Common principles behind rainbows and boat wakes

Eduardo A. Jagla, Alberto G. Rojo · 2025

Read Common principles behind rainbows and boat wakes by Eduardo A. Jagla, Alberto G. Rojo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-05644.txt.

Introduction

Eduardo Jagla and Alberto Rojo draw one math thread through rainbows and boat wakes in this 2025 paper. The two sights seem unrelated at first glance. Both, though, arise when rays fold and pile up along bright lines.

The shared ideas are caustics and Airy interference patterns. The same frame explains shimmer on pool floors and the twinkle of stars. The authors revisit Airy's classic work on wavefronts and bright edges. They extend it from light and water waves to quantum wave packets. Only undergraduate physics is needed to follow the thread. Teachers will find a rich set of linked examples in one short treatment.

Catalog record

CREATOREduardo A. Jagla, Alberto G. Rojo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-05644

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Common principles behind rainbows and boat wakes Eduardo A. Jagla, Alberto G. Rojo Abstract Rainbows and boat wakes may seem unrelated, but they share deep mathematical connections through ray folding, caustics, and Airy interference. This paper explores these principles, which are also relevant for explaining phenomena such as shimmering effects on the bottom of pools and twinkling stars. By revisiting Airy’s theories on wavefronts and caustics, we demonstrate their applications not only in optics and for water waves but also in quantum wave packets. Using concepts from undergraduate physics, we highlight the universal patterns that unify these diverse phenomena. “Caminante no hay camino, sino estelas en la mar.” ( Traveler, there is no road; only a ship’s wake on the sea ) Antonio Machado Machado “Why are there so many songs about rainbows And what’s on the other side” Paul Williams Williams I Introduction Rainbows and boat wakes are two examples of wave phenomena, the first related to electromagnetism and the second involving gravity waves on a liquid surface. Despite this shared property, the two phenomena may seem unrelated at first glance. However, a deep mathematical and physical relation exists between them. Although the physics of rainbows and boat wakes is well understood individually Crawford0 ; Boyer , the pedagogical value of this work lies in emphasizing the unifying principles that connect them. These principles include ray folding, caustics, and Airy interference, which also play a central role in other everyday phenomena, such as the shimmering patterns that can be observed on the bottom of a swimming pool, the twinkling of stars, and the reflections of light inside a cup of tea. The modern theory of the rainbow is due to George Biddle Airy Airy , who improved upon the Cartesian-Newtonian ray optics theory. Specifically, ray optics failed to explain how the water droplet size influences the colors of the bow and could not account for the supernumerary arcs, the additional, fainter arcs separated by darker regions that appear inside the main rainbow (Fig. 1 ). This phenomenon was documented as early as the 13th century Boyer . Two important concepts were central to Airy’s treatment: the Huygens concept of wavefronts, and the mathematical concept of caustic surfaces—the envelope of a family of reflected or refracted light rays Eckman . A common example of a caustic curve, a plane section of a caustic surface, are the bright arcs on the bottom of a swimming pool formed by light rays refracted at the surface. Applying these concepts to rainbows, Airy derived an analytical expression for the light intensity at each point of the bow and showed that the brightest region lies at a radius smaller than what geometrical optics predicts. In this paper, we will show using undergraduate-level concepts that Airy’s treatment of caustics can also successfully apply to boat wakes and quantum wave packets, revealing a universal principle that underpins both phenomena. Figure 1: (Color online) Supernumerary arcs generated on a sunny day from drops produced by a flower mister. Photograph by one of the authors (A.G.R.) II Caustics from cubic wavefronts. In the context of geometric optics, caustics are the envelopes of a family of rays along which light propagates. The detailed analysis of caustics goes back to the studies of burning mirrors and lenses in the Middle Ages. Astronomer and musician Francesco Maurolico (1494–1575) noted that, due to spherical aberration, light rays hitting a spherical mirror do not converge at a single focal point, but rather on a surface MarkSmith . The caustic surface is the surface to which the light rays are tangent. In this section we will discuss the main properties of caustics with a simple generic example using light rays which is applicable to the three physical realizations presented in the rest of the paper. Let us consider a two-dimensional curve defining a starting wavefront. Rays emerge perpendicularly at every point of the wavefront, and they converge or diverge depending on the wavefront concavity. Points of constant optic length along the rays define the time evolution of the wavefront. We consider a situation in which the starting wavefront generates a combination of convergent and divergent rays. In other words the starting wavefront has an inflection point. We will now show how this wavefront gives rise to a caustic line. The simplest continuous curve that exhibits this behavior is a cubic wavefront, which happens to arise naturally in the physical phenomena discussed in this paper. It is also the generic form of a smooth curve sufficiently close to an inflection point. We show an example of such a wavefront in Fig. 2 (a). Note that when the wave has propagated sufficiently far away from the initial cubic line, the wavefronts “fold”, giving rise to two divergent wavefronts of equal optical paths (Fig. 2 (b), dash-dotted lines), that meet at the caustic line (dashed line). The folded wavefront also means that, for any direction emerging from the wavefront, two parallel rays exist, as illustrated with the rays a and a^{\prime} in Fig. 2 (a). Near the inflection point, the starting wavefront can be described with the equation y=-x^{3}/3d^{2} , with d a scale factor (see Figure 3(a)). Equivalently, in parametric form we have: \mathbf{x}(x)=\left(x,-\frac{x^{3}}{3d^{2}}\right). (1) The unit normals \hat{\mathbf{n}}\equiv(n_{x},n_{y})=(\sin\alpha,\cos\alpha) to the curve \mathbf{x}(x) correspond to the directions of the light rays. The angle \alpha of the normal with the vertical is given by: \alpha\simeq\tan\alpha=\frac{n_{x}}{n_{y}}=\left({x\over d}\right)^{2}. (2) Figure 2: (a) : Rays normal to a cubic wavefront parametrized as \mathbf{x}=(x,-x^{3}/(3d^{2})) . Rays a and a^{\prime} , originating at \mathbf{x} and -\mathbf{x} , are parallel and differ in path length by 2\mathbf{x}\cdot\hat{\mathbf{n}} , where \hat{\mathbf{n}} is the normal to the wavefront at \mathbf{x} . Ray a belongs to a “fold”: it is part of a beam of rays that are initially convergent and then become divergent upon propagation. (b) : Wavefronts propagating from the initial wavefront shown in panel (a). The structure of these wavefronts, particularly the “fold” (giving rise to two superimposed divergent fronts (dotted)) and the caustic line (dashed), is similar to the one observed in the case of raindrops (Fig. 3 b). Considering the situation in which rays impact a very distant screen (or are observed by a distant eye), the coordinate on the screen is simply proportional to \alpha . Disregarding interference among rays, the intensity observed for each direction \alpha is given by the density I(\alpha) of rays as a function of \alpha . The quadratic dependence of \alpha on x (for small x ) of Eq. 2 shows no solutions for \alpha<0 ; in other words, no rays will emerge with \alpha<0 , meaning that the intensity is zero for negative angles. If we consider the number of rays per unit length of the wavefront I_{0} as uniform, the number of rays dN incident in an interval dx is I_{0}\sqrt{1+\alpha^{2}}dx . These rays emerge in the interval (\alpha,\alpha+d\alpha) : dN=I(\alpha)d\alpha , with I(\alpha) the density of rays per unit angle. Using Equation ( 2 ) we obtain, for small \alpha I(\alpha)=I_{0}\sqrt{1+\alpha\texttwosuperior}{dx\over d\alpha}\simeq\frac{I_{0}d}{2\alpha^{1/2}}. (3) The above expression shows a divergent accumulation of rays at the angular position of the caustic: \alpha\to 0^{+} . In the next section we will see how the previous generic

Read the complete text