Vertex corrections and wavefunction renormalization for atoms, nuclei, and other heavy composite particles

Ryan Plestid, Mark B. Wise · 2025

Read Vertex corrections and wavefunction renormalization for atoms, nuclei, and other heavy composite particles by Ryan Plestid, Mark B. Wise (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-05540.txt.

Introduction

Ryan Plestid and Mark Wise set out the fine print of radiation fixes for heavy built-up particles like atoms and nuclei. Such fixes tweak how operators act on those particles, and sloppy books can spoil the sums. Their 2025 work sorts graphs into kinds that fit systems with many rungs of energy states.

The pair show two classic ways to count agree, step by step. Self-energy and vertex fixes get clean all-order forms, and one-loop sums shrink to parts that hands-on teams can run. Gauge drift, a known trap, cancels in a class of gauges. A beta decay case links the frame to old current algebra work. A known two-loop fix also falls out of the frame.

Catalog record

CREATORRyan Plestid, Mark B. Wise
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE84 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-05540

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Vertex corrections and wavefunction renormalization for atoms, nuclei, and other heavy composite particles Preprint: CALT-TH/2025-025 Ryan Plestid, Mark B. Wise Abstract We study one-loop QED corrections to operator matrix elements involving heavy composite particles (e.g., heavy-mesons, nuclei, and atoms). We define a new notion of reducible and irreducible graphs which is useful for systems with many discrete excited states. The equivalence of the LSZ reduction formula and old fashioned perturbation theory is explicitly demonstrated. The self energy and vertex corrections are defined (to all orders), and the one-loop corrections are reduced to operator matrix elements which may be evaluated by hadronic, nuclear, or atomic theorists. The gauge dependence of the various pieces are studied in detail, and cancellation of spurious contributions are demonstrated in a class of covariant gauges; Coulomb gauge is also discussed. The formalism is applied to superallowed beta decay where we identify a number of effects that arise at one loop that are, to the best of our knowledge, not included in current extractions of | V u ​ d | |V_{ud}| . In particular we find an electromagnetic isospin breaking correction at O ⁡ ( α ) O(\alpha) in addition to the well known O ⁡ ( Z 2 ​ α 2 ) O(Z^{2}\alpha^{2}) corrections from the intranuclear Coulomb field. {fmffile} fmfnotes I Introduction There is a growing interest in high precision measurements of processes involving atoms, nuclei, and heavy hadrons Afanasev et al. 2024 ; Hardy and Towner 2020 ; Zwicky 2021 ; Tomalak et al. 2022a ; Pastore et al. 2009 ; Cornella et al. 2023 ; Adhikari et al. 2021 ; Hill and Plestid 2024a ; Seng and Gorchtein 2023 ; Cirigliano et al. 2024 ; Plestid and Wise 2024a ; Beneke et al. 2018 ; Tomalak et al. 2021 ; Combes et al. 2024 ; Cirigliano et al. 2023 ; Seng and Gorchtein 2024 ; Baroni et al. 2021 ; Hill and Paz 2017 ; Pastore et al. 2008 ; Vander Griend et al. 2025 ; Seng et al. 2025 ; Lovato et al. 2020 ; Plestid and Wise 2024b ; Cirigliano et al. 2018 ; Richardson and Reis 2024 ; Gennari et al. 2025 ; Epelbaum et al. 2020 ; Seng and Gorchtein 2023 ; Cirigliano et al. 2024 ; Cirigliano et al. 2022 ; Tomalak et al. 2022b ; Cirigliano et al. 2025 ; Hill and Plestid 2024b ; Rocco 2020 ; Abbiendi et al. 2017 ; Pastore et al. 2011 ; Hill and Paz 2010 ; Borah et al. 2024 ; Adhikari et al. 2022 ; Ruso et al. 2025 ; Richardson and Reis 2025 . For precision targets of \sim 1\% or better, an understanding of quantum electrodynamic (QED) corrections at least through one-loop order is required. Analysis of these systems are complicated by the complexity of the bound-state dynamics, despite their underlying constituents being relatively well understood. As a concrete example, in leptonic reactions involving nuclei, existing analyses often restrict themselves to leptonic corrections and so-called “box diagrams” in which a photon is exchanged between a charged lepton and the hadronic system. For neutral current reactions, these topologies are separately gauge invariant, as are the (often neglected) nuclear vertex corrections. Nevertheless a complete analysis through O(\alpha) (with \alpha the fine structure constant) demands the inclusion of the corrections to the nuclear vertex, and it is desirable to have a formalism that both properly defines this object, and facilitates realistic calculations given nuclear wavefunctions for the initial and final state.​ 1 1 1 See Ref. Preparata and Weisberger 1968 ; Sirlin 1978 for a discussion of some of these issues in the language of current algebra. For charged current reactions, such as neutrino nucleus scattering or beta decay, the problem of the nuclear vertex correction is more pressing. Because the charge of the initial and final nucleus differ, the leptonic, box, and nuclear vertex corrections will all in general carry gauge dependence. Therefore, in order to ensure gauge invariance of the amplitude, the gauge dependencies of the various pieces must be properly understood. In this paper we study the construction of the Lehman-Symanzik-Zimmerman (LSZ) reduction formula Lehmann et al. 1955 for bound states composed of electrically charged constituents. The resulting perturbation theory can be expressed entirely in terms of nuclear matrix elements taken between the initial state \ket{A} and the final state \ket{B} defined in the absence of electromagnetism. The results can also be derived using time-independent perturbation theory. Next the gauge dependence of the vertex correction is studied in covariant gauges, and a comparison is made with a calculation in Coulomb gauge. We then apply our results to the theory of beta decay, and note a number of interesting results, some of which we believe to be missing in current analyses of radiative corrections. We finally summarize our results and present an outlook for future work. II Structure of the LSZ reduction formula Let us review the standard LSZ construction Lehmann et al. 1955 ; Weinberg 2005 . Consider the matrix element of an arbitrary operator, \mathcal{O} , between single particle states A and B . We denote exact eigenstates of the full theory 2 2 2 Our notation is taken from Refs. Miller and Schwenk 2008 ; Miller and Schwenk 2009 , but follows an opposite convention where |A) is the fully interacting state. We find this choice convenient since we work in perturbation theory and mostly use \ket{A} . by |A) and |B) , \mathcal{M}=(B(p^{\prime})|\mathcal{O}|A(p))~. (1) Let us suppose we have interpolating operators \psi_{A}^{\dagger} and \psi_{B}^{\dagger} which satisfy \displaystyle(A(p)|\psi_{A}^{\dagger}|\Omega) \displaystyle=\sqrt{Z_{A}}\xi_{A}^{\dagger}(p)~,~ (2) \displaystyle(B(p)|\psi_{B}^{\dagger}|\Omega) \displaystyle=\sqrt{Z_{B}}\xi_{B}^{\dagger}(p)~, (3) where |\Omega) is the full interacting vacuum, Z_{A,B} are real numbers, and \xi_{A,B} are external wavefunctions which transform appropriately under the Lorentz group (e.g., Dirac spinor wavefunctions for spin- 1/2 particles). Operators at a position x are defined by acting with the generator of translations P , which gives, \psi_{A,B}(x)=\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}P\cdot x}\psi_{A,B}\mathrm{e}^{-\mathrm{i}P\cdot x} . The LSZ reduction formula then tells us that \begin{split}\mathcal{M}=\lim_{p_{0}^{\prime}\rightarrow E_{B}}\lim_{p_{0}\rightarrow E_{A}}\int&\differential^{4}x\int\differential^{4}y~~\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}p^{\prime}\cdot x}\mathrm{e}^{-\mathrm{i}p\cdot y}\\ &\times Z_{B}^{-1/2}\xi_{B}^{\dagger}(p^{\prime})\overset{\rightarrow}{\mathcal{D}_{x}}(\Omega|T\{\psi_{B}(x)\psi_{A}^{\dagger}(y)\mathcal{O}(0)\}|\Omega)\overset{\leftarrow}{\mathcal{D}_{y}}\xi_{A}(p)Z_{A}^{-1/2}~,\end{split} (4) where \mathcal{D}_{x} is the appropriate differential operator for particle B (as dictated by its spin) and likewise for \mathcal{D}_{y} and particle A . Accounting for factors of Z_{A} and Z_{B} from the residues on the external legs, this may be conveniently summarized by \mathcal{M}=\sqrt{Z_{A}}\sqrt{Z_{B}}\times\quantity[\xi_B^\dagger(p')~ G_{\rm amp.}(p',p) ~\xi_A(p)]~, (5) where G_{\rm amp}(p^{\prime},p) is the amputated Greens function evaluated at on-shell kinematics for a particle A transitioning to another particle B as mediated by the operator \mathcal{O} . II.1 Perturbative expansion For conceptual simplicity let us consider nuclei, which are bound in the absence of electromagnetism. In the limit that the electromagnetic coupling constant tends to zero, e\rightarrow 0 , the system is described by the strong interaction H_{S} . Neglecting the target recoil kinetic energy (we will always assume the bound state is heavy enough that this is a good approximation) the full Hamiltonian is then H_{\rm full}=H_{S}+H_{\gamma}+H_{\rm int}~, (6) where H_{\rm\gamma} is the free photon Hamiltonian, and H_{\rm int} contains all interactions between the constituent nucleons and photons i.e., the current operators. Next, define a modified interaction picture, where H_{\rm int} is treated as the interaction Hamiltonian, and H_{S} is treated as the zeroth order Hamiltonian. Let us illustrate how this picture

Read the complete text