Neutrino fog in the light dark sector: the role of isospin violation

Víctor Martín Lozano, Shankar Pramanik, Soumya Sadhukhan, Adrián Terrones · 2025

Read Neutrino fog in the light dark sector: the role of isospin violation by Víctor Martín Lozano, Shankar Pramanik, Soumya Sadhukhan, Adrián Terrones (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-05787.txt.

Introduction

Victor Martin Lozano and co-authors study how a hidden sector of particles could shift the neutrino fog that limits dark matter searches, in a paper from 2025. Detectors that hunt dark matter now face a background from neutrinos that looks much like the signal they seek. Near a mass of about ten giga electron volts, the two start to overlap.

The team works in a simple model that adds a new force carrier to the known particles. In that model, both dark matter and neutrinos can hit atomic nuclei in a way that breaks a balance called isospin symmetry. That change can raise or lower the neutrino background floor. It also shifts the bound set by current searches. The paper maps how the search window moves with model choices.

Catalog record

CREATORVíctor Martín Lozano, Shankar Pramanik, Soumya Sadhukhan, Adrián Terrones
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-05787

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Neutrino fog in the light dark sector: the role of isospin violation Víctor Martín Lozano, Shankar Pramanik, Soumya Sadhukhan, Adrián Terrones Abstract Dark matter (DM) direct detection is now standing at an interesting juncture, where the Standard Model (SM) neutrino background and the upper bound on the DM signal cross section are starting to overlap in the DM mass region around 10 GeV. The neutrino floor, which defines the extent of the neutrino background, can be modified in different Beyond Standard Model (BSM) setups. We work in a simple BSM dark sector extension of the SM visible sector, where isospin-violating interactions occur naturally. In this model, both DM and neutrinos have, in general, isospin-violating (IV) interactions with nuclei, through a newly added local U(1) gauge boson Z ′ Z^{\prime} . Depending on the choice of the model parameters, the coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering (CE ν \upnu NS) cross section can either increase or decrease, shifting up or down the neutrino floor in the parameter space. The same is true for the DM experimental upper bound, whose change is driven exclusively by the IV parameter f n / f p f_{n}/f_{p} . Several scenarios are constructed, based on the interplay between the two regions and the allowed parameter space left between them, and discussed. The potential observation of solar neutrinos in DM direct detection experiments is also discussed in the context of our framework. I Introduction Even if dark matter (DM) has been established to form 85% of the matter density of the Universe, we are yet to observe it in DM direct detection experiments. In these, we expect DM particles around us to scatter off the detector material, inducing nuclear recoils within the detector. Great efforts have been made in this direction, culminating in the ton-scale generation of xenon (Xe) experiments such as LZ LZ:2022lsv , PandaX PandaX-4T:2021bab ; PandaX:2024qfu and XENONnT XENON:2025vwd , imposing stringent bounds to the DM parameter space. At the same time, neutrinos, predominantly those produced in the Sun, can also scatter off the detector material’s nuclei through neutral current processes, known as coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering (CE \upnu NS). These neutrino-induced recoils could potentially act as background for prospective DM signals. In this context, the neutrino floor or neutrino fog OHare:2021utq is defined as the lower boundary of the DM-nucleon scattering cross section, as a function of DM mass, above which it is possible to definitely identify a recoil as a DM signal. Below that boundary, neutrinos become a background, making DM searches more challenging, while at the same time allowing for the exploration of new physics in the neutrino sector AristizabalSierra:2019ykk ; AristizabalSierra:2024nwf ; DeRomeri:2024iaw ; DeRomeri:2024hvc ; Blanco-Mas:2024ale . Recent searches by DM direct detection experiments have set bounds on the DM-nucleon scattering cross section that are becoming closer to the neutrino floor LZ:2022lsv ; XENON:2025vwd ; PandaX:2024qfu ; PandaX-4T:2021bab . Furthermore, low-energy threshold searches by PandaX PandaX:2022xqx ; PandaX:2024muv and XENONnT XENON:2020gfr ; XENON:2024ijk found indications of solar neutrino events, albeit with very low significant statistics ( \sim 2.7\penalty\ \sigma ). This is leading us to different but connected conundrums: where are the Standard Model (SM) neutrino interactions that were supposed to be present even when no DM signal is present? Has the background-free DM parameter space totally disappeared? Are the DM and the neutrino sectors connected? In the study of DM scenarios in both theoretical and experimental contexts, the assumption that DM interacts equally with protons and neutrons, known as isospin-conserving interactions, is often made. However, this might not be the case for the new physics of DM interactions Giuliani:2005my ; Feng:2011vu . A clear example of isospin-violating (IV) interactions can be found in the SM itself, where the Z boson interactions to neutrons are stronger than to protons. Isospin-violating interactions can arise naturally in numerous theoretical scenarios of DM sectors Chun:2010ve ; Frandsen:2011cg ; Gao:2011ka ; He:2011gc ; He:2013suk ; Feng:2013vod ; Belanger:2013tla ; Hamaguchi:2014pja ; Chen:2014tka ; Lozano:2015vlv ; Crivellin:2015bva ; Drozd:2015gda ; Chang:2017gla ; Martin-Lozano:2018sxw ; Li:2019sty ; Lozano:2021zbu . One of the most visible effects that distinguishes isospin-violating models from isospin-conserving ones is the need to reinterpret DM direct detection bounds, since they are typically derived under the assumption of isospin-conserving interactions Tovey:2000mm ; Zheng:2014nga ; Yaguna:2016bga ; Kelso:2017gib ; Yaguna:2019llp ; Cheek:2023zhv ; Kumar:2023lrj . The presence of isospin-violating interactions can either relax or make the bounds more stringent. One of the most studied isospin-violating scenarios is one that connects the DM sector to the SM through a Z^{\prime} coming from a \mathrm{U}(1) gauge extension. In this case, the Z^{\prime} couplings to up and down quarks can be different and, as a consequence, the DM particles interact differently with protons and neutrons. On the other hand, the presence of a \mathrm{U}(1) extension can also affect SM particles by introducing new interactions. In particular, neutrino interactions with quarks will be affected, and thus their scattering off nuclei. If neutrino interactions with nuclei get modified, then the neutrino floor region in the parameter space will be placed differently compared to the one predicted by SM interactions alone. In this work, we will study the phenomenology of a generic Z^{\prime} isospin-violating model that connects the DM sector to the SM. In particular, we will study how different amounts of isospin violation can relax or enhance direct detection bounds. Furthermore, we will also study the impact of such models on the neutrino sector and consequently on the neutrino floor. Taking into account both physical observables, we will study how the remaining background-free scenario for DM is affected by isospin-violating interactions. This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we introduce the isospin-violating DM framework that we will study. Then, the phenomenology of isospin-violating DM models in light of direct detection experiments is discussed in Sec. III . We present our results in Sec. IV for different scenarios, and we draw our conclusions in Sec. V . II Isospin-Violating Dark Matter Framework In order to study the phenomenology of isospin-violating dark matter interactions, we extend the SM with a simplified model that adds a fermionic DM candidate, \chi , with mass m_{\chi} ; and a spin-1 mediator, Z^{\prime} , with mass m_{Z^{\prime}} . The general Lagrangian term considered here can be read as \mathcal{L}\supset Z^{\prime}_{\mu}\sum_{f}\bar{f}\gamma^{\mu}(g_{V}^{f}+g_{A}^{f}\gamma_{5})f+Z^{\prime}_{\mu}\bar{\chi}\gamma^{\mu}(g_{V}^{\chi}+g_{A}^{\chi}\gamma_{5})\chi+\frac{1}{2}m_{Z^{\prime}}^{2}Z^{\prime}_{\mu}Z^{\prime\mu}+m_{\chi}\bar{\chi}\chi\,, (1) where g_{V,A} are vector and axial-vector couplings, respectively, and f runs over the SM fermions. The choice of this Lagrangian is motivated by the simplified DM models used in colliders Abdallah:2015ter ; DeSimone:2016fbz , although we are aware that it could develop problems in the ultraviolet (UV) regime Kahlhoefer:2015bea ; DEramo:2016gos ; Ismail:2016tod ; Ellis:2017tkh . Nonetheless, Eq. ( 1 ) can be considered an effective Lagrangian with a UV completion at some high scale, for example, with a Stückelberg mass realization for the Z^{\prime} (see, for instance, Ref. Lozano:2015vlv ). In the following, we set g_{A}^{\chi}=0 to avoid any problems with unitarity Kahlhoefer:2015bea . This choice, g_{A}^{\chi}=0 , avoids spin-dependent (SD) interactions, so we assume only spin-independent (SI) processes take place in the direct detection experiments. 1 1 1 If g_{A}^{\chi}\neq 0 is chosen, the number of events coming from SD processes also has to be considered when computing the total number of

Read the complete text