Gradient and Hessian-Based Temperature Estimator in Lattice Gauge Theories: A Diagnostic Tool for Stability and Consistency in Numerical Simulations
Navdeep Singh Dhindsa, Anosh Joseph, Vamika Longia · 2025
Read Gradient and Hessian-Based Temperature Estimator in Lattice Gauge Theories: A Diagnostic Tool for Stability and Consistency in Numerical Simulations by Navdeep Singh Dhindsa, Anosh Joseph, Vamika Longia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-05595.txt.
Introduction
Navdeep Singh Dhindsa, Anosh Joseph, and Vamika Longia build a thermometer for lattice gauge simulations from the shape of the action itself, in a 2025 paper. Lattice simulations sample field configurations to study gauge theories, the math behind forces between particles. Standard temperature comes from the lattice's time size, with no independent cross-check.
Their estimator reads the gradient and curvature of the Euclidean action at each sampled configuration. The idea borrows from geometric formulas for entropy in classical mechanics, and the result does not depend on gauge choices. Tests on a compact U(1) theory in one, two, and four dimensions matched the set temperature closely. The match held across volumes and coupling strengths. The authors offer the estimator as a general diagnostic for simulation health. Uses could include non-Abelian theories and live monitoring during hybrid Monte Carlo runs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Navdeep Singh Dhindsa, Anosh Joseph, Vamika Longia |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-05595
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gradient and Hessian-Based Temperature Estimator in Lattice Gauge Theories: A Diagnostic Tool for Stability and Consistency in Numerical Simulations Navdeep Singh Dhindsa, Anosh Joseph, Vamika Longia Abstract We present a field configuration-based temperature estimator in lattice gauge theories. It is constructed from the gradient and Hessian of the Euclidean action of the theory. Adapted from geometric formulations of entropy in classical statistical mechanics, this estimator provides a gauge-invariant, non-kinetic diagnostic of thermodynamic consistency in Monte Carlo simulations of lattice gauge theories. We validate the method in compact U(1) lattice gauge theories across one, two, and four dimensions, comparing the estimated temperature to the input temperature. Our results show that the estimator accurately reproduces the input temperature and remains robust across a range of lattice volumes and coupling strengths. The temperature estimator offers a general-purpose diagnostic for lattice field theory simulations, with potential applications to non-Abelian theories, anisotropic lattices, and real-time monitoring in hybrid Monte Carlo algorithms. I Introduction In molecular dynamics simulations, we can use conserved quantities such as energy and momentum as effective indicators of algorithmic correctness. Although the conservation of these quantities does not guarantee a simulation’s validity, violations typically signal programming or numerical errors, which are often easy to detect. In contrast, canonical Monte Carlo simulations lack straightforward conservation laws that can be used for validation. In particular, there has traditionally been no method for directly computing the thermodynamic temperature using only the field configurational data. As a result, algorithm validation in the canonical ensemble relies largely on comparison with known thermodynamic properties. This approach can become problematic when studying novel systems or exploring state points for which no reference data exist. A significant advance in this area was the work of Rugh, who derived an expression for temperature based on a geometric analysis of phase space within the microcanonical ensemble Rugh 1997 . His formulation relates the temperature to the curvature of the constant-energy hypersurface and offers a purely dynamical definition grounded in the phase space structure. Building on Rugh’s insight, Butler et al. proposed a configurational definition of temperature applicable to canonical ensembles Butler et al. 1998 . This expression requires only configurational information, namely, gradients and curvatures of the potential energy or action, and is therefore ideally suited to Monte Carlo simulations, which do not sample momenta. Interestingly, this type of definition, based on mean-square forces, was not entirely new: related ideas can be traced back to earlier works, including the 1952 Russian-language edition of Statistical Physics by Landau and Lifshitz Landau and Lifshitz 1952 , and even more indirectly to Tolman’s 1938 textbook The Principles of Statistical Mechanics , which discusses generalized equipartition without explicitly formulating the concept Tolman 1979 . A later historical account by Hoover also notes this lineage Hoover and Hoover 2007 . In Ref. Jepps et al. 2000 , the authors demonstrate that arbitrary phase-space vector fields can be used to construct phase functions whose ensemble averages yield the thermodynamic temperature. They establish conditions under which these functions are valid in systems with periodic boundaries and within the molecular dynamics (MD) ensemble, supporting their results with simulations involving short-ranged potentials. In Ref. Butler et al. 1998 , the configurational temperature is shown, via Lennard-Jones simulations, to respond rapidly and accurately to changes in the input temperature, even when the system deviates from global thermodynamic equilibrium. A numerical test of the temperature estimator in the canonical ensemble is presented in Ref. Palma et al. 2016 , where the authors simulate the two-dimensional XY model using a generalized Wolff cluster algorithm. Broader discussions and generalizations of the underlying theoretical framework can be found in Refs. Rugh 1998 ; Jepps et al. 2000 ; Rickayzen and Powles 2001 , while further applications and validation in MD simulations are provided in Refs. Butler et al. 1998 ; Baranyai 2000 . Although the configurational temperature was initially proposed as a tool for thermostat design and system control in numerical simulations, Butler et al. emphasized its practical value as a diagnostic. They demonstrated its utility in detecting sampling inconsistencies and numerical errors in Monte Carlo simulations. In modern simulations, the configurational temperature can provide a means of assessing thermodynamic consistency independently of the microscopic momentum variables associated with kinetic definitions of the temperature. Understanding thermodynamic properties in lattice field theory simulations requires precise control over temperature. In such simulations, the physical temperature is typically introduced through the temporal lattice extent or inverse coupling. However, discretization artifacts can lead to significant deviations in physical observables, such as a shift in the transition temperature at finite lattice spacing. These effects vanish only in the continuum limit; thus, verifying that the simulation temperature matches the intended physical temperature is a nontrivial task. The microscopic temperature estimator offers a nontrivial and gauge-invariant way to verify whether a system is truly sampling from the expected thermal distribution. It is especially useful in lattice gauge theories where discretization and algorithmic artifacts can shift critical temperatures or other thermodynamic properties. Using this estimator, we can independently measure the temperature and compare it with the input parameter to diagnose such issues. The structure of the paper is as follows. In Section II , we introduce the concept of a microscopic temperature estimator, based on Refs. Rugh 1997 ; Butler et al. 1998 , and outline its theoretical basis and practical motivation. This section sets the stage for using the estimator as a diagnostic tool in equilibrium simulations. In Section III , we apply the estimator to compact U(1) lattice gauge theories in various dimensions, where analytic or high-precision numerical results are available. We explore how the measured temperature compares to the input temperature. Finally, in Section IV , we summarize our findings and discuss possible extensions of this approach to more complex theories. II Temperature Estimator This section outlines the construction of the microscopic temperature estimator entirely from the sampled field configurations. In Hybrid Monte Carlo (HMC) simulations, where the momenta are auxiliary, this estimator can provide a nontrivial check on thermodynamic consistency. II.1 Derivation of the temperature estimator From elementary thermodynamics, we have the first law expressed as dE=TdS-pdV. (1) For an isochoric transformation, the rate of change of entropy with an increase in energy determines the inverse temperature: \frac{1}{T}=\left(\frac{\partial S}{\partial E}\right)_{V}. (2) Let \vec{\Gamma} denote a point in phase space, comprising all position and momentum coordinates of the system \vec{\Gamma}\equiv\left(q_{1},q_{2},\ldots,q_{N};p_{1},p_{2},\ldots,p_{N}\right), (3) where q_{i} and p_{i} represent the position and momentum of the i -th particle, respectively. We define a microcanonical ensemble corresponding to a Hamiltonian H(\vec{\Gamma}) as the set of phase space points for which the total energy lies within a narrow interval [E,E+\Delta E] , with \Delta E\ll E . Under the assumption of equal a priori probabilities, the entropy associated with this ensemble is proportional to the volume of this energy shell in phase space: \displaystyle S(E) \displaystyle=k_{B}\ln\Omega_{\Gamma}(E,N,V) \displaystyle=k_{B}\ln\left(\int_{\mu C(E)}d\vec{\Gamma}\right), (4) where \mu C(E) denotes the microcanonical shell, defined as the set of all \vec{\Gamma} satisfying E\leq H(\vec{\Gamma})\leq E+\Delta E . To compute the derivative \partial S/\partial E , we examine how this phase-space volume changes under an infinitesimal shift in energy. Specifically, we introduce a displacement of each phase space point along a vector field \vec{n}(\vec{\Gamma}) that is