Magnetic shear effects on ballooning turbulence in the boundary of fusion devices

Z. Tecchiolli, A. J. Coelho, J. Loizu, B. De Lucca, P. Ricci · 2025

Read Magnetic shear effects on ballooning turbulence in the boundary of fusion devices by Z. Tecchiolli, A. J. Coelho, J. Loizu, B. De Lucca, P. Ricci (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-04881.txt.

Introduction

Tecchiolli and co-authors simulated edge turbulence in fusion devices in two thousand twenty-five. The plasma edge sets how heat escapes a tokamak. Ballooning modes drive much of that turbulence. Magnetic shear shapes the eddies those modes form. The team ran global three-dimensional simulations. Linear analysis complemented the heavy numerics.

At high shear, eddies stretched thin in one direction. That matches classic scaling used for scrape-off width. At low shear, eddies turned nearly round instead. Recent stellarator results showed the same round pattern. Linear mode studies captured the transition qualitatively. Coupling between poloidal modes proved decisive. The findings refine predictions of heat loads on walls.

Catalog record

CREATORZ. Tecchiolli, A. J. Coelho, J. Loizu, B. De Lucca, P. Ricci
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-04881

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Magnetic shear effects on ballooning turbulence in the boundary of fusion devices Preprint: AIP/123-QED Z. Tecchiolli, A. J. Coelho, J. Loizu, B. De Lucca, P. Ricci Abstract The effect of magnetic shear on ballooning-driven plasma edge turbulence is studied through nonlinear simulations complemented by linear numerical and analytical investigations. Nonlinear, 3D, global, flux-driven simulations using the GBS code show that the scale separation between radial, x x , and poloidal, y y , size of turbulent eddies, k x ≪ k y k_{x}\ll k_{y} , considered by Ricci, Rogers, and Brunner 2008 and extensively used to predict pressure gradient lengths, SOL width, particle and heat fluxes, is observed with high magnetic shear. In contrast, for low magnetic shear, k x ∼ k y k_{x}\sim k_{y} is observed, with fluctuation properties resembling those shown by recent low-shear stellarator simulations reported in Coehlo, Loizu, Ricci, and Tecchiolli Coelho et al. 2024a . Global linear investigations of the ballooning mode qualitatively captures the transition in mode structure with varying magnetic shear, showing that k x ≪ k y k_{x}\ll k_{y} is achieved with sufficiently strong poloidal mode coupling enhanced by increasing magnetic shear, resistivity, toroidal mode number, and equilibrium gradient scale length. This is confirmed by an analytical study considering a dominant poloidal mode and its sidebands, which highlights that the poloidal mode structure is determined by curvature and k ∥ k_{\parallel} effects. I Introduction Turbulence in the boundary of tokamaks shows the presence of small-scale eddies originating inside the last closed flux surface (LCFS), that may develop into filaments detaching and propagating into the far scrape-off layer (SOL) ( Endler 1999 ; Garcia 2009 ) . The size of these eddies in the radial and binormal ( \sim poloidal) direction is of crucial importance for determining the plasma dynamics in the boundary region ( Zeiler et al. 1996 ; Rogers, Drake, and Zeiler 1998 ; Giacomin and Ricci 2020 ) . The eddy size combined with quasi-linear theories ( Zeiler 1999 ) allows for the prediction of fundamental quantities such as the equilibrium pressure gradient length and the SOL width ( Ricci and Rogers 2010 ) . Indeed, the evaluation of the eddy size is a key element to estimate the particle and heat turbulent fluxes as it affects the turbulent regimes in the boundary ( Ricci and Rogers 2010 ; Mosetto et al. 2013 ; Halpern et al. 2013 ; Giacomin and Ricci 2020 ) and the plasma-wall interaction Loarte et al. 2007 . Ultimately, operational limits and turbulent regime transitions such as the density and \beta operational limits, and of the L-H transition ( Ricci and Rogers 2013 ; Giacomin et al. 2022a ; Giacomin and Ricci 2022 ) depend on the shape of the turbulent eddies. Scaling laws for the equilibrium lengths and confinement times based on an estimate of the eddy size were successfully validated against multi-machine databases ( Giacomin et al. 2022a ; Ricci et al. 2023 ; Lim et al. 2023 ; Lim et al. 2024 ) . Previous studies ( Ricci, Rogers, and Brunner 2008 ; Rogers and Dorland 2005a ; Ricci and Rogers 2013 ) have investigated the radial extension of the turbulent eddies in ballooning mode (BM) ( Ricci, Rogers, and Brunner 2008 ) and drift waves (DWs) ( Rogers and Dorland 2005a ) driven turbulence. For BM and DWs, the relationship k_{x}\sim\sqrt{k_{y}/L_{p}} is found analytically, where k_{x} and k_{y} denote radial and binormal wavenumbers, and L_{p} is the time-averaged pressure radial scale length. For Kelvin-Helmholtz turbulence ( Rogers and Dorland 2005a ; Ricci and Rogers 2013 ) , expected to be significant only in the presence of strong E\times B shear flow ( Giacomin and Ricci 2020 ) , the scaling k_{x}\sim 0.6k_{y} is observed. To simplify the study of eddy properties, mode locality assumptions are often made in linear studies of edge instabilities. In the case of ballooning modes (BMs), a key scaling relation, k_{x}\sim\sqrt{k_{y}/L_{p}} , is derived by assuming strong poloidal localization, which holds when k_{y}L_{p}\gg 1 and a single dominant poloidal mode is considered ( Rogers and Dorland 2005a ; Ricci, Rogers, and Brunner 2008 ) . The relation k_{x}\sim\sqrt{k_{y}/L_{p}} has been widely used to simplify the eddies analysis, as it ensures k_{x}\ll k_{y} , allowing radial derivatives of the mode to be neglected. In fact, linear studies often adopt a flux-tube approach ( Zeiler 1999 ; Rogers and Dorland 2005a ; Mosetto et al. 2012 ; Halpern et al. 2013 ) , which assumes 1/L_{p}\ll k_{x},k_{y} . In contrast to tokamak simulations, recent, global, flux-driven, two-fluid, plasma turbulence simulations of an island-diverted stellarator ( Coelho et al. 2022 ) show a BM dominated regime with k_{x}\sim k_{y} eddies and fluctuation scales comparable to equilibrium gradients, k_{y}\sim 1/L_{p} . Fluctuations with these properties are also found experimentally in the TJ-K stellarator ( Krause et al. 2002 ) , a feature successfully reproduced by global turbulent simulations ( Coelho et al. 2023 ) . The island diverted configuration and TJ-K both have a small global magnetic shear, s\equiv(r/q)dq/dr\ll 1 with r being the radial direction and q(r) the safety factor, while tokamak configurations are characterised by high magnetic shear, s\sim 2-4 . These recent results motivate a detailed investigation of the size of turbulent eddies as a function of the magnetic shear. This paper presents low magnetic-shear and a high magnetic-shear simulations of plasma in the edge region of a simple tokamak with circular flux surfaces. Given the high collisionality in the boundary region and being interested in turbulence time scales, the plasma dynamics is described by the drift-reduced Braginskii equations ( Zeiler 1999 ) evolved by GBS, a three-dimensional, global, two-fluid, flux-driven code ( Coelho et al. 2024b ) . Simulations parameters are chosen to ensure that turbulence is driven by BM, by tuning the ratio between collisionality and mass-ratio ( Mosetto et al. 2013 ) . Results show that, as magnetic shear decreases, the dominant mode wavenumber k_{y} decreases, and k_{x}\sim\sqrt{k_{y}/L_{p}} no longer holds. Indeed, the properties of the fluctuations recall those of recent low-shear stellarator simulations, where k_{x}\sim k_{y} ( Coelho et al. 2022 ; Coelho et al. 2023 ) . These simulations show that, at low-shear, radial and poloidal fluctuations extend over a region comparable to L_{p} , breaking the validity of the flux-tube approximation. Therefore, a global theory is needed to accurately describe the spatial structure of BMs in general magnetic shear conditions, without assuming a fixed relation between L_{p} and fluctuation size. We introduce a novel global 3D linear theory demonstrating that, in low-shear regimes, radial and poloidal fluctuations are comparable in size, while k_{x}\sim\sqrt{k_{y}/L_{p}} is recovered in high-shear regimes. The analytical theory supports our numerical results, pointing out that the turbulent mode poloidal structure results from the interplay between magnetic curvature, inducing mode coupling, and parallel gradient effects. The paper is organized as follows. Section II describes the drift-reduced Braginskii equations used for simulating plasma turbulence in the boundary of fusion devices and the GBS code we use to evolve them. Section III outlines the tokamak configurations with circular flux surfaces and varying magnetic shear considered for our study, and discusses nonlinear results of ballooning-driven turbulence. Section IV details the extended linear ballooning

Read the complete text