The Docking Game: Loop Self-Play for Fast, Dynamic, and Accurate Prediction of Flexible Protein–Ligand Binding
Youzhi Zhang, Yufei Li, Gaofeng Meng, Hongbin Liu, Jiebo Luo · 2025
Read The Docking Game: Loop Self-Play for Fast, Dynamic, and Accurate Prediction of Flexible Protein–Ligand Binding by Youzhi Zhang, Yufei Li, Gaofeng Meng, Hongbin Liu, Jiebo Luo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-05006.txt.
Introduction
Youzhi Zhang and co-authors frame molecular docking as a two-player game in work from 2025. Docking predicts how a small drug molecule fits a protein pocket, a key step in drug discovery, but joint models dock ligands worse than pockets.
In their game, a ligand module and a pocket module act as rival players that exchange predicted poses. An outer loop lets each adapt to the other, while an inner loop refines each module on its own predictions. Theory shows the training converges. On public benchmarks, accurate binding modes rose by about ten percent over prior best methods.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Youzhi Zhang, Yufei Li, Gaofeng Meng, Hongbin Liu, Jiebo Luo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-05006
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Docking Game: Loop Self-Play for Fast, Dynamic, and Accurate Prediction of Flexible Protein–Ligand Binding Youzhi Zhang, Yufei Li, Gaofeng Meng, Hongbin Liu, Jiebo Luo Abstract . Molecular docking is a crucial aspect of drug discovery, as it predicts the binding interactions between small-molecule ligands and protein pockets. However, current multi-task learning models for docking often show inferior performance in ligand docking compared to protein pocket docking. This disparity arises largely due to the distinct structural complexities of ligands and proteins. To address this issue, we propose a novel game-theoretic framework that models the protein-ligand interaction as a two-player game called the Docking Game , with the ligand docking module acting as the ligand player and the protein pocket docking module as the protein player. To solve this game, we develop a novel Loop Self-Play ( LoopPlay ) algorithm, which alternately trains these players through a two-level loop. In the outer loop, the players exchange predicted poses, allowing each to incorporate the other’s structural predictions, which fosters mutual adaptation over multiple iterations. In the inner loop, each player dynamically refines its predictions by incorporating its own predicted ligand or pocket poses back into its model. We theoretically show the convergence of LoopPlay, ensuring stable optimization. Extensive experiments conducted on public benchmark datasets demonstrate that LoopPlay achieves approximately a 10% improvement in predicting accurate binding modes compared to previous state-of-the-art methods. This highlights its potential to enhance the accuracy of molecular docking in drug discovery. 1. Introduction Small molecules—organic compounds with low molecular weight—are the primary therapeutic agents in the pharmaceutical industry ( Zhang2023 ) . These compounds exert their effects by binding to target proteins and modulating molecular pathways associated with diseases. Understanding the structural details of protein-ligand interactions is crucial for determining drug potency, mechanisms of action, and potential side effects. Despite significant efforts to elucidate the structures of protein-ligand complexes, the Protein Data Bank (PDB) ( berman2000protein ) contains only a small fraction of the possible configurations. This scarcity is particularly striking when considering the immense combinatorial space of potential interactions, which includes over 10^{60} drug-like molecules ( hert2009quantifying ; luttens2025rapid ) and at least 20,000 human proteins ( uniprot2019uniprot ) . This gap highlights the urgent need for reliable protein-ligand docking methods ( Zhang2023 ) . Molecular docking is a fundamental aspect of drug discovery, focused on predicting the binding structures of protein-ligand complexes ( Morris1996 ; agarwal2016overview ) . This helps us understand how small drug-like molecules, known as ligands, interact with target proteins ( Morris1996 ; agarwal2016overview ) . Traditional methods, based on principles from physics and chemistry, often come with high computational costs ( Friesner2004 ; Trott2010 ; McNutt2021 ) . However, the emergence of deep learning-based docking methods ( Corso2023 ; Zhang2023 ; Pei2023 ; gao2025fabind+ ; zhang2025fast ) has brought about a significant shift, allowing for faster and more accurate predictions of docked protein-ligand poses. Many of these new methods ( Lu2022 ; Zhang2023 ; Stark2022 ; Pei2023 ; gao2025fabind+ ; Corso2023 ; zhou2023unimol ) operate under the rigid docking paradigm, which assumes that proteins remain static during the docking process. This assumption does not align with the dynamic and flexible nature of proteins in physiological conditions ( HenzlerWildman2007 ; Lane2023 ) , thus limiting the practical applicability of these approaches. Consequently, it is crucial to develop flexible docking methods that better account for realistic protein dynamics ( Sahu2024 ) . Recent flexible docking methods ( Lu2024 ; Huang2024 ; zhang2024packdock ; Qiao2024 ) primarily utilize diffusion models and sampling strategies ( Yang2023 ) because of their strong ability to model complex distributions. However, the iterative nature of the diffusion process and the extensive sampling can decrease computational efficiency ( zhang2025fast ) . On the other hand, regression-based methods ( Lu2022 ; Zhang2023 ; Stark2022 ; Pei2023 ) provide faster predictions by directly estimating the bound structures of protein-ligand complexes using specialized neural networks. The regression-based FABind series ( Pei2023 ; gao2025fabind+ ) aims to strike a balance between docking accuracy and computational efficiency through an end-to-end multitask model. This model integrates pocket prediction and docking prediction, thereby eliminating the need for a separate external module for pocket selection. FABFlex ( zhang2025fast ) extends the FABind series to flexible docking scenarios by incorporating a pocket docking prediction module. However, the regression-based multi-task framework for protein-ligand docking, as demonstrated by FABFlex ( zhang2025fast ) , shows a significant weakness in its ligand docking performance compared to protein pocket docking. This discrepancy arises primarily due to the differing properties of ligands and protein pockets. Although FABFlex employs separate modules for ligand docking (predicting ligand holo structures from apo states) and protein pocket docking (forecasting holo conformations of protein pockets), the joint training through a multi-task learning model leads to suboptimal outcomes for ligand docking. The average Root Mean Square Deviation (RMSD) for ligand docking is 5.44, while that for pocket docking is only 1.1. This performance gap is likely a result of the substantial differences in structural complexity between the two tasks. For instance, protein pockets typically have many more nodes than ligands, with pockets like the one in PDB 3ZZF containing 144 nodes compared to just 13 for ligands in the same structure. These differences can lead the model to prioritize the more complex pocket docking task, resulting in inadequate optimization for the ligand docking module. Figure 1 . The Docking Game : given apo ligand and protein structures, the ligand player first identifies the protein pocket location and repositions the ligand from the protein’s center to the pocket’s center, forming an unbound protein pocket–ligand complex. Subsequently, the ligand player and protein player independently predict the holo ligand pose and holo protein pocket pose, respectively, to construct the bound protein pocket–ligand complex. To enhance protein-ligand docking performance, we propose a novel game-theoretic framework that models the interaction between end-to-end ligand docking pose prediction and protein pocket docking pose prediction as a two-player game called the Docking Game , with the ligand docking module as the ligand player and the protein pocket docking module as the protein player . Drawing inspiration from the FABind series ( Pei2023 ; gao2025fabind+ ; zhang2025fast ) , the ligand player incorporates an integrated pocket prediction module to eliminate the need for an external pocket selection step. In our game-theoretic approach to blind flexible protein-ligand docking, given apo ligand and protein structures, the ligand player first identifies the protein pocket location and repositions the ligand from the protein’s center to the pocket’s center, forming an unbound protein pocket–ligand complex. Subsequently, the ligand player and protein player independently predict the holo ligand pose and holo protein pocket pose, respectively, to construct the bound protein pocket–ligand complex, as illustrated in Figure 1 . To solve this game, we develop a novel Loop Self-Play ( LoopPlay ) algorithm to alternately train these two models. In LoopPlay, each player model undergoes training through a two-level loop. In the outer loop, the ligand and protein players exchange predicted poses to incorporate the opponent’s structural insights, fostering mutual adaptation over multiple iterations. In the inner loop, each player dynamically refines its predictions by iteratively feeding its own predicted ligand or pocket poses back into its