 2014 ; Bec et al. 2023 ) leading to strong inhomogeneity in the particle density across flow scales. This robust phenomenon is known as Turbulent Concentration (TC hereafter) and is involved in observations of many varied physical systems (rain initiation, reactive dispersed flow including combustion chambers, etc.) and also in numerical studies of pure fluid flows exhibiting isotropic homogeneous turbulence ( Squires & Eaton 1990 ; Squires & Eaton 1991 ; Elghobashi & Truesdell 1992 ; Yang & Lei 1998 ; Wang & Squires 1996 ) . TC has been numerically modeled to explain certain properties of tiny grains in turbulent molecular clouds ( Hopkins & Lee 2016 ) and examined in detail through statistical analyses informed by fluid dynamics simulations ( Hartlep et al. 2017 ) . In the context of planetesimal formation, TC has also been explored using statistical models to extrapolate numerical simulation results to the relevant scales ( Cuzzi et al. 2001 ; Cuzzi et al. 2008 ; Cuzzi et al. 2010 ; Pan et al. 2011 ; Hopkins 2016a ; Hopkins 2016b ; Gerosa et al. 2023 ) . The work presented here, however, is the first to demonstrate TC directly under nebula conditions at realistic length scales and with sufficient numerical resolution to capture the essential dynamics. In protoplanetary disks, solid particles settle towards the midplane under the influence of the vertical component of the stellar gravity and generate a particle-gas shear layer leading to a turbulent state, as originally envisioned by Weidenschilling 1980 . Later on, Cuzzi et al. 1993 and Dobrovolskis et al. 1999 predicted the generation of an Ekman-type flow structure in these shearing particle layers owing to the strong rotation present in the disk. Recently, Sengupta & Umurhan 2023 confirmed these predictions through moderate to high resolution particle-gas simulations in which they demonstrate that a combination of three separate instabilities are responsible for the turbulence generated by the particle laden midplane layer: 1) the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability (KHI) arising from the vertical variation of radial flow field; 2) the Symmetric Instability (SymI; Stamper & Taylor 2017 ; Sengupta & Umurhan 2023 , under the single fluid approximation) arising from the vertical variation of the azimuthal flow field; and finally 3) the Streaming Instability ( Youdin & Goodman 2005 , SI;) rooted in the differential drift of particle and gas fields, present in the form of axisymmetric filamentary bands of solid overdensities, when the parameters are favorable. Of these, SI has been the favored mechanism for the formation of the self-gravitating bound clumps that form planetesimals ( Johansen et al. 2007 ; Yang et al. 2017 , among many others) under conditions where the nebula is marginally laminar and/or particles are bigger than implied by observations ( Carrasco-González et al. 2019 ; Tazzari et al. 2021 ) , growth models ( Estrada et al. 2016 ; Estrada et al. 2022 ; Sengupta et al. 2019 ) , and meteoritic evidence ( Simon et al. 2018 , and references therein) . The SI is both subtle and manifold in its mechanical expression. As a resonant momentum exchange between the particle and gas fields ( Squire & Hopkins 2018 ) , it operates across the full spectrum of vertical wavenumbers, though it is limited to radial scales above a certain threshold. The SI’s fastest linear growth occurs at the shortest vertical wavelengths with rates on the order of the local disk rotation frequency ( Youdin & Goodman 2005 ; Youdin & Johansen 2007 ) . In globally laminar disk models—such as those considered here—these ultra-short vertical wavelength modes dominate the generation of turbulence, as shown in the carefully detailed analysis of Baronett et al. 2024 . Longer vertical wavelengths, while also unstable, grow over extended timescales more slowly and can give rise to broader radial-scale azimuthally aligned filaments. These filaments are the sites of high-amplitude particle density fluctuations, as has been reported throughout the literature. However, their development is sensitive to the background turbulence level. If the turbulence is too strong, the filaments can be weakened, lose spatial coherence, or become suppressed entirely ( Umurhan et al. 2020 ; Chen & Lin 2020 , e.g.,) . In situations where turbulence is generated self-consistently in, and locally around the particle-laden midplane layer of the protoplanetary disk (irrespective of mechanism), the two necessary conditions for TC – the presence of turbulence and inertial particles therein – are automatically satisfied, and there is no reason to think that this mechanism refrains from taking part in the process of particle clumping. Recently, Hartlep & Cuzzi 2020 presented a statistical study based on homogeneous and isotropic 3D turbulence data ( Bec et al. 2010 ) showing that the realization of the maximum clumping (maximum intermittency in the particle density field) by TC requires certain scales to be resolved. However, even in lower-resolution numerical simulations, TC nevertheless still operates and contributes to particle clumping to a finite extent, although not attaining the maximum level of clustering. In simulations like these, we expect that there is always some contribution from TC to particle clumping that

Read the complete text