Conformal gravity as a deformed topological field theory
James A. Reid · 2025
Read Conformal gravity as a deformed topological field theory by James A. Reid (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-05683.txt.
Introduction
James Reid reformulates conformal gravity, a scale-free cousin of Einstein's theory, as a perturbed version of a theory with no local physics at all, in this 2025 paper. Topological field theories are mathematically tidy but describe worlds where nothing happens locally. A known trick deforms one into general relativity: bundle the geometry into a single connection, add a helper field, and the Einstein equations fall out.
Reid's move is to promote the theory's built-in length scale into a living field of its own, a cosmological scalar that can vary across spacetime. Varying the new action then yields the conformal Einstein equations instead. Through Cartan geometry he draws the contrast. In the conformal world, each point of spacetime is approximated by a uniform model space. Its size is set by that scalar field's local value, a geometry that breathes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | James A. Reid |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-05683
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Conformal gravity as a deformed topological field theory James A. Reid Abstract . In the MacDowell-Mansouri formulation of general relativity, the spin connection and coframe variables are incorporated into a single Lie algebra-valued connection called the MacDowell-Mansouri connection, ω \omega . From the curvature form F F of ω \omega and an auxiliary field, B B , one may formulate general relativity as a deformed topological field theory by constructing an action functional whose variation yields a set of field equations that are equivalent to the Einstein equations on shell. In this article, we show that when the fundamental length scale of the MacDowell-Mansouri connection is regarded as a dynamical variable - a cosmological scalar field - the field equations obtained from the variation of the resulting action are equivalent to the conformal Einstein equations on shell. Through the lens of Cartan geometry, we then discuss a notable geometrical difference between general relativity and its conformally transformed counterpart. Specifically, for the latter, we show that points in spacetime are infinitesimally approximated by homogeneous spaces (restricted to a point) whose radii are parameterised by the value of the cosmological scalar field. PACS numbers: 04.50.Kd, 04.20.-q, 02.40.-k. On the occasion of Sir Roger Penrose’s 94 th birthday. 1. Motivation In fundamental physics, no mathematical concept is arguably more important, or more far-reaching in its consequences, than that of the action functional. By varying an action functional, one obtains in a straightforward manner the field equations of the theory under consideration. It is little wonder then that the cover of the storied Encyclopedia of Mathematical Physics is emblazoned with the solitary, bold expression \delta\int\mathcal{L}=0, articulating with brevity its ubiquity in physical theories of nature. The importance of action functionals in general relativity is perhaps attested to by the multitude that have been constructed. Other than the Einstein-Hilbert, MacDowell-Mansouri and Palatini actions that we will discuss in this article, other examples include those constructed by Arnowitt-Deser-Misner [ 1 ] , Baierlein-Sharp-Wheeler [ 3 ] , Capovilla-Dell-Jacobson-Mason [ 6 ] , Goldberg [ 15 ] , Plebánski [ 21 ] and numerous others ( c.f. [ 4 ] for a large list). Similarly, there are almost as many action functionals for scalar-tensor theory: gravitational theories that incorporate in a fundamental way, a cosmological scalar field. In this article we will construct a deformed topological field theory action for conformally transformed general relativity, and show that the cosmological scalar field therein has a direct geometric interpretation in the context of Cartan geometry. Conformally transformed general relativity is commonly known as conformal gravity, or scale-invariant gravity [ 16 , 20 ] , and the familiar action functional from which the field equations are derived is called the conformal Einstein-Hilbert action [ 7 ] : (1) S_{\text{CEH}}:=\int_{M}\mathrm{d}^{4}x~\sqrt{-g}\Big(\phi^{2}\mathsf{scal}(\{~\})+6g^{ab}\partial_{a}\phi\partial_{b}\phi-2\Lambda\phi^{4}\Big), where M is a smooth 4-manifold with boundary, \phi the cosmological scalar field and \{~\} denotes the Christoffel symbol of the Levi-Čività connection. This action is so-called because it is the image of the conformal transformation g_{ab}\rightarrow e^{2\Upsilon}g_{ab} of the Einstein-Hilbert action with a cosmological constant: (2) S_{\text{EH}}=\int_{M}\mathrm{d}^{4}x~\sqrt{-g}\Big(\mathsf{scal}(\{~\})-2\Lambda\Big), where \phi=e^{\Upsilon} for \Upsilon a smooth function. Varying the conformal Einstein-Hilbert action, one obtains the (vacuum) conformal Einstein equations (3) \bigg\{\begin{array}[]{l}0=\phi^{2}\mathsf{G}_{ab}(\{~\})+4\partial_{a}\phi\partial_{b}\phi-g_{ab}\partial_{c}\phi\partial^{c}\phi-2\phi\left(\partial_{a}\partial_{b}-g_{ab}\square\right)\phi+g_{ab}\Lambda\phi^{4},\\ 0=2\phi\mathsf{scal}(\{~\})-12\square\phi-8\Lambda\phi^{3},\end{array} where (4) \mathsf{G}_{ab}(\{~\})=\mathsf{Ric}_{ab}(\{~\})-\frac{1}{2}\mathsf{scal}(\{~\})g_{ab} is the Einstein tensor (of the Levi-Čività connection). Conformal gravity is so-called because both the conformal Einstein-Hilbert action ( 1 ) and the conformal Einstein equations ( 3 ) are invariant with respect to the joint conformal transformations 1 1 1 In addition to these facts, one may additionally show that the vacuum conformal Einstein equations are the image of the conformal transformation of the vacuum Einstein equations. g_{ab}\rightarrow e^{2\Upsilon}g_{ab} and \phi\rightarrow e^{-\Upsilon}\phi . This fact was one of Dirac’s motivations for basing an alternative cosmology on conformal gravity: he believed that “basic [physical] laws should be invariant under the widest possible group of transformations” [ 7 ] . Another motivation for conformal gravity stems from canonical general relativity. It has been argued that the dynamical degrees of freedom of the gravitational field ought to be identified with conformal 3-geometries, which are to say, equivalence classes of conformal metrics upto diffeomorphism [ 25 ] . Consequently, the configuration space of general relativity should not be identified with superspace 2 2 2 The superspace [ 10 ] of a closed 3-manifold M is the orbit space \mathscr{S}(M):=\text{Riem}(M)/\text{Diff}(M) of the diffeomorphism group acting by coordinate transformation on the space of Riemannian metrics on M , \text{Riem}(M) . , but rather with conformal superspace: the space of Riemannian metrics modulo diffeomorphisms and conformal transformations ( c.f. [ 12 ] for a precise definition). The conformal Einstein-Hilbert action has been shown to decompose to a canonical gravity action describing a theory whose configuration space is precisely conformal superspace [ 16 ] . The conformal Einstein-Hilbert action has also been adopted by Mannheim as a conformally invariant matter action for his conformal cosmology [ 19 ] . Our construction of an action for conformal gravity however, is motivated by providing a geometrical description for the scalar field \phi . Indeed, one of the proposed criticisms of scalar-tensor theories of gravity in general is that the cosmological scalar field does not have a geometrical origin [ 9 ] . In the early 1950’s, Lyra addressed this pathology by formulating scalar-tensor gravity on (the now eponymous) Lyra manifolds [ 17 ] . A Lyra manifold is a triple (M,g,\psi) consisting of an n -dimensional manifold M with semi-Riemannian metric g and a scalar field \psi called the gauge function. Lyra’s connection coefficients take the form [ 9 ] (5) \Gamma^{c}_{\phantom{c}ab}=\frac{1}{\psi}\left\{\begin{array}[]{c}c\\ a~~~b\end{array}\right\}+\frac{s+1}{\psi^{2}}g^{cd}\left(g_{bd}\partial_{a}\psi-g_{ab}\partial_{d}\psi\right), where s is a constant related to the torsion of Lyra’s connection. The action for the 4-dimensional Lorentzian theory, (6) S_{\text{Lyra}}=\int_{M}\mathrm{d}^{4}x~\sqrt{-g}~\psi^{4}\mathsf{K}, with \mathsf{K} the Lyra scalar curvature [ 22 ] (7) \mathsf{K}=\frac{\mathsf{scal}}{\psi^{2}}+\frac{2(s+1)}{\psi^{3}}(1-n)\square\psi+\frac{1}{\psi^{4}}\Big[(s+1)^{2}\left(3n-n^{2}-2\right)-(s+1)(2-2n)\Big]\partial_{a}\psi\partial^{a}\psi, has been shown to be equivalent to the scalar-tensor theory given by the action (8) S=\int_{M}\mathrm{d}^{4}x~\sqrt{-g}~\left(\psi^{2}\mathsf{scal}-4\omega g^{ab}\partial_{a}\psi\partial_{b}\psi\right) in n=4 dimensions, where the coupling constant \omega is related to the torsional constant s according to \omega=3(s^{2}-1)/2 . Other formulations of scalar-tensor gravity in which the scalar field has a geometrical interpretation include Kaluza-Klein theory and bosonic string theory. In the former, the scalar field is the determinant of the metric on the d extra spatial dimensions and in the latter, the scalar field is the dimensionless string dilaton in the low energy action in the string frame [ 9 ] . 2. MacDowell-Mansouri Gravity and Deformed BF Theory To preface our exposition, we begin by recalling the MacDowell-Mansouri formulation of general relativity. Consider a four-dimensional Lorentzian (respectively Riemannian) manifold with boundary (M,g) and let Latin letters from the middle of the alphabet, i,\ldots,j\in\{0,\ldots,3\}\subset\mathbb{Z}^{+} , denote Minkowskian (Euclidean) internal indices ( c.f. [ 24 ] ), corresponding to the structure group SO(1,3) ( SO(4) ) of the orthonormal frame bundle. Similarly, let Latin letters from the beginning of the alphabet, a,\ldots,b\in\{0,\ldots,3\}\subset\mathbb{Z}^{+} , denote the usual spacetime indices. The key feature of the MacDowell-Mansouri formulation of general relativity is the incorporation of both the coframe e^{i} and general spin connection A^{ij} variables into a single Lie algebra-valued Cartan connection \omega called the MacDowell-Mansouri connection [ 24 ] , (9) \omega=A+\frac{1}{l}e. The Lie algebra \mathfrak{g} , in which \omega takes values, is called the MacDowell-Mansouri gauge